Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Child at Risk Nov 2016 PDF
Child at Risk Nov 2016 PDF
Learning Objectives
1. Recognition of violence as a public health problem
2. Recognition of child victimization within the spectrum of community violence
3. Knowledge of basic concepts of child rights
4. Awareness of documents and legal instruments to promote implementation of
child rights
5. Knowledge of different categories of child maltreatment
6. Recognition of modes of presentation of physical and sexual abuse
Youth violence
Child maltreatment
Intimate partner violence
Elder abuse
Sexual violence
1
World Health Organization http://www.who.int/topics/violence/en/ accessed 31 Oct 2017
2
World Report on Violence against Children 2006 https://www.unicef.org/violencestudy/reports.html accessed 31
Oct 2017
1|Page
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Children who experience violence often have co-existing family problems. The Adverse
Childhood Experiences (ACE) study3 has reported that children who experience adversity in
childhood have poorer long-term health outcomes leading to disability and early death.
Early
death
Figure 1: Potential influences throughout lifespan of adverse childhood experiences (Source: Felliti
et al 1998. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 14(4): 245-248)
3
Felliti, Anda, et al. 1998. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 14 (4): 245-248
2|Page
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
The ACE study reported a dose-response relationship between the cumulative number of
adversities experienced in childhood and the risk of a number of adverse health outcomes listed
in Table 3.
Table 3: Association between exposure to childhood adversity & adverse health
outcomes (Source: Felliti et al 1998 Am J Prev Med 14(4): 245-248 & Anda et al 2006
European Archives of Psychiatry & Clinical Neuroscience 256(3): 174-186)
3|Page
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Child Rights
There was an old woman who lived in a shoe
She had so many children she didn’t know what to do
She gave them some broth without any bread
Then whipped them all soundly
And sent them to bed4
The ill-treatment and exploitation of children has existed for a long time and is not a new
phenomenon. Stories in literature (e.g.Oliver Twist5), folklore (e.g.Cinderella) and ancient history
make references to this problem. However, these problems were often ignored or tolerated
because children were not seen as individuals with their own rights and were subject to the
authority of adults.
In 1962, a paediatrician named Henry Kempe published a landmark paper6 describing features
of physical abuse in children entitled The Battered Child Syndrome. This led to greater
awareness of this problem and advocacy for the protection of children.
The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989 (UNCRC)7 was drawn up as an
international legal treaty recognizing the rights of children. The UNCRC recognizes children as
human beings entitled to rights. However due to their young age, immaturity, lack of authority
and power, children are unable to seek or exercise their rights by themselves. Hence it is the
duty of governments and society as a whole to advocate on behalf of children.
Under the UNCRC, a child is defined as an individual under the age of 18 years. The UNCRC
contains 54 articles which outlines the rights of children and the responsibilities of adults and
governments to work together to ensure that children are able to enjoy these rights.
Table 4: Important principles within the UNCRC (Source: Unicef)
Best interests of the child (Article 3) The best interests of the child must be a top priority
in all decisions and actions that affect children
The UNRC outlines rights which related to all aspects of childhood. They include survival rights,
development rights, protection rights and participation rights. Countries which have signed the
UNCRC have made a commitment to implement laws and policies that will make these rights a
reality in their respective countries.
4
Old nursery rhyme
5
19th century novel by Charles Dickens
6
Kempe, Silverman & Steele 1962. JAMA 181(1): 17-24
7
https://www.unicef.org/crc/accessed 31 October 2017
4|Page
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
In addition to the UNCRC, the are three Optional Protocols on the sale of children, child
prostitution and child pornography. Governments which have ratified the UNCRC can choose
whether or not to sign the Optional Protocols. Malaysia has ratified the UNCRC in 1995 but has
placed reservations on some articles8
Table 5: Some examples of child rights under the UNCRC (Source: Unicef)
Survival rights Right to life
Right to an identity (identity documents, nationality)
Right to food, shelter & health care
Right to remain with parents
8
These reservations include Article 2 on non-discrimination, Article 7 on name and nationality, Article 14 on
freedom of thought, conscience and religion, Article 28(1) on free and compulsory education at primary level,
Article 27 on torture and deprivation of liberty (https://www.unicef.org/malaysia/childrights_crc-reservations-
malaysia.html accessed 4 November 2017)
5|Page
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Physical abuse
Sexual abuse
Emotional abuse
Neglect
Does this problem exist in Malaysia?
Every year, an increasing number of cases of child maltreatment are reported to the Department
of Social Welfare (Table 6). However, a much larger proportion of child maltreatment remains
hidden and unreported.
Prevalence data from population-based studies provide a better reflection of the true magnitude
of the problem. Anonymous surveys conducted among primary and secondary school children
in peninsular Malaysia reveal that a significant proportion have experienced child maltreatment
and other forms of victimization (Table 7). At least 20% have experienced multiple types of
maltreatment.
9
Examples include any child suspected to have been abused or neglected, children with suspicious injuries,
children found in suspicious or dangerous circumstances & any children who are living under the same roof as
these children
10
Fine of RM 5000, imprisonment of < 2 years or both
6|Page
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Table 6: Cases of child abuse and neglect reported to the Department of Social Welfare,
Malaysia from 2000-2010 (Source: Department of Social Welfare, 2012)
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Abandoned 71 70 121 98 26 68 53 63 58 62 115
Neglect 183 303 357 389 563 601 682 761 952 981 1250
Physical 362 287 354 410 445 431 495 586 863 895 846
Sexual 258 251 324 430 559 623 728 775 805 728 937
Emotional 24 56 32 32 63 77 50 45 90 98 71
Others 36 69 54 31 0 0 0 49 12 25 38
Total 934 1036 1242 1390 1656 1800 1999 2279 2780 2789 3257
Table 7: Prevalence studies in Malaysia on child victimization (Source: Choo, Dunne, Marret,
Fleming, Wong, 2011. Journal of Adolescent Health 49(6): 627-634, Ahmed, Choo, Marret, Cheah,
Othman, Chinna 2015. PLoS ONE 10(3): e0119449, Marret, Choo 2017. BMJ Open 7: e014959)
Choo, Dunne, Marret, Ahmed, Choo, Marret, Marret & Choo 2017
Fleming, Wong 2011 Cheah, Othman, Chinna n= 1487
n = 1870 2015
adolescents in Selangor n = 3509 adolescents in N.
children in Selangor Sembilan
Physical (%) 19.0 52.7 (parents) 50.2
29.2 (teachers)
Emotional (%) 20.4 20.5 26.3
Sexual (%) 22.2 not available 17.0
Neglect (%) 21.3 38.9 not available
Multiple (%) 22 43 not available
Online harassment (%) 52.2
Online unwanted sexual 17.2
solicitation (%)
A child lives within the ecosystem of the community as individual who depends on adults for
care and attention. Factors which increase a child’s vulnerability to maltreatment include: (a)
requirement for higher levels of care due to infancy or special needs (b) diminished capacity of
parents and families to provide for the child’s needs (c) lack of community resources and
infrastructure to support families with children.
parent/family
communityparent child
Society community
Figure 2. An ecological model of child maltreatment. Adapted from Garbarino 1977. Journal
of Marriage & the Family 39(4): 721-735
11
Child Maltreatment Fact sheet, WHO (www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheet/fs150/en accessed 4 Nov 2017)
7|Page
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Child Factors
Some children may be at increased risk of maltreatment through no fault of their own
Physical abuse
Children who present with physical injuries should be carefully examined, bearing in mind the
possibility that the injury may have been inflicted or could be the result of inadequate care and
supervision.
Table 8: Terms used in reference to childhood injury
Accidental injury Injury that was unintentional, resulting from an unexpected event
Injury that is unavoidable
8|Page
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Bruising is the commonest injury seen in physical abuse12. A systematic review of literature has
identified the following patterns of bruising in children to be suspicious of abuse13
12
Kemp, Maguire, Nuttal, Collins, Dunstan 2015. Archives of Disease in Childhood 99(2):108-113
13
Maguire, Mann, Sibert, Kemp 2005. Archives of Disease in Childhood 90: 182-186
9|Page
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Figure 4: Soft tissue bruising patterns from various instruments used in inflicted injuries
(Source: Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics, 18th edition)
Oral injuries
Force feeding using utensils such as spoons can result in oral injuries. These may include
lacerations to the lips, and tearing of the frenulum of the tongue or lips.
Burns
Figure 5: Common burn patterns from heated objects which reflect instruments used in
inflicted injuries (Source: Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics, 18th edition)
10 | P a g e
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Skeletal injuries
Unlike accidental fractures which typically present with a history of loss of function/mobility
immediately following a fall or trauma, fractures due to physical abuse may be discovered
incidentally or when a skeletal survey is done.
The following patterns are suspicious of abuse
Infants and young children under the age of 3 years are most vulnerable to severe injuries that
may result in fatality or long-term disability. Abusive head trauma and abdominal injuries are the
most common type of injuries seen in fatal child physical abuse.
Abusive Head Trauma (AHT)14
This includes injuries from blunt force trauma, shaking or a combination of forces. The term
“abusive head trauma” is recommended instead of the older term of “Shaken Baby Syndrome”
as shaking is not the only form of trauma that may be inflicted on an infant with head injuries15.
Children under the age of 2 years are most vulnerable. The relatively large head size of infants
combined with weak neck muscles make young infants more susceptible.
The usual patterns of injury seen in AHT are subdural haemorrhage, subarachnoid
haemorrhage and hypoxic-ischaemic injury to the brain. There may sometimes be other
associated injuries such as skull fractures, retinal haemorrhages, bruises and other skeletal
injuries.
Infants who suffer AHT usually present with non-specific symptoms:
14
Committee on Child Abuse and Neglect 2001. Pediatrics 108 (1): 206-210
15
Christian, Block et al 2009. Pediatrics 123(5):
11 | P a g e
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Abdominal trauma
Blunt abdominal trauma (eg by punching, kicking, stepping) can result in rupture of solid organs,
bowel perforation and tearing of mesentery. Death may result from hypovolaemic shock due to
haemorrhage or peritonitis and sepsis. The injury pattern as well as associated delays in
seeking treatment contributes to high mortality.
Child
Unkempt, malnourished
“frozen watchfulness”: child who is alert, aware of surroundings but displays no
response or expression
Abnormal interaction with parent
Frequent absence from school
12 | P a g e
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Sexual abuse
Child sexual abuse (csa) is the involvement of dependent, developmentally immature children
and adolescents in sexual activities that they do not fully comprehend, are unable to give their
informed consent to and that violate the social taboos of family roles16.
This includes a spectrum of sexual activities:
exposure
touching or fondling
penetration
online exploitation: sexual solicitation, grooming & transmission of images
using children in transactional sex or prostitution
Most children are sexually abused by people known to them, in places where they usually
spend time such as home, school, and the homes of relatives or friends. Their abusers include
family members, teachers, neighbours, drivers & babysitters.
Child sexual abuse is not uncommon and affects children of both genders. A systematic review
across 24 countries reported a prevalence of 8 to 31% for girls and 3 to 17% for boys17. In
contrast, prevalence data from some Asian countries including Malaysia report a similar
prevalence across genders.
The disparity between reported cases of child sexual abuse and prevalence data (refer Table 6
& 7) indicates that it is a largely hidden problem within the community. Cultural inhibitions and
taboos that limit discussions regarding sexual matters make it difficult for affected children to
talk about their problems. In Malaysia, more girls compared to boys are brought for medical
attention in relation to concerns surrounding sexual abuse. Many parents are protective of their
daughters and monitor their movements closely. Few parents are aware that their sons are also
vulnerable to child sexual abuse. It appears that boys may be more inhibited about disclosing
their experiences.
Table 9: Child sexual abuse in Asia (sources: Choo et al 2011. J of Adolescent Health 49(6); Ji,
Finkelhor, Dunne 2013. Child Abuse & Neglect 37(9): 613-22; Zhu et al 2015. Asia Pacific J of Public
Health 27(6): 643-51; Kacker 2007. Study on Child Abuse :India 2007, Ministry of Women & Child
Development, India; Nguyen et al 2009. Bull World Health Organ 87:22–30)
16
Schecter & Roberge 1976. In Child Abuse and Neglect: The family and Community. Helfer, Kempe (Eds).
Cambridge: Ballinger
17
Barth, Bermetz, Helm, Trelle, Tonia 2013. International Journal of Public Health 58(3):469-83
13 | P a g e
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
The child may not reveal He/she may not realize that this is “sexual abuse”
the problem or tell
someone much later He/she may have been silenced with threats or bribes
The child may have tried to tell someone but was not believed
or silenced
Children may be selected Any child can be a victim if perpetrators find an opportunity
and groomed Children who are timid, over-friendly or isolated may be easy
targets
14 | P a g e
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Neglect
Neglect occurs when a child’s basic needs are not met. It is the commonest form of child
maltreatment worldwide. Chronic neglect is detrimental to the health and well-being of children.
Some forms of neglect
18
Henry & Powell 2016. Trauma, Violence & Abuse doi 10.1177/1524838016650189
19
The term “child sexual exploitation material” replaces what is commonly referred to as “child pornography”
20
Marret & Choo 2016. Journal of Interpersonal Violence doi: 10.1177/00886260515625502
21
Ahmed, Choo, Marret, Cheah, Othman, Chinna 2015. PLoS ONE 10(3): e0119449
15 | P a g e
Stage 3.2 Paediatrics Child at risk Mary J Marret
Emotional abuse
Emotional abuse is the most prevalent form of child abuse. It can occur by itself or in
combination with other forms of child maltreatment22.
Table 12: Some examples of emotional abuse23
22
Claussen & Crittenden 1991. Child Abuse and Neglect. 15(1-2): 5-18
23
Glaser 2002. Child Abuse and Neglect 26 (6-7): 697-714
16 | P a g e