Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By Sally Morem
Take “Do not kill,” for example. In English, the verb “kill” means to put any
organism to death. Such a broad moral command would be wholly impractical
for human life (if anyone actually bothered to obey it). In effect, this
commandment is ordering us to starve to death. We are animals. We don’t do
photosynthesis. We must kill or have proxies kill in order for us to live.
Changing the word to “murder” would quickly clear up any confusion.
However, religious dogma seems to disdain any such tampering with Holy
Writ.
Or, “You shall have no other gods before me.” This commandment presumably
records a decree from a tribal god to a specific ancient desert tribe, ordering
members to disdain worship of other, presumably equally real, tribal gods. Not
exactly the message a monotheistic religion would intent to deliver to its
present-day believers.
Religious commandments and dogma can’t possibly instill and enforce moral
thinking in stubborn and willful human beings anyway. Commandments and
dogma are too abstract and too legalistic to fulfill these sociological roles. All
they can do is codify existing moral sentiments and religious beliefs.
So, where does morality come from? We are primed for moral thought and
action by deeply encoded emotional responses (such as anger, shame,
gratification, pride, and joy) to acutely important events in our lives. These
emotions are programmed into the limbic system by our interactions early in
life with a truly powerful, universal, primal being: Mom. You don’t believe
me? Check out Mom’s Ten Commandments:
1. Hello love! Give me a hug!
2. Don’t throw that ball in here! Go outside!
3. Clean up your room!
4. Don’t touch!
5. That isn’t yours! Put it back!
6. Don’t talk with your mouth full!
7. Quit hitting your brother!
8. Share with your sister!
9. Remember the magic words! Say, ‘Please and thank you!’
10. Bedtime! Give me a kiss!
Mom’s simple words and gestures eventually fashion and uphold every cultural
imperative and moral sentiment that ever existed or will exist.
Where does Mom get morality? From Grandma. How about Grandma? From
Great Grandma…and so on.
So, if you’re confused and don’t know which way to go, don’t worry about
religious commandments. Ask Mom.