Professional Documents
Culture Documents
!+ &+-!"
a@szja@n
www.rsscrs.info
"2 0
5 %!!3
0
5 ,8&
&!##!&/! :#
& $
(
0 ,1 2 /
,-+ ,
5
*+
0 /7
6 $
9 0 8
0< ; :
=
?0 >.+
D
( A?B
B0.
!&(#3-# :
$
&` / _+
/= 6 :;G.
$
/`K _+ YB.
Jd[( 7
b
B 9
$ .8+ _+0 :
!#3!#!/!#3! :#
; 99 : 99 $ :
\( V /5O J ) O - g
/d
+Y ) R=V ( .....( j
; 99599 :
\ /5O J/d ) 2 6 k , Bd2
?d/+G ? ( g V? ,
?0 0 ...8O ?/.(:
) ! $
G# 3 E ) C # 3 !+&(
! $ :
Y A/G 80 0B.
3 K+ :Feed Back KL0
/7O0
QG
?
$.
8-:
O = 6 7O7O
Q 0 7O [ ) /+_+
?d VR=V (.
= 6 7O _+G
&`0= / 7O
?
] Q
A?B0.
0 =0 7O?
]0 Q ?.
p 7O
/ IG?
&`/ ]Q
; /`K + .
+N OK
'+,8 !!3
O :6
( 00B
(0Q \O\O : O
+> 7O /(
/+.
8=
00B
(0Q\O , :
= 8; 0
V (\ `J
.7O
8!/&
!
:7
$ :\ J2;
A?B0.
$ : x\O ; , XYG
,7O
AO=
A?B 6/z0.
3- :
\( - ((
2 6].QG I
vG
-$ A?B0 0B 6 AQO.
vG
-$ /RO (($.J
/7
V -$ 8 V
J ,7O
$ J .
- J$ 6 8 JOQ
) J , OQRG v
J" JVz"
O$ 1$ 0 x.((($
- J$ 6 IG J ) OQ[
A/> 6 ;QO 6/z
0 .(QO
&
! :
)+ 5 . #$
, \ 00B
-0
R XYG/+ [0
J
Y
AO[(\ Y XYG/+
G
?/ V/
\
?
, ($ R
V
./
A?BR
V / 6\/ 6 _+.YB
8/ /
Y 00V2 6
\ O
8
kB+ V 2 \/.
)+ 5 ).%:
=<4#!&/#!836
:
!+ &+-!"
a@szja@n
www.rsscrs.info
X%
!!3
&7
;+
:#!-
6RGH 6 /d.7O
KLY999+999 : 9 9-Z B QO
[g
+Y(V \
\ /`&
RG /+\ RG
/7O?0 O=$.
K! /`K
V :; :
J 0
J0G C9#
Semantic B# ( ,2.
V 0G
J H$
R 0O
]
[; /- O p A 8 :/
] O
[9 / A
= I 0B V /1 xH V(
,;
6; 6
(
R
6 /2 /
;K
O
Q IG
Q 6 H$ ; 0 V 0O x
] I >6 +
O +W;
2 */ 62 O O
2
V / ?
+(.
R
V /W 7Q
2 ( /\ 6 /d .J
R
V 6/ J? 92
/
J+
/ /B
H$
B R
V.
&/?+:
&! :[
0G
/H //
1 /0B
7Q /w / 7Q
/J
/J
?J+
?J+
:
[2
/[2.
]
QY$.
Kenneth Burke"!<!!("#!6:
999K3!)999 &
: Consubstantiation %999]K 0 ,
?YO\/ /> 6VR
V
A?B
6-
O?
R
R
([ O
?YO Jd J
J
\/ 6>/ R
V.
; :
Jd J ? 0 W ?d 60/w 6
J
\/ [/.
x
J /+
x \/ 6[/
R
V
J?( A?B O?
R O.
&!#
:
( \ JVR
V $ &` /( .7O
( VR
V $ 0= 0 / J
RB ?:0R
6?.J+
JdR
V Q 0 [
7O:
V
.,
VR Q J 6 J
0; :0
/W g XY / :Y
?.J+ /.J
/ ?O.
,R/.
XB.7O
XB7O /
?J+ /J
) $ (
JQ
R
V
&6#7+&:
99 99 ):-99 0 G99 $ 0 O / J
/2 J5 (?
J
+ :O
K 0 /R
J.
p/ J
/5O p
= I ?
&`/ .
A=0/2Q
0 00B B
J5/.
)9:- X 9 9 #! O999
? : / J
R
81
8/ 6?:J+
\ RG&
] Q
8 6/z
IG
=.I
J
2 R
V /
8/+ /W5.
[
?/Y , (? J/
O 8 pJ5
1.
&6#7+&
E:
):- 0 :G / /`K
/7 O/ ? J+
JRB
6[0 :
0
/W ) ?.( J+
0
/W
= I; :;G/Y [ attitudes /
.
0
/W
) ? ) J Jd ( J+?J /-B ( J+
>
?+ J 0.7O
):- X #! O %50 : ? J+/ /
1
B
] Q XB 7O; J
;
1 x `0/ 6(+Y .0
5 :
A?B ,Q; 00B
p
/
O:
p
/.
:O$!+999999
YG ? D /
/Q
Interpenetration/
B
,
g\ 0/
/J
=0 V 0 ?
B
J+/ &` / .7O
" ?
B J+ /" ; O ??
J+
5 gQ( JR [2 (? /.J
" ?
B J+ /"
2 ( +Y O0 6
/ / J
1 ; +Y(V ;QO
Y JR O
):- XX %): . +
):- XX0 b1
: + \/ 6/ J?.J+
!6I : &7
g/6
!3:
k Y&
G ?/
;QO [( 8?
7
vGH 0
2 ; \ vG 0&V:
g g$
/0
/0
\/
0
,= g
<Q V O Y&
O 8 p J].Q
0B
I5
] Q0 VR
V 0 J2] QVR
V
G $
[/ .7O
&G!&6&
!!:#
+ _
,O Y& ?
+ $
; x? / ,
.
!6I: E:
&!# (&!3&G! :
/+VR
V $
7O] Q$
:
.XYG
.,7O
? AO
.
=/ .,2B
VR
V 0 Q
8Y /0 _
:
.Q]
8 J
JRBV.,
JRB .J
JRB
].Q
JRB (.Q
/0 8 J [= [/.
+= JRB B .6/z
JRB
Q / .Q]
6
6 /W ( /7 / 6/z
.,
JRB = .7O
2 Y 0 J 7O.
J Y 7O , 0B
.
Q( J /d xK 6 6B .
A?B+H
6 (
.
A?B
6 (2 <+d ( .
VR
V 0 Q
8Y
] I:
/ :/0 8 J 6/0_
.6
8 J
].6Q
J?O :
\ 6 J? / ,$.
\ 0 /
].Q
Q( 6 J. /d
#!6
! :K
6 ; :
] J5
Q
RB
.
O; :
] Q +?B A
J0((.
62 VY ,2B 5/\ RG > Q +
B
6 :W+
62 d
8?./
> ;QO
p+ 0B.
/H p? / .O
+ =/ .
B
+
XYG ,= J;
J
+V:
<=
00BR
V.
00B , 6 60Q
.
00B R
V J?O 0G
.
6 00B ,[/ [GH 6 60Q.+
0 00B V0 / + V0 ?
+
.
J [+
& 0 V0 ? J+
;QO
/:
6 9B 0 01 6/Y./z
B A 0.6/Y
0 V $ .J
0 ` ? 6/
6/Y< ` . +
=
2
0 RGH 0/YW ) 6/Y .( X
(< RGH 0 O; 1 6/Y ] Q+
O
J2H ;K Y V ,7[ 6
/`K /RO + ?d 6.6/Y
#!62// :
O; :
] Q
/R 6 7O 1$
+?B A
.
XO
J (20 /7O]
\ /[ p g /+O=$.
_ 0/ J = ? J+ / O=V
;QO
.
,] Q ,Q?0 (? J
/+G 6 +2
vGH ./
/7] Q , $
0O/ 6
0.,+
/7] Q ,?/ $ 5G
.
6 6B 8/ /0 ?/ $
0 gB
J+= 6 ?+Y/.6
#!6
/!E& -E :
G ?/ $
/
00+ J 60 -/d
, 0.
?/
0 0 = B5
.
G ?/ O 0 pVR
V + .Q
8
! #& :#&6
(? J
6/ /.6
AO IG 6
;+[- $.
J5
? 6
2
G =/
.
I/- ?
* 6 ,O 0? 2 .
(? J ( /7- :
,[/
R .,
>
)
6/d ...6/w ( ,( 7O
\
2 YY > Q(0 .
!+N3
E1&:
4#!6
!: .AO
: Q2 .Q
+
+ /+G /
= / (( > + .O
/!*&E1!#&63
! :#
& /Y.0
.<=
/
(?/+ J ].Q ( .
,
\ 8V2.
Id2.
( ./
_X
!)#$
' %!!3
&!&/&
#!&:O&/&:
R IG
7O 0 >+
(\ Y
? 8+.
=/ 0R
6= 8 Y =
(+.
; :8
Jd= 7O 6/ g0 /.6
Y( , /H$ &` / (
VR
V.
" //O Sisk, H (1977 ) "x "$ "7O
+/" k= (VA Graicunes) "g(
2 Y( /`K
JB /H$
& 0
1
? 0 V
0B VR
V
6/ g/ ; x 6/ 6(.,Q
E
!:)'#
&!.#
.#!&!V
&! :#
8+ J2 7O/ .7O
X+
/ ,R
V ( =Y
B :0B Y Jw\
G
]Q
O 5 J/ (Y /H$.
;K; :?
O /
6 6:
W+ : ,?O:
, 6 :
5 JQ /
.
99, 99
99 6 JQ
5 =/
2H.
W+ : E:
B :
, ( gQ
5 0
\ 0
/.
&
/2#!/
&!)#&& :7
2 =
O VR
V B10.
2 ; :?
O = (? J
1 R
V.
2 O 6
K (? J
5
.(0
2 O (? J
0?+ ; : 0B
=
O VR
V.
&!
1!7&&#&6
!
&! :#
A?B
(2
A+Y p=/ .
*
Q
(2 Y
$ .(0
A?B+-(V (? J
/
.7O
R
$
6 9 QG.
2
! :#
;
O / 6VR
V / ? 8p [ /+$
Y k
JB& $ (? J
$ .(0
2
!#7 :#
0B VR
V / 6 Y
$
$ .(0
?/> 6 J?O
b[(.7
0
" I5 Goldhaber () / VR
V Y
7O :
/+VR
V Y /d(
VR
V 0G .7O
VR
V :Y
Y
6 A+Y
Q[( 7
.b
; J2H/ Y.
Y
6
] I$ = ,O
J2H /.
/2 ;W/ [` 6 /$
O 8/
].6Q
vG J?O
+ / J 6GH 7O; 6gQ( ,
$.
/
6
2 5/Q /W5 J?,0
/`& ,
?.,
0 +w* [= \
QB 5
R
? p+ ,(0 R
V [?.
99 :$+Y99+ :K p+/d
8Y/Q /R
/
Y.
: + J[/
IOR
1 p[
& / O , JY[.,
K+ :/ 6 O
02
bO k[/
*QG
/[ Q2.
:g)+ K [/ /
0O ,[ p+
+ 0 ?
O
/d
.
'K99 :
O+[/
V+ 0 V/
-/ . J
/Q ;
O 6\ bRO J VR
V / -
=<.
*'!V#;)#!-
&/ :
J-Q[/ R
V \ RG
Q
/\ k,
\ ,RGK ,? 6 J0 /.
bRO R
V 6/0K _
R
V 7Q/\ k
/ ` ,
2 W5 1.
!V&!:#
VR
V
0 Q]
6$ QG J
.
6/-
/ $ VR
V /W.
R
V /W/ 0G
] I :
Y+
K 0 .A
5' /KZ [
/w B1R
V /.
"$+ ( .
R
V !f .A
/ K 9 # 69
$ [/
R
.
g,
R .A
;K
VVR
V /
0B ?YO )
0B \
(.
0= 0 \ vG R
V=
\.RG
/(\
6
] 6Q)" , "c$
" "Grape Vine
O0 %+
) G) ` K! %!: !3
- 7O /?/
&`/
,.7O
JB* \ J$
G ?/ /B pRJ
O= A/> 6 VR
V /.
A/> 60G =
O R
V /W / 62 J*
?/ =05 J+ / 0O 0$.
,R
V 7Q
2 ]
O= J VR
V / QR :
J Q
(+.
/
(+ 0O.B
00B&.
?/ [ /
2
K O= /+ R
V / .X
? /;/ /=V +Y
/
2 J O= /+ R
V
/ .0R
vGVR
V
2
J5/H ,7
+R
62?/2
6 J+ =/
/ ( ,Q
; : B;
O 6R
V " m % K".
vG
RB / 6 J J/
2 -
`$ ? J+
` A; R
V ; : B;
O 6
R
V " Ln".
,; R
V
O= /+ VR
V / (Y
O= /+ 8
VR
V /w/ 8
6 x A?B
J[0
:
.+
O=$.
$ ./Q
\=O?.//
p2 .
0G R
V \ Q [
:
RB `$ J /Y [/ -D /Q
=!:O
!V: 6
5 0 VR
V /+
+ / J
0G 2
[Q.
,VR
V ;
O A/> 6/ , XB
;
JGVR
V.
) ` K %3# %+K ")
: "Goldhaber K
+ .
(1 (1 .+
&76/+ . &;( .
!+ &+-!"
a@szja@n
www.rsscrs.info
K
K3 C 3+5 %!
5
:O!6
!E! :#
/7O? 0
6 J /+
.
(< ,7
IR
, 7O( (7 X? , JQ /w AW
Y J? (Y /H$
= IR,7O
].I
Y , + [ R
V ,7O$
xVR
V
/ 6
[ [(.
V [ /RO 0
Q /G.
0 p 8/ 6Q
,.($
81 0B
X( .J J
2 8 6 J2
0B J+= 6$.
O # 5 !#$ Kp:%
( (/7 J0+ (K .
<Qw
J QO.J V
.
p+ J / - (/7 [ > + J b+5
O
Y#!6 X#!6
/7O J( H :/2B J
pO?
>.+ J
Y <BO.5/Q
($ pB J/ +B
+Y :/2 J/
V . ./Y
=
( Q QO,2B B \00 =B 0
Y 0O5/Q ;($
j?
?
+ J. J
+
].Q
, 7O
A?B0 0 J-Q
$HX? , ...
_2
7O.x BR[
].Q
8Y J+?
,& */& B
+O
( JB .O kB+ .62
0?0 $0 ($. 0
Y.
"=!&)I
:
("#!6(
"X(!
&!1
: !&(7 &!6
R
, Q ;B
G.
,7/ JVR
V
;K 6 :
V
[ [(.
,
G ?/ $
$ [.
VR
V 6
[( [ 0B
6-/=V...j
2
G
V ?/ /w=? \
.
2 VR
V 6
[ [(
RB
?/ / 0G \ /Q V.
"#!6#-(
"YI(!
&!1
: !&(7 &!6
1 / J ?0
[( +w
w.
=
,
RB J?/ J-.Jd
A0
,VR
V 6
[ [( g2 G.
,
G ?/ $ 8 ,7O
+
.
\ 8VR
V
.
"99)99" K"
b1V 0G 9 /0 /7( 6
Q]
8 0
?+> x B/ O
[/
1/ 6 A+YO.
:"Rensis Likert(!"#!6
=
/7( 81 6 ;K
7O+V
./Y /w
/ ,77O $ IOR
62
02H
[( 7?/ :
,8$
,8$ !
]K "q
$
K3 !)#$ Kf
5 5+
)"K X
!#$
'!3$ 3 *QGO I
Y?
X
X
=
0
V 0
V 'm$
6X = 3 II
0
V 0
V 2 8Q
/ = 3 III
Y? Y? Y 8Q
/ 6 = 3 III
6 :I
7( Jd "Authoritarian" Y 1/ ; 7O
1/ 6 J2 " "g1/ $ O+:
?d
]0 I.
XB I1 JQ V
.
A?B[0 & 6 $ .
8OR J?/
[.
,7VR
V
6 A0
[
[(.
\
I/B
0
& .B5
0 =0
] \=O I
81 5G J$.
0
V
VR
p+
] 6 6Q& ,
7O /w K0
6 IG0 .7O
6 :II
Jd; "7O /G 6 "Benevolent ( /7/ g
O+
1/Q :
O `? > 8 Q
].I
8Y
] IR
V / ( \=O
5.7O
,7 ,VR
V 6
[
[( ; x*
VR
V 6
[( [
RB VR
V
pw/ /.g
9
V
Y
[.
/R
, JQ
J.
6
2 0 XB / /w K0 =
2
0 ` [0
.7O
, 7 ,?/
[ *
Q
8
G * ?/
O[/.
6 :III
O/? - "/2" ( /7 =/ (" /7 "Y Jd;
7O V\ " "Consultative
O+/Q :
?d
].Q
/ I
, 6 0$ .
A?B[0 & 6 .8
8Y/Q \=O
81 5G J\ 6./B
VR
V 6/Q + [2 z V\.
A0VR
V 6
[
[( .g2
+= , ,7VR
V 6 ?0
[
[(
/Q
0= 62( \ 6;B .+/
,7VR
V 6 ?0
[( [ .BB5
= /
0
6
2
XB /w K0 =
2
0 Y? [0
$ ? QG $.
6 :IIII
1/Q =/ "/2" ; 7O
Y? 1/Q (/7
" "Y - /7O "9" 1/2" Q5" 7( Jd
(K
\ $ " "Participative
2 1/ ; 7O :
?d 2
].I
A0
,VR
V 8
V $.
,
G ?/ 8 ,7O$.
? 6/ ,7O$
R = .
+= , 8VR
V ?0
[(
/Q _.
JQ A/> 6 /VR
V \=O O=D \
G
?/.
VR
V 6 ?0
[(
[
JB
BB5.
;K /w ,7O/ ( J2H gQ ,7O/ ;
, x 0[0
.??B
J
/+
0
/ /1 .
# :
O
2 0= 7O /? O ./? /w
7O
O <B
J ?
/ / 0
/W >QQ
O;
? 0 g27O
O <B
J ./? /w
O /W /W
8 /? +> /`& O 7O (<.
"=!&)#!2
:
gO > ?/0 62 d
8 +VB
=I
/Q /Q 6 /5O /\+V 6
=I
/7"...
Q /7O
= 0 Q /+
O
R b/
0 8 6$ ,7O$.
!+ &+-!"
a@szja@n
www.rsscrs.info
"2 X%
! ' 5
'+ $
-o
) 5
&1&!#
:
O _
A/ JVR
V :
" c #! % *#
00B
! C+ q!)#$ /w R
V. !
K$ O )+ ? J+R
V. O
C+ Q !)#$
R
V. Q
C+ O 2 R
V. O
G+ 6R
V. G+
8V
:
?( pR
V
0B
+w $ ; & / 00 /W 6R
V.
Q ,7O$ ,R
V 6 A?B
J 0 * 6]I
VR
V :
]/ I. /=$. .,Q O=$. .+
&E
&#/
:
6
? J+; p /
B R
V
=
2 0 vGH 0 GH =
2 0 ? gQ( J+
$
/ J
IG (.
,2B+Y(V
> pY 6 pY IVR
V.
:
J?( , I
/ p?O /+ , R
V ; 00B
x[
0G
R
V.
&(
:
, 6R
V
=
2 0 R
V p2 /0 _
=
2 0 = &
/
6 =
2 0 > \.
2 / R
V
/`K Q( /+ /> 6 JR
V.
&
:
0B R
V
00B
,
J[/
,/ ? Jd0 R
V0
? +R
V
] +? QR
V <=
62 ( 6
R
V 8 R
V.
R
V.
=< R
V /+
; :#!-
B ,7VR
V $
(< /w J
+ 0
B R
V.
( gQ
=<
JB; : J+ >
IR=
6/ J?.J+
)+
x 6
??B ?( pw/
/
2
0? J ; : /
=/ /
RB
;QO. /
IR= 6/ J ? 62 J+\Q
6
/ /+ 0G [ g/
O1
0 J2H /7 :
O(KY ?.A
+B .:/2
?
.I-
V/ 0 V/.
/ 0 / )9(V(.
g/.
62
2 VR
V RGH /w JB
V 0O x gV
B = ((.
2 RGH ( (( 2 -(< /
JB
RGH((
H ? J+/ O_>V 6/J
(.Q
;!)#
&( :
? 0RR
V \
Q xR
V ; 0G [Q =
YO\J
J / + / .0Q O
0B V
]Q 0G R
V \
Q.
R
V \
Q
/
J (
0 JQ 6[/.
6 ( b 62 V ( =.J
( = 0R? V 0 ,2 O; .8
&(
:#
VR
2 7Q
+w ,> VR
V / .7O
` A
(+.
=0G
0 00B& 99
R .QH
/R
V
2 8
V $.
dVR
V
2 )
b[ / /\O....(j
!V :#!6
/w /+ R
V \) Q
2 /w
2(.
=
2 0 R
V A/> 60G 6O H$
0G 60 A/> 6 p-W / A9R ./QR
/7\ vG 6 k g+ 7/
Jd
/
G V
[ k0B
5
5 6 VR
V
/w.7Q
!V) 7;!V( ;) 7(
/3
2. .=
YO ( &4() 6
)2 /?/( )0B /V(
/ /Q. 0
R. ( &4(!V) 6!V
/7/Q. /5 / A.
/
.
.
5.
+ C#f+ Q K
!+ ! Q !'
+f c+f Q
K K Q : %
/ R
V 0
/
/`K /+ O
]Q
/Q.
/Q 0= JB
/ Q1=
.
.:O
O 00B
0
1 0 6?
1 $ [_
vG; /RO
xRG(< 6; :[_ /> 62
( ;
, ?$
6
O9
1
Y O k0B
=!:O&
&? .
0 /RO; " xRG(<" $ [_
vG
/RO
... J+d :
6
/ 8
= 8 xO 8
0 +w / 8
1 / 6 8
1
==
!8!(:O
&!1/
-
RB
.
-/ , I
1 :
-?) 0V(.
6 -
1 ) ? ,/(.
-/?)
G G(.
#!!(#/&:O/ .*E
I?
I
,2
O?$
0 R x(.xQ
/ 9 6 vG? A.QO
/
=0
=
1 .kB+
JGO=V ?0
x J (K( .
:1 :
&/76 :#3!7 O V /7 X? g+ J_ \ vG.
=.Q /.
.
W ., .g+
#A&
-&&#
E:
JB
V) O 6 /d .(- /w
W
V [ ) vGH (. ( :Q7 0
V =.B+
-&/ p :
2 2 R V b1 ,d
p
.AYO
';/&
&?
& p :
8 JQ 8
JQ
p
8. -
'#A76+ O( : W , x JB
I
0G -
[/)[( 6 6O ,Q$( W p ,
2 (Q7
= B1
O(
Y / xO:I
0G
.
0G .60
0G /.
/ x
! x+= 6 ,+
0+ ; :V x 62 V
/ +Y(V 6B
Y.
! 3#
(!(&!8
!1&7
!#
p2
I YG 2
=/ Y ;/
?/ /?
I ?/
/HV k0 \=O?
1 ,2
I 0B
/ ?
8 J /W5 V 8
I
(
:#
(!#
(
8
=0/+
H/.
1 /.
`?
B p
2 / IY/. B5
:OF :#
p
2 2 B1&`/ 6?/ [
J5 :x
,7O; J+= O\/ 2 ) x /
?( pw/
?
6 J+(.
(? J/2Q
?/Y ?YO.+
/
81 =
.?( pw/
0G \ / ?/ /Q
00B [2.
0G
?+> J ?
+>) J+ O =0 ?
.(,
=!&;:O!# :#
/= p
< K
H 6 0/ / J /+
( Q?K J+ , 6 0/ 0
H
.
#1:O/#&4&/& :
p
2 /
W
2
>
W /w BB5
+ KY
?O 0 0R / &`0R /=.
:O8 :#
J-Q
2 / J2H k0 /B
+B
JG\vG
;
p2 (K x J
x
2
0O p
/ .
!#&(
:#
pwVR
V $
;K\ J2/
B
6
K
VR
V 2H 00 6; :[2H:
.!E &( . - .
(
#-&( :
/+YG ;/ 0
` A$ /RG.
2 ,; :
`? BQ5 6 6BQ5 6 , Bx
//?
/+.
0G ;/ YG [/w 00 :O
pY./H+
JB+ > + _.
J?O
J5 Y Jd vGH 6
.5
/W
RB =
+ / O=D.
Y ./2H
/
.O
k YG
JB+ =/ _ =Q( 00H 8
5 p\K p b1
p
2 /5O:
J?
,Q ; ?/ 5 6 7OO [(7
.+
b10 ?/ =0 2V.
b1K =
J9
V 7O / 05 6 ,w/
; ?/.
J
/ , X J+?
62/.
vG;/
+
6[= $ J7O
YG
/ J
2
7O JB RRG 0
6
/+ 6 J= .
+1
:!E
0 ,? //0 /W 60.:
" c99 99+ K)99 O99
99x K99K+ ! 99m +99 *#99K99K+
:G# )+
>/ J? / R
1. W .
Q
]
(+ J2
1.
RB 0 /= 6 ?.//
]
/2Q [ 0 ?.//
m! + *# KK+*:
Y /w. (?.
? .RGH
.BB5 /w
( /w .G- ; 81
/ .6/
3-
!EI!+ :
99!)#$99 :
B ?
// BB5 /7(
.p
2
-+99 ! :{99: 0= /7 p
20G AYO0 9B
0 X?B A
K B5 6 0
2 ?.JH //
C 3+$ f9W :K9K+
2
2 \ J ,7O J2?J+
=/
Jd
B ? ) //!
Introduction 99999
++999999/ !)#$999999 ! Findings 999999Z+f K999999 +- 999999
Conclusion )+ .(Recommendation
(!!+'#*& :4E
/+?
R / 6 )? (J; / ( ""K9 -
0 / "K-" / 6 ) /? (J; / " -!
+".
/ ,2B ?
pY 6? )/W 6?(.
&#E
D 7 8
RB / Y
.
2\ JB 7 O 8
G =/ .6
O=D
(7 O /7 /W
8z.
]7 I 8
RB 0? J- O p
] Q\/w.
/ 9QB
? ,[ 7 ,?
8 /Q.
$0 BRO$H 7 80 \ J
J /Q.
K p(K
/ p 7 J0
8
bBR
/Q.
7 / 8
Q /Q 8
W- $.
!6& :#E
81[_ VQ
.?YO J
0 81_ Q
;K 6 /d
=< 0B.
0+ ?" J p> "/+G? ? Q( ,0K
IY;.
?/> 8
O
[_.
" ,G "/+G? \=O ,
vGH K ? xH(V.
&-& :4E
/+? 6 VR
V $
Y
6 O/ .7O
?
/ JQ
0 /> 6R
V V R
V
\
Q ; 8 JQR
V /w.7Q
W 0G
/
,
/
/7
/Q
9 b+R 6
O kB+?" J."/+G
J5Q
1
B ,Q 8Y = X /5O 6
1
J
8 k0B 0G ;
O 0O /H 6 0[/
0OY
/H 0O /1B.
E
4*A0B : 0O JB
+w/
/Q/ \
Q0G
B 0O ,2=O 8 /K /2 .
+a*A
10B : WR 0O/Q +B (B
Jd 8
J
/
?/ .,/2
(!!!1
#&!# :
G99# 99!$599 :
= I 6 k0B H B ;
;/ .Notes
" cK :O /2Q/R .:+(V
!+ {Ka O0 O) O $ (K3.c#
G# Cf!)+ G#.~-Z
!+ f/+ :0B 6 ( , x.d0B
BW& ! !K
:*+$ 0 0B
,Q/ /.
:C# 6/
V , ,2B
?> 80B.
% Cf+0 /`K
xQ> J
V :2 .QO
-+ ! :{: ?YO 6
B ?(V.
K f+K O8f.
) O Q,8f.
` K" 3#K"2
&7
!V" 6& :"I
/+R
V /w /w" 7Q\ 6 "Q X(
VR
V 0G
0B ([ x A/> 6/ ,\ J2.
K2HK 0 )
/+
/7
60 = ($
(.
R
V /w
= g 7Q O 0 g2R
V 7Q; 8-G
?
0.W
=
2 0 R
V /w
R? 7Q
R? /w.
836
!V : 6
Y
.=0
/W ,$.
/\ 6 /+(VQ.
,2B /`K.6/z
A0
,2B k0B / /J2 +.
K 0
? /V 1$ .
QH
2
!V : 6
62 I50 R
V /w A/> 6 7Q&/H
0
B0 / Kinesics
/RBO:
:O+(!
&W76&/I : 1
/ ,($ = 8
Q
2 0= 6 ;
Q O =0
2 _ .
/ / B# ,".Body Language C
& /H ??B
b1; /7VQ(V [(D g.
/7O+
62
RB
/d
J5 0
VB / 9 A>O 0
d ;
? [ d
x/d:O
A/> 6 /7O 9 [ 6 JQ
.6O
G A/> 6 /7O .6O
A/> 6 p/ /7O 6O 9 [ 6 JQ
.
A/> 6 p-W /7O 9 [ 6 JQ
(
.
?9 A/> 6 /7O 9 [ 6 JQ
.
9B A/> 6.6O
?YO
/7
Y /d /+
6O
.
O $
:
0/\ vG$ K R
V
Q .
pw/\ vG
RB 2 J.6/z
0/\ vG0
H ? Anxiety A.6/z
0/\ vG
( 0 /H ( 8.6/z
c"+K
-+
O $:
pw/Q \ /0.
2 = =0 +/ 8/Q ./z
2 O
/= (
Q0 J :/ 0 6 w0
.6/Y
pw//Q B(V ) JRO
YO ( 6 (Q? K
R J [ 6 p+[+.
:#4-
( 6 vG; JRQ O (
/+ ,
R 7Q /w
; :[(
:
" C$Z Jd O $ 8 60 8 8+5$;2 .Emblems
"
-+ C ) )] Jd 8
.Illustrators b1
"K C c, Jd C30G / .Regulators 6
" K'3 C Jd a$ +B .Affect Display
" Q f CK* ; # $! .Adaptors
Q f] " Gesture CK* .Movement
!1&!#
!V : 6
J/
xH
/w xY
7Q A
.x
0G R
V O?0
b 8; (<
V ,;
O 6R
V.
V 0 x Q=
x\[ x ; Y6 5 J
/Q 6 k 8
Q.6/z
7O\ J2.
= p/
x Y
V >_ xO
H 6
0= x(K
Getting Bored ##
H x0 6 +
1 \Q( vG
O ??B g2.x
Y ( :++Y( /d [ / O J( x+Y; (
6 /7; 0 6 x/Q /
OYR ( .
VQ
K0
( gQ
=< /Q 0= /z
( +Y[ xO ,2
x
6 ; +Y(V.
0 (/+ 0O x
5[ k0B 0
R
/H& /+
\/ x
O; :7B 61 J0+Y(V
[ .; ( gQ
=< x
6/z
00H (,Q
) .(0
/
p xO 6/Q 0O /z
.
0; : (/7 x; 8 =0 =
/ xY\ vG
2
0? ./z ; := : 9-W Social 99 !+
Personal Public 99) 99 0 / p+ 0= x*
?- & 6/ \ /_ 2 6[>/ .O
* /R /w? :Jd
/7O ? /1B.
9 xO 6/Y ./z
? 0 O.x ,2 x
! X qK ' G# K LY .
/ , /7; p
/7 )0 G(<(K
;
5 Y xRGH 6/9 . J ]
/7
Y ?` xY xQ( /+ J;
?
K.
XO
,)$ 5
&/ &2
= .
= .
W
= .RGH
=
.7O
:O&/2(! :#
6+ > /R
V.
Y ( /W gQO2
/.
+w\ vG 0/ ?.X
0 =
+
- 8Q ,
V \./
=!:O&/2A! :#
= JB
0
/ 0G & QG ( 0 ,O
/ ; = :0R /> 0R
V.
6 0B ) x 0G 2 X+
/ O 6 /d
0O 5
R 81( 7
0 ( (b O
b/Q
6 0B
,* 2
/Q /Q.>G
==:O&/2; :#!-
? 0R
x
= 6
O\ Q( vG R
V.
)
9
9-W 9 9 #! G9# KL99
9 C9L G9# KL9
- K ':
&
;!
:8!1
p
= 8
].Q
0 6
K 9O.
p BR\.RG 0 +B./W /G
0R ?-?
.Q- +Y J
].Q
&; : -
; /`& J ,2\ vG 6/z/
( ,
k 0
) O _( ? .8
( ,+Y(V [ ) 6 ( / O?
/Q.
&&!#&; :#
0B
2 0O \ JB vG\ vG /z .:01 9B
&-; :#!-
?
/
" :Jd \ vG V / ".
:O/&/2
:#!&!6
J/0
$ / 9/Y( 9
/H$.
,
J /.
? \ vG[ \ vG O , (d/ .g2
&82 :#/
G V 8 JO
6=B
+5 I JK
?8O
; 6B
62 I2 VR
V 8[GH 6+
B ; 0G =+ 6 /Q 1$ x
0G J / Q
[
Y / 5
R O
$ ? +
AO
6 6/z> x
A/
;
xY/ $.
6(
\RG +R
B / / Q J
:
vGH? J?.
\5 vG p/+G.
\ vG?) p+d(.
\ vG ,\
2 )\(.
\ vG) /
(.
GH .................. 6/
;-!EE :
R 6:R
K _ .RGH
,0$ ?
\.RG
g
/ 6 .6/z
6 ; \ vG B \ I/ .6/z
Q$+ !... *9$ 0 \ I/ 0= +O
. Y .(BR
0 \ I/ .6/z
1 :-
; \ vG
2 /+ ?? 0R 6 x:R
/d 0.
.6/ 8 V
? 0( ,QH J.
x/
BB5 .KY
Q99$+ 99B
!... *99$ 8;
O 0G ?B A /
62
,
?B x 62 A0G 5/ W5
Jd& :
</ I x x
<RB
I
.
;-&
()E=/( :
R 6:R
0R V /d.k0B
x_Q *++ /w.
B / 6 /W 2.
[_ Jd +> /w 0G J; !bB5
J =
? Ad
V 0 .+( 6& V +w
Q99$+ 99 !... *99$
2 ?
5/ ; :
?$ 5/ ; A k0BD 0 6
6_.
;-;( :
R 6:R
0+ +( ( 0G /2H .b0
+ V .J
8Y V ?
B K 6B
= I; \.O 2
Q$+ 6 !... *$ 62
2 5 p
? AB
8
\/Q O 2 ,` O/
x
1[
1 ./
2\ 8 :
gB ?
B
0= O
( gQ
=< :/+( x
0G ( x 8 < =
.!......
;-&
)
7/( :
R 6:R
/&
.
+
8Y V O O J ; + /d.
8-= Q2 VB
x 8-= x. -
/K
-B
0
</ 0B
./K
K
)( :I
O )/R( 6/ ] 7O/ > + +O
62 V
.
0G VR
V ? 62
O 6 7O
IQG0 O .Q
=
2 0 O )R( /1 / ( _+ -0 ([ 7O
7O *+
.QG
1!
8!/
)
(
1<
!6
:I
-+ )2(:
2 % :B# (9 \9O ( 9 = = .8/
+
629 29+ ? :29+ p29
\ 1
6
(
BV .299+ %99Z :(? ./G2999
O
2 .
RG! %)- O O B
RG .9+
O ,5G
O ?
R 9( ,O
R AB ; /7O O (K
=0B I 6
>& 6/ .
R
-+ )K(:
K O
:/Y [ !9 /R /R
5 + O
K 0O ,B[ p-W /R ( +-w 2
= /= 0=
0 ) .
R /H / 0 .(-
8- XG /d2 6; O V 0G 6 J 9+
+ 0 B
= I /> 6.
RG
!1#!-
:
0B O +w7O ( >
/Q
RB Y
6 /+?
?
< Y JRB +/Q ?+> Y
=
8 6/z=0G
0 YVB :
x
- 6 p :02 Y [/ 6/z .p+
6 x
- :0 6 YY
B/ .7O
6 x
- :00 6 Y
;QO?/ 5G.6/z
6 x
- :00 6 Y
;QO[( 7
b$ A
.
? 6/R;
?B 6 ?
(!!#+/&#
:
/7O2.2
/7O.(($
/7O.d0B
:O#!6( :#!(!4
0B5 ; :
) /7O
( ( "O 0
V".
/0
= J 1O/ 0H O
] I
/w= J/w
1O ;QO
p[ / (?.
]/
0
;QO[ / += 6 0
] I
0
V ([ R/
O /7O2.2
==:O#!61!= :#
0B O p+ ./
O = 0 0/ 7O /7O\ J.,
=
2 0 9O `
+7O dB+.
O
IQG
620 O ? 6 J
+7O /
.O
= 0 09O * / 7O/ ,- *+
O
= .J-
0[/ V /Q /V
B
?
v ; :V.
/
6 V 0/Q >
//B
W- p-W0 0
B5 /`& Q( J (.
62
2 O ` O _ /Q ;/Q 7O x =0
I\2
\ J* $/
7O
1 B
x
7O[;
x
J0$/
.
:
- .bR
6+
Y.
O / O.
O 0 Q2
].Q
/w 8 6RRG.6RRG
RB gO 9 /]... +
/ / Q
O [ Q?
+
] Q . J
J$ & 9O 8.6/z
\0 RG
RGH ,/Q 8.6/z
O V [0 ? , [
] Q +.
O 0 B5
0 =0 (7
7O
/.
!'
!1!+
:
= 0 0 JO 0 /+ *
:Jd J
-?? \) vG[GH( ;
pO \.2
-?? \) vG/Y (0B; /0O
O
x
>/ .0B
-1 +-
:
/Y kd O 0 0O =0 66/Y
5 O J p
/ ) Mediator 999 C9999f
Arbitrator * # !fK :%+
-/> J 9V R(V ?/ ; 0R :.,2B
J -?/ O pO
6 JR.6/Y
-Y 5/ 6/Y$
=K , ,O J
.:0
* #$ MediatorK ):- : +
8 -2 6/Y .0B
b - ?O 6.6/Y
-Y 5/ 6/Y$V
=K , .,
: p 6B
5
J - O 6/Y +O \=O Q1
<.
-Y /$ 5/ ? /2 < B .x
-9 6/Y?/
,Q
V .
; / " 6
2
O
"7O
6[/
6 JJ
A?B0
/\ 0.
R
V : 0 0
pO R.
0 :0R? ,/Y ./z
$ 0 ,\
B( J-./z
RB
0/
B 6 J$.
(? / J/+ ) 6( >/ /Y ./z
O
V 0B 8/ g J9 , 0 J
x
.7O =0
x A?B
- b+R
x
/0R
g O( * [Y " /w?
R"
6 -O/Q B 0G R
V /??B
[+ < 0
x[Y.
/ g p J /d , ) :O
_ 8
,
/R
6
_ J A?B
6[
]\ Q
Y$ 0 RO b$H 8
_
6 JG(.
0 \ 2+0 . Q
V + \ 2
0
\2
62 V; : ?/Y
RB
5
\ 2[.
=/
B O.+
( p
/
B.
Q
V J.0
E)A&/2
:
RB
0
/ ) / ;W 2 / [`(/
[
x
6 J2/ J?.J+
0G R
V \
Q )
( b1
5
RB
0
/ / [`./
Q
V ( ?
R V 0 6R
V ; pY
V O9/ ,2
bBR.,
0G
>+ =0R
V 5
RR
V \
Q.
!+ &+-!"
a@szja@n
www.rsscrs.info
+
,8 !$5
&;(# :#!1
= 0
0
= 2 =
2 V 0 = 2 / g2
2 /w= 0B 0= 8 8 /
R > +
Q
?B A[= / 6 / 8 6 ,` 6 9 +
8
/7 ? < ( 0; :[2
6 J/d) :O x2Q[/ \0
(0
O0+=$ (0( /z +w/Q
RB K > ?/ /2Q >GK 0 7O
0
A?B= R b *W 6 /7O=
RB ; /.(b
:!24-:
[= + 6
6? ,[/ ? 0
AQ
/ 8
/ A0
,7O
.,
: ,- :(
2
60 8+Y .
0 ,8 %58 0R? :
? ,\/ AQ,
/`K b1
G /G ??B( \/
/5O ABO J>+ -0 0 $ /,7 -
WY
= 61 8 00B / ,2B
;
.
81( ,2B
7= J / 7O = O 6 > ?+
XB;
. J
$
] /`K 0= I 6 00
J
J
,7O$
g2 0 (
.+
- :
=/ Q[(
$ /Q
x
6
K/Q
=K J$ $ ;( , / VO IQY
2 _
/Q
] I
?
.
!+ &+-!"
a@szja@n
www.rsscrs.info
: =
Attitudes /[ /Y Semantic W ,
Motivation 9QB
k Interpretation /Q
Actuation x/B
k Stimulation :+( 8
Interaction Q
Communication VR
:&-
Carefully 9 Intelligently
:
Findings OV Introduction 0?
Recommendations 5
Conclusion G /?Q
:?
Disgust
Body ,
Gesture 9_H Bored J
:=&
Mediator X Arbitrator ,2
1!/
#&-
&(&/)I
1!
+
:/;
: &(8- : &(A
Anxiety A= I
Angry p1w
Concerned +
W\ , Annoyed A-
Fear p \G
Bitter /
Horrified p/ / Contempt (
Intimidated / 0 Furious .p-W
Nervous
G 9 +R Irritated .p-W d
Panicked Q / Pissed Off W 9_\
Scared 8 Q Resentful *
Terrified / p/ Upset A= /-
Uneasy A= x+
/ I : &(!"
Worried + /-
Crushed ,YB
:&
&?+&/ Defeated J[ p 9
Alienated 9/0+ ( gB Discouraged X`
Aloof , V 9O Helpless
V 9
Bewilderment x+
/0O / Hopeless O _
g
Bored ,_ K / - Inadequate .pO/, /w
Cold + /w / Incompetent J &/ I /w
Disconnected R
V
Y? JRQO Insecure 99 A` /w
Put Off pO 0R Sad p_ 69
&
1!
84A
& 1!
!+ &+-!"
a@szja@n
www.rsscrs.info