Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Evaluation Form For Paper of Conference of Indonesian Students Association in South Korea (Cisak) 2017
Evaluation Form For Paper of Conference of Indonesian Students Association in South Korea (Cisak) 2017
Paper ID:
Paper Title (at least the first four-words of paper title should be written):
Dear reviewers,
This form is consisted of three sections in two pages. First, please fill your identity and date at the top of this
page, followed by paper code and title. In this form, you are kindly asked to evaluate the paper article at hand
based on a number of criteria, and then give some additional comments and recommendation.
Section C. Recommendation
For each number 1-3, please put one mark v or x within bracket [ ] to represent your recommendation.
1. Paper Acceptance 2. Recommendation Level for Best 3. Need second round (last) review?
[ ] Accepted without revision Paper Award [ ] Yes
[ ] Accepted with revision [ ] Not recommended [ ] No
[ ] Rejected for reason below [ ] High
[ ] Very High
4. Remark/Reason (if rejected):