Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RG-1 Agents that are not associated with diseases Bacillus subtilis, Escherichia coli
in healthy adult humans K12, adeno-associated virus (AAV)
RG-2 Agents that are associated with human Staphylococcus aureus, Salmonella
diseases that are rarely serious and for which sp, Herpes simplex viruses,
preventive or therapeutic interventions are Adenovirus
often available
RG-3 Agents that are associated with serious or Mycobacterium tuberculosis,
lethal human diseases for which preventive or Bacillus anthracis, HIV
therapeutic interventions may be available
RG-4 Agents that are likely to cause serious or Ebola virus, Marbug virus, Lassa
lethal human diseases for which preventive or virus
therapeutic interventions are not usually
available
PERTINENT LAWS
I. ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER (AO) 2007-0027 (CLINICAL LABORATORY STAFF)
- Governs the licensing and regulation of clinical laboratories in the Philippines
- A clinical laboratory should be headed by a registered medical technologist and managed by a
pathologist (clinical/anatomical) who is duly certified by the Philippine Board of Pathology
SEC. 1
Any person, firm or corporation, operating and maintaining a clinical laboratory in which body
fluids, tissues, secretions, excretions and radioactivity from beings or animals are analyzed for the
determination of the presence of pathologic organisms, processes and/or conditions in the
persons or animals from which they were obtained, shall register and secure a license annually at
the office of the Secretary of Health: provided, that government hospital laboratories doing
routine or minimum laboratory examinations shall be exempt from the provisions of this section
if their services are extensions of government regional or central laboratories.
and provided further that laboratories being used solely for academic training and/or for purely
research activities are likewise not herein covered. (AO 201 s. 1973)
SEC. 2
It shall be unlawful for any person to be professionally in-charge of a registered clinical laboratory
unless he is a licensed physician duly qualified in laboratory medicine and authorized by the
Secretary of Health, such authorization to be renewed annually.
No license shall be granted or renewed by the Secretary of Health for the operation and
maintenance of a clinical laboratory unless such laboratory is under the administration, direction
and supervision of an authorized physician, as provided for in the preceding paragraph.
SEC. 3
The Secretary of Health, through the Bureau of Research and Laboratories shall be charged with
the responsibility of strictly enforcing the provisions of this Act and shall be authorized to issue
such rules and regulations as may be necessary to carry out its provisions.
SEC. 4
Any person, firm or corporation who violates any provisions of this Act or the rules and regulations
issued thereunder by the Secretary of Health shall be punished with imprisonment for not less
than one month but not more than one year, or by a fine of not less than one thousand pesos nor
more than five thousand pesos, or both such fine and imprisonment, at the discretion of the court.
SEC. 5
If any section or part of this Act shall be adjudged by any court of competent jurisdiction to be
invalid, the judgment shall not affect, impair, or invalidate the remainder thereof.
SEC. 6
The sum of fifty thousand pesos, or so mush thereof as may be necessary, is hereby authorized to
be appropriated, out of any funds in the National Treasury not otherwise appropriated, to carry
into effect the provisions of this Act.
SEC. 7
All Acts or parts of Acts which are inconsistent with the provisions of this Act are hereby repealed.
SEC. 8
This Act shall take effect upon its approval.
III. ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER (AO) 201 S. 1973
If the applicant is a partnership or corporation it must be duly registered under existing laws, and
that a copy of its registration papers to be attached to the corresponding petition. An inspector of
the Bureau of Research and Laboratories shall, upon receipt of said application inspect within 60
days the establishment and verify if the applicant has complied with the requirements prescribed
in these regulations. The license will henceforth be issued, signed and approved by the Secretary
of Health, if the application is found to be meritorious; otherwise the same shall be returned
without action.
SEC. 5
No Clinical Laboratory is allowed to operate without the proper license from the Secretary of
Health thru the Bureau of Research and Laboratories who are charged with the responsibility of
strictly enforcing the provisions of Republic Act No. 4688 and the Rules herein promulgated.
SEC. 6
No person is permitted to manage, administer or supervise a clinical laboratory unless he is a
physician, licensed and duly registered with the Board of Medical Examiners of the Republic of the
Philippines, qualified in laboratory medicine as stipulated in Section 7 (b) and duly authorized by
the Secretary of Health, such authorization to be renewed annually. This authorization shall be
exempted of any fees.
SEC. 8 INTERPRETATIONS
Except as specifically authorized by the Secretary of Health in writing, no interpretation of the
meaning of the regulations or its part by any officer or employee of the Office of the Secretary of
Health other than a written interpretation by the Secretary of Justice will be recognized to be
binding upon the Secretary of Health.
SEC. 12 REPORTING
All laboratory requests shall be considered as consultations between the requesting physician and
the pathologist of the laboratory. As such all laboratory reports on various examinations of human
specimens shall be construed as consultations. No person working in an approved clinical
laboratory shall issue a report, orally or in writing or portions thereof without the actual signature
of the Pathologist or his authorized associate or assistants, to the requesting physician or his
authorized representative except in emergencies when the results may be released as authorized
by the Pathologist.
SEC. 13 RECORDING
An adequate and effective system of recording all requests and reports of all human specimens
submitted to and examined in the laboratory should be maintained to include provisions for filing,
storage, indexing and accession number in addition to patient's personal and clinical information
to prevent erroneous reporting and permit ready identification and retrieving. All requests and
reports in clinical laboratory shall be kept on file for at least one year provided a duplicate copy is
on file for the patient's medical records. Records of anatomic and forensic pathology should be
kept permanently in the laboratory.
SEC. 15 PUBLICITY
Publicity of approved laboratory should be within the normal, ethical and professional concepts
of acceptable medical practice. Only the name of the laboratory, address, telephone number of
the laboratory, pathologists and assistants and field of work covered by the licensure shall appear
on the letterhead and other information media. Advertising matter should be directed exclusively
to physician through recognized professional bulletins or medical journals. No laboratory shall
make advertisement on medical pad, fictitious and unproven claim misleading statements and to
advocate directly or by any means of subterfuge unreliable and inconclusive laboratory
procedures which may prove detriment to patient care.
SEC. 16 Exhibition of Certificate of Approval and license and rules and regulations
The license of the clinical laboratory must be placed in a conspicuous place within the laboratory.
The physician-in-charge must likewise place his or her license and authority together with his
certificate of proficiency in the specialty in a prominent place in the laboratory. A copy of the rules
and regulations should be readily available for guidance of all staff and personnel in the laboratory.
SEC. 17 EXPIRATION
Each specific license shall expire on the last day of December of the year stated therein, including
the authorization given to the Head, Director or Physician-in-charge of the clinical laboratory.
SEC. 18 RENEWAL
Application for renewal of license shall be filed in accordance with the preceding Section 3 & 4.
The Bureau of Research and Laboratories shall process applications for license or renewal
immediately upon receipt thereof, provided, however, that such clinical laboratory may continue
operation during the pendency of the final action of their applications unless otherwise or ordered
or advised by the Secretary of Health to cease operation.
SEC. 19 INSPECTION
It shall be the duty of the Secretary of Health or his representative to conduct periodical inspection
of clinical laboratories
(1) Each license shall give the Secretary of Health or his duly authorized representatives the
opportunity at all reasonable time to inspect the premises and facilities of the clinical
laboratory.
(2) Each license shall make available all records kept him pursuant to those regulations for
inspection by the Secretary of Health of his authorized representatives.
(3) Directors of Regional Health Office, Provincial, city or municipal Health Officers are required
to report the existence of unlicensed clinical laboratories, and/or violations of these rules to
the Bureau of Research and Laboratories.
SEC. 23 VIOLATIONS
Any person who violated any provisions of these rules and regulations shall be punished with
imprisonment for not less than one month but not more than one year or a fine of not less than
one month but not more than one year or a fine of not less than one thousand pesos (P 1,000.00)
but not more than five thousand (P5,000.00) pesos, or both such fine and imprisonment at the
discretion of the court. Provided, however, that if the offender is a firm or corporation, the
managing head and/or owner thereof shall be liable to the penalty imposed herein.
SEC. 24 EFFECTIVITY
These rules and regulations shall take effect upon approval and publication as required.
V. AO NO. 59 S. 2001
- Implements provisions regarding the rules and regulations on the operation, maintenance
and establishment of clinical laboratories in the Philippines
SEC. 2 AUTHORITY
These rules and regulations are issued to implement R.A. 4688: Clinical Laboratory Law
consistent with E.O. 102 series 1999: Redirecting the Functions and Operations of the
Department of Health. The Department of Health (DOH), through the Bureau of Health Facilities
and Services (BHFS) in the Health Regulation Cluster, shall exercise the regulatory functions
under these rules and regulations.
SEC. 3 PURPOSE
These rules and regulations are promulgated to protect and promote the health of the people
by ensuring availability of clinical laboratories that are properly managed with adequate
resources, with effective and efficient performance through compliance with quality standards.
SEC. 4 SCOPE
1. These regulations shall apply to all entities performing the activities and functions of clinical
laboratories which shall include the examination and analysis of any or all samples of human
and other related tissues, fluids, secretions, radioactive, or other materials from the human
body for the determination of the existence of pathogenic organisms, pathologic processes
or conditions in the person from whom such samples are obtained.
2. These regulations do not include government laboratories doing laboratory examinations
limited to acid fast bacilli microscopy, malaria screening and cervical cancer screening,
provided their services are declared as extension of a licensed government clinical
laboratory.
SEC. 6 POLICIES
1. An approved permit to construct and design lay-out of a clinical laboratory shall be secured
form the BHFS prior to submission of an application for a Petition to Operate.
2. No clinical laboratory shall be constructed unless plans have been approved and
construction permit issued by the BHFS.
3. A clinical laboratory shall operate with a valid license issued by BHFS/CHD, based on
compliance with the minimum licensing requirements (Annex A).
4. The clinical laboratory shall be organized and managed to provide effective and efficient
laboratory services.
5. The clinical laboratory shall provide adequate and appropriate safety practices for its
personnel and clientele.
SEC. 8 VIOLATIONS
1. The license to operate a clinical laboratory shall be suspended or revoked by the Secretary
of Health upon violation of R.A. 4688 or the Rules and Regulations issued in pursuance
thereto.
2. The following acts committed by the Owner, President, Managers, Board of
Trustees/Director, Pathologist or its personnel are considered violations.
a. Operation of a clinical laboratory without a certified pathologist or without a
registered medical technologist.
b. Change of ownership, location, head of laboratory or personnel without informing
the BHFS and/or the CHD.
c. Refusal to allow inspection of the clinical laboratory by the person(s) authorized by
the BHFS during reasonable hours.
d. Gross negligence.
e. Any act or omission detrimental to the public.
3. The Provincial, City and Municipal Health Officers are authorized to report to the CHD and
BHFS the existence of unlicensed clinical laboratories or any private party performing
laboratory examinations without proper license and/or violations to these rules and
regulations.
If upon investigation, any person is found violating the provision of R.A. 4688, or any of these
rules and regulations, the BHFS/CHD or his duly authorized representative(s) shall suspend,
cancel or revoke for a determined period of time the license, as well as the authority of the
offending person(s), without prejudice to taking the case to judicial authority for criminal
action.
2. Any person who operated a clinical laboratory without the proper license from the
Department of Health shall upon conviction be subject to imprisonment for not less than 1
month but not more 1 year or a fine of not less than P1,000.00 and not more than P5,000.00
and not more than P5,000.00 or both at the discretion of the court. Provided, however, that
if the offender is a firm or corporation, the Managing Head and/or owner/s thereof shall be
liable to the penalty imposed herein.
3. Any Clinical Laboratory operating without a valid license or whose license has been
revoked/cancelled shall be summarily closed upon order issued by the BHFS/CHD or his duly
authorized representative. The BHFS/CHD may seek the assistance of the law enforcement
agency to enforce the closure of any clinical laboratory.
4. The closure order issued by the DOH shall not be rendered ineffective by any restraining
order and injunction order issued by any court, tribunal or agency or instrumentalities.
2) Freestanding laboratory
a laboratory that operates outside the premises of an institution and operates
independently.
II. OBJECTIVE
- To prescribe a revised minimum standard for clinical laboratories
- To ensure accuracy and precision of laboratory examinations in order to safeguard public
health and safety
§ Clinical Laboratory- a facility where tests are done on specimens from the human body
to obtain information about the health status of a patient for the prevention, diagnosis
and treatment of diseases.
§ STAT Tests- tests done on urgent cases, the results of which shall be released
immediately, within one (1) hour after the procedure. STAT is an abbreviation for sta'tim
which means immediately.
VI. GUIDELINES
A. GENERAL GUIDELINES
1. The LTO shall be issued only to clinical laboratories that comply with the standards and
technical requirements formulated by the BHFS.
2. Clinical laboratories that are operated and maintained exclusively for research and teaching
purposes shall be exempted from the licensing requirement of this Order but shall be
required to register with the BHFS.
3. Special clinical laboratories that are not subject to the provisions of other administrative
orders, such as but not limited to, Assisted Reproduction Technology Laboratories,
Molecular and Cellular Technology, Molecular Biology, Molecular Pathology, Forensic
Pathology, Anatomic Pathology laboratories operating independent of a clinical laboratory
are required to register with the BHFS without being licensed under the provisions of this
Order. Such procedure shall subsist until the appropriate regulation for such purpose is
subsequently promulgated. A pathologist or a licensed physician who is trained in the
management, principles and methodology of the specialized services that are being
provided shall head this type of laboratory.
4. The NRL designated by the DOH shall be covered by the license of the clinical laboratory of
the hospital where they are respectively assigned. The NRL that is physically independent
from the clinical laboratory of the hospital where they are respectively assigned shall be
allowed to register only with the BHFS, provided that, they are duly accredited or certified
by an international accrediting or certifying body, such as but not limited to, the Center for
Disease Control of the U.S.A. and the World Health Organization and/or local accrediting or
certifying body recognized by the DOH.
B. SPECIFIC GUIDELINES
I. Standards
Every clinical laboratory shall be organized to provide quality, effective and efficient
laboratory services.
(a) Human Resource
(b) Equipment
(c) Glassware, Reagents and Supplies
(d) Administrative Policies and Procedures
(e) Technical Procedures
(f) Quality Assurance Program
(g) Communication and Records
(h) Physical Facilities/Work Environment
(i) Referral of Examinations outside of the Clinical Laboratory
II. LTO (License to Operate)
IX. VIOLATIONS
Violation of Republic Act 4688 or these rules and regulations and/or commission of the following
acts by personnel operating the clinical laboratory under this authority shall be penalized.
X. INVESTIGATION OF COMPLAINTS
A. The BHFS or the CHD Director or his authorized representative(s) shall investigate the
complaint and verify if the laboratory concerned or any of its personnel is accountable for
an alleged violation.
B. The CHD Director or his authorized representative(s), after investigation, shall suspend,
cancel or revoke for a determined period of time the LTO of licensees who are found
violating the provision of R.A. 4688 or this Order, without prejudice to taking the case to
judicial authority for criminal action. The CHD shall seek the assistance of any law
enforcement agency to execute the closure of any erring clinical laboratory, when necessary.
XI. PENALTY
Any person who operates a clinical laboratory without the proper license from the DOH shall
upon conviction be subject to imprisonment for not less than one (1) month or a fine of not less
than Php 1,000.00 and not more than Php 5,000.00 or both at the discretion of the court.
Provided, however, that if the offender is a firm or corporation, the managing head and/or
owner(s) thereof shall be liable to the penalty imposed herein.
XII. APPEAL
The decision of the BHFS/CHD may be appealed to the Office of the Health Secretary within ten
(10) days after receipt of the notice of the decision. Thereupon, the BHFS shall promptly certify
and file a copy of the decision, including all documents and transcripts of hearings on which the
decision is based, with the Office of the Health Secretary for review. The decision of the Office
of the Health Secretary is final and executory.
Section III of Administrative Order No. 2007 - 0027 "Revised Rules and Regulation Governing
Licensure and Regulation of Clinical Laboratories in the Philippines" is hereby amended to
exempt the NTRL and its regional TB Reference Laboratories performing TB culture from securing
a license to operate a clinical laboratory provided they adhere to program policies and
international standards and requirements as a National Reference Laboratory.
The following guidelines shall be enforced as requirement for renewal of license to operate (LTO)
of clinical laboratories nationwide:
Starting 2013, upon filing for renewal of License to Operate (LTO) for 2014 and thereafter, a
NEQAS Certificate of Participation/Proficiency Testing Certificate of the previous year or the
current year if available shall be included as documentary requirement in the following areas:
a) Hematology for Primary, Secondary and Tertiary Clinical Laboratories issued by the
National Kidney and Transplant Institute.
b) Clinical Chemistry for Secondary and Tertiary Clinical Laboratories issued by the Lung
Center of the Philippines.
c) HIV/AIDS, hepatitis, Syphilis and other STIs for all HIV Accredited Testing Laboratories,
Secondary and Tertiary Clinical Laboratories performing the tests issued by STD - AIDS
Central Clinical Laboratory (SACCL), San Lazaro Hospital.
d) Drug and Drinking Water Testing Laboratories issued by East Avenue Medical Center.
e) Bacteriology, TB, and Parasitology for all Tertiary Clinical Laboratories issued by Research
Institute for Tropical Medicine (RITM). By 2014, the certificate of participation in
Antimicrobial Resistance Surveillance Program (ARSP) for PhilHealth accreditation shall not
be recognized as NEQAS for bacteriology component.
Health laboratory services of the Department of Health have been established primarily to give
the adequate laboratory support to the clinicians in the diagnosis and therapy of patients and to
help detect pathologic changes prior to its manifest signs and symptoms. However, it has been
long been aware that while accomplishing this primary objective, it plays an important role in
the training of medical technology interns. A balance must be had at all times so that service and
training can go hand in hand effectively. In line thereof with the policies of fully maximizing the
effectivity of laboratory services, of upgrading the training of medical technology interns and of
properly utilizing the medical technology during training, the Department of Health promulgated
rules and regulations to be strictly observed and complied with in the affiliation of medical
technology interns in the Department of Health laboratories
Sec. 2 Authority
These rules and regulations are issued in accordance to Section 13 of Republic Act 5527 (Medical
Technology Act of 1969) and consistent with Executive Order 119 (Reorganization Act of the
Ministry of Health) and R.A. 4688 (Clinical Laboratory Law), R.A. 1517 (Blood Bank Law).
Sec. 3 Purpose
These rules and regulations are promulgated to upgrade the training of medical technology
interns to maintain the quality of laboratory services, and to properly utilize the medical
technology interns during their training. Only those laboratories which are accredited for training
shall be utilized for the affiliation of medical technology interns.
Sec. 4 Scope
The rules and regulations embodied herein shall apply to all clinical laboratories performing
examinations for the diagnosis of diseases or for public health purposes as defined in R.A. 4688
and utilized as training laboratories for medical technology interns from universities and colleges
offering medical technology courses.
Sec. 6 Accreditation Requirements for a Training Laboratory for Medical Technology Interns
1. All clinical laboratories must be required to demonstrate compliance with the following
technical standards as requirements for accreditation.
a. The Clinical Laboratory shall be duly licensed by the Bureau of Research and
Laboratories (BRL).
b. The laboratory shall be headed by and under the supervision of a duly licensed physician
who is certified by the Philippine Board of Pathology.
c. The laboratory shall be staffed by at least one (1) medical technologist, duly registered
with the Board of Medical Technology for each of the sections of Clinical Chemistry,
Clinical Microscopy, Microbiology, Hematology, Blood Banking and Serology and
Histopathology
d. The physical plant shall have adequate laboratory space to accommodate both
laboratory staff and medical technology interns.
e. There should be sufficient equipment and supplies necessary depending on the volume
and type of examinations as well as the number of interns to be trained by the
laboratory.
f. A section of the laboratory can be utilized for training only if it has a sufficient volume
of laboratory examination adequate for training of at least one Medical Technology
Intern.
g. The laboratory should have a written training program for the Medical Technology
interns.
2. The BRL shall evaluate compliance to the technical standards in accordance with the
requirements including the minimum number of examination of samples required of each
section as the BRL may promulgate.
Sec 8. Reporting
Each accredited clinical laboratories shall render an annual report of the number of Medical
Technology interns training, the number of examinations performed and other activities in
accordance with the format prescribed of the BRL.
Sec 9. Affiliation of Medical Technology Interns from Universities, Colleges and School of
Medical Technology
Accredited clinical laboratories shall be allowed to accept for affiliation Medical Technology
interns from universities, schools or colleges of Medical Technology who have met the
requirements specified in the Department of Health Administrative Order No. 70-A series 1989.
Sec. 13 Inspection
Clinical Laboratory for training of Medical Technology intern's facilities and records shall be
subject to regular inspection to determine compliance with the above regulations.
1. The Director of Bureau of Research and Laboratories or his duly authorized representative(s)
shall be given reasonable time and opportunity to inspect the premises and facilities wherein
the training of Medical Technology interns is being performed.
2. Each laboratory shall make available to the Director of the Bureau of Research and
Laboratories or his duly authorized representative all records kept pursuant to these
regulations for inspection.
3. The Director of the Bureau of Research and Laboratories or his representative may be
assisted by duly designated experts from professional associations in such inspections.
4. Directors of Regional Health Offices, Provincial, City and Municipal Health Officers are
hereby directed to report to the Bureau of Research and Laboratories the existence of
unaccredited clinical laboratories training Medical Technology interns or any private party
performing such training without a proper accreditation certificate.
Sec. 20 Violations
1. The certificate of accreditation of a laboratory to train Medical Technology interns shall be
suspended or revoked by the Undersecretary of Health for Standards and Regulation for any
violation of these Rules and Regulations, including the following acts:
a. Training Medical Technology interns without a qualified Pathologist or Medical
Technologist.
b. Any material false statement in the application.
c. Failure to correct deficiencies within a reasonable time after due notice from the Bureau
of Research and Laboratories.
d. Refusal to allow inspection of the laboratory by persons authorized by the Bureau of
Research and Laboratories during reasonable hours.
e. Repeated failure to submit an annual report to the Bureau of Research and Laboratories.
2. Any clinical laboratory that violates these rules and regulations shall be liable under the
Medical Technology Act (R.A. 5527) and Clinical Laboratory Law (R.A. 4688), and shall suffer
penalties provided for in these laws and the Revised Rules and Regulations issued pursuant to
such laws. Such violations shall be the basis for sanctions including suspension or revocation of
the license to operate the Clinical Laboratory.
Section 21
Upon the filing of a complaint or charge duly sworn to by any person or interested party against
a clinical laboratory or of any of its personnel for violating any provisions of this regulations, the
Undersecretary of Health for Standards and Regulation or his duly authorized representative(s)
shall investigate the complaint or charges and verify if the laboratory concerned or any of its
personnel is guilty of the charges. If upon investigation, a person or persons are found violating
any of the provision of this rules and regulations, the Undersecretary of Health for Standards and
Regulations shall suspend for a definite or indefinite period of time or cancel or revoke the
accreditation of the laboratory without prejudice to taking the case to judicial authorities for
criminal action.
CASE
ORLANDO D. GARCIA, JR., doing business under the name and style COMMUNITY
DIAGNOSTIC CENTER and BU CASTRO
vs.
RANIDA D. SALVADOR and RAMON SALVADOR
FACTS
When Ranida submitted the test result to Dr. Sto. Domingo, the Company physician, the latter
apprised her that the findings indicated that she is suffering from Hepatitis B, a liver disease.
Thus, based on the medical report submitted by Sto. Domingo, the Company terminated Ranida's
employment for failing the physical examination.
When Ranida informed her father, Ramon, about her ailment, the latter suffered a heart attack
and was confined at the Bataan Doctors Hospital. During Ramon's confinement, Ranida
underwent another HBs Ag test at the said hospital and the result indicated that she is non-
reactive. She informed Sto. Domingo of this development but was told that the test conducted
by CDC was more reliable because it used the Micro-Elisa Method.
Thus, Ranida went back to CDC for confirmatory testing, and this time, the Anti-HBs test
conducted on her indicated a "Negative" result. Ranida also underwent another HBs Ag test at
the Bataan Doctors Hospital using the Micro-Elisa Method. The result indicated that she was non-
reactive.
Ranida submitted the test results from Bataan Doctors Hospital and CDC to the Executive Officer
of the Company who requested her to undergo another similar test before her re-employment
would be considered. Thus, CDC conducted another HBs Ag test on Ranida which indicated a
"Negative" result. Ma. Ruby G. Calderon, Med-Tech Officer-in-Charge of CDC, issued a
Certification correcting the initial result and explaining that the examining medical technologist
(Garcia) interpreted the delayed reaction as positive or reactive. Thereafter, the Company
rehired Ranida.
Ranida and Ramon filed a complaint for damages against petitioner Garcia and a purportedly
unknown pathologist of CDC, claiming that, by reason of the erroneous interpretation of the
results of Ranida's examination, she lost her job and suffered serious mental anxiety, trauma and
sleepless nights, while Ramon was hospitalized and lost business opportunities.
Garcia denied the allegations of gross negligence and incompetence and reiterated the scientific
explanation for the "false positive" result of the first HBs Ag test. On the other hand, Castro
claimed that as pathologist, he rarely went to CDC and only when a case was referred to him;
that he did not examine Ranida; and that the test results bore only his rubber-stamp signature.
ISSUE
Whether or not Garcia should be held liable liable for damages to the respondents for issuing an
incorrect HBsAG test result.
RULING
YES. Owners and operators of clinical laboratories have the duty to comply with statutes, as well
as rules and regulations, purposely promulgated to protect and promote the health of the people
by preventing the operation of substandard, improperly managed and inadequately supported
clinical laboratories and by improving the quality of performance of clinical laboratory
examinations. Their business is impressed with public interest, as such, high standards of
performance are expected from them.
In fine, violation of a statutory duty is negligence. Where the law imposes upon a person the
duty to do something, his omission or non-performance will render him liable to whoever may
be injured thereby.
The Supreme Court ruled that petitioner Garcia failed to comply with these standards. First, CDC
is not administered, directed and supervised by a licensed physician as required by law, but by
Ma. Ruby C. Calderon, a licensed Medical Technologist. Second, Garcia conducted the HBsAG
test of respondent Ranida without the supervision of defendant-appellee Castro. Last, the
disputed HBsAG test result was released to respondent Ranida without the authorization of
defendant-appellee Castro.