Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This pap+v was presented at the 25th Annual OTC In Houston, Texas, U.S.A., 3-S May 1993.
This paper was selectad for presentation by the OTC Program Committee following review of information mntained in an abatract submitted by tha author(s). Contents of tha paper,
as presented, hava not been reviewed by tha Offshore Technology Conference and are subject to correot~n by tha author(s). The mater[~, = wsent~d, does not neces=rilY reffe~
anv oosition of the OfLshoreTochnoloov Conference or Ikeofficers. Permission to copy la restricted to an abstract of not mora than 300 words. Illustrations may not be copied. The abstract
shb~ld contain conaplcuoua acknowf&dgmant of where and by whom the PaPer ia presented.
fault block, the Troll West Gas Province (TWGP), the oil
ABSTRACT zone is 12 - 14m thick and the estimated oil in-place
440x 10*Sm3. In the Troll East fault block the oil column is
only O - 4m.
The 22- 26m thick oil zone in the Troll West Oi[ Province,
offshore Norway, is planned to be developed by 18800m The major gas accumulation is found in Troll East with a
long horizontal wells. The viability of such wells has been gas in-place estimated at 1072xI 0%m3. In the TWGP the
proven by long-term testing. To obtain economic oil estimated gas in-place is 570x I 0gSm3, and in the TWOP
production the wells will be completed in the lower part of 27x10gSm3.
the oil rim close to the oil-water contact. The high water
production which is expected can, to some extent, be The development of Troll is divided in three phases. Phase
controlled by gas reinfection. A flexible gas injection 1 includes gas production from Troll East and is planned to
scheme will therefore be implemented. start in October 1996. Phase 2 covers development of the
oil resources. A planfordevelopmentandoperations(PDO)
Allowing wells to produce free gas together with the oil of the oil in the TWOP was prepared during 1991 and was
(super<riticalproduction) has been shown to accelerate oil approved in 1992. This plan assumes production startup
recovery and to improve lift and balance well pressures at by the beginning of 1996. Oil production from the TWGP
the subsea manifolds. is presently under evaluation, The TWOP development
concept has flexibility to include a future development also
The complexity of the Troll field together with of the oil resources in the TWGP.
simultaneous oil and gas production from different parts of
the field makes development planning and reservoir Phase 3 includes large scale gas production from Troll
management a great challenge. Significant movements of West. The gas strategy will be coordinated with the oil
the fluid contacts across the field are expected. Topredict production and will not be settled until the extent of the oil
the globat effects accurately in addition to local development in the TWGP has been defined.
phenomena, such as gas and water coning in oil wells,
very flexible simulation models have been constructed. RESERVOIR DESCRIPTION
INTRODUCTION The reservoir sequence is of Middle to Upper Jurrassic age
and is approximately 160m thick. The sediments consist
The Troll oil and gas field is located in 300m water depth of alternating layers of moderately to poorly sorted, clean,
offshore Norway and covers an area of 700km2 (Fig. 11. It medium to coarse grained sand with permeabilities in the
contains an up to 26m thick oil rim sandwiched between 1 -30 Darcy range (C-sands) and micaceous, silty, very
a large gas cap and an active aquifer. The field consists of fine to fine sands and siltstones with permeabilities of tens
three easterly tilted fault blocks (Fig.2). In the to hundreds of milli-Darcies (M-sands). The structural dip
westernmost fault block, the Troll West Oil Province is generally less than one degree in the TWOP and up to
(TWOP), the oil column is 22- 26m thick. The estimated five degrees in the TWGP.
oil in-place in this province is 155x10%m3. In the central
449
2 Reservoir Management Aspects of Producing 011From Thin ON Rims in the, Troll Field OTC 007173
The thickness of the productive C-sands is variable and up the range of pre-test predictions. Fig.5 shows actual
to a few tens of meters at its maximum. This in production from the test wells compared to the pre-test
combination with a dipping formation and thin oil column, predictions.
limits the well target areas to distinct, often elongated
sandbodies, whose exact areal location is very sensitive to The main observations from the long-term tests can be
geological and seismic uncertainty (Fig.3). The fraction of summarised as follows:4
oil in-place within C-sands is estimated at about 76% in
the TWOP and about 66% in the TWGP. Drilling and completion of up to 800m horizontal
sections in the unconsolidated sands in Troll was found
Calcite cemented zones with very low permeability occur technically feasible.
throughout the reservoir. Such zones may be divided in
two classes based on their potential lateral extension. Even in environments with significant calcite density
Regional calcites, inferred to be up to several kilometers there were no indications that they act as sealing
wide sheets, might occur at the boundaries of the barriers to flow.
geological zones, while less extensive local calcites (1 -
100m wide) occur within the geological zones. The calcite Relative permeabilities and residual oil saturations were
cemented zones represent restrictions to flow, but are re-evaluated through the history matching of the tests,
assumed not to act as complete barriers. thus narrowing the uncertainty range for these
parameters.
In parts of the field a relict oil zone below the oil-water
contact (OWC) exists. This zone is assumed to slow down Super-critical production was found to accelerate the
the inflow of water into the oil leg, but is uncertain both oil production significantly and the simulation models
with respect to extension and properties. The possibility of predicted increased total recovery.
a stronger influx of water than expected is therefore
reflected in the design criteria for the development. Using history-matched models, inverse coning was
identified as a method for accelerating oil production
A list of major reservoir and fluid properties is given in and possibly increasing oil recovery.
Table 1.
The long-term tests have significantly increased the
LONG-TERM PRODUCTION TESTING understanding of producing from the thin oil zones on Troll
and have reduced the uncertainty associated with the field
development.
All studies of oil production from the thin oil zones on Troll
based on vertical wells concluded with negative or
marginal economy. Horizontal wells were therefore DEVELOPMENT CONCEPT OF THE
proposed as a viable solution, but large uncertainties were OIL PROVINCE
connected to the predicted performance of such wells.
Optimisation studies were carried out to determine the
To confirm the well potential and feasibility of drilling and
optimum number of wells and production capacity. Well
operating on Troll, two long-term tests in horizontal wells numbers between 16 and 21 with horizontal section
have been performed. The test well 31 /2-Tl was drilled in
lengths of 500 and 800m were evaluated. Oil production
the southern part of the TWOP (Fig.4). The length of the capacities in the range 15 - 25,000 Sm3/d were
horizontal section was 502m with a vertical location
considered.
approximately 4m above the OWC, An 11-month
production test was carried out in this well during 1990.’ It was concluded in 1991 that the optimium scenario
consisted of 17 800m long oil producers. This number has
A 4-month production test was carried out in the southern
later been increased to 18 as a result of updated geological
part of the TWGP during 1991,2 This test well, 31 /5-Tl, modelling. Also, a vertical well for gas injection will be
was drilled with an 800m horizontal section and was
drilled. The location of the wells are shown in Fig.6.
located at an average distance of 1m above the OWC. The
produced volumes of oil, gas and water during the two
The oil production rate which gave the best economy was
tests are shown in Table 2. 25,000 Sm3/d. This capacity was selected as the design
processing capacity. In addition, 40,000 Sm3/d water and
Actual well performance confirmed the predicted benefit
5x 108Sm3/d gas are designed for.
of horizontal wells with respect to high initial oil rate and
delayed time for gas breakthrough. Both the initial oil rate The high permeability formations of Troll require sand
as well as the total oil production was typically four times
exclusion. A 6 5/8” pre-packed screen will be used to
higher than could be expected for a vertical well in the
complete the 8 1/2” horizontal sections. This liner design
same environment. was successfully applied in the horizontal test wells
31/2-Tl and 31/5-Tl (Fig.7).
The productivity of the TWOP test well was good3, with
significantly more oil produced in the test period than The wells will be tied back to four subsea manifold
predicted. The TWGP test well productivity was lower
stations and the fluids transported to the semi-submersible
than expected, but the cumulative production was within production unit by two parallel gathering lines per manifold
460 I
I
OTC O07173 T. Kydland, S.E. Wennemo and G. Olsen 3
station. It is flexibility to tie in up to 26 wells to the four well to drop, and the well may shut in when the pressure
manifolds. is too low to transport the fluids to the processing unit.
Production is scheduled to start by the beginning of 1996. A typical performance plot of a well in the southern part of
Eight oil producers and one gas injector are planned to be the TWOP is shown in Fig.1 O.
predrilled, starting in March 1994.
The Troll reservoirs are expected to communicate through
The TWOP oil reserves are estimated to 60x10’%m3. the gas cap in the north and through the aquifer in the
Expected production profiles areshownin Fig.8. south (Fig.4). Consequently, the reservoir behaviour in the
southern part of the TWOP is dominated by water influx
while the northern part gets pressure support from the
CRITERIA FOR LOCATING OIL large gas cap in the TWGP. The fluid contacts are
PRODUCERS expected to move strongly upwards in TWOP South while
they stay relatively constant in TWOP North. The
The main parameters governing individual well simulations predict that several of the southern wells,
performance have been identified by reservoir simulation: especially at the flank, will experience very high water cuts
and shut in early due to lift problems. Allowing such wells
- presence of highly permeable sand around the well to produce supercritically (i.e. produce free gas together
- vertical distance of the well to the OWC with the oil) to improve lift, is beneficial only in the short
thickness of the high-permeability sand between the term, because the reduced pressure in the gas cap will
well and the gas-oil contact (GOC) accelerate the rise of the OWC and cause even larger lift
- presence of low permeable sand below the well. problems at a later stage.
451
4 Reservoir Management Aspects of Producing Oil From Thin Oil Rims in the, Troll Fir#d OTC O07173
The two long-term tests on Troll both showed an increased strategy is a very high water production and possible lift
oiirate when free gas was produced together with the oil. problems. The target depth for wells in the TWGP will
However, the benefit of a super-critical production strategy therefore most probably be at the OWC.
applied on a large scale, depends on several factors of
which fluid contact movements and hydraulics are the Super-critical production has been found to be very
most important. beneficial in the TWGP and will be the recommended
production strategy. Reservoir simulations show that such
In the TWOP South the contacts are expected to move a strategy both accelerates the oil production and
upwards as an effect of the expanding aquifer. increases the total recovery. Free gas production together
Super-critical production without reinfection of free gas with the oil improves lifting capacity and prolongs life time
fortifies this movement and was found to have a negative of the wells. Due to the large gas cap in the TWGP free
effect on the oil recovery. Reinfection of the free gas gas can be produced without significant loss of reservoir
tended to remove the negative effect, but the simulations energy. The income from gas sales will make the project
did not predict increased recovery. The selected production economy more robust.
strategy for the wells in TWOP South is therefore to keep
the liquid rate as high as possible without significant EFFECT OF LARGE SCALE GAS
production of free gas. However, wells with very high
water cut will be allowed to produce free gas to a limited PRODUCTION ON OIL RECOVERY
extent to improve lift and to balance the tubing head
pressure for wells manifolded into a common pipeline. Optimum recovery of both oil and gas resources on Troll is
difficult to achieve since the two types of resources
In TWOP North the contacts are expected to stay relatively require opposite production philosophies. The gas cap
constant. Simulations show that the oil production is would benefit from a high off take rate to avoid excessive
accelerated and the total recovery increased by allowing volumes of gas to be trapped by encroaching aquifers. The
the wells to produce some free gas together with the oil. oil resources, on the contrary, benefit from stable
The current strategy is therefore to produce these wells conditions in the reservoir with contact movements and
slightly super-critical with a gas-oil ratio 3-4 times higher drop of reservoir pressure kept at a minimum.
than the solution gas-oil ratio of 55 Sm3/Sm3. A potential
for further optimizing this strategy is believed to exist. The gas deliveries from Troll East are already settled and
based on an annual offtake in the order of 23x10gSm3 at
plateau and scheduled to start in Octcber 1996, Troll East
DEVELOPMENT OF THE OIL IN THE is expected to be in communication with the TWGP in the
GAS PROVINCE hydrocarbon zone in north and in the aquifer in south.
When depletion of Troll East starts, an upward contact
Considerable oil resources are present in the Troll West movement is induced in TWGP North and a downward
Gas Province (TWGP) which has an estimated oil in-place movement in TWGP South. Together with the drop in
about 2.5 times that of the TWOP. However, with an oil reservoir pressure, this is unfavorable for the TWGP oil
column thickness of only 12-14m it is a great challenge to production. Also the oil production from the TWOP is
obtain economic oil production even from such a large negatively influenced by the Troll East gas production, but
potential. to a lesser extent than the TWGP.
It was concluded in the 1991 PDO that further appraisal of The 1991 PDO assumes that the large scale gas
the TWGP oil resources was required before a production from the TWGP (Phase 3) is started in 2010
development decision could be taken. Since then, two and based on a yearly off take of 15x 10gSm3. However,
appraisal wells have been drilled and 3-D seismic has because the gas strategy is not yet settled, this is merely
replaced the original 2-D data. This has significantly a reference point for reservoir simulation. Producing gas at
improved the quality of the data base, and evaluations are a large scale from the TWGP induces an upward
currently ongoing aiming at a decision about development movement of the oil zone. This is beneficial for the oil
early in 1994. The Troll West production unit has flexibility production from TWGP South in the short term because it
to phase in up to five oil production clusters from the counteracts the otherwise downward movement induced
TWGP. by production from Troll East and the TWOP. In the long
term, however, it is negative because of the strong decline
The thin oil zone combined with a moderately dipping in reservoir pressure. In TWGP North the effect of the
reservoir tends to locate the producible oil in the TWGP large scale gas production is solely negative.
into distinct, elongated sand bodies (Fig.3). A relatively
small vertical adjustment of the structural model will result The oil production from the TWOP is negatively affected
in a large lateral displacement of the target areas for wells, by the large scale gas production because of the rapid
and the chance for drilling an unsuccessful producer could decline in reservoir pressure. A too early startup of the gas
be considerable. production will therefore reduce the oil reserves in the
TWOP.
Simulation studies by single well models have shown that
the highest oil production from a thin oil zone can be The gas sales strategy for Troll West primarily must be
obtained when the horizontal section is located below the seen in light of the effect on the oil production. An
OWC (inverse coning). 5 However, the penalty for such a aggressive strategy could be beneficial for the gas
452
OTC O07173 T. Kydland, S.E. Wennemoand G. Olsen 5
Several initiatives will be taken to reduce the impact of - full field model covering all parts of the Troll field
uncertainty. Before production drilling is started extended sector models covering the separate provinces or parts
use of the seismic data base will be made. The quality of of them
the 3-D seismic on Troll is very good, and the planned sirlgle well models.
utilisation of intra-reservoir reflectors will improve the
accuracy of the geological model. Due to the very large area covered, the full field model is
relatively coarse. It contains six vertical layers and has a
About half of the development wells will be combined with grid block size of 500m x 500m. Horizontal wells are
a pilot hole to determine the reservoir properties and the modelled by local grid refinements. A typical local grid
exact location of the contacts. The horizontal section will contains some 500 grid blocks. Depending on the number
be obtained by sidetracking the pilot hole. In addition, the of wells, the total number of grid blocks in the full field
drilling programme assumes that up to three of the planned model varies between 22,000 and 40,000.
pilot holes will be failures, i.e. that a satisfactory horizontal
section cannot be obtained by kicking off from the pilot Sector models covering the TWOP, the TWGP South and
hole. the TWGP North have been constructed. Such models,
which typically have 12 vertical layers and a grid block
A comprehensive data acquisition activity is part of the size of 250m x 250m, have been used to establish more
predrilling programme. The information obtained will be
accurate well locations and production forecasts than
continuously utilised to impose corrective actions on the could be obtained by the full field model.
remaining programme. “Back-to-back” drilling of wells in
the same area will be avoided, even if this will lead to Very detailed sector models, covering specific areas in the
extra rig movement. To secure an initially high production TWOP, will be constructed to aid in establishing final
level, the wells with the best geological control will be
target locations for the development wells. These models
drilled first. will be frequently updated based on the geological
information obtained during the drilling period.
After production startup the largest uncertainty is related
to the behaviour of the fluid contacts. The contact The single well models were used for matching of test
movements are mainly governed by factors like a) data and performing sensitivity studies, covering a wide
transmissibility across major faults, b) aquifer properties range of geological and reservoir technical conditions.
and continuity, and c) residual oil zone below the OWC.
453
6 Reservoir Management Aspects of Producing Oil From Thin 011Rims br the Troll Field 0TCO07173
Super-critical production accelerates the oil recovery Reservoir pressure at 1547mMSL 158 bar
and may be utilised to improve lift and to balance well Reservoir temperature 68 “c
pressures at the subsea manifolds. Gas-oil contact (GOC) 1543-1547 mMSL
Oil-water contact (OWC) 1559-1569 mMSL
Large scale gas production generally has a negative Oil formation volume factor (Bd) 1.16-1.20 m3/Sm3
influence on the oil production and should not be Gas formation volume factor (Bo) 0.0064 m3/Sm3
started until the majority of the oil reserves have been Solution gas-oil ratio (R.) 55-70 Sm3/Sm3
recovered. Oil viscosity 1.3 -2.1 mPas
Gas viscosity 0.018 mPas
Obtainin~ economic oii production from the thin oil Water viscosity 0.45 mPas
layers in- the Gas Province is even more challenging Oil density (at standard cond.) 884 kglm’
than for the Oil Province. Gas density (at standard cond.) 0.75 kglm3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Data given at in;t. reservoir cond. if not otherwise stated
The authors wish to express their thanks to all their
colleagues in Norsk Hydro Exploration and Production Table 1 Reservoir and Fluid Properties, Troll West
Division who have contributed to this paper and to the
management of Norsk Hydro a.s for permission to publish
it. We also thank the other Troll Iicence owners for
permission to publish this paper. The opinions expressed
Produced Volume 3112-TI 31 /5-Tl
are those of Norsk Hydro as, and may not represent the
views of other partners.
Oil (103Sm3) 1043 123
Gas (1O’%m31 83
REFERENCES Water (103) 424 152
1. Lien, S.C., Seines, K., Havig, S.0., Kydland, T.: “The Table 2 Production by Horizontal Test Wells
First Long-Term Horizontal-Well Test in the Troll Thin
Oil Zone”, JPT (August 1991), p.914.
al12 am
I I I
8muM
474CQX
cm
%Jn y
em +
W5 3116 m-31 .7w.2sQlB@
I !
I ,
- Wwel Wx44
Fig. 2- Troll Field Hydrocarbons in Plaoe Fig. 4- Looation Map, The Troll west Area
455
S20300 625Q04
+ 67s6sco
TWOP (31/2-Tl)
OiL CUM. S4L
~lJODD_770N W##lON
67YXOI
8745W.3
DAYS DAYS
TWGP(31/5-Tl)
S740X0
DAYS DAYS
673SWU
PRE-Ts2TPREDICTW
- %W710N
— i“itm%?
0Gas60il I I
n oil
L, I
TR,68.92.1/lM{L
520300 S20200
30. cas
10 2/4”
ty valve
18 w“
b
5 IL? wbmg’ 20
13 2/8- casing ““.., ..
.. . .
.. .. .. .
~ ““i 1“’”-
, \ —
9 S/S”casing \ L1
6 S/6”qeTwAed screen OIL’ o
I I I I
TR.1S,1O.91
.l,PR(Mfl) 1995 2s+0 2C?15 2010 2015
YEARS 26.01,931 SSW E“
456
:%*L
. . . 148s 1
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
1
GOC 16s3
. . . . . owc
1624
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . .... .. .. .... . . . .
15s4
*“.,8C”U
1s60
Fig, 9- Alternative Well Locations within a Dipping
High Permeability Sand
1404 [
After 8Years Pmduc$iq with Gas Injection
Astted fmm tfw Begmnmg of the Year 5
: MShL
14s5 h
CM Rate
..
lsm%d)
3200-
.
//”
/
cum C41
(IW Srr?)
-4,4 T#J202
a
..(2s
f&3&
\ //
-4,0
2800- / -3,6
/
I
/ -3,2
24tX! -
!654
-2,2
mo -
— oil Ra10 -2,4
— -041 Curws, t two
1600- -2,0
i200- -1,6
-12
/
800-
,s
4C0 -
II ,4
0,
I ,0 =Cn
20@l 2005 2010 2015 lwos02 ❑
1995
YEARS “oh Water
1s33
Water
Cut
I ,0
1554
70
60 ,8 1560
50
1604
.6
Initial Situation
40
30 4
Fig. 11- Movement of Fluid Contacts in TWOP South
20
(
—
— -
TutiIw Haed Pr,ssuro
Watw cut
I 8
with and without Gas Injection
10
0 ,0
2000 200S 2010
457