Professional Documents
Culture Documents
pdf1 PDF
pdf1 PDF
True or false
Is the Bygging-Uddemann
method for Steel Tank Erection
and Repair cheaper than other
conventional methods?
www.
bygging-uddemann.se
True
The lifting trestles must be
provided with a stable base
for all of these operations.
The steel tank construction
method, like Bygging-Uddemanns other systems, has
been in use all over the world
for many years.
Project:
Client:
Building Method:
Date: 15/02 - 08
STEEL CONSTRUCTION
2M LITRE UNITS
COMPLETED
11/01 - 09
Advantage:
FASTER, MORE
ECONOMICAL
AND SAFER
Result:
11. The lifting lugs and guides are removed from the top shell plate and
new lugs and guides are welded to the next shell plate. The hydraulic jacks
are lowered to the original lifting position.
1.
12. The steel tank is lifted again to allow the continued erections of shell plates
until the full height of the steel tank has been reached.
3.
13. When the last shell plate is fitted and welded in place, the finished
steel tank is lifted slightly so that the guide trestles can be dismantled.
14. The steel tank is lowered and the shell plates and base plate are welded
together.
15. The jacking equipment is dismantled.
www.
bygging-uddemann.se
Project:
Client:
Building Method:
Date: 15/02 - 08
STEEL CONSTRUCTION
2M LITRE UNITS
COMPLETED
11/01 - 09
2.
4.
5.
6.
Advantage:
FASTER, MORE
ECONOMICAL
AND SAFER
Result:
Guide Trestles
The guide trestle fix the shell plate in the
eact correct position and serve as supports
during the welding.
The guide tretles are spaced at approximately 2 m.
The guide trestles can be provided
with adjustable brackets
for a work platform.
www.
bygging-uddemann.se
Project:
Client:
Building Method:
Date: 15/02 - 08
STEEL CONSTRUCTION
2M LITRE UNITS
COMPLETED
11/01 - 09
Advantage:
FASTER, MORE
ECONOMICAL
AND SAFER
Result:
Volume 35.000m3
Dia 48 m
Height 20 m
Weight 600 ton (lifted weight 500 ton)
42 Nos tank jacking units
100%
76%
75%
56%
50%
Construction time
Manpower
BYUM method
14 weeks (76%)
7300 hours (56%)
Conv. method
25%
17 weeks (100%)
12.900 hours (100%)
0%
Time
Labor
Conv. method
BYUM method
Cost comparison
Lifting equipment
---freight
---supervision
Labor cost
Construction method
BYUM
Conventional
3
1
4
0
37
Equipment cost
---scaffolding
---welding
---plate handling
Other costs
Jig and tool
Machining
Non destructive test
Consumable materials
Field expenses
Overhead charge
3
1
4
Remarks
Based on depreciation
after 6 tanks with a
40% resudial value
66
1
3
6
10
100
100
90
80
70
66
50
37
40
3
3
2
3
4
4
19
5
3
2
5
4
5
24
64
100
30
24
19
20
10
10
4
Lifting
eq.
www.
bygging-uddemann.se
64
60
Labor
Site eq.
BYUM method
Project:
Client:
Building Method:
Date: 15/02 - 08
STEEL CONSTRUCTION
2M LITRE UNITS
COMPLETED
11/01 - 09
Other
Total
Conv. method
Advantage:
FASTER, MORE
ECONOMICAL
AND SAFER
Result:
www.
bygging-uddemann.se
Project:
Client:
Building Method:
Date: 15/02 - 08
STEEL CONSTRUCTION
2M LITRE UNITS
COMPLETED
11/01 - 09
Advantage:
FASTER, MORE
ECONOMICAL
AND SAFER
Result: