I.

ISP224 ACCEPTANCE LETTER

Inbo
X
x
Reply

show details Apr
1) PromoteResearch 10 
 to me, kshitij223
Dear Colleague(s),
 
On behalf of the committee of the 2010 International Conference on Information Security and Privacy (ISP-10), we
are pleased to inform you that your paper:
RWD - Securing Mobile Ad-hoc Networks from Wormhole Attacks
Maharaja Agrasen Institute of Technology, New Delhi, India
paper reference number: isp224
has been accepted for oral presentation at the ISP-10 conference to be held in Orlando, FL, USA during July 12-14,
2010. Congratulations! The reviewers’ comments are attached to this email. The paper will be included in the
conference proceedings provided the authors complete all the formalities (according to the timelines) specified in
this email.
 
The conference organizers should receive the revised and properly formatted final paper, copyright form and the
registration fee before April 26, 2010.
 
Details regarding submission of final paper, copyright form:
1.           Send an email to contact@promoteresearch.org,  as explained below:
a.       The subject of the email should be the paper number.
b.      The body (i.e., content) of the email should contain the following: (i). the statement “final
paper and material submission” (ii). the name of the author who presents the paper during the
conference (i.e., in favor of whom the registration fee is/will be paid) (iii). the title of the paper
and the names of all the authors (in the same order they appear in the final paper. Make sure there
are no mistakes in the title or author names).
c.       The email should  contain the following attachments: 
                                                              i.      The final paper (no headers, footers, page numbers or
security settings. But it should contain the authors’ details and affiliations) should be no
more than 8 pages in WORD or PDF format and should be formatted and submitted as
per the instructions provided at: http://www.promoteresearch.org/2010/additional-
information/paper-submission.html 
                                                            ii.       The scanned copyright form and submission instructions
are   available at:http://www.promoteresearch.org/2010/additional-information/paper-
submission.html
 
2.           Details regarding payment of the registration fee:
The registration fee amount is provided at the conference website. Please see the registration
page:http://www.promoteresearch.org/2010/additional-information/fee-payment.html for
registration fee payment options.
 
 
Note 1: This email cannot be used for applying for your Visa, if needed, to enter the USA. If you want,
we may send a separate letter for Visa purpose, once you fulfill the above requirements such as final
paper, copyright form, registration fee, etc.
 
Note 2: If you need any additional information on this email or any other matter related to the
conference, you please contact us at contact@promoteresearch.org only.
 
The registration fee allows you to get a copy of the above conference proceedings during the conference. It will also
allow you to attend any one or more conferences that are planned to take place at the same time and place, as part of
MULTICONF-10. The fee also allows you to take part in the conference banquet and other services (and/or
material) that we may provide.
 
Once again, congratulations and look forward to see you in Orlando. We hope you enjoy the event!
 
Sincerely
 
Dimitrios Karras, Zoran Majkic, John Edward
(ISP-10 organizing committee)
 
 
PS: The registration fee is non-refundable. In case of disasters such as hurricanes, earth quakes and/or other events
that are beyond the control of the organizers then the organizers’ responsibility will be limited to mail the
proceedings after the conference. The conference organizers are not responsible for the delay and/or loss of the
registration fee payments and/or other communications made by the authors.  The conference schedule will be
announced later on and it is subject to change. In case the proceedings are not ready by the time of the conference
due to circumstances beyond the control of the organizers then the organizers will provide the proceedings after the
conference.
 
 
 
2 attachments — Download all attachments  
isp224-1.txt
2K   Open as a Google
document   View   Download  
isp224-2.txt
2K   Open as a Google
document   View   Download  
 Forwar
 Reply  Reply to all
d
 
 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Title of the Paper:RWD - Securing Mobile Ad-hoc Networks from Wormhole Attacks

Paper id:224

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Primary factors that determine the acceptance/rejection decision.
The decision will be based on the scores below (mandatory). 1=worst, 5=best

Relevance to conference (1-5):5

Originality (1-5):4

Contribution (1-5):4

Technical quality (1-5):4

Writing Style and Language (1-5):5

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Secondary factors that influence the acceptance/rejection decision.
Scores: 1=worst, 5=best. Comments are welcome, wherever necessary

Abstract is perfect (1-5):5

Introduction (1-5):5

Organization of the Content (1-5):5

Figures (1-5):3

Critical Discussion/Evaluation (1-5):3

Conclusions (1-5):4

References (1-5):4

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--

Recommendation: >a) Full paper b) Short paper c) Reject

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--

Additional comments, if any, for communications to authors:

Put the actual programs on a website and provide a link to them in the paper.

Providng the performnce studies by considering the nodes with non-empty

routing tables will enhance the work.

Overall, a good piece of work!

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--

Confidential comments to organizers:

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Title of the Paper: RWD - Securing Mobile Ad-hoc Networks from Wormhole
Attacks

Paper id: ISP/224

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Primary factors that determine the acceptance/rejection decision.
The decision will be based on the scores below (mandatory). 1=worst, 5=best

Relevance to conference (1-5): 5

Originality (1-5): 4

Contribution (1-5): 3

Technical quality (1-5): 5

Writing Style and Language (1-5): 5

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Secondary factors that influence the acceptance/rejection decision.
Scores: 1=worst, 5=best. Comments are welcome, wherever necessary

Abstract is perfect (1-5): 5

Introduction (1-5): 4

Organization of the Content (1-5): 5

Figures (1-5): 5

Critical Discussion/Evaluation (1-5): 4

Conclusions (1-5): 4

References (1-5): 4

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--

Recommendation: Full paper

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--

Additional comments, if any, for communications to authors:

The paper is very convincing but the real merit depends on how fast it can
determine the wormhole in a large-scale network.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Confidential comments to organizers: