Article ID: 007

Reviewer Manuscript Evaluation Form

The International Conference on “Education for Social Innovation:
1st
Knowledge for Sustainable Development” March 26, 2022

Title of Manuscript: Students’ Experiences with the Online Flipped English Writing Class

Please rate each aspect of the research study in scale from 1 – Strongly Disagree to
5 – Strongly Agreed. (Type letter X in the appropriate box)

No. Statements 1 2 3 4 5

1 The title is connected to the content of the X

research paper.
2 An argument for the need to conduct research X
on the topic was clear.
3 The research methodology was appropriate to X
address hypotheses / research questions.
4 Study results were clearly interpreted or X
communicated.
5 The research study made a contribution to the X
advancement of teaching and learning.
6 The writing style was in accordance with X
APA6.
7 The research paper was well written and X
expressed.
8 The research study presented new ideas for X Total
results that have not been previously published /40
Total 12 25 37

Reviewer’s recommendation: check one (Check in the appropriate box)

☐ Accept
☒Accept after minor revisions
☐Reject

Suggestions for Improvement:

1. Clarify the type of design/type of qualitative research.
2. Give examples of respondents' answers to the research results.
3. Fix the spaces in the reference list.
 Elements Suggestions

Abstract Abstracts are written with adequate descriptions to represent the

contents of the writing

The use of grammar is fairly good.

No plagiarism found.

Introduction No plagiarism found.

Study Purpose The researcher did not write specifically about the purpose of the
study.

Study Design The researcher did not specify what qualitative research design
was used.

Research Respondent selection is well described.

Findings and Well delivered

Conclusions
It is better if the researcher displays examples of respondents'
answers to give confidence to the reader about the research
results.

Discussions / Explained with good and logical arguments

Recommendations

Research Research findings are very useful for developing learning

contribution methods, especially for online lectures

Writing style in Writing style in accordance with APA 6th edition still needs a
accordance with APA little correction, related to spaces in references
6th edition)