A

B
C

Alternatives
Breakwater Project
Port
Revetment/Embankment

D
E

Extension Bridge
Relocation

Description
Offshore structure protection from waves
Concrete structure for ships
A raised bank or wall that is carry a roadway or hold back
water
Two-way extension bridge connecting the land
A location that is suitable for anchorage

Analysis of Alternatives
Core Problem:Difficult Condition on Transportation
Criteria
1. Resources
2. Time Frame
3. Social Impact
4. Environmental Impact
5. Technical Impacts
6. Financial Impact
TOTAL

Criteria

Breakwater
Rank

1.
2.
3.
4.

Resources
Time Frame
Social Impact
Environmental
Impact
5. Technical Impacts
6. Financial Impact
Total

Description
Availability of materials and resources
Time duration of the project
Willingness and interest of stakeholders
Effect to nature
Availability of equipments and technologies
Budget cost needed

2
2
2
4
2
2

Ranking
Revetment

Port

Wg
t
.40
.40
.20
.40

Rank

Wgt

Rank

4
4
4
2

.80
.80
.80
.20

1
1
1
3

.40
.40
2.0

4
4

.80
.80
4.0

1
1

Wg
t
.20
.20
.10
.30
.20
.20
1.0

Weights
20%
20%
10%
10%
20%
20%
100%

Extension
Bridge
Rank Wg
t
3
.60
3
.60
3
.30
1
.10
3
3

.60
.60
3.0

Relocation
Rank

Wgt

5
5
5
5

1
1
.50
.50

5
5

1.0
1.0
5.0

Criteria
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.

Resources
Time Frame
Social Impact
Environmental Impact
Technical Impacts
Financial Impact

A
1 year

P2,

B
2 years

Alternatives
C
1 year

1 year

2 years