Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Progress, Not Perfection: The Effects of Different Forms of Opioid Addiction Rehabilitation
Kelsey A. Hurt
Abstract
This paper discusses the drugs that led to the opioid epidemic, as well as the treatments that help
opioid users to be rid of their addiction. The author begins by introducing the main types of
opioids and how they affect the body and brain. Several types of traditional treatments will be
discussed, as well as types of non-traditional treatments. The author also discusses what the state
of Virginia as well as the United States are doing about the issue. Finally, the author writes about
relapse and why it is so difficult to get rid of an opioid addiction for good.
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 3
Progress, Not Perfection: The Effects of Different Forms of Opioid Addiction Rehabilitation
The United States is currently going through an opioid addiction and overdose epidemic.
Opioid addiction encompasses the dependence on opiates and synthetic opioids. Opiates are
naturally occurring opioids derived from the opium poppy, while synthetic opioids are opiates
that have been chemically altered. Opioid addiction is commonly referred to as opioid use
disorder. Because the use of opioids is so highly stimulating to the reward and pleasure centers
of the brain, beating the addiction is incredibly difficult (Kosten & George, 2002).
When opioids were first prescribed, medical professionals truly believed they were
medications, people began to misuses the drug; medical professionals as well as the public
quickly realized that opioids are, in fact, addictive. According to the United States Department of
Health and Human Services, 80% of heroin users abused prescription opioids before using
heroin, and over 130 people die everyday from some sort of opioid overdose (U.S. Department
of Health and Human Services, n.d.). The opioid epidemic affects every person in the United
States, either directly or indirectly, and the United States as a whole is responsible for getting
Types of Opioids
Heroin
Heroin is an opioid that comes in the form of powder or a tar-like substance and is made
from morphine. The drug can be injected several ways, depending on the form it is being used in
(Sunrise House, n.d.). In some instances, people mix heroin with crack cocaine, and this is called
speedballing. Heroin goes directly into the brain and causes a sense of euphoria, and this is why
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 4
it is both so dangerous and so addictive. The section of the brain that it influences affects
common bodily functions like heart rate and breathing, as well as different mental functions
(Dowshen, 2015). The long term effects of using heroin are very dangerous, some including
heart and lung complications. Heroin is highly addictive, and people often turn to heroin use
after having another type of opioid addiction (Mayo Clinic, 2016). The withdrawal symptoms are
often the hardest part of rehabilitation, and they include sharp pain and intense cravings
(Melemis, 2018). Heroin overdose is often times fatal (National Institute on Drug Abuse, 2018).
Fentanyl
Fentanyl is an opioid similar to morphine; however, it is almost 100 times more potent.
The drug can be prescribed medically or sold illegally; according to U.S. Code § 841(a), unless
someone is legally authorized to give someone prescription drugs, it is illegal to give another
person prescription drugs (Criminal Defense Lawyer, n.d.). When sold illegally, like heroin, it
comes in several different forms; the most common form is powder or tablets. Often times, the
tablet form is intended to mimic another opioid, making an accidental overdose very possible. In
addition, fentanyl can replace heroin or be combined with it (National Institute on Drug Abuse,
2018).
Like heroin, fentanyl goes directly to the brain, and affects areas of the brain responsible
for common bodily functions like emotions and pain. Fentanyl has many effects on the body,
some of the worst being nausea, depression, and even death (Healthline, n.d.). The two main
factors that make fentanyl so dangerous are the potency and its resemblance of heroin and other
opioids (Tate, 2018). The potency makes the risk of an overdose higher than that of heroin.
Because it resembles heroin and other opioids so closely, people are unaware that they are, in
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 5
fact, consuming fentanyl. When someone thinks they are taking their “normal” dose, they could
actually be intaking much higher chemical levels than their body can handle (National Institute
Prescription pain relievers are often in the form of opioids, and they are prescribed by
medical professionals to patients in attempt to reduce the intensity of how the brain perceives
pain. That being said, prescription pain-relieving opioids go straight to the brain. Some of the
most widely used prescription pain-relieving opioids include hydrocodone, oxycodone, and
codeine (American Addiction Centers, 2018). Some of the more intense side effects that come
with using prescription pain-relieving opioids include nausea and respiratory depression (Mayo
Clinic, 2018). However, users also report feeling a sense of euphoria after use (National Institute
Many people begin treatment with detoxification (CRC Health, n.d.). Detoxification
involves clearing the body of opioids, or any drug for that matter. The process is often extremely
mentally taxing and physically painful. Because of this, some people pair detoxification with
medicine to help cope with the pain (Goodman, n.d.). Detoxification should not be confused with
treatment, as it only addresses the physical side of opioid addiction (National Institute on Drug
Abuse, 2018).
Naltrexone is a once monthly injection form of Naloxone. Naloxone and Naltrexone are
opioid antagonists, meaning they bind to the receptors in the brain where opioids do damage and
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 6
block the activity of the drug (The National Alliance of Advocates for Buprenorphine Treatment,
n.d.). Naloxone and Naltrexone are very attractive, and they bind to the receptors so strongly that
they remove the opioid and block it from re-binding (Bloom, 2018). This is why Naloxone works
in an overdose (Harm Reduction Coalition, n.d.). If an addict tries to use heroin, fentanyl, or
prescription pain relievers, they will not work if Naltrexone is in his or her system (Tate, 2018).
Naloxone or Naltrexone Therapy are only successful in very motivated individuals who have a
lot to lose if they continue to use or work in sectors where other Medically Assisted Treatment
modalities are not acceptable, such as pilots or physicians (National Institute on Drug Abuse,
2018).
Methadone
Methadone, at its core, is really just a substitution of one opioid for another in a
controlled, safe, and monitored environment. Methadone is a long-acting opioid agonist. Because
of its long duration of action, it doesn’t produce the same high and euphoria as heroin,
oxycodone, fentanyl, etc. The goal is to give it at a dose that keeps the patient from feeling
withdrawal and craving, but still allows them to function, hold a job, etc (Ambardekar, 2017).
The danger of the drug is that Methadone can be abused. For example, it can be crushed
and injected. It doesn’t relieve the patient of their addiction, but refocuses their addiction on
something less destructive (National Institute on Drug Abuse, 2018). Methadone maintenance
therapy can be quite effective. It decreases homelessness and joblessness among users, as well as
Buprenorphine
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 7
opioid and has some opioid properties; however, it produces about half the effect of other
strongly and out-competes the pure opioids. This provides some safety if a person with opioid
use disorder tries to use heroin, fentanyl, or prescription pain relievers while on buprenorphine
(National Institute on Drug Abuse, 2018). Also, buprenorphine does not have the same risk of
respiratory depression that come with other drugs. People don’t seem to stop breathing when
they misuse the buprenorphine, which is what kills almost all people who overdose (The
Naloxone has no, or very little, activity when taken orally. However, if the patient tries to melt
the suboxone and inject it to get high, the naloxone is active and prevents the user from feeling
any rush, making it less likely to be used inappropriately. Buprenorphine has less abuse potential
than methadone, but there have been cases of illicit use now that it is being used more frequently
Narcotics Anonymous
Almost all addicts have done better when prescribed drugs are combined with
psychological and social counseling. Narcotics Anonymous is one of the biggest support groups
in the nation. It was inspired by the success of Alcoholics Anonymous. Anyone is able to join a
group, meaning it is accessible to anyone who believes they need it (Addiction Center, 2018).
Narcotics Anonymous has two meeting styles, including discussion meetings or speaker
meetings (National Institute on Drug Abuse, 2018). Discussion meetings model a group
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 8
discussion, while speaker meetings typically only have one speaker sharing. While sharing is
encouraged, it is not enforced. In addition, addicts are encouraged to rely on a higher power to go
through recovery with. A higher power can be anything the addict wants it to be; many people
Equine Assisted Psychotherapy has proven effective in addicts, especially youth and
adolescent addicts. Addiction affects more than just the body, and in adolescents especially, has
adolescents who struggle with drug addiction also struggle with self confidence
teaches responsibility. Therapists often allow the client to take care of the basic needs of horses,
including grooming and feeding. Taking care of something bigger than themself is often both
Because it is often difficult for adolescents to bond with a therapist, due to either distrust
or defiance, the presence of the horse allows them to connect with the animal in the presence of
the therapist (Filippides, 2016). According to the theories of Ivan Pavlov, a physiologist and
psychologist widely known for his work in classical conditioning, when the good thoughts are
associated with the horse, they will also be associated with the therapist (The Nobel Prize, n.d.).
This allows for a connection with both the animal and the person.
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 9
While Equine Assisted Psychotherapy has been very successful in alleviating the social
effects of opioid addiction, it does not address the physical needs of patients (Foundations
Recovery Network, n.d.). Because of this, it is often paired with some type of medication
(Filippides, 2016). According to an Eagala study in 2013, children/youth ages 10-18 benefited
most among each age group from Equine Assisted Psychotherapy (Eagala, n.d.). This set of data
implies that Equine Assisted Psychotherapy may not work well for younger children, but mostly
Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing is typically used for addicts who
started using opioids due to trauma or emotional issues. The process encourages drug addicts to
first focus on why they began using drugs (the past), what is causing them to continue to use
drugs (the present), and how they can get out of the situation (the future) (EMDR Institute Inc.,
n.d.).
Eye Movement Desensitization consists of eight phases per meeting. The beginning
phases focus on familiarizing the therapist with the client’s current situation, as well as
addressing the stressors that contribute to the situation. The middle phases are when the actual
visualizing takes place; the patient focuses on the image, and identifies how it makes them feel
both emotionally and physically. The therapist’s job is to assist the patient in creating goals. In
the final phases, the client is encouraged to create a log of anything they think might be relevant
meeting. The patient must be committed for several months for the treatment to be successful.
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 10
While Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing helps to calm the patient over issues
that caused them to start using drugs in the first place, it does not address the actual addiction;
for that reason, Eye Movement Desensitization Reprocessing is often paired with a form of
Each activity is guided by a therapist, and the activities can take place individually or with a
group. One of the most popular methods of wilderness therapy is therapeutic camps. Therapeutic
camps date back to the 1800s, and have been used ever since. The point is to get away from their
everyday life and focus on the nature around them. This is important for addicts, as many of
Much like therapeutic camps, adventure therapy is meant to take the patient out of their
comfort zone and bring them somewhere outside of their normal life. Adventure therapy pushes
the patient to learn more about both their environment and themself. Leadership is one of the
main skills people take away from adventure therapy. There are many different kinds of
adventure therapy because different patients have different fears or interests. Some of the most
popular methods include rock climbing and ropes courses (Learn Through Experience, n.d.).
Art therapy has a heavy emphasis on self expression, and is popular throughout each age
group. The therapy is guided by a therapist, and it usually takes place one on one. One of the
main goals of art therapy is simply relaxation. There are three different types of art therapy,
including self-expressive art, art studio, and legacy projects. Self-expressive art and art studio are
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 11
the more popular types, as they predominantly focus on how the patient is feeling in the moment.
Legacy projects, however, focus on memories. The style of art therapy that the patient chooses
really just depends on their background and the details of their addiction (Hope Healthcare, n.d.).
therapist, listen to music, and oftentimes are encouraged to create their own. Many patients enjoy
writing songs and performing them to the therapist. Music has many physical effects on the brain
and releases endorphins when people hear music they enjoy. This is what causes the positive
symptoms like relaxation and contentedness. While the meetings with the therapist are critically
important to improving, patients are encouraged to listen and create music outside of therapy
Virginia Efforts
The state of Virginia has taken several approaches to address opioid addiction in the
commonwealth. According to Tina Pullen, the Public Affairs Officer for the Norfolk Field
Office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, Virginia is a leader in addressing the opioid
epidemic. From the Governor of Virginia, who is a pediatrician, to the Virginia Attorney General
and the United States Attorney, there is a strong sense of urgency at every level of government to
in education curriculum both at the K-12 level and in higher education. More emphasis has been
placed on education about opioids and the hazards associated with its use as opposed to focusing
on the traditional DARE program. Additionally, there has been an improved response capability
by the law enforcement and first responders community. Naloxone is more readily available and
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 12
coordination in investigations and the responsibilities of the first person to respond to a scene
involving opioids are being handled in an unprecedented way. Also, the medical community in
Virginia has changed the way they treat pain and has led efforts to incorporate comprehensive
opioid education and training for medical and nursing students. Furthermore, the outreach groups
have engaged the faith-based community and initiated social media efforts to crowdsource
awareness and information sharing (T. Pullen, personal communication, November 2, 2018).
In the Coastal Plain region of Virginia, the Virginia Attorney General and the United
States Attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia teamed up in 2016 to form the Hampton
Roads Opioid Working Group. The Hampton Roads Opioid Working Group is a
community-based group of action oriented members who are dedicated to reducing the number
of opioid related deaths by addressing the demand side of the threat through community
awareness, medical community innovation and leadership, and through the support of service
based organizations and treatment facilities. The group is made up of members of the law
outreach coordinators. Since September 2016, it has met regularly to address all angles of the
Because of all of these changes, Virginia was able to report that opioid related deaths in
Hampton Roads went down 17% in 2017 (T. Pullen, personal communication, November 2,
2018).
The Drug Addiction Treatment Act of 2000 is the act that allowed certified doctors to
prescribe illegal drugs to opioid-dependent patients in order to combat addiction. This was a
major act because it popularized the prescription of Buprenorphine, and 18 years later, it is still a
top choice for physicians. Buprenorphine is so effective because it has a very low abuse rate due
to the presence of Naloxone within it (The National Alliance of Advocates for Buprenorphine
Treatment, n.d.). According to a study done by the United States Department of Health and
Human Sciences, Buprenorphine saw an 80% success rate in reducing opioid use (Substance
In October 2018, President Donald Trump signed the Substance Use-Disorder Prevention
that Promotes Opioid Recovery and Treatment (SUPPORT) for Patients and Communities Act of
2018. The act mainly focuses on hospitals and state health programs, and its goal is to make
treatment more accessible throughout the United States. This legislation aims to encourage
hospitals to be more conservative when prescribing opioids for pain-relief by increasing the
number of prescription drug monitoring programs (PDMPs). In addition, the new law will
encourage identifying substance abuse by allowing doctors to look for symptoms at regular
wellness checkups. Hospitals have been encouraged to view the act in its entirety on order to
addresses the supply of opioids by targeting the violent crime organizations that distribute
putting people in jail is not the only solution to the opioid epidemic. Because the epidemic is
rooted in drug abuse and addiction, the demand for the drugs needs to be addressed. They use a
task force model, which leverages the strengths of each of the local, state, and federal law
enforcement partners who work as a team to investigate violent street gangs and drug related
violence. These large FBI sponsored task forces can indict and prosecute using federal and state
laws. Their mission is different than the Drug Enforcement Administration in that they target
groups based on their level of violence, which is measured by the number murders, assaults, use
of weapons, etc. during a drug deal, not simply the distribution. That being said, violence and
distribution often go hand in hand, so the Bureau routinely partners with the Drug Enforcement
The Federal Bureau of Investigation has used their national platform to shed light on the
dangers of opioid abuse through awareness initiatives such as their video Chasing the Dragon:
Relapse
Addiction is so complex, and opioid addiction, especially, is really hard to get rid of for
good. Many people describe addicts as “once and addict, always an addict.” The initial use of
opioids causes a rush, a euphoria, and feeling of wellbeing that is very stimulating the the reward
and pleasure center in the brain, causing a physiological addiction. It is very powerful, and
begins to change the brain’s neurochemistry from the first use. Over time, that rush and euphoria
starts to fade. Users are always trying to recapture their first high, which is why they are
The danger comes when the brain realizes that its normal function is being blunted by the
drug, because it increases a number of receptors to include those that sense pain and those that
give you energy and motivation. The longer the drug is used, the more these receptors are
increased. At this point, the addict is in a situation where they depend on the drug to feel healthy.
When they don’t use opioids, those increased receptors are still active; the increased pain
receptors make the addict feel pain; the increased energy and motivation receptors make the
addict feel agitated, antsy, and shaky. Those biochemical changes take a long time to fully
There is also a psychological component, which can be just as harmful for some addicts.
The things that led them to use opioids in the first place can remain such strong triggers for
relapse, such as friends, locations, romantic partners, other psychological diseases or disorders,
past trauma, stress, homelessness, joblessness; the list goes on. These can be reminders of why
they started in the first place, and make the addict feel the need to go back to the perceived safety
Conclusion
The United States needs to break the stigma that surrounds addiction, particularly opioid
addiction. It affects all walks of life, no matter what race, religion, color, creed, sexual
orientation, or age. Some start use on the street, but the majority start using from legitimate
prescriptions, out of curiosity, or a desire to party. Suddenly, they are hooked and can’t stop.
Nobody starts with the desire to completely destroy their lives. These people have a disease, and
society needs to treat them the way society would treat somebody with any other disease such as
cancer or diabetes; people need to treat them with support and focused care.
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 16
As a country, the United States needs to eliminate the supply of illicit drugs that are
entering the market. Similarly, hospitals and doctors need to be smarter and safer in their
prescribing of these drugs. Small amounts of the least potent opioid should be used for the
shortest time possible and only when absolutely needed. The United States needs to work on
developing better pain medications that are not opioids and that have little to no risk of
dependence.
The things needed to make treatment more accessible include money, training, education,
advertising, and access. The United States should focus on educating providers of treatment,
people with substance use disorder, and the general public. More advertising is needed because
treatment is useless if the user doesn’t know where to access it. Access loops back to money, as
well as geography. Posh treatment centers in exotic places don’t really do much good for people
who will never be able to get there. When, and only when, the United States takes responsibility
References
https://www.addictioncenter.com/treatment/12-step-programs/narcotics-anonymous/
Ambardekar, N. (Ed.). (2017, August 19). What is methadone: Side effects, uses, risks. Retrieved
from https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/addiction/what-is-methadone#2
American Addiction Centers. (2018, November). The big list of narcotic drugs. Retrieved from
https://americanaddictioncenters.org/the-big-list-of-narcotic-drugs
Bennington-Castro, J. (2014, December). How horses help with mental health issues. Retrieved
from https://www.everydayhealth.com/news/how-horses-help-with-mental-health-issues/
Bloom, J. (2018, July). Naloxone and naltroxene look and sound the same, but are used
https://www.acsh.org/news/2018/07/05/naloxone-and-naltroxone-they-sound-same-thats-
it-13161
https://www.crchealth.com/find-a-treatment-center/rehab-work/medical-detox/
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 18
Criminal Defense Lawyer. (n.d.). Selling prescription drugs illegally. Retrieved from
https://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/resources/criminal-defense/drug-possession/selli
ng-prescription-drugs-illegally.htm
Dowshen, S. (Ed.). (2015, July). Brain and nervous system. Retrieved from
https://kidshealth.org/en/teens/brain-nervous-system.html
http://www.emdr.com/frequent-questions/
Foundations Recovery Network. (n.d.). How equine therapy is used in addiction treatment.
Retrieved from
https://www.foundationsrecoverynetwork.com/how-equine-therapy-is-used-in-addition-tr
eatment/
Goodman, M. S. (Ed.). (n.d.). Private drug detox and withdrawal programs. Retrieved from
https://luxury.rehabs.com/drug-detox/
https://www.goodtherapy.org/wilderness-therapy.html
https://harmreduction.org/issues/overdose-prevention/overview/overdose-basics/understa
nding-naloxone/
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 19
https://www.healthline.com/health/fentanyl/transdermal-patch#highlights
https://www.hopehospice.org/Expressive/
Kerkar, P. (Ed.). (2015, March 10). Opioid dependence vs opioid addiction. Retrieved from
https://www.epainassist.com/opioid-treatment/opioids/opioid-dependence-vs-opioid-addi
ction
Kosten, T. R., & George, T. P. (2002, July). The neurobiology of opioid dependence:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2851054/
Learn Through Experience. (n.d.). Deep dive into the history of adventure therapy. Retrieved
from http://learnthroughexperience.org/blog/history-adventure-therapy/
Mayo Clinic. (2016, February). How opioid addiction occurs. Retrieved from
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/prescription-drug-abuse/in-depth/how-o
pioid-addiction-occurs/art-20360372
Mayo Clinic. (2018, February). Chronic pain: Medication decisions. Retrieved from
https://www.mayoclinic.org/chronic-pain-medication-decisions/art-20360371
https://www.addictionsandrecovery.org/withdrawal.htm
https://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2018/07/14/understanding-the-opioid-e
pidemic.aspx
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 20
The National Alliance of Advocates for Buprenorphine Treatment. (n.d.). What exactly is
The National Alliance of Advocates for Buprenorphine Treatment. (n.d.). What is the DATA
The National Alliance of Advocates for Buprenorphine Treatment. (n.d.). What's this
National Institute on Drug Abuse. (2015, July). Addiction science. Retrieved from
https://www.drugabuse.gov/related-topics/addiction-science
National Institute on Drug Abuse. (2018, January). Principles of drug addiction treatment: A
https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/principles-drug-addiction-treatment-research-ba
sed-guide-third-edition/drug-addiction-treatment-in-united-states
National Institute on Drug Abuse. (2018, April). Opioid Overdose Reversal with Naloxone
https://www.drugabuse.gov/related-topics/opioid-overdose-reversal-naloxone-narcan-evz
io
https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/drugfacts/heroin
https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1904/pavlov/biographical/
Opium.com. (n.d.). What you should know about opiates and opioids. Retrieved from
https://opium.com/what-is-opium/know-opiates-opioids/
PROGRESS, NOT PERFECTION 21
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/addiction
Qadri, A. (2017, August 11). The making of America's opioid epidemic. TRT World. Retrieved
from
https://www.trtworld.com/magazine/the-making-of-the-opioid-epidemic-in-the-united-sta
tes-419409
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. (2018, January). Buprenorphine
https://www.samhsa.gov/programs-campaigns/medication-assisted-treatment/training-ma
terials-resources/buprenorphine-waiver
Sunrise House. (n.d.). The path drugs take through the body. Retrieved from
https://sunrisehouse.com/cause-effect/path-drugs-take-body/
The SUPPORT for Patients and Communities Act of 2018, H.R. 6, 115th Cong. (Oct. 24, 2018).
Retrieved from
https://images.magnetmail.net/images/clients/AHA_MCHF/attach/2018/October/Opioid_
LegislativeAdvisory_SUPPORT_ACT_10242018.pdf
Tate, N. (2018, May). Fentanyl: What you should know. Retrieved from
https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/addiction/news/20180501/fentanyl-what-you-sho
uld-know
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (n.d.). The opioid epidemic in numbers.
U.S. Department of Justice. (n.d.). Raising awareness of opioid addiction. Retrieved from
https://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/raising-awareness-of-opioid-addiction