Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Autogenic Drainage: Modern Physiotherapy Cystic Fibrosis: Approach
Autogenic Drainage: Modern Physiotherapy Cystic Fibrosis: Approach
16 Volume 82 1989
Keywords: cystic fibrosis; physiotherapy; autogenic drainage; PEP mask; forced expiration technique
when the PEP method was compared to postural was to (a) unstick the peripheral mucus by breathing
drainage, FET, clapping and directed coughing, and at low lung volumes, (b) collect the mucus in the
despite the absence of any short-term improvement middle airways by breathing at tidal volume level and
in lung function, the PEP mask was said to be the finally (c) evacuate the secretions from the central
most acceptable, subjectively. It has been argued that airways by breathing at higher lung volumes. At the
PEP mask breathing affects the peripheral airways beginning of this breathing technique, inspiration
and collateral air channels, whereas coughing and should be slowly through the nose to guarantee
FET were only effective in airways where dynamic optimal moistening and heating of the inspired air;
compression occurs. One month of PEP treatment, this partly prevents coughing. At the end of an
however, was not superior to conventional clapping inspiration a short stop of breathing with an open
physiotherapy15 whereas 18 months of forced glottis is performed. Expiration is done without
expiration through PEP, a slightly modified PEP pursed lips breathing through the open mouth and
technique with high expiratory pressures, increased open glottis; the latter has to be learned and practised.
sputum yield in the range of 20%, increased Whether the glottis is kept open or closed can be
expiratory flow rates, decreased hyperinflation and verified by gasping without making a sound. By this
lowered airway instability16. The results of compar- breathing manoeuvre compression and bronchial
able studies over short axid long periods are given in obstruction are probably avoided.
Table 1. The first phase of unsticking secretions is then
started by a directed increased inspiration followed
Exercises by deep expiration. By concomitantly lowering mid
The need to have effective physiotherapy has been tidal volume below FRC level, the range of closing
demonstrated by the fact that continual physical volume is automatically reached and secretions from
therapy improves well being and the life of the CF peripheral lung regions are mobilized by compression
patients. Besides active treatment it has been of peripheral alveolar ducts. Mid respiratory tidal
recognized that sports at school and physical exercises volume is lowered in the range of normal expiratory
may substitute for chest physiotherapy in a minority reserve volume (ERV). The end of inhalation is
of patients. Although one study has shown that followed by a short breathing stop with open glottis
7 weeks of supervised swimming training can improve to ensure equal filling of all the lung segments,
lung function'7, in another study, 3 months exercise including the obstructed ones, by collateral filling.
training at home did not improve lung function or During the next exhalation the alveolar pressure
exercise tolerance and resulted in poor compliance18. will be the same in most lung parts, with minor
Favourable results of controlled sporting activities paradoxical airflow. The second phase of collecting
compared to physiotherapy were, however, reported mucus in the larger bronchi is achieved by deepening
by Blomquist'9, Edlund20 and Stanghelle2122. A inspiration and expiration. Tidal volume breathing
supplement of the International Journal of Sports is then changed gradually from expiratory reserve
Medicine23 has highlighted the benefits and pitfalls volume into the inspiratory reserve volume (IRV)
of exercise and training in CF patients. Other range to mobilize secretions from the apical parts of
reports24 suggest that active physical treatment - the lungs as well. The velocity of flow must be
such as PEP mask breathing - and exercise have controlled to avoid high flow peaks which result in
different immediate effects, with PEP mask breathing spasm of the collapsible segments at the equal
being superior to submaximal exercise in terms of pressure point (EPP). The longer the expiration
sputum production. For. older patients, ergometer time, the greater the distance the secretions are
exercise training at home improved the sense ofwell- transported. In the third and last phase the patient
being and had a positive effect in clearing sputum in increases flow starting from a level at about the
an adjunct to routine chest physiotherapy25. middle of his inspiratory reserve capacity (IRC) and
by a small burst of coughing the mucus is finally
Autogenic drainage (AD) brought out. At the end of this phase self control
In the search for an improved self-performed chest of flow is essential to avoid unproductive forced
physiotherapy to provide independence to the patient coughing.
and the most effective lung clearance of secretions, All the three phases are depicted in Figure 1 which
Chevaillier introduced a novel technique which was has been drawn according to the published data of
based mainly on precise observation of patients. Kraemer28. Several points havelto be considered
Mobilization of mucus was constantly observed in when learning this technique: first, it can only be
children during sleep when one could hear the mucus learned by the help of a trained person; secondly, the
move. Furthermore daily observations of children patient is in an upright sitting position, undergoes
showed that during breathing exercises, during anti- relaxation and concentration, performs diaphragmatic
crisis techniques (positions which are taken during breathing and tries to avoid paradoxical movements
acute asthmatic attacks), during playing and of the chest and coughing; thirdly, when learning this
laughing and during FEV, manoeuvres, mucus technique the patient is guided by tactile and auditive
moved better than most of the time during postural assistance of the teacher, which he gradually takes
drainage, pursed lip breathing, vibration and over and adds his proprioceptive sensations for
clapping. Based on these observations, Chevaillier detecting moving secretions; and finally, sessions of
introduced autogenic drainage (AD) which he 30-45 min twice a day are necessary.
described as a series of principles. In his description26, Based on the theory that, with autogenic drainage,
based on a paper by Alexander-7 and later again in higher flows of a longer duration can be achieved
a paper by Kraemer et aL28, the principle of reaching when performing partially forced expirations starting
the highest possible airflow in different generations from various volumes smaller than the total lung
of bronchi by controlled breathing was put into capacity (TLC), we registered flow volume curves from
practice by a three phase breathing exercise. The aim CF patients during autogenic drainage, from which
34 Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine Supplement No. 16 Volume 82 1989
Table 1. Summary ofpapers dealing with physiotherapy listed according to year as they appeared since 1979
Duration Durationi
Author n of session of trial Techniques Results
continued
Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine Supplement No. 16 Volume 82 1989 35
Table 1 continued
Duration Duration
Author n of session of trial Techniques Results
NOMAU PHASE: 1 2 3
technique preliminary results have been presented29,
showing that the mean sputum amount with AD was
16.3±4 g and with PEP mask breathing it was
RV
5.8±2.6 g, (n=8 CFI's, age 4-17 years, immediate
effect after one session with AD or PEP). In this same
report it is claimed that trapped gas was significantly
reduced. However, these data have never been
kl F I_ _ _ I . , v
published in a peer reviewed journal, and results are,
therefore, to be interpreted with caution. Autogenic
drainage has also been compared with PEP, PD and
Figure 1. Phases of autogenic drainage shown on a spirogram conventional physiotherapy by a cross-over design by
of a normal person Phase 1: unstick, phase 2: collect, phase the Vancouver Children's Hospital group30. These
3: evacuate. (Vt=tidal volume, ERV=expiratory reserve authors reported that after a two month period of
volume, RV=reserve volume, FRC= functional residual therapy several advantages ofAD or PEP over conven-
capacity, IRV= inspiratory reserve voume;IRV+ Vt+ERV= tional therapy occurred in patients with hyperreactive
vital capacity) airways with more sputum produced with AD. These
results agree with our own experiences. In a two
Fl ow (V) week's controlled inpatient study no statistically
l/sec significant improvement of lung function occurred,
but sputum production decreased and transcutaneous
oxygen saturation improved.
Conclusions
Several techni-ques are available today for effective
physiotherapy in CF patients. No single technique is
better than the others, so an individual adjustment
of a specific technique has to be determined for every
patient. General rules cannot be given but guidelines
can be suggested to adjust the techniques to the needs
of the patient. Age, severity of the disease, concomitant
Volius (V) pathology, familiarity with the technique, family back-
ground, social situation, intelligence, self esteem and
acceptance have to be considered when the physio-
therapy regimen is considered for a patient. A multi-
disciplinary approach is needed, with the views of
physicians, nurses, physiotherapists, sport therapists,
parents and friends being taken into account when
devising the physical therapy for each patient. The
best technique' for any patient is the one which he
Figure 2. Forced flow-volume curve (fat line) and partial flow- feels most comfortable with and is able to continue,
volume curves (small lines as they are produced in AD) from which produces the largest amount of sputum, and
a patient doing autogenic drainage; explanation see text which maintains acceptable health according to the
stage of disease. It is also known that the enthusiasm
a representative experiment is shown in Figure 2. of the physiotherapist, physician or teacher affects the
During forced expiration, (thick line) compression level of benefit received from the treatment. In this
occurs at low lung volumes, whereas, during AD, way, every effort we direct towards the individual needs
higher flow transients with the same low lung of the patient is rewarded by his or her well being.
volumes are achieved without bronchial collapse.
Thus, it seems that moving secretions is made easier Acknowledgment: The author thanks Mrs Rita Kieselmann,
in the peripheral parts of the lung. Munich, for assistance in teaching autogenic drainage in our
However, parts of this technique have been clinic.
challenged by German physiotherapists and clinicans
who stated that breathing in the ERV range was References
seldom observed in their patients due to difficulties to 1 Livingstone JL, Gillespie M. The value of breathing
exercises in asthma. Lancet 1935;i:705-6
lower mid tidal volume level. Therefore, they simplified 2 Miller WF. A physiologic evaluation of the effects of
the procedure so that the patient begins by moving his diaphragmatic breathing training in patients with
mid tidal volume up and down by deepening breaths chronic pulmonary emphysema. Am JMed 1954;17:471-9
and comfortably adapts the process to his individual 3 Sinclair JD. The effects of breathing exercises in
need without undue force or effort. After a breath pulmonary emphysema. Thorax 1955;10:246-52
arrest of about 2-3 s at the end of every inspiration, a 4 Becklake MR, McGregor M, Goldman HL, Brando JL. A
passive, relaxed but rather fast expiration to normal study of the effects of physiotherapy in chronic hyper-
expiratory level follows, succeeded by an actively trophic emphysema using lung function tests. Dis Chest
performed expiration supported by expiratory inter- 1954;26:180-90
costal muscles and thus driving down exhalation to 5 Feldman J, Traver GA, Taussig LM. Maximal expiratery
flows after postural drainage. Am Rev Respir Die 1979;
low ERV. Therefore, this 'German' technique uses a 119:239-43
combination of diaphragmatic and rib-cage breathing. 6 Desmond KJ, Schwenk WF, Eli Thomas PT, Beaudry PH,
In patients with easily collapsible airways, a Coates AL. Immediate and long term effects of chest
proximal expiratory stenosis such as pursed lips or physiotherapy in patients with cystic fibrosis. J Pediatr
nose breathing is recommended. Using this modified 1983;103:538-42
Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine Supplement No. 16 Volume 82 1989 37
7 Zapletal A, Stefanova J, Horak J, Vavrova V, Samanek 26 Chevaillier J. Autogenic Drainage (A.D.) In: Lawson D,
M. Chest physiotherapy and airway obstruction in ed. Cystic fibrosis: horizons. Chichester: John Wiley,
patients with cystic fibrosis - a negative report. Eur J 1984:235
Respir Dis 1983;64:426-33 27 Alexander FA. Physikalische Therapie beim kindlichen
8 Murray JF. The ketchup-bottle method. N Engl J Med Asthma bronchiale. Mschr Kinderheilk 1976;124:222-4
1979;300:1155-7 28 Kraemer R, Zumbuihl C, Rudeberg A, Lentze, MJ,
9 Pryor JA, Webber BA, Hodson ME, Batten JC. Evalu- Chevaillier J. 'Autogene Drainage' bei Patienten mit
ation of the forced expiration technique as an adjunct zystischer Fibrose. Pddiatr Prax 1986;33:223-32
to postural drainage in treatment of cystic fibrosis. Br 29 Schlemper B, Lindemann H, Bittner P. Ergebnisse einer
Med J 1979;2:417-8 Vergleichsstudie zwischen autogener Drainage und
10 Mead J, Turner J, Macklem PY, Little JB. Significance PEP-Maskenatmung. 7. Ambulanzleitertagung der
of the relationship between lung recoil and maximal Deutschen Gesellschaft zur Bekampfung der Muco-
expiratory flow. J Appi Physiol 1967;22:95-108 viscidose. Schumacher H. ed. 1986.
11 Rossman CM, Waldes R, Sampson D, Newhouse MT. 30 Mcllwaine M, Davison AGF, Wong LTK, Pirie GE,
Effect of chest physiotherapy on the removal of mucus Nakielna EM. Comparison of positive expiratory
in patients with cystic fibrosis. Am Rev Respir Dis pressure and autogenic drainage with conventional
1982;126:131-5 percussion and drainage therapy in the treatment of CF.
12 De Boeck Ch, Zinman R. Cough versus chest physio- Congress Abstracts, Exerpta Medica, Asia Pacific
therapy. Am Rev Respir Dis 1984;129:182-4 Congress Series, 10th International Cystic Fibrosis
13 Hartsell M. The effect of postural drainage, manual Congress, Sydney, Australia, 1988
percussion and vibration vs. postural drainage and and 31 Hardy KA, Wolfson MR, Titinsky M, Motley R, Shaffer
mechanical vibration on maximal expiratory flows. Am H, Schidlow DV. The effect of combined therapy of
Rev Respir Dis 1978;117:204 aerolized bronchodilators and chest physiotherapy on
14 Falk M, Kelstrup M, Andersen JB, Kinoshita T, Falk newly diagnosed infants with cystic fibrosis. CF Club
P, Stovring S, Gothgen I. Improving the ketchup bottle Abstracts 1986;27:33
method with positive expiratory pressure,PEP, in cystic 32 DeCesare, JA, Babchyck BM, Colten HR, Treves S.
fibrosis. Eur J Respir Dis 1984;65:423-32 Radionuclide assessment of the effects of chest physical
15 Tyrrell JC, Martin J, Hiller EJ. PEP mask therapy on ventilation in cystic fibrosis. Phys Ther
physiotherapy in cystic fibrosis. 13th Annual Meeting 1982;62:820-5
of the European Working Group for Cystic Fibrosis. 33 Sutton PP, Parker RA, Webber BA, Newman SP,
Book of Abstracts, Jerusalem. 1985:23 Garland N, Lopez-Vidriero MT, Pavia D, Clarke SW.
16 Oberwaldner B, Evans JC, Zach MS. Forced expiration Assessment of the forced expiration technique, postural
against a variable resistance: A new chest physiotherapy drainage and directed coughing in chest physiotherapy.
method in cystic fibrosis. Pediatr Pulmonol 1986;2: Eur J Respir Dis 1983;64:62-8
358-67 34 Webber BA, Parker RA, Hofmeyr JL, Hodson ME. Evalu-
17 Zach MS, Purrer B, Oberwaldner B. Effect of swimming ation of self-percussion during postural drainage using
on forced expiration and sputum clearance in cystic the forced expiration technique (FET). In: Lawson D, ed.
fibrosis. Lancet 1981;ii:1201-3 Cystic fibrosis: horizons. Chichester: John Wiley, 1984:229
18 Holzer FJ, Schnall R, Landau LI. The effect of home 35 Parker RA, Webber BA, Sutton PP, Newman SP.
exercise programme in children with cystic fibrosis and Garland N, Lopez-Vidriero, Pavia D, Clarke SW.
asthma. Aust Paediatr 1984;20:297-302 Evaluation of three individual components of postural
19 Blomquist M, Freyschuss U, Wiman L-G, Strandvik B. drainage treatment. In: Lawson D, ed. Cystic fibrosis:
Physical activity and self treatment in cystic fibrosis. horizons. Chichester: John Wiley, 1984:230
Arch Dis Child 1986;61:362-7 36 Rogers D, Tottle J, Pickering DM, Plews E, Davies V,
20 Edlund LD, French FW, Herbst JJ, Ruttenbuerg HD, Newcombe RG, Goodchild MC, Dodge JA. Comparison
Ruhlung RO, Adams TD. Effects of a swimming program of physiotherapy techniques employed in cystic fibrosis.
on children with cystic fibrosis. Am J Dis Child In: Lawson D, ed Cystic fibrosis: horizons. Chichester:
1986;140:80-83 John Wiley, 1984:232
21 Stanghelle JK, Michalsen H, Skyberg D. Five-year 37 Van der LaagJ, Steenbergen H,Helders PJM. Prolonged
follow-up of pulmonary function and peak oxygen uptake use of forced expiration technique in cystic fibrosis. In:
in 16 year old boys with cystic fibrosis, with special Lawson D, ed Cystic fibrosis: horizons. Chichester: John
regard to the influence of regular physical exercise. Int Wiley, 1984:233
J Sports Med 1988;Supplement 9:19-25 38 Verboon JML, Bakker W, Dukman JH. Effect of the
22 Stanghelle JK, Hjeltnes N, Bangstad HJ, Michalsen H. forced expiration technique and postural drainage in
Effect of daily short bouts of trampoline exercise during adults with cystic fibrosis. In: Lawson D, ed Cystic
8 weeks on pulmonary function and the maximal oxygen fibrosis: horizons. Chichester: John Wiley, 1984:234
uptake of children with cystic fibrosis. Int J Sports Med 39 Groth S, Stafanger G, Dirksen H, Andersen JB, Falk
1988;Supplement 9:32-7 M, Kelstrup M. Positive expiratory pressure (PEP-mask)
23 Supplement 1, Vol 9, International Journal of Sports physiotherapy improves ventilation and reduces volume
Medicine 1988 of trapped gas incystic fibrosis. Bull Eur Physiopathol
24 Falk M, Kelstrup M, Andersen JB, Pedersen SS, Rossing Respir 1985;21:339-43
I, Dirksen H. PEP treatment or physical exercise- Effects 40 Webber BA, Hofmeyr JL, Hodson ME, Batten JC. The
on secretions expectorated and indices of central and effects of postural drainage incorporating the forced
peripheral airway function. Congress Abstracts, Exerpta Expiration technique on pulmonary function in cystic
Medica, Asia Pacific Congress Series, 10th International fibrosis. 13th Annual Meeting ofthe European Working
Cystic Fibrosis Congress, Sydney, Australia, 1988;35 Group for Cystic Fibrosis. Book of Abstracts, Jerusalem
25 Salh B, Dodds M, Webb AK. Influence of ergometer 1985:24
training on sputum output and physical fitness in 41 Webber BA, Hofmeyr Jn, Hodson ME, Baten JC.
adult cystic fibrosis patients. Congress Abstracts, Evaluation of positive expiratory pressure as an adjunct
Excerpta Medica, Asia Pacific Congress Series, 10th to postural drainage. 13th Annual Meeting of the
International Cystic Fibrosis Congress, Sydney, European Working Group for Cystic Fibrosis. Book of
Australia, 1988;36 Abstracts, Jerusalem. 1985:95