Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reactive
Power Management
It gives us immense pleasure to present a compilation of the first twelve issues of –|VArticle|–, a
technical write-up related to Reactive Power Management. Over the past twelve articles, we
have tried our best to provide insights into selection of capacitors, filters, switchgear for capacitor
switching and harmonics.
Our aim has been to create awareness on latest technology trends, and present some facts in the
domain of Reactive Power Management. Some –|VArticle|– also give information about
available product options to satisfy customer requirements.
Most of the information included in the –|VArticle|– is based on basic electrical engineering
fundamentals and our on-field experience.
This compilation would be useful to consultants, end users and individuals interested in
understanding current issues in Reactive Power Management.
Please feel free to get back to us with technical queries or requests for covering specific topics in
future –|VArticle|– .
Regards,
Q-factor 07
K-factor Transformers 08
Transformer Compensation 09
Capacitor Switching in APFC Panels 10
Fuse Selection for APFC Panels 11
MCCB Selection for APFC Panels 12
Life of Power Capacitors 13
Capacitor Power Loss Calculation 14
Harmonic Mitigation
The importance given to harmonics analysis in 1 /()
2pLC of the capacitor-reactor
installation design is increasing these days. If any combination (In case of a de-tuned reactor, this
problem occurs due to harmonics, it results in major frequency is well below the resonant frequency of
loss of material and money. International the system), the inductance-capacitance
standardisation has been tackling these phenomena combination is of crucial importance. If a lower
for many years, although the standards and value capacitor is used, the tuning frequency of
recommendations in force are yet to produce the combination will increase and might even
significant results in India. coincide with the resonant frequency of the
system. This can be a very dangerous condition.
There are certain cases of malfunctions linked
essentially to the above phenomena; some of these Thus the capacitor reactor combination has to be
are illustrated below: selected properly for successful harmonic mitigation.
It is difficult to solve harmonics related problems,
l
Overloading of power factor correction once the power factor correcting system is installed.
capacitors It is important to incorporate Harmonic Mitigation
techniques while the system is being designed.
l
Tripping of protection devices
l
Overloads in neutral conductors due to third-
order harmonics created by single-phase loads
l
Overheating of cables
l
Overloading of transformers or generators
03
Interpretation of Total Harmonic Distortion (THD)
It's a known fact that harmonics cause over loading of Case 2:
power capacitors and consequently reduce the life of
Assumptions:
power capacitors. Normally lot of emphasis is given
only to %THD for assessing the harmonics level. But 1. VTHD: 25%
the frequency spectrum (5th, 7th, 11th, 13th and so on) of 2. Harmonic frequencies considered: 5th (250 Hz), 7th
the harmonics are not given as much importance. (350 Hz), 11th (550 Hz), 13th (650 Hz)
The over-current (and hence the stress on the 3. V5=18%V1, V7=15%V1, V11=8%V1 and V13=4%V1
capacitors) will not only depend on the %THD value
but also on the magnitude of individual harmonics, Calculation:
which can be clearly seen in the frequency spectrum. I5 = V5/Xc5
Following calculations prove the above statement.
= 0.18V1/[1/(2 x π x 5 x fx C)]
VTHD =
S( Vi2 ) / V1) , where i=3 to 99 Thus, in the above two cases, even the THD value
Calculations: remains same (25%), the over current (ref. Eq 1 and
Using the superposition theorem, we can calculate Eq 2) value is different depending upon the spectral
the current contribution of individual harmonic values.
voltages.
Hence THD value and detailed information of the
I5 = V5/Xc5 frequency spectrum are necessary to predict the
= 0.2V1/[1/(2 x π x 5 x f x C)] capacitor over-current. Harmonics study is the best
way to get the frequency spectrum details and hence
= 0.2 x 5 x V1/Xc1
the exact over current value can be calculated.
= 1 x V1/Xc1
= I1
Similarly,
I7 = 1.05I1
The total current I will be a vector sum of I1, I5 and I7
Thus I =I12 +(
I 52 +
I 27 )
=(
1+1 .1025 )
1+ I1
´
Net current, I =1.8 I1 -----------------------> (1)
04
De-tuned Filters
What are De-tuned Filters?
1. Prevent resonance VS
VC
2. Prevent harmonic amplification
VC VC=VS+VL
3. Protect power factor correction capacitors from
overload
05
Linearity of Reactor
An industry whose load includes a high proportion of =
As the resonant frequency rises, the capacitor-
non-linear load (harmonic generating loads), and has reactor combination will offer lower impedance
poor power factor, requires capacitor with de-tuned to the fifth harmonic component and the current
filter. This would perform the function of power factor through the combination will increase further.
improvement while preventing harmonic
amplification. =
Thus, the resonant frequency of the reactor
capacitor combination will increase continuously
Normally, the inductance of the series reactor (of de- resulting in a thermal runaway.
tuned filter) connected is chosen such that the tuning
frequency of the de-tuned filter is 10% below the =
The new resonant frequency may match the fifth
lowest harmonic frequency with considerable harmonic frequency and can results in resonance.
current/voltage amplitude. Therefore, resonance will
not happen in the system and reactor offers high Normally, reactors are designed with predefined
impedance for higher frequency harmonics. linearity. A reactor having a higher linearity will not
saturate for higher harmonic currents and will
Normally, 7% detuned reactors are designed prevent the system from a thermal run-away as
considering typical industrial loads such as drives described above.
that have the following harmonic voltages: V3=0.5%
VN, V5=6% VN, V7=5% VN and so on. However, if the
individual harmonic voltages increase, the following
phenomenon happens:
Ln
x 1,05 – Tolerance
Air Core
x 1,00
x 0,95
0 1 2 3 xln
=
The magnitude of net current (through LC)
increases.
=
If the current increases beyond certain limit, the
reactor will be driven into its saturation region.
=
Once the reactor saturates, inductance value
(L, in henry) of the reactor starts decreasing
(as L = N ϕ/I).
=
Therefore, the resonant frequency (FR) of the LC
will rise [as Resonant frequency = LC ]
1 / 2p
06
Q-factor of Reactor
The quality factor or Q-factor is a dimensionless I0
parameter that characterizes a resonator's bandwidth
relative to its center frequency. It also describes the R1
damping nature of a resonant circuit. Higher Q
(High Q Factor)
indicates a lower rate of energy loss relative to the
stored energy of the oscillator; the oscillations die
out more slowly. For example, a pendulum R2>R1
suspended from a high-quality bearing, oscillating in (Low Q Factor)
air, has a high Q, while a pendulum immersed in oil
has a low one. Oscillators with high quality factors R2
have low damping so that they ring longer.
PF 2
sin f1 - 1
Q= = =2 -1
cos f PF PF
Q =
ta n f
07
K-factor Transformers
Harmonic currents are generated whenever non- Hence, if we know the harmonics spectrum, we can
linear loads are connected to the mains supply. The easily arrive at the amount of de-rating or the k-factor
problems caused by harmonic currents include of the transformer.
increased losses and overheating of transformers,
over heating of cables, especially the neutral K-Factor transformers available, are designed to take
conductor, overheating and vibration in induction care of the increased stresses on account of
motors and premature failure of power factor Harmonics. Depending on the nature of the non linear
correction capacitors. This article discusses the load, suitable K-Factor transformers can be selected.
effects of harmonics specifically on transformers and
a method to ensure the reliability of transformers in Following are the typical K-Factor for non-linear loads
harmonics rich environments. connected:
In order to overcome the above ill effects, a special Hence choosing K-Factor transformers for modern
transformer called as k-factor transformer has been building loads, industries with more non-linear loads,
developed. This is a specifically de-rated transformer would result in better performance and long life of the
that is designed keeping in mind harmonic loads. transformers.
l
K-factor will account for the increase in eddy
current losses, because of non-linear loads, along
with normal losses in the transformers.
l
This special transformer also has 200% neutral or
more for triplen harmonics.
l
Moreover, it also has stranded conductors for
reducing skin effect, low loss steel in the core for
reducing eddy current loss.
Pt n
K = =
å I h2 h 2
Pf h= 1
08
Transformer Compensation
Background: Magnetizing VAR requirement of a transformer:
With increased emphasis on power quality and The magnetizing VAR consumption is a function of
significant incentives / penalties associated with the rated voltage and the magnetizing current of the
power factor improvement, most customers are transformer. The no load current of a transformer
trying to operate their plant electrical system at near varies between 0.5 % and 2.5% of the full load current
unity power factor. depending on the design of the transformer and the
operating flux level. The magnetizing current is
In order to achieve near unity power factor, all around 80% of the no load current and thus varies
sources of reactive power need to be identified and between 0.4% and 2%. It is safe to assume a value of
fully compensated. One such element that consumes 1-1.2% for distribution transformers.
reactive power is the transformer. Reactive power is
consumed by transformers through the no load Thus the VAR required to compensate for the
magnetizing current and through the leakage magnetizing current of the transformer is around 1-
reactance. This issue is aimed at helping customers 1.2% of the transformer kVA rating.
size capacitor banks for transformer compensation.
VAR requirement due to leakage reactance
Basics:
The VAR requirement due to leakage reactance is a
The power factor on the HT side (source side) of a function of the square of the current and the leakage
transformer depends upon the following: reactance. At full load the voltage drop across the
leakage reactance is equal to the impedance voltage
l
LT side (Load side) power factor (%Z impedance). The reactive VAR consumption is
equal to the product of impedance voltage and load
l
Real power consumed by transformer current.
l
Reactive power consumed by transformer
QX = IL2 x XLeakage ;
The load side power factor is compensated by
Where IL is the load current and XLeakage is the leakage
employing APFC panels or/and by providing
reactance; Qx is the kVAR
individual compensation to connected loads.
Transformer compensation on the other hand is not
as well understood. Power requirement:
09
Capacitor Switching in APFC Panels
The switching of capacitor banks is a special and it withstands the heavy inrush current for which
challenging application in Automatic Power Factor some amount of derating would be required.
Correction (APFC) panels. The selection of
l
Power contactors should be used along with
appropriate switching device for such applications is
inrush current limiting reactors, which will
based on two criteria:
increase the cost and size of the APFC panel.
l
Ability to carry rated capacitor current
l
Instead of de-rating power contactors and
continuously
using current limiting reactors, capacitor duty
l
Ability to make the peak-inrush current of contactors shall be used.
capacitor
Capacitor duty contactor:
It is simple to calculate the capacitor rated current
and select the switching device to be able to carry l
MO C range of capacitor duty contactors can be
rated capacitor current (2.5 to 3 times the capacitor used to limit the inrush current to less than 10*IN.
rated current to take care of overload, harmonics, l
Capacitor duty contactors have pre-contacts with
supply voltage variation and capacitor value current limiting resistors (of 4 Ω).
tolerance). However, it is a little difficult to select the
switching device which is able to make the peak- l
Capacitor duty contactors are employed where
inrush current. This is because the peak inrush the frequency of switching is less i.e., the load
current for capacitor switching application depends fluctuation is not often. The capacitor requires
upon various factors such as: atleast 60 seconds to discharge to a nominal
value (50 V). So capacitor duty contactors cannot
l
The inductance of the network (including cables, be used when load fluctuation is heavy.
switchgears and transformer)
l
MO C contactors can be used for switching
l
The transformer power rating and % impedance capacitors upto 80 kVAr in each branch.
l
Methods used for power factor correction:
Thyristor switching module:
¢
fixed capacitor bank
l
TSM is used for dynamic power factor correction
¢
multi-stage capacitor bank with steps of equal i.e., wherever the load fluctuation is heavy
ratings (welding, steel rolling, etc.)
¢
multi-stage capacitor bank with steps of l
Rapid switching (5 ms) is possible with TSM along
unequal ratings with Quick Discharge Resistor (QDR). Existing
discharge resistor in capacitors shall be replaced
l
In multi-stage capacitor bank, the nos. and rating
with QDR.
of steps already switched on
l
There will be no inrush current while using TSM
In most of the installations, the multi-stage capacitor
(zero voltage switching and zero current
banks are used with steps of unequal ratings. The
switching). So frequent switching will not affect
bigger steps of higher kVAr ratings being switched on
the life of capacitors and there may not be a need
initially and smaller steps are switched on
to use extra current limiting reactors.
periodically, for achieving the targeted power factor.
In such cases, the value of inrush-current peak will be l
TSM has thermal cutoff, which will switch off
far higher and hence the smaller capacitors will be when temperature exceeds beyond a certain
heavily stressed. limit. It will automatically switch on when
optimum temperature is attained.
Capacitor switching can be done by various ways
such as: l
Panel design becomes critical while using TSMs
and adequate cooling arrangements need to be
Power contactor: employed.
l
Normal power contactors will simply allow the
inrush current to flow through them and because
of this, contactors and capacitors are heavily
stressed. Contactor selection should be such that
10
Fuse Selection for APFC Panels
For any APFC panel, fuses are required for faster The fuse used for branch protection must be capable
short circuit protection and overload protection of of carrying this current continuously. Hence the fuse
capacitors. Fuse selection for capacitive load is should be sufficiently rated so as to avoid the
critical because of heavy inrush current, high deterioration of the fuse element. Further the fuse
overload capacity and continuous full load. These should not blow during switching of the capacitors
inherent traits of a capacitor, complicates the because of the inrush current (more than 100 times
selection process. Hence the selection should be the rated capacitor current under normal conditions).
such that even during these permissible In order to prevent nuisance operation of fuse, its
abnormalities, the fuse should not blow. time-current characteristic should cover the peak
inrush current of the capacitor. Hence for the optimal
Normally, the maximum permissible current in a selection of fuses, the inrush current must be limited
capacitor branch is 1.46 times the rated current. This by using either capacitor duty contactor or inrush
factor is comprised of the following: current limiting reactor.
l
Harmonics overload and over voltage – 30% The following table** shows the selection of Fuses
and Capacitor switching contactors for an APFC
l
Capacitance tolerance – 10% panel:
l
Frequency variation – 2%
kVAr Rated current+ (A) O/C factor Allowed O/C for Recommended Fuse rating
+
capacitor (A) Contactor (A)
The rated current of a capacitor can be calculated as. Above selection chart is valid only if fuses are used
1000 ´
kVAr along with capacitor duty contactor or inrush current
limiting reactor (0.2% reactor). Please consider the
3´
V
above table purely as a guideline for selection. Actual
For any capacitor bank, permissible overload is 1.46 selection needs to be done based on considerations
times rated capacitor current. Hence, fuses should of connected load and the electrical network
be rated to carry continuous overcurrent as given in properties.
the above table. In case Thyristor Switching Modules
are used instead of capacitor duty contactors, it is
highly recommended to use High Speed Fuses
(semiconductor fuse).
11
MCCB Selection for APFC Panels
For any APFC panel, MCCBs are required for short MCCB. This multiple bounce can result in premature
circuit protection, overload protection and for failure of MCCB contacts. In order to reduce the
isolation of capacitors. MCCB selection for capacitive magnitude of the peak inrush current, MCCBs must
load is tricky because of heavy inrush current, high be used along with capacitor duty contactors or
overload capacity and continuous full load. These inrush current limiting reactors.
inherent traits of a capacitor, complicates the
selection process. The selection should be such that The maximum permissible current in a capacitor
the MCCB should not nuisance trip during inrush branch is 1.46 times the rated current. This factor is
current and should withstand continuous flow of comprised of the following:
overload current. l
Harmonics overload and over voltage – 30%
Whenever we use MCCB in an APFC panel, proper l
Capacitance tolerance – 10%
measures need to be taken against the ill effects of
the inrush current. Normally the inrush current (more l
Frequency variation – 2%
than 100 times the rated capacitor current) will
remain for a few micro-seconds and will not be The branch MCCB must be capable of carrying this
sensed by the MCCB. However the contacts of MCCB current continuously. The following table** shows
may repel and bounce because of the current limiting the selection of MCCBs and Capacitor switching
feature, causing micro-arcs between the contacts of contactors for an APFC panel:
kVAr Rated O/L Permissible Recommended MCCB* Thermal Setting (A) Magnetic
+ setting
current (A) factor capacitor Contactor+ IN IR
(6 to 10*IR)
O/L (A) (100% IN)
The rated current of a capacitor can be calculated as limiting reactor (0.2% reactor). Please consider the
above table purely as a guideline for selection. Actual
(1000 ´
kVAr ) /( 3 ´
V) selection needs to be done based on considerations
of connected load and the electrical network
For any capacitor bank, permissible overload is 1.46 properties.
times rated capacitor current. Hence, MCCB should
be rated to carry continuous over current as given in
the above table.
12
Life of Power Capacitors
The life of a capacitor is influenced by the following reduce the life of the capacitor.
three parameters:
Over-voltage limits of the capacitors are +10%
l
Temperature for 12 hrs in 24 hrs, +15% for 30 min in 24h, +20%
for 5 min in 24 hrs and +30% for 1 min in 24 hrs.
l
Voltage
Current:
l
Current
The parameters that are related to current, which
Temperature: affect the life of the capacitor are:
l
Increase in current flow through the capacitor:
(as capacitors are linear in nature) As the voltage
increases, the capacitor current also increases
because XC remains constant (IC=V/XC). This
results in overloading of the capacitor, which may
13
Capacitor Power Loss Calculation
A capacitor is a passive device which has two = (ωC) x (ωCV2) x ESR
conductors separated by a dielectric of infinite
resistance, ideally. Hence, this would offer only = (ωC) x Q x ESR
capacitive reactance, with zero resistance and zero
inductance values. But practically, the dielectric of = Q x ESR / XC
the capacitor will offer a finite resistance along with
Power loss = Q tan δ [from Eq 1]
the capacitance. This finite resistance is called as
Equivalent Series Resistance (ESR), and its
Where, Q is the reactive power rating of the capacitor
equivalent circuit can be represented as below:
(in VAr).
Creal Cideal ESR
Typically, for good quality power capacitors, tan δ
value would be less than 0.0002. Power loss of any
capacitor can be computed if tan δ value is known. An
The ESR in the capacitor causes the leakage current example calculation is given below:
to flow through the dielectric of the capacitor. This
For a 10 kVAr capacitor, consider the value of tan δ as
results in real power loss (I2 * ESR) called as dielectric
0.0002
loss. Higher the ESR, higher will be the power loss,
and hence the heat generated by the capacitor will
Total watt loss = 10 x 1000 x 0.0002
also be more. The heat generated should be
dissipated properly; otherwise it may result in = 2 watts
significant temperature rise. A good quality capacitor
will have very low ESR value. Per kVAr power loss = Total watt loss / kVAr
-jXc
14
Electrical Standard Products (ESP) Branch Offices:
REGISTERED OFFICE AND Khairasol, Degaul Avenue EBG North Wing Office-Level 2
HEAD OFFICE Durgapur 713 212 Gate 7, Powai Campus
L&T House, Ballard Estate Tel: 2559848, 2559849, 2559844 Mumbai 400 072
P. O. Box 278 Fax: 0343-2553614 Tel: 022-67052874 / 2737 / 1156
Mumbai 400 001 e-mail: esp-dgp@LNTEBG.com Fax: 022-67051112
Tel: 022-67525656 e-mail: esp-bom@LNTEBG.com
Fax: 022-67525858 5, Milanpur Road, Bamuni Maidan
Website: www.Larsentoubro.com Guwahati 781 021 12, Shivaji Nagar
Tel: +91 8876554410 / 8876554417 North Ambajhari Road
ELECTRICAL STANDARD PRODUCTS (ESP) Fax: 361-2551308 Nagpur 440 010
501, Sakar Complex I e-mail: hazrasudipto@LNTEBG.com Tel: 0712-2260012 / 6606421
Opp. Gandhigram Rly. Station Fax: 2260030 / 6606434
Ashram Road II Floor, Vasantha Chambers e-mail: esp-nag@LNTEBG.com
Ahmedabad 380 009
5-10-173, Fateh Maidan Road
Tel: 079-66304006-11
Hyderabad 500 004 32, Shivaji Marg
Fax: 079-66304025
e-mail: esp-ahm@LNTEBG.com Tel: 040-67015052 P. O. Box 6223
Fax: 040-23296468 New Delhi 110 015
38, Cubbon Road, P. O. Box 5098 e-mail: esp-hyd@LNTEBG.com Tel: 011-41419514 / 5 / 6
Bangalore 560 001 Fax: 011-41419600
Tel: 080-25020100 / 25020324 Monarch Building, 1st Floor e-mail: esp-del@LNTEBG.com
Fax: 080-25580525 D-236 & 237, Amrapali Marg
e-mail: esp-blr@LNTEBG.com Vaishali Nagar L&T House
Jaipur 302 021 P. O. Box 119
131/1, Zone II Tel: 0141-4385914 to 18 191/1, Dhole Patil Road
Maharana Pratap Nagar Fax: 0141-4385925 Pune 411 001
Bhopal 462 011 e-mail: esp-jai@LNTEBG.com Tel: 020-66033395 / 66033279
Tel: 0755-3080511 / 05 / 08 / 13 / 17 / 19 Fax: 020-26164048 / 26164910
Fax: 0755-3080502 Akashdeep Plaza, 2nd Floor e-mail: esp-pnq@LNTEBG.com
e-mail: esp-bho@LNTEBG.com P. O. Golmuri
Jamshedpur 831 003 Crystal Tower,
Plot No. 559, Annapurna Complex Jharkhand 4th Floor, G. E. Road
Lewis Road Tel: 0657-2312205 / 38 Telibandha
Bhubaneswar 751 014 Fax: 0657-2341250 Raipur - 492 006
Tel: 0674-6451342, 2436690, 2436696 e-mail: esp-jam@LNTEBG.com Tel: 0771-4283214
Fax: 0674-2537309 e-mail: esp-raipur@LNTEBG.com
e-mail: nayakd@LNTEBG.com Skybright Bldg; M. G. Road
Ravipuram Junction, Ernakulam 3rd Floor
SCO 32, Sector 26-D Kochi 682 016 Vishwakarma Chambers
Madhya Marg, P. O. Box 14 Tel: 0484-4409420 / 4 / 5 / 7 Majura Gate, Ring Road
Chandigarh 160 019 Fax: 0484-4409426 Surat 395 002
Tel: 0172-4646840, 4646853
e-mail: esp-cok@LNTEBG.com Tel: 0261-2473726
Fax: 0172-4646802
e-mail: esp-chd@LNTEBG.com Fax: 0261-2477078
3-B, Shakespeare Sarani e-mail: esp-sur@LNTEBG.com
L&T Construction Campus Kolkata 700 071
TC-1 Building, II Floor Tel: 033-44002572 / 3 / 4 Radhadaya Complex
Mount-Poonamallee Road Fax: 033-22821025 / 7587 Old Padra Road
Manapakkam e-mail: esp-ccu@LNTEBG.com Near Charotar Society
Chennai 600 089 Vadodara 390 007
Tel: 044-2270 6800 A28, Indira Nagar, Faizabad Road Tel: 0265-6613610 / 1 / 2
Fax: 044-22706940 Lucknow 226 016 Fax: 0265-2336184
e-mail: esp-maa1@LNTEBG.com Tel: 0522-4929905 / 04 e-mail: esp-bar@LNTEBG.com
Fax: 0522-2311671
67, Appuswamy Road e-mail: esp-Lko@LNTEBG.com 48-8-16, Dwarakanagar
Post Bag 7156 Visakhapatnam 530 016
Opp. Nirmala College No: 73, Karpaga Nagar, 8th Street Tel: 0891-6701125 to 30
Coimbatore 641 045 K. Pudur Fax: 0891-6701139
Tel: 0422-2588120 / 1 / 5 Madurai 625 007 e-mail: esp-viz@LNTEBG.com
Fax: 0422-2588148 Tel: 0452-2537404, 2521068
e-mail: esp-cbe@LNTEBG.com Fax: 0452-2537552
e-mail: esp-mdu@LNTEBG.com
Product improvement is a continuous process. For the latest information and special applications, please contact any of our offices listed here.
SP 50564 R1