You are on page 1of 7

THE PATH AHEAD

Is Mold Toxicity Really a Problem for Our


Patients? Part 2—Nonrespiratory Conditions
Joseph Pizzorno, ND, Editor in Chief; Ann Shippy, MD

Abstract
In my last editorial, I addressed the respiratory effects of that toxins have now become a primary driver of disease
mold exposure. The surprising research shows that as in the general population, not only among those most
many as 50% of residential and work environments have susceptible. The mold toxicity conundrum illustrates this
water damage1 and that mold toxicity should be issue quite well. As summarized in this editorial, there
considered in all patients with any chronic respiratory clearly is a portion of the population, the size of which is
condition. This is especially true in adult-onset asthma, currently unknown, who experience neurological and/or
two-thirds of which appears to be caused by toxins immunological damage from mold toxicity. In addition,
released from water-damaged buildings. The carcinogenic a substantial portion of the population experiences
effects of food-borne mold contamination are also well chronic respiratory problems from mold exposure. This
documented. Less clear is the role of indoor mold does not mean we should stop paying attention to our
exposure in water-damaged buildings and its relationship more affected patients. Rather, we need to realize that
to nonrespiratory conditions. As we look at the research almost everyone is being affected by toxins to some
on mold toxicity and toxins in general, we propose that degree: molds, metals, solvents, persistent organic
the medical community (by all its names) has focused too pollutants, etc.
much on the “yellow canaries” and missed the big picture

National and International Organizations on Mold addition, human testing for mold toxin load via sampling
and Nonrespiratory Conditions tissue and body fluids is very limited. At the time of this
According to the World Health Organization (WHO), publication, we can test for only 4 mycotoxin groups with
“Although mycotoxins can induce a wide range of adverse 15 individual toxins. There are likely hundreds of
health effects in both animals and human beings, the mycotoxins, possibly even an order of magnitude more.
evidence that they play a role in health problems related to Another challenge with standard research is that statistical
indoor air is extremely weak.”1 The US Centers for Disease results in population groups inherently obfuscate
Control and Prevention (CDC) issued a report in 2004 individual susceptibility. This, of course, is where our
that asserts there is no conclusive evidence of medicine is so important for suffering patients who are
nonrespiratory conditions being caused by mold or damp outside those statistical norms. Clearly, we know that
buildings. Review of the current recommendations toxins affect individuals in different ways depending on
according to its Web site shows no apparent change in its their genetics, synergistic toxins present, and nutritional
position.2 These statements appear highly conclusive but status. Studies that evaluate the most important variables
are in fact based on a very limited body of published of genetics, toxin exposure, and nutritional status and
research and are probably outdated. Research in this area their complex effect on health need to be conducted.
has been limited, because it has not been possible to build
cohorts of individuals exposed to mycotoxins and their Toxins Produced in Water-damaged Buildings
controls and study them. This is due primarily to the The research is unequivocal that water-damaged
serious limitations of the testing technology used to detect buildings expose their occupants to a diverse range of toxins
the presence of hidden indoor mold. with many physiologically damaging effects. They are
There are many different testing approaches all with produced by chemical, microbial, and physical processes
unique limitations and all with many false negatives. In that break down building materials. Tables 1 and 2 list the

8 Integrative Medicine • Vol. 15, No. 3 • June 2016 Pizzorno and Shippy—The Path Ahead
Table 1. Toxic Metabolites Produced by Bacteria Isolated From Water-damaged Materials and Indoor Air3

Metabolite Organisms Physiological Effects Disease


Valinomycin Streptomyces griseus Mitochondrial poison Unknown
Leptomycin B Streptomyces species Inhibition of inducible nitric oxide synthetase Unknown
Toxic peptide Bacillus amyloliquefaciens Depolarized transmembrane; decreased ATP Unknown
and NADH cell death
Mitochondrial toxin Bacillus pumilus Disruption of mitochondrial membrane Unknown
Mitochondrial toxin Nocardiopsis species Disruption of mitochondrial membrane Unknown
Cytostatic compounds Coculture of Stachybotrys Cytotoxic compounds that are just as toxic as Unknown
chartarum and doxorubicin and AMD
Stachybotrys californicus

Abbreviations: ATP, adenosine triphosphate; NADH, nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide + hydrogen;


AMD, actinomycin D.

Table 2. Mycotoxins Produced by Toxic Molds3

Metabolite Organisms Physiological Effects Disease


Gliotoxin Aspergillus fumigatus, Immune toxicity, immune Invasive
terreus, flavus, niger; suppression, neurotoxicity aspergillosis
Trichoderma virens;
Penicillium spp;
Candida albicans
Aflatoxin B1, kojic acid, Aspergillus flavus Liver pathology and cancer, immune Carcinogenesis
aspergillic acid, toxicity, neurotoxicity
nitropropionic acid
Fumigaclavines, Aspergillus fumigatus Lung disease, neurotoxicity, tremors, Aspergillosis
fumitoxins, immune toxicity
fumitremorgins,
verruculogen, gliotoxin
Ochratoxin A Immunosuppression BEN
Urinary tract tumors Aspergillus niger BEN
Aspergillosis Penicillium Lung disease
verrucosum
Ochratoxin A Aspergillus ochraceus Nephropathology Urinary tract
damage
Penicillic acid, Tumors
xanthomegnin, viomellein,
vioxanthin
Sterigmatocystin, Aspergillus versicolor Liver pathology and cancer Carcinogenesis
5-methoxysterigmato
cystin
Chaetomiums Chaetomium globosum Cytotoxicity Unknown
Chaetoglobosum A and C Cell division Unknown
Griseofulvin Memnoniella echinata Carcinogenesis? Unknown
Dechlorogriseofulvins Reproductive toxin

Pizzorno and Shippy—The Path Ahead Integrative Medicine • Vol. 15, No. 3 • June 2016 9
Table 2. (continued)

Metabolite Organisms Physiological Effects Disease


Trichodermin Hypersensitivity?
Trichodermo Protein synthesis inhibition
Mycophenolic acid Penicillium Cytotoxic, mutagen Unknown
brevicompactum
Botryodiploidin Penicillium expansum Immune toxicity, cytotoxic Unknown
Patulin, citrinin, Tremors
chaetoglobosin,
roquefortine C
Verrucosidins Penicillium plonicium Cytotoxicity Tremors
Penicillic acid, nephrotoxic Nephropathology
glycopeptides
Trichothecenes Trichoderma species Trichothecene toxicity Unknown
Trichodermol, trichodermin, Immunotoxicity Immune
gliotoxin, viridin impairment
Fumonisins Fusarium verticillioides Neural tube defects in animals and CNS birth defects
(AKA Fusarium humans
moniliforme)
Spirocyclic Stachybotrys Respiratory bleeding Pulmonary bleeding
chartarum
Drimanes, roridin Protein synthesis inhibition
Satratoxins (F, G, H) Neurotoxicity
Hydroxyroridin E Cytotoxicity
Verrucarin J; trichodermin; Immune toxicity
dolabellanes; altrones B, C;
stachybotrylactams

Abbreviations: BEN, Balkan endemic nephropathy; CNS, central nervous system.

toxins released, organisms involved, physiological PubMed and still a huge 10 000 with limit humans. Although
dysfunctions induced, and disease associations. Although this is the area apparently of most interest in the integrative
we are focusing on molds in water-damaged buildings, medicine community, outside respiratory effects of
Table 1 shows that bacterial growth also releases toxins. mycotoxins the research is disappointingly limited.
As can be seen from the above, a wide diversity of Andrew Campbell, MD, editor in chief of our sister
physiological dysfunction can be caused by these toxins publication Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine,
released in water-damaged buildings and many have has written several excellent articles on mold toxicity. In a
associated diseases. In addition, food-borne mycotoxins comprehensive review published in 2004, Campbell in
have been shown to cause cancer, impaired child growth, collaboration with functional medicine laboratory expert
neural tube defects, immunotoxicity, gastroenteritis, and Aristo Vojdani, PhD, and colleagues5 evaluated the research
renal disease.4 on the physiological effects of mold toxins. The research
Add to this biochemical individuality, and most any they reported included the symptoms of people living or
chronic clinical condition could be caused by these toxins. working in water-damaged buildings. Particularly
The challenge is that statistical, generic research makes important is that they compared their symptoms with an
documenting such effects in specific patients very difficult “unexposed” control population. (I believe this is critical,
to prove. as too often ignoring false positives overstates the
significance of symptoms.) This is a conservative view, as
Mycotoxins the “controls” may have included individuals being
A tremendous amount of research has been published exposed to hidden active mold, which is estimated to be as
on the clinical effects mycotoxins: more than 40 000 hits in high as 50%. In Table 3, I reworked their data a bit to show

10 Integrative Medicine • Vol. 15, No. 3 • June 2016 Pizzorno and Shippy—The Path Ahead
Table 3. Symptoms Caused by Mold Toxicity/Water-damaged Buildings5

Symptom % in Exposed Population % in Controls P Value


Memory problems 5.1 3.3 .0002
Spaciness 4.8 3.2 .0007
Excessive fatigue 5.8 4.3 .0001
Coughing 4.6 3.2 .001
Slurred speech 4.5 3.1 .002
Weak voice 4.1 2.8 .003
Watery eyes 4.6 3.4 .004
Lightheadedness 4.4 3.2 .006
Dizziness 4.3 3.1 .005
Weakness 4.2 3.0 .008
Headache 5.2 4.1 .005
Throat discomfort 4.5 3.4 .008
Sinus discomfort 4.7 3.6 .01
Coordination 4.0 2.9 .01
problems
Nasal symptoms 5.1 4.1 .02
Bloating 4.2 3.2 .02
Visual changes 3.9 2.9 .02
Rash 3.9 2.9 .02

which symptoms have the best predictive value for reported that fungal VOCs had a greater toxic effect than do
suspicion of mold exposure. As can be seen, neurological formaldehyde, xylene, benzene, and toluene.10
symptoms are predominant. mVOCs increase inflammation biomarkers such as
Although damage from mold/damp buildings can myeloperoxidase, lysozyme, and eosinophil cationic
affect all systems of the body, the two nonrespiratory protein, and they cause headache, nausea, and mucosal
systems with the strongest research are neurological and irritation.11 A recent study reported:
immunological. Authors comparing mycotoxins with
pesticides have concluded that mycotoxins are more toxic The impact of fungal VOCs, 2-octenal and oct-1-en-3-ol on
than pesticides.6 In addition, fungal metabolites have bone marrow stromal cells that are vital for the appropriate
synergistic genotoxic and other harmful effects.7 development and activation of the immune system showed
increased membrane fluidity.12
Microbial Volatile Organic Compounds The same study also stated that “these vast changes in
In addition to mycotoxins, active mold produces membrane are known to contribute to the breakdown of
microbial volatile organic compounds (mVOCs). This is normal cellular function and possibly lead to death.” mVOCs
currently a very active area of research. mVOCs are low induce neurotoxicity in the Drosophila model even at very
molecular weight compounds that include numerous low concentrations inducing locomotor defects and changes
alcohols, esters, ethers, ketones, aldehydes, terpenoids, in antigen-labeled dopaminergic neurons.13 Another
thiols, and their derivatives. Because these compounds are Drosophila study showed that the mVOC 1-Octen-3-ol
small and volatile, they can diffuse into the air and enter the induces nitric oxide-mediated inflammatory response.14
body through the lungs and skin. Some researchers have
suggested that mVOCs be thought of as mycotoxins and Neurotoxicity
have proposed the term volatoxin.8 Research is showing that Neurotoxicity is clearly associated with mycotoxins
mVOCs are even more toxic than the chemicals traditionally and other chemicals produced by mold. An interesting
thought of as being industrial toxins. For example, study looked at neurobehavioral and pulmonary
1-Octen-3-ol has been shown to be more toxic to human impairment in 105 adults with indoor exposure to molds
embryonic stem cells than is toluene.9 Another study and 100 exposed to chemicals, comparing them with

Pizzorno and Shippy—The Path Ahead Integrative Medicine • Vol. 15, No. 3 • June 2016 11
202 “unexposed” community referents.15 A big challenge, While digging our way through the mold toxicity
of course, is, as noted in past IMCJ editorials, we conclude research, we came across a fascinating article that proposed
finding a control group without toxin exposure is multiple sclerosis is primarily a mold toxin disease.20 Their
essentially impossible. Looking at several respiratory basic thesis is that gliotoxin, a heat-stable secondary
measures, they found 6.1% abnormalities in mold exposed metabolite produced by various species of Aspergillus and
and 7.1% in chemical exposed compared with 1.2% Candida, suppresses immune function, increases blood-
abnormalities in controls. This is consistent with the brain-barrier permeability, and is highly neurotoxic. As is
clearly demonstrable respiratory effects reported in the well known, the incidence of multiple sclerosis (MS)
last editorial. Neurologically, they found statistically increases with distance from the equator, which also
significant problems in both exposed groups: decreased correlates with mold exposure and decreased vitamin D—a
balance, longer reaction times, increased blink reflex critical nutrient for immune system modulation. Could MS
latency, increased color discrimination errors, decreased be primarily due to the combination of mold exposure and
visual field, and reduced grip strength. They also found vitamin D deficiency?
several measures of cognitive and memory performance Another study of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS)
measures abnormal, again in both exposed groups. We patients showed a high correlation in the presence of
find interesting that they found little difference in virtually mycotoxins in the patient’s urine and having a diagnosis of
all measures between the mold and chemical exposed CFS. Of the 102 CFS patients studied, 93% had
populations. 1 mycotoxin present. Almost 30% had 2 or more
A study of 100 individuals exposed to mold in their mycotoxins present.21 Further research is warranted to
home found multiple neurological deficits in 70% and better understand this association.
abnormalities in T and B cells in more than 80% of the
patients.16 A study of 95 employees working in a well- Conclusion
documented water-damaged school building compared The research cited in this and the last editorial supports
with 110 “unexposed” controls found statistically the conclusion that indoor mold metabolites have a harmful
significant loss of visual contrast sensitivity  (VCS), an effect on human health. The nonrespiratory mold evidence,
apparently sensitive measure of neurodysfunction, as well although limited, is quite compelling. We need further
as the usual respiratory problems.17 data/research. It is somewhat shocking that more research is
An important study suggests that individuals not being done based on what is known about these
exposed to satratoxin (SH), a trichothecene, and environmental toxins and their potential effect, especially
microbial organisms results in a chronic immune given the common occurrence of water damage in buildings.
response (inflammation and oxidative stress) leading to As can be seen in Tables 1 and 2, the bacterial, mold,
neural damage.18 Their results demonstrate that and building material breakdown products have definitively
“regardless of whether the neurons were exposed to SH been documented in cell culture, animal models, and very
alone or under additive effects, the sensitivity of the limited human studies to cause diverse physiological
neurons to these compounds is high and neurological dysfunctions. The challenge when applying this data to
system cell damage can occur from SH exposure.” In humans is obvious, ranging from differences between
addition, these data demonstrate that constant activation human and animal physiology, to dramatically varying
of inflammatory and apoptotic pathways at low levels dosages, sensitization, genetic polymorphisms, etc. Even so,
amplifies the devastation and leads to neurological cell the animal, Drosophila, and human cellular studies support
damage from indirect events triggered by the presence of similar conclusions to the very limited human findings thus
a trichothecene mycotoxin. And they concluded, “From far. Note that the Disease columns in Tables 1 and 2 are full
this study and others, we show that neurological system of unknowns as the research simply has not been done or is
cell damage from exposure to mycotoxins is a potential inconclusive when considering population groups. And, as
public health threat for occupants of water-damaged we all well know, real patients are very different from
buildings.” generic populations used for statistical analyses of
significance. As can be seen in these tables, disrupting
Immunotoxicity mitochondrial function, misbalancing nitric oxide synthesis,
A number of animal studies have clearly shown mold- inflammatory mediators, neurotoxicity, cytotoxicity,
induced immunotoxicity. The research in humans is quite immune suppression, carcinogenesis, and mutagenesis—
clear that chronic mold/damp building exposure increases the list is long and can show up in virtually any clinical
production of multiple inflammatory measures and alters manifestation in our patients depending on their specific
immune function mediators. These effects are not small, exposure and unique biochemistry.
with the immune systems of those working in damp Because as many as 50% of buildings in North America
buildings reacting to exposure with 2- to 1000-fold show water damage, here are our recommendations for
increased production of a wide variety of these when to consider investigating the presence of mold toxins
inflammatory/immune mediators.19 or hidden water damage in homes and/or workplaces:

12 Integrative Medicine • Vol. 15, No. 3 • June 2016 Pizzorno and Shippy—The Path Ahead
1. Every patient with a chronic respiratory disease, peer-review process. I would to express my sincere
especially asthma. appreciation to our contributing editors for being willing
2. Every patient with a chronic disease, especially to subject themselves to this added rigor. As widely
neurological or immunological, and chronic acknowledged and leading experts in their field, having
respiratory symptoms. others critique their work might be felt as disrespectful. I
3. Any patient with a chronic disease, again especially believe their receptivity is a powerful validation of their
neurological or immunological, who is not commitment to excellence and egoless advancement of
responding as expected and all other causes have this medicine that is so critical to restoring and improving
been ruled out. health.
Associate Editor Jeffrey Bland, PhD, leads off this issue
Let us be clear: We do not believe that every patient in one with an intriguing discussion of the intersection of
of the 3 categories above is affected by mold. We do believe personalization of health care, technology, and innovation.
that potential mold exposure should be considered. With I thought particularly compelling his quote from NEJM of
the solid advances in technology for both medical and how this will impact health care professionals and
environmental testing during the last 10 years, we can professions and the choices they can make. To paraphrase:
now, as practitioners, actively begin to link medical symp- ignore, regulate, or compete. We know the choices made
toms with indoor mold exposure. For individual patients by the conventional medicine political entities in the past.
we can now use enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay Let’s not make the same mistakes.
(ELISA) testing to detect 15 mycotoxins both in the Congratulations to John Weeks, the new editor in chief
patient and in their environment and assess the relation- of Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine.
ship between the two. In addition, we can now detect and Good luck in your new endeavor my friend. In his review of
quantify the presence of 36 molds by qualitative poly- the new federal strategies on opioid addiction, he chastises
merase chain reaction (QPCR) in human tissue and the the Obama administration for total lack of consideration of
environment. nonpharmacological approaches and the non-MD healing
Genetic testing can help us to identify those most arts experts. One of the first chapters written for the
susceptible to mold toxins and other environmental toxins. Textbook of Natural Medicine in 1985 was
Genetic single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), “Non-Pharmacological Control of Pain” by Richard Kitaeff,
proteomics, and other markers of cellular function of the MA, ND, LAc. Come on people, the research has been there
immune, detoxification, mitochondrial, and methylation for more than 30 years and practiced for centuries!
systems may help identify those most susceptible and Loren Israelsen and Frank Lampe take on the very
those most affected, as well as potential treatment options. challenging issue of the politics, regulatory environment, and
In addition, assessing potential nutritional deficiencies marketplace dynamic that powerfully affect the quality of the
and levels of other environmental toxins that may help natural health products we prescribe our patients. Long-time
identify those with increased individual susceptibility. As readers will remember that we have published more than
additional research is completed, it will be imperative to 50 editorials and articles on the extremely important issue of
improve and expand these technologies. Given the product quality and safety. We practitioners must take a lead
complex nature of the interaction between the human in recognizing and supporting the companies investing the
genome and environmental toxins, this seems a likely resources to create truly great product and warn our patients
problem to be solved, at least in part, with applying the about the unscrupulous who don’t.
science of bioinformatics. Such an approach will help us Christopher Hobbs, PhD, LAc, through his interview by
understand more fully the relationship (ie, severity and Managing Editor Craig Gustafson provides us useful
magnitude) of indoor mold exposure to human health. guidance in the use of mushrooms for wellness and health
promotion. He is a keynote lecture at the 14th Annual
In This Issue International Conference of the Association for the
Thank you Ann Shippy, MD, for coauthoring the Advancement of Restorative Medicine. I will also be
second part of this mold editorial with me. I was really lecturing at this conference on how toxicity has become
struggling with the topic and she brought clarity. As a one of the primary causes of chronic disease.
former IBM engineer, Dr Shippy left over a decade in Original research on postmarketing safety of Rheum
engineering to adapt her skill-set to the world of medicine rhaponticum is provided by Jyh-Lurn Chang, PhD; Michael
after recovering from an illness that allopathic medicine B. Montalto, PhD; Peter W. Heger; Eva Thiemann; Reinhard
alone did not have solutions for. She attended the University Rettenberger, PhD; and Jürgen Wacker, MD, PhD. Assessing
of Texas Medical School and has a thriving functional the efficacy AND safety of natural medicines is critical for
medicine practice in Austin, Texas. She is board certified in the advancement of our medicine.
internal medicine and functional medicine. Ferdi Yavuz, MD; Bayram Kelle, MD; and Birol
As part of our efforts to continually improve IMCJ, we Balaban, MD, from Turkey provide us an informative case
are now also putting commentaries through our standard report of the use of neural therapy in patients with Bell’s

Pizzorno and Shippy—The Path Ahead Integrative Medicine • Vol. 15, No. 3 • June 2016 13
palsy. I thought especially interesting the efficacy on a References
1. World Health Organizataion. WHO guidelines for indoor air quality:
nonpharmacological approach after conventional D a m p n e s s a n d m o u l d . h t t p : / / w w w. w h o . i n t / i n d o o r a i r /
treatments had failed. Great to see growing international publications/7989289041683/en/. Published 2009. Accessed June 7, 2016.
2. US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Basic facts: Molds in the
interest in IMCJ. environment. http://www.cdc.gov/mold/faqs.htm#affect. Updated May 22,
Mikhail Kogan, MD; Carlos Cuellar Castillo, MS; and 2014. Accessed February 15, 2016.
3. Thrasher JD, Crawley S. The biocontaminants and complexity of damp
Melissa S. Barber, MS, provide us a case report on a woman indoor spaces: More than what meets the eyes. Toxicol Ind Health. 2009;25(9-
with comorbidities of chronic rhinosinusitis and irritable 10):583-615.
4. Wu F,  Groopman JD, Pestka JJ. Public health impacts of foodborne
bowel syndrome. An excellent example of how the mycotoxins. Annu Rev Food Sci Technol. 2014;5:351-372
symptom-treatment model fails so many patients who 5. Campbell AW, Thrasher JD, Gray MR, Vojdani A. Mold and mycotoxins:
Effects on the neurological and immune systems in humans. Adv Appl
then experience real cure by treating the actual causes of Microbiol. 2004;55:375-406.
their illness. Great that innovative laboratories are 6. Paterson RR, Lima N. Toxicology of mycotoxins. EXS. 2010;100:31-63.
7. Juil K, Seong-Hwan P, Hun Do K, Kim D, Moon Y. Interference with
providing us an ever growing range of tests to help us mutagenic aflatoxin B1-induced checkpoints through antagonistic action of
understand our unique patients. ochratoxin A in intestinal cancer cells: A molecular explanation on potential
risk of crosstalk between carcinogens. Oncotarget. April 2016. doi:10.18632/
When I first heard Datis Kharrazian, DHSc, DC, MS, oncotarget.8914. [Epub ahead of print]
MNeuroSci, CNS, lecture, my immediate thought was, “This 8. Bennett JW, Inamdar AA. Are some fungal volatile organic compounds
(VOCs) mycotoxins? Toxins (Basel). 2015;7(9):3785-3804.
fells like a Jeff Bland firehose lecture!” Such a treat. Another 9. Inamdar AA, Moore JC, Cohen RI, Bennett JW. A model to evaluate the
great interview by Craig. Full disclosure, I think his work so cytotoxicity of the fungal volatile organic compound 1-octen-3-ol in human
embryonic stem cells. Mycopathologia. 2012;173(1):13-20.
important I have accepted Datis’s invitation to join the 10. Inamdar AA, Zaman T, Morath SU, Pu DC, Bennett JW. Drosophila
board of his International Association of Functional melanogaster as a model to characterize fungal volatile organic compounds.
Environ Toxicol. 2014;29(7):829-836.
Neurology and Rehabilitation. If you’ve not heard him 11. Robert Wålindera, Lena Ernstgårdb, Dan Norbäcka, et al. Acute effects of
lecture, you are in for quite a treat that will change how you 1-octen-3-ol, a microbial volatile organic compound (MVOC)—An
experimental study. Toxicol Lett. 2008;181(3):141-147.
think about patients with neurological disease. 12. Hokeness K, Kratch J, Nadolny C, et al. The effects of fungal volatile organic
Finally, Bill Benda, MD in BackTalk makes a very, very compounds on bone marrow stromal cells. Can J Microbiol. 2014;60(1):1-4.
13. Inamdar AA, Masurekar P, Bennett JW. Neurotoxicity of fungal volatile
valid point: While easy to critique conventional medicine organic compounds  in Drosophila melanogaster. Toxicol Sci.
for being the third leading cause of death in the United 2010;117(2):418-426.
14. Inamdar AA, Bennett JW. A common fungal volatile organic compound
States, this is totally unfair as dramatically more deaths induces a nitric oxide mediated inflammatory response in Drosophila
were prevented by conventional medicine. The problem is melanogaster. Sci Rep. February 2014;4:3833.
15. Kilburn KH. Neurobehavioral and pulmonary impairment in 105 adults with
not the conventional medicine model—where indoor exposure to molds compared to 100 exposed to chemicals. Toxicol Ind
appropriately applied. The problem is use of symptom Health. 2009;25(9-10):681-692.
16. Rea WJ, Didriksen N, Simon TR, et al. Effects of toxic exposure to molds and
suppression instead of curative understanding of why mycotoxins in building-related illnesses. Arch Environ Health.
patients are sick and how to restore health. Such a 2003;58(7):399-405.
17. Thomas G, Burton NC, Mueller C, et al. Comparison of work-related
monolithic system is only possible when other perspectives symptoms and visual contrast sensitivity between employees at a severely
have been actively suppressed. See my comment about water-damaged school and a school without significant water damage. Am J
Ind Med. 2012;55(9):844-854.
Jeff ’s commentary above. 18. Karunasena E, Larrañaga MD, Simoni JS, Douglas DR, Straus DC. Building-
An optimal health care system collaboratively associated neurological damage modeled
in human cells: A mechanism of
neurotoxic effects by exposure to mycotoxins in the indoor environment.
combines public health, life-saving conventional medicine, Mycopathologia. 2010;170(6):377-390.
and the curative health restoration we advocate. 19. Rosenblum Lichtenstein JH, Hsu YH, Gavin IM, et al. Environmental mold
and mycotoxin exposures elicit specific cytokine and chemokine responses.
PLoS One. 2015;10(5):e0126926.
20. Purzycki CB, Shain DH. Fungal toxins and multiple sclerosis: A compelling
connection. Brain Res Bull. 2010;82(1-2):4-6.
21. Brewer JH, Thrasher JD, Straus DC, et al. Detection of mycotoxins in
patients with chronic fatigue syndrome. Toxins (Basel). 2013;5(4):605-617.

Joseph Pizzorno, ND, Editor in Chief


drpizzorno@innovisionhm.com
http://twitter.com/drpizzorno

14 Integrative Medicine • Vol. 15, No. 3 • June 2016 Pizzorno and Shippy—The Path Ahead

You might also like