Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I201621261
Abstract
China is the worlds number one country with most population while Indonesia is
the fourth. There was a policy in China to control the population growth, which is called One
Child Policy, but already changed to 2 children policy. They can have 2 children per family
within some conditions. Indonesia also has been trying to control the population growth since
many years ago. Each country has their own policy and the positive-negative side, and this paper
is to study them.
Background Introduction
A population is the number of all the organisms of the same group or species, which live
in a particular geographical, and have the capability of interbreeding. The area that is used to
define a sexual population is defined as the area where interbreeding is potentially possible
between any pair within the area, and where the probability of interbreeding is greater than the
probability of cross breeding with individuals from other areas. In sociology, population refers to
a collection of humans. Demogprahy is a social science which entails the statistical study of
human populations.
The number of inhabitants on the planet, now to some degree in abundance of three
billion people, is developing at around two for each penny a year, or quicker than at whatever
other period in man's history. While there has been an enduring increment of populace
development amid the previous a few centuries, it has been particularly quick amid the previous
20 years. To value the pace of populace development we ought to review that total populace
multiplied in around 1,700 years from the time of Christ until the center of the seventeenth
century; it multiplied again in around 200 years, multiplied again in under 100, and, if the current
rate of population increase were to remain constant, would double every 35 years. Moreover, this
It is easy to see why some people have become alarmists when it comes to population
growth rates in developing nations. Looking at the worlds low-income countries, they see a
population of more than 2 billion growing at a rate that suggests a doubling every 31 years. How
will we cope with so many more people? The following statement captures the essence of widely
expressed concerns:
At the end of each day, the world now has over two hundred thousand more mouths to
feed than it had the day before; at the end of each week, one and one-half million more; at the
close of each year, an additional eighty million. Humankind, now doubling its numbers every
thirty-five years, has fallen into an ambush of its own making; economists call it the Malthusian
trap, after the man who most forcefully stated our biological predicament: population growth
tends to outstrip the supply of food.Phillip Appleman, ed., Thomas Robert Malthus: An Essay
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 5
on the Principle of PopulationText, Sources and Background, Criticism (New York: Norton,
1976), xi.
In any case, what are we to put forth of such an expression? Unquestionably, if the total
population keeps on expanding at the rate that it developed in the previous 50 years, monetary
development is more averse to be converted into a change in the normal way of life. Thus, the
rate of populace development is not a steady; it is influenced by other financial powers. This area
starts with a dialog of the connection between populace development and wage development,
then swings to a clarification of the wellsprings of populace development in low-pay nations, and
closes with a discourse of the Malthusian cautioning recommended in the quote above.
Population of China
China is the world's most populous country, with about 1.34 billion people (2010 census),
but the birthrate has been falling significantly from more than 20 per 1,000 people in 1990 to
about 12 today. (Hays, 2013). There is an old joke that goes: " In China when they say you are
one in a million there are a thousand just like you." There are twice the same number of
individuals in China as there are in European Union and the Assembled States combinied. India
is the main other nation that has achieved the one billion mark. Together China and India
represent 33% of the total populace and 60 percent of Asia's population. India is relied upon to
have a greater number of individuals than China by the year 2030 therefore of having a less
China is a case of a nation that has accomplished a low rate of populace development and
a high rate of development in per capita GNP. China's low rate of populace development speaks
to an emotional move. As of late as the mid 1970s, China had a generally high rate of populace
development; its populace extended at a yearly rate of 2.7% from 1965 to 1973. By the 1980s,
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 6
that rate had dove to 1.5%. The World Bank reports a development rate in China's populace of
Population of Indonesia
Indonesia is the forth most populous nation in the world after China, India and the United
States. Population: 253,609,643 (July 2014 est.). The population of Indonesia was 237.6 million
according to preliminary 2010 census figures released in August 2010 with an annual growth rate
of 1.1 percent. This marked an increase of about 35 million since 2000. [Source: CIA World
With such a huge population, every social problem is magnified. If 10 percent of the
population in China is unemployed, for example, the number of people out of work is equal to
half the population of the United States. A migrant from Henan told journalist Howard French,
Im frightened for my son's future, China's biggest problem is the population. There are just too
many of us, and the competition for opportunity is murderous." [Source: Howard W. French,
A strict government approach by which couples are permitted to have just a single child.
Disincentives have been known to incorporate fines, loss of business, seizure of property,
pulverization of homes, constrained premature births, and disinfection. While the Chinese
government has denied that constrained premature births and disinfections are a piece of its
technique, strategies are directed locally, and the greater part of the above methods for
compulsion appear to have been utilized at some time. In the event that a lady who as of now has
one child ends up plainly pregnant, she will probably be compelled to have an abortion.
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 7
In spite of the fact that the strategy has accomplished its coveted outcomediminished
populace developmentit has had some unpleasant reactions. Given a solid social custom
favoring having a child, a few couples fall back on child murder as a methods for disposing of
baby girls. At the point when the sex of an unborn child is resolved to be female, abortion is
normal.
The coercive parts of China's approaches and their undesirable symptoms have been
Cairo in 1994 and the UN Gathering on Ladies in Beijing in 1995have stressed that birth rates
are connected to the monetary states of ladies and that enhancing wellbeing, training, and
business open doors for ladies constitutes a superior and more others conscious method for
lessening birth rates. Dreadful that ace majority rule government and human rights activists from
different nations may mix up those developments locally, the Chinese government really planned
the 1995 Beijing Meeting to limit contact amongst Chinese and nonnatives.
There are signs, however, that Chinese authorities may have heard the message. In
various districts in China, exploratory projects with mottos, for example, "Complete
Contraception and Family Arranging Measures Deliberately" are in progress. The new way to
deal with family arranging underscores social insurance, training, and diminishment in
Traditionally, Indonesian society has viewed children as the source of rejeki (fortune). A
local saying, banyak anak banyak rejeki, maintained that more children equated to more
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 8
fortune and it was widely believed that the use of contraceptives contravened religious and moral
Rural and remote areas have more limited access to healthcare than urban areas. Studies
suggest that, as of 2014, 40 per cent of Indonesians do not have access to proper sanitation
facilities. Improving access to sanitation facilities and improving education in regard to safe
hygiene practices will be vital to achieving better basic health outcomes. Maternal mortality has
also increased in recent years. In 2007, there were 288 deaths per 100,000 births. By 2014, this
The economic growth rate must increase in order to ensure job creation and maintain low
The Indonesian education system lags behind those of other regional states.
Unsurprisingly, it trails behind wealthy Singapore, but it also lags behind Vietnam, a country
with a per capita GDP two-fifths lower than that of Indonesia. Tellingly, at the end of their school
careers, only 25 per cent of Indonesia students meet minimum standards in literacy and
numeracy.
Indonesian education system. Three separate government ministries are responsible for various
parts of the system, the education ministry oversees state primary, junior and secondary schools;
the religious affairs ministry is responsible for madrassas (Islamic schools) and the ministry for
Corruption also remains a major impediment to the proper functioning of the education
system. According to Indonesian Corruption Watch, there are very few schools that are free of
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 9
graft, bribery or embezzlement. It claims that in some schools up to 40 per cent of the budget is
lost to corruption.
You know a country is overpopulated when people cannot afford to queue. In Indonesia
this is visible every day at bus and train stations. Transport facilities have long lost their battle
These every day scenes will be worse during the Eid festival, when rich individuals pass
out cash to the poor who pass on battling for a couple of money. Or, on the other hand those of
kids offered confection. Once in a while observed hostility on their blameless countenances
when they are attempting to get their offer. Waiting politely for your turn is only affordable to
social issues. Some of these, such as an ageing population, will not be experienced until after
2050. Others social issues relating to education, employment, the distribution of wealth and
urbanisation, will likely be made manifest in the near-term. The current administration will need
to ensure that it has the correct policy settings to address them. (FDI TEAM, 2015)
The relationship between population growth and economic development has been a
recurrent theme in economic analysis since at least 1798 when Thomas Malthus famously argued
that population growth would depress living standards in the long run. The theory was simple:
given that there is a fixed quantity of land, population growth will eventually reduce the amount
of resources that each individual can consume, ultimately resulting in disease, starvation, and
war. The way to avoid such unfortunate outcomes was moral restraint (i.e. refraining from
having too many children). He didnt foresee the technological advances that would raise
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 10
agricultural productivity and reduce the toll of infectious diseasesadvances that have enabled
the worlds population to grow from 1 billion in 1798 to 7.4 billion today. (Fox & Dyson, 2015)
danger to financial advancement stayed powerful and educated global improvement arrangement
motivation, particularly in the 1960sa period set apart by exceptionally fast rates of population
Quantity vs Quality: Around then, the general perspective of financial analysts was that
high birth rates and quick populace development in poor nations would redirect rare capital far
from funds and speculation, along these lines putting a delay monetary advancement. They
speculated that bigger families have less total assets and less assets per kid. Bigger families in
this manner spread their assets all the more meagerly to bolster more kids. This leaves less to
save and putting resources into development improving exercises. It additionally decreases
High birth rates and rapid population growth in poor countries would divert scarce capital
away from savings and investment, thereby placing a drag on economic development. Change in
age composition creates a window of opportunity during which a country can potentially raise its
level of savings and investmenta phenomenon now known as the demographic dividend.
In 1798, Thomas Robert Malthus distributed his essay Essay on the Principle of
Population. It turned out to be a standout amongst the most continuing works of the time.
Malthus' essential contention was that populace development will definitely slam into
unavoidable losses. Unavoidable losses infer that adding more work to a settled amount of land
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 11
builds yield, however by ever littler sums. In the end, Malthus finished up, increments in
nourishment generation would be too little to support the expanded number of individuals who
devour that yield. As the populace kept on becoming unchecked, the quantity of individuals
would in the long run overwhelm the capacity of the land to produce enough sustenance. There
would be an unavoidable Malthusian trap, a time when the world is no longer ready to meet the
nourishment prerequisites of the populace, and starvation turns into the essential check to
populace development.
We can determine the total amount of food needed by multiplying the population in any
period by the amount of food required to keep one person alive. Because population grows
exponentially, food requirements rise at an increasing rate, as shown by the curve labeled Food
required. Food produced, according to Malthus, rises by a constant amount each period; Its
increase is shown by an upward-sloping straight line labeled Food produced. Food required
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 12
eventually exceeds food produced, and the Malthusian trap is reached at time t1. The faster the
bolster the populace development inferred by the "Sustenance required" bend. Rather,
individuals starve, and populace starts rising numerically, kept within proper limits by the
"Sustenance delivered" bend. Starvation turns into the constraining power for populace; the
populace lives at the edge of subsistence. For Malthus, the long-run destiny of individuals was a
way of life scarcely adequate to keep them alive. As he put it, "the view has a despairing tone."
Joyfully, Malthus' forecasts don't coordinate the experience of Western social orders in
the nineteenth and twentieth hundreds of years. One shortcoming of his contention is that he
neglected to consider the additions in yield that could be accomplished through expanded
utilization of physical capital and new innovations in agribusiness. Increments in the measure of
capital per specialist as machines, enhanced seed, water system, and preparation have made
conceivable colossal increments in agrarian yield in the meantime as the supply of work was
rising. Farming efficiency climbed quickly in the Assembled States in the course of the most
recent two centuries, the exact inverse of the fall in profitability expected by Malthus. Efficiency
Malthus wasn't right too about the connection between populace development and salary.
He trusted that any expansion in wage would support populace development. However, the law
of interest discloses to us that the inverse might be valid: higher salaries have a tendency to
diminish populace development. The essential cost of having kids is the open door cost of the
guardians' chance in raising themhigher salaries increment this open door cost. Higher
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 13
livelihoods increment the cost of having kids and have a tendency to lessen the quantity of kids
Figure2: Salary Levels and Populace Development. Panel (a) shows that low-income
nations had much higher total fertility rates (births per woman) during the 20002005 period
than did high-income nations. In Panel (b), we see that low-income nations had a much higher
"Salary Levels and Populace Development" demonstrates the birth rates of low-, center ,
and high-wage nations for the period 20002005. We see that the higher the pay level, the lower
the birth rate. Less births convert into slower populace development. In Board (b), we see that
high-salary countries had much slower rates of populace development than did center and low-
likewise expand it. One of the principal picks up a creating country can accomplish is upgrades
in such nuts and bolts as the arrangement of clean drinking water, enhanced sanitation, and
general wellbeing measures, for example, inoculation against youth infections. Such picks up can
drastically decrease sickness and passing rates. As alluring in that capacity picks up seem to be,
they additionally support the rate of populace development. Countries are probably going to
appreciate sharp decreases in death rates before they accomplish picks up in per capita wage.
That can quicken populace development right on time in the advancement procedure.
ascends with a fall in death rates and afterward falls with a lessening in birth rates.
The procedure of statistic move has unfurled in a strikingly extraordinary way in created
versus less created countries in the course of recent hundreds of years. In 1800, birth rates
scarcely surpassed passing rates in both created and less created nations. The outcome was a rate
of populace development of just around 0.5% every year around the world. By 1900, the demise
rate in created countries had fallen by around 25%, with little change in the birth rate. Among
creating countries, the birth rate was unaltered, while the passing rate was down just somewhat.
The joined outcome was an unobtrusive increment in the rate of total populace development.
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 15
There are four broad ways in which a countrys GDP per capita can increase.
The first is to increase the number of labor hours worked, either because a larger share of
the population is employed or because employed workers are working more hours per year. In
turn, the employment ratio can increase either because more people join the labor force -- those
The three remaining sources of growth in per capita GDP represent different sources of
Investment in physical capital increases the quality and quantity of equipment that each
worker uses to produce output, and thereby increases workers productive capacity;
Investment in human capital -- skills and knowledge, through education and training --
improves the performance of the workforce by enabling them to do more complex and more
productive tasks; and Improvements in the productivity with which capital and labor are used,
resulting in more valuable output from the same value of physical inputs. This source of output
growth is known as total factor productivity or TFP, and it has been by far the most important
source of growth in U.S. GDP per capita, as the table below -- copied from Charles Joness essay
Similarly, developing countries have far greater scope to improve the allocation of
resources from less productive to more productive uses. The most obvious example of this
reallocation is the shift of the labor force from traditional agriculture to modern agriculture as
well as to modern industry and services, where output per worker tends to be much higher. In
addition, most developing countries have considerable scope to improve average productivity by
adopting policies that allow and encourage more productive firms to expand and less productive
firms to disappear and release their workers to their more productive competitors. Here again, the
role of policies and institutions is crucial, creating incentives that either encourage or block such
organizations in the nation all the more so the legislature can spend more. The obvious issue here
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 17
is exhausting the overall public means they will spend less in the private part. At first look this is
a zero entirety diversion. That implies the spending is moved yet not expanded.
Expanding private area monetary movement should be possible numerous ways. The
least demanding for an administration to utilize is to lessen controls that force an additional heap
on organizations and inhabitants. Regardless of the possibility that the main diminishment is in a
requirement for detailing measurable data on a business the time spent on that report could be
better spent on creating more products and ventures or creating more deals. More huge controls
have a greater effect in the event that they are evacuated. Then again (prime financial specialist
talk) expanding controls on organizations and occupants is sure to decrease private part monetary
An exceptional case exists in the territory of foundation. An awesome case of this is the
exertion in the USA amid the Common War (1860 to 1865) to interface numerous territories with
railways. A comparable occasion occurred after World War II when the old national expressway
framework was supplemented with the Interstate Thruway framework which could deal with
significantly more movement with no inalienable deferrals as the new parkways avoided towns
and urban areas as opposed to going directly through the center of every one. Both of these
foundation ventures empowered lower cost and more quick transportation of individuals and
There is a surprising news that was submitted by Chinese authorities, namely the end of
"one child policy" policy in China. The Chinese government now allows families to have two
children for whom one parent is the result of a one-child policy, which is one of the most
extreme demographic policies in the world. The Chinese government has given a stern sanction
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 18
to those who violate it, including fines in the form of money and imprisonment and loss of work,
and many demographers judge that an end to "one child policy" policy is a victim of China's
economic progress which began to dominate the world. The world's strongest economies look to
the eyes of the world's economy. At that time the economic power in Asia is held by Japan. It is
the map of world economic power has changed because China has been transformed not only
become economic power in Asia but has become a world economic power. This is evident when
China lowered the value of its currency, the world economy And also the value of other countries
shook great currency. No doubt China is now playing an important role and determining the map
of the world economy. However, this remarkable economic development of China is not
accompanied by sufficient social capital due to the erosion of the productive age group which is
one of the impacts of the implementation of "one child policy" implemented about 35 years ago.
What is the "one child Policy" "One Child Policy" adopted by the Chinese government in 1979
only allows couples to have one child only. In some rural areas as well as for ethnic minorities
under the "one child policy" policy still allows couples to have a second child if the first child is
female. This policy resulted in abortion cases as well as female infanticide. The greatest impact
of this policy is in addition to slowing the growth of the productive age category population and
also creating an imbalance between male and female population or in terms of demography
The policy of "one child policy" controversy adopted in 1979 has made the Chinese
government rethink due to its bad impact and if it continues will affect China's competitiveness
in the future.
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 19
The impact of the implementation of the "one child policy" program on productive age
groups and old age in China compared to the world population. China faces an increasingly
Since the implementation of this policy China has been successful in preventing the birth
of 400 million, but what is worrisome is the demographic structure of China is increasingly
dominated by the old age group. This condition in the demographics is called the "aging
population". This is the condition that worries Chinese demographers and sociologists because it
will have an impact on social problems and a decline in the labor force that can not sustain
China's economic development in the future. This demographic policy reliance is intended to
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 20
improve the balance of Chinese population growth. Currently as much as 30% of China's
The 35-year policy of China has now become a time bomb because it has resulted in an
increasingly aging Chinese population and a declining workforce. The United Nations is
predicting that by 2050, Chinese people aged 60 and above will reach 440 million people, while
the 15-59-year-old workforce declines by 3.71 million annually and this downward trend is
expected to continue.
The lax birth regime to be adopted by China is considered too late and can not rapidly
demographicize the demographic structure. For example, 30,000 families in Beijing are only
6.7% who meet the criteria for having a second child. But the Beijing municipal government
says that through this policy there will be an additional 54,200 child births annually.
applying kebikan because the impact is only visible within the next 20-30 years.
Indonesia under the Soeharto government was once successful in controlling the growth
of the Indonesian population by implementing a family planning program with the motto "Just
Two Children Only". This policy is considered to be quite successful in controlling the growth
rate of the Indonesian population and has an impact on demographic bonuses in which the
Indonesian productive age population in the next 10-20 years is one of the best demographic
properly. However, the increase of the productive age population which is not accompanied by
adequate educational and skill preparation will turn into a burden and cause social problems that
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 21
will reduce Indonesia's competitiveness in the future. Indonesia classified as a country that will
grow rapidly the population. If Indonesia can not control the rate of population growth then
uncontrolled population will be a big problem in the future. Lessons can be learned from cases of
tightening birth rates in China. The birth control program in Indonesia without any adverse and
harmful effects in the future should have begun to prepare by the government if Indonesia wants
Problem Statements
China is the worlds most populated country. Indonesia is the fourth. And they are
still growing until now. China has a very high rate in growth per capita in GDP, but not for
Indonesia. Is it true that the population growth and economic growth are connected? How to
control the population growth and keep the economic growth in balance?
Conclusion
The focus on human capital as a driver of financial development for creating nations
has prompted undue consideration on school fulfillment. Creating nations have gained
impressive ground in shutting the crevice with created nations as far as school achievement,
however late research has underscored the significance of psychological abilities for
quality, and there creating nations have been a great deal less fruitful in shutting the holes
with created nations. Without enhancing school quality, creating nations will think that its
Improvements in long run development are firmly identified with the level of
nations, while enhancing in school accomplishment, have not enhanced in quality terms. School
strategy in creating nations ought to consider upgrading both essential and propelled abilities.
The two-kid standard has clearly been rising in Indonesia, as demonstrated by the way
that almost 40 percent of all married ladies see two children as the perfect and over portion of the
ladies with two kids need no more. The present fertility rate proposes that this extent will
increment in consequent eras. Actually, a few areas in Indonesia have come to or are moving
toward substitution level. In Yogyakarta, DKI Jakarta, Bali, East Java, and possibly North
In addition to provincial variation, the two critical covariates of the inclination for smaller
families are ladies' instruction and ladies' presentation to broad communications. Ladies' training
has all the earmarks of being decidedly and reliably connected with inclinations for a littler
family estimate. This is additionally valid for ladies' presentation to broad communications. Far
beyond the impact of instruction, perusing daily papers, staring at the TV, and tuning in to radio
This examination demonstrates the proceeding with rise and improvement of a two-kid
standard in Indonesia. Unless policy changes relax the family planning programs' strong anti-
natalist policy, the objectives of accomplishing substitution level ripeness by the year 2015 and
zero population development by the year 2050 are presumably not very goal-oriented.
POPULATION POLICY IN CHINA AND INDONESIA 23
Bibliography
Hays, J. (2013, - -). Facts and Details. Retrieved 6 6, 2017, from Facts and Details:
http://factsanddetails.com/china/cat4/sub15/item129.html
http://www.aljazeera.com/blogs/asia/2015/03/indonesia-facing-overpopulation-crisis-
150319200635063.html
http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/
Fox, S., & Dyson, T. (2015, 12 3). IGC. Retrieved 6 6, 2017, from IGG International
development/
FDI TEAM. (2015, 8 27). Future Directions International. Retrieved 6 6, 2017, from
demographic-issues-in-indonesia/
quora. (2016, 9 13). How do countries increase their GDP per capita? (D. Sillers,
Interviewer)