International Journal of Mechanical and Production

Engineering Research and Development (IJMPERD)

ISSN (P): 2249-6890; ISSN (E): 2249-8001
Vol. 8, Issue 1, Feb 2018, 863-868
© TJPRC Pvt. Ltd.

TRANSFORMER OILS AND REMEDIAL PROCEDURES

ON CORROSIVE SULFUR EFFECTS

KARTHIKEYAN
Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering (Marine), AMET University, Chennai Tamil Nadu, India
ABSTRACT

The conduct of destructive sulphur in mineral oils is analysed as far as the disappointments saw in
transformers, the copper's surfaces sulphide secured conveyors and corrupted paper protecting tapes. The part of
Dissolved Gas Analysis (DGA) in the hazard's assessment of copper sulphide arrangement is depicted. The level of the
destructiveness of some sulphur mixes is analysed and looked at utilising a Kraft paper wrapped-copper test (Standard
IEC 62535). The event of DBDS as the most appropriate destructive compound is contrasted and the vicinity of other
destructive species in protecting mineral oils. Various moderation strategies for destructive sulphur are portrayed and
assessed.

KEYWORDS: Corrosive Sulphur, Transformer Failures, Mineral Oils, Corrosion & Mechanism

Original Article
Received: Oct 06, 2017; Accepted: Oct 26, 2017; Published: Jan 30, 2018; Paper Id.: IJMPERDFEB2018102

INTRODUCTION

Over the previous decade there has been expanded enthusiasm for the impacts of destructive sulphur in
mineral protecting oils, which has been resolved to be the primary guilty party for the late disappointments
recorded in shunt reactors and force transformers L.R. Lewand (2004) A.H. Rocha (2001) Rajesh et.al (2016)

The instrument of dissatisfaction has been shown to include directing particles of copper sulphide, which
is shaped on the copper conveyors and stored upon the paper protecting tapes, rendering them somewhat
conductive. This offer ascends to upgraded dielectric misfortunes inside of the influenced paper tapes, prompting
mild shakiness lastly to a thermo-electric breakdown of the protecting framework Kannan et al. (2015) T.Prabhu,
(2013). The uncovered copper conveyor surfaces have been seen to wind up secured with copper sulphide movies,
as are likewise the copper channels themselves. With an end goal to reproduce the actual conditions inside of
transformer windings, Method IEC 62535 was created in which the examples comprise of copper conveyors after
that a separate paper tape layer is held. In this test system, it has been found that the vicinity of destructive sulphur
in the oil may show itself either by copper sulphide stores on the copper transmitter or upon the paper tape
touching with it or on both. One of the goals of this examination is to look at the reasons for this particular
conductF. Scatiggio et al. (2008). Specific consideration is given to the negative qualities sulphur corruption
system on both the copper conduits and paper tapes and its general impacts on the transformer and protecting
frameworks. An additional aim is likewise to consider the oils' passivation for the security of the copper
transmitters against destructive sulphur and in Maina et al. (2011) addition the extraction techniques of destructive
sulphur from the oils. Some articles are discussed, Performance of leaf springs made of composite material
subjected to low-frequency impact loading. Investigation Of The Optical And Electrical Properties Of Tin Sulfide
Thin Films.

www.tjprc.org editor@tjprc.org
864 Karthikeyan

TRANSFORMER FAILURES

A standout amongst the most widely recognized sorts of destructive sulphur related transformer disappointment in
the field is observed to be because of high temperatures in the windings, regularly coming about

because of insufficient cooling of the windings or configuration imperfections. The event of copper sulphide on
the copper channels and the Kraft paper tapes contiguous they speaks to conceivable locales of overheating in either a
sound winding or the other wellspring of overheating in an officially broken winding. Examination of fizzled transformer
windings gives confirm that numerous disappointments happen either in close region to the top bit of the winding where
the temperature is most noteworthy, or in zones of the winding where inadequate cooling results in a higher level of
cellulose chain scission than what can be foreseen on the premise of lifespan of the unit in administration. These high-
temperature problem areas every now and again uncover copper sulphide stores unequivocally proposing that in these
disappointments, destructive sulphur is either the primary driver of the deficiency or at all a critical contributing
component Maina et al. (2009) Scatiggio et.al (2011) Scatiggio et.al (2009, May).

Figure 1: Copper Sulfide Deposit on a Copper Conductor at a Failure Site

Warm blames at lower temperatures (T1 as indicated by Guidance IEC 60599, i.e. T< 300 °C), that are generally
regarded less hazardous than warm blames at medium and high temperatures for the unit's security, ought to be considered
more important in situations where the transformer oils contain critical measures of destructive sulfur. The most ordinarily
happening deleterious sulphur compound, DBDS, breaks down at 270 °C; in this way, its reactivity against copper,
regardless of the possibility that improved by temperature, is likely lessened when the temperature surpasses its
deterioration point. Also, the low temperature warm blames more often than not influence a bigger part of the force device,
in this manner prompting a more diffused affidavit of directing copper sulphide inside of the general protecting framework
structure

MECHANISMS OF CORROSION
Among destructive sulphur mixes, dibenzyl disulphide (DBDS) seems to assume a dominating part of the erosion
process. Recognized as a unique sulphur compound in a few offending oils, it is available in roughly 90% of the protecting
oils utilised inside of the European market. Considering 20 mg/kg of DBDS as the limit to render an oil destructive, 89.7%
of the oils in this populace get their destructiveness from DBDS. Henceforth it is not shocking, that the vast majority of the
investigative endeavours on the mineral's destructiveness protecting oils have been done on DBDS Singh et.al (2008)
Oweimreen et.al (2012) Facciotti et.al (2014). It has been proposed that a more responsive destructive animal type can

Impact Factor (JCC): 6.8765 NAAS Rating: 3.11

Transformer Oils and Remedial Procedures on Corrosive Sulfur Effects 865

come about when DBDS is decreased to benzyl mercaptan with a utilisation of a stoichiometric hydrogen. Then again, it
has been recommended the copper sulphide may be shaped specifically upon the Kraft's surface paper, whereby the copper
is transported as a complex of DBDS, bringing about by-items, for example, bis-benzyl and dibenzyl sulphide. Hints of the
by-items distinguished have been recognised in mineral oils that are as of now in administration.

MITIGATING CORROSION ON TRANSFORMER

A few moderation procedures may be utilised to diminish the effect of destructive sulphur in transformers and
reactors. The most evident methodology is to utilise metal surface passivation to give a film spread over the copper conduit
to ensure its surface. A typical metal passivation being used is that of toluitrazole-dialkyl-ammine (financially accessible as
Irgamet39®) that is added to new and utilised transformer oils as a part of focus levels of around 100 mg/kg. The reason
for the metal passivation is to ensure the copper conveyor by framing an atomic layer onto the copper surface; then again,
it doesn't expel the destructive mixes from the oil, and it manifests some startling and undesired insurance impacts, for
example, the arrival of hydrogen and carbon oxides. This regularly prompts incorrect gas advancement test outcomes.
Depicts hydrogen gas advancement in a transformer before and taking after metal passivation; the presentation of a metal
passivator is seen to prompt a remarkably checked increment in the gas era. Maybe a standout amongst the most unfriendly
impacts of warm push and oxidation by-results of the oil is the following insecurity of the metal passivator. Metal
passivator consumption amid administration is seen in exceptionally stacked force transformer units, containing oils where
the oxidation procedure has as of now started. A beginning exhaustion of the metal passivator is to be foreseen in 10-15%
of the units passivated amid the administration; then again, transformers at first impregnated with a passivated oil shows up
not to be influenced by issues of irregular passivator utilization Bruzzoniti et al. (2014) Wan et.al (2012) Rajeswari (2015).
A perturbing impact of metal passivator consumption is outlined in where it can be seen that a diminishment beneath a
centralization of 25-30 mg/kg can bring about the protecting oil to return to a destructive state; surface staining of the
copper examples exhibits the copper's development sulphide movies on the copper transmitter examples.

Effects of Corrosive Sulphur

Destructive sulphur prompts the arrangement of substances that are insoluble in oil, hasten as muck or frame
copper sulphide stores on the copper conveyors and paper protecting tapes. In transformer and shunt reactor windings,
copper sulphide development is joined by its relocation inside of the protecting's layers paper. In the greater part of the
watched cases, the copper sulphide focus tends to be most astounding inside of the internal tape layers contiguous the
copper conveyors, with a propensity to diffuse outwards; this procedure is strikingly in confirmation in which was acquired
on Kraft paper tapes recovered from a real transformer. A conceivable clarification for the watched diminish in the
grouping of copper sulphide towards the external layers is that it is because of the higher fixation slope of copper sulphide
at the copper's surface transmitter. Furthermore, there is likewise an expanded temperature inclination impact at the copper
channel surface or in its region, as a high's consequence streams conveyed by the copper conveyor, which will enlarge the
response rate of the destructive sulphur with the copper to shape copper sulphide. It can be regularly expected that the
Kraft paper will tend to be obscured more at raised temperatures as an oxidation's outcome of cellulose papers. It is
additionally much of the time watching that the external layer tapes may turn out to be significantly more obscured because
of the oil's oxidation itself.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

www.tjprc.org editor@tjprc.org
866 Karthikeyan

In contradistinction, dibenzothiophene, which is regularly taken as being inactive, produces a negative sign. As to
be foreseen, the IEC test is a successful test for sulphides and disulphides for which it was purposefully concocted.
The evident and incompletely startling changes in the size of reactivity acquired with the IEC test are to be credited to its
expected degree, i.e., to recognise oils that can exchange copper sulphide onto the protecting papers and not evaluate the
oil's reactivity on copper. This gives essential test information, because the stored semiconducting copper sulphide
improves the conductivity and dielectric loss of the paper tapes, subsequently making the likelihood of thermally poor
districts and problem areas along the paper tapes that inevitably may prompt thermally incited dielectric breakdown of the
protecting frameworks in transformers and shunt reactors.

CONCLUSIONS

Copper conduits and paper tape examples recovered from destructive sulfur incited disappointments in
transformers and shunt reactors show that the highest convergence of copper sulfide happens on the Kraft's surface paper
layer nearby the copper conveyors, and from that point its fixation diminishes with each progressive external tape paper
layer, i.e., the dissemination inclination is a reverse capacity of the separation from the most elevated to the least focus. On
the other hand, the outward relocation of copper sulphide through the moderately open fibre structure of the paper is not by
any means the only system dynamic; different components assume a contributing part to the presence of copper sulphide
on the Kraft paper tapes. The development of a copper-DBDS complex has been recommended by a few specialists to be
in charge of the copper relocation onto the active protection, however the copper's exchange itself on the paper surface was
watched either in vicinity of destructive sulfur and non-destructive oils; along these lines, this movement component is still
a long way from being wholly explained and will need further studies The event of elemental copper in the protecting oils
of force contraption and links, and it's going to impact on expanding the dispersal variable in mineral oils has been very
much perceived now for a long time. In spite of the fact that the particular procedure of how essential copper is changed
into miscible particles that enlarge the tan values of oils is not surely known the vicinity of copper in the paper tapes was
identified even without copper sulphide stores after the response of the paper wrapped copper conveyor with oils free from
destructive sulphur. The essential copper in the article will in this manner, in the end, respond with the destructive oils to
frame the semiconductive copper sulphide, which, given its ionic character, will improve the general dielectric misfortunes
of the paper tapes.

REFERENCES

1. L.R. Lewand (2004), “The negative effects of corrosive sulphur on transformer components”, Doble Engineering Company /
NETA World.

2. A.H. Rocha (2001), “Faults in a 500 kV shunt reactor by corrosive sulphur in insulating oil”, 68th International Conference
of Doble Clients, Sec. 5-4, Boston, USA.

3. Rajesh et.al (2016). Performance of leaf springs made of composite material subjected to low-frequency impact loading.
Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology, 30(9), pp.4291-4298.

4. Kannan et al. (2015). Reactive Power Pricing Using Group Search Optimization in Deregulated Electricity Market. In Power
Electronics and Renewable Energy Systems (pp. 305-312). Springer India.

5. T.Prabhu, (2013) Study Of Superconducting Fault Current Limiter (Sfcl) Technology For Optimal Power Plant Performance
And Grid Expansion, International Journal of MC Square Scientific Research Vol.5, No.1 Nov 2013.

Impact Factor (JCC): 6.8765 NAAS Rating: 3.11

Transformer Oils and Remedial Procedures on Corrosive Sulfur Effects 867

6. F. Scatiggio et al. (2008), “Corrosive sulphur in insulating oils: its detection and correlated apparatus failures”, IEEE Trans.
Power Delivery, Vol. 23, pp. 508-509.

7. Sadeq Yasoob Jasim & Jyoti Shrivastava, Dissolved Gas Analysis of Power Transformers, International Journal of Electrical
and Electronics Engineering Research (IJEEER), Volume 3, Issue 5, November - December 2013, pp. 1-10

8. Maina et al. (2011). Transformers surveillance following corrosive sulphur remedial procedures. IEEE Transactions on
Power Delivery, 26(4), 2391-2397.

9. Maina et al. (2009). Corrosive sulphur effects in transformer oils and therapeutic procedures. IEEE Transactions on
Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation, 16(6).

10. Scatiggio et.al (2011). Effects of metal deactivator concentration upon the gassing characteristics of transformer oils. IEEE
Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation, 18(3).

11. Scatiggio et.al (2009, May). Oils with the presence of corrosive sulphur: mitigation and collateral effects. In Electrical
Insulation Conference, 2009. EIC 2009. IEEE (pp. 478-481). IEEE.

12. Singh et.al (2008). Condition monitoring of power transformers-bibliography survey. IEEE Electrical Insulation Magazine,
24(3), 11.

13. Oweimreen et.al (2012). The depletion of dibenzyl disulphide from a mineral transformer insulating oil. IEEE Transactions on
Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation, 19(6).

14. Facciotti et.al (2014). Contact-based corrosion mechanism is leading to copper sulphide deposition on insulating paper used
in oil-immersed electrical power equipment. Corrosion Science, 84, 172-179.

15. Bruzzoniti et al. (2014). Stability and reactivity of sulphur compounds against copper in insulating mineral oil: definition of a
corrosiveness ranking. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 53(21), 8675-8684.

16. Wan et.al (2012). Suppressive mechanism of the passivator Irgamet 39 on the corrosion of copper conductors in transformers.
IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation, 19(2).

17. Rajeswari (2015), “power quality improvement of novel PWM based 15 level inverter for modified unified power Quality
conditioner (UPC)” International Journal of MC Square Scientific Research Vol.7, No.1

www.tjprc.org editor@tjprc.org