Date: Sheet 1

BRAIN Debating Competition

Adjudication Sheet
Topic:

1st Speaker School: 2nd Speaker School:

Definition: Definition:

Allocation: 1st spkr. 2nd spkr. Allocation: 1st spkr. 2nd spkr.
Team Line? Team Line?

Case clear? Case clear?

Method score /16 Method score /16

Arguments: Rebuttal/Arguments:

Matter score /32 Matter score /32

Effectiveness of delivery: Effectiveness of delivery:

Manner score /32 Manner score /32

Total: /80 Total: /80
Commendable aspects: Commendable aspects:

Weaknesses: Weaknesses:
Which of these two speakers was more convincing?
Why?

Sheet 2
BRAIN Debating Competition
Adjudication Sheet
3rd Speaker 4th Speaker
Rebuttal/Arguments: Rebuttal/Arguments:

Matter score /32 Matter score /32

Effectiveness of delivery: Effectiveness of delivery:

Manner score /32 Manner score /32

Teamwork, continuity, consistency, use of time Teamwork, continuity, consistency, use of time

Method score /16 Method score /16

Total: /80 Total: /80
Commendable aspects: Commendable aspects:

Weaknesses: Weaknesses:
Which of these two speakers was more convincing? Why?

Who is winning the debate at this stage and by how much?

Sheet 3
BRAIN Debating Competition
Adjudication Sheet
5th Speaker 6th Speaker
Rebuttal/Summary Rebuttal/Summary

Matter score /32 Matter score /32

Effectiveness of delivery: Effectiveness of delivery:

Manner score /32 Manner score /32

Teamwork, continuity, consistency, use of time Teamwork, continuity, consistency, use of time,
no new material

Method score /16 Method score /16

Total: /80 Total: /80
Commendable aspects: Commendable aspects:

Weaknesses: Weaknesses:
Which of these two speakers was more convincing?

Who won the overall debate and why?