Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Introduction/Objectives: Procalcitonin has become an important marker for
infection. However, previous studies of solid organ transplants, including liver,
have related its elevation to non-infectious adverse outcomes. The purpose of
this study is to determine the predictive value of the trend of PCT levels and its
association with non-infectious complications.
Methods: A retrospective observational study of children who underwent liver
transplantation at our center, between August 2009 and December 2015.
Results: 45 patients were included, 40% male. 63% with cholestatic disease .
67% had a moderate to high mortality risk. A declining procalcitonin delta
between the 2nd and 1st day greater than 1 was found to have a 100%
specificity for primary dysfunction of the graft, with an OR of 21.6 (95% CI 1.8-
250.2, p=0.014). Persistently elevated levels were not associated with mortality,
OR 2.57 (95% CI 0.49 - 13.4 p=0.26), or infection, OR 0.18 (95% CI 0.1 – 5.6,
p=0.56).
Conclusion: The procalcitonin trend is a good predictive factor of graft
dysfunction in post-liver transplant pediatric patients, after the second
postoperative day. According to our experience, there is no association between
the trend and mortality. In infected patients, procalcitonin declines in the usual
manner after the second postoperative day.
Key Words: Children, Calcitonin, Liver Transplantation/adverse effects, Liver
Transplantation/mortality, Postoperative Complications/diagnosis, Primary Graft Dysfunction
Pediatric liver transplantation is one of the most successful solid organ transplants
(1), which has consolidated it as an effective strategy for the treatment of
irreversible acute liver failure in children, with a great impact on survival and quality
of life (2)(3). These significant advances have been possible due to the
development of new surgical techniques as well as in the identification of problems
and early intervention (4).
Among the tools that allow this anticipation is procalcitonin (PCT). This is a protein
precursor of the calcitonin hormone, with a molecular weight of approximately 13
kDa, made up of 116 amino acids. It is primarily produced in the thyroid gland and
has a half life close to 26 to 30 hours, with low levels being found in healthy
individuals, < 0.5 mg/dL (5).
Clinically, it is used as an infectious marker in patients with bacterial or fungal
sepsis (6). However, this elevation shows conflicting results when the organ
2
involved is the liver. Meisner et al. showed that septic shock induced by the
application of endotoxins is not followed by a PCT elevation in anhepatic baboons
(8), which shows the relevance of this organ in the regulation of the production of
this marker.
Taking into account that its main production outside of the thyroid is in the liver, it is
very important to identify its role in determining its prognostic value in pediatric
post-liver transplant patients. The purpose of this research is to evaluate the
prognostic value of the PCT level behavior and its association with non-infectious
complications, such as organ failure, primary graft dysfunction and rejection, during
the postoperative period in the Intensive Care Unit, in children immediately post-
liver transplantation.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study design
All pediatric patients undergoing liver transplant, of any type and due to any
etiology, who received complete postoperative care at the Fundación Cardioinfantil
Instituto de Cardiología up to discharge from the Intensive Care Unit or death,
between August 1, 2009 and December 31, 2015, were included. These patients
followed a specific post-operative treatment plan, according to the post-transplant
treatment protocol in the PICU (14). Patients were excluded who had a history of
associated thyroid pathology, transplantation of another solid organ, or who had a
donor history of infection, confirmed clinically, radiologically or by laboratory
exams.
The measurement technique for serum levels of procalcitonin was the same
throughout the sample collection period. It was the LUMI test for quantitative
determination in human plasma or serum (B.R.A.H.M.S., Hennigsdorf, Germany),
with immunoluminometric assay. This test has an analytical sensitivity of
approximately 0.1 ng/mL, and an approximate inter-measurement variability of 0.3
ng/mL, according to the manufacturer, being registered as a continuous variable
during the first seven days of PICU stay, in order to evaluate the trend over time.
Outcomes
The variables to be evaluated were obtained from the included patients by a review
of the electronic patient charts. The non-infectious complication variables were
recorded as dichotomous variables. Organ dysfunction was defined according to
Goldstein´s criteria (15), presenting at any time during the intensive care unit stay.
The graft dysfunction variable was interpreted as poor functioning of the graft
beginning postoperatively, defined by acute liver failure with encephalopathy,
coagulopathy, metabolic acidosis, hemodynamic instability, oliguria, transaminases
>3,000 and persistently prolonged PT without another apparent cause. The
diagnosis of graft rejection was taken from the chart, when clinical suspicion was
confirmed by biopsy.
The presence or absence of infection was recorded, according to the definitions of
the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (16), and if it presented during the
first 10 days of treatment. Mortality will be followed until hospital discharge.
A non-infectious complication was defined as the presence of one of the previously
mentioned events: organ failure, primary graft dysfunction, or graft rejection.
Statistical analysis
RESULTS
During the study period, a total of 47 liver transplants were carried out, 32 patients
with a cadaver donor, and 15 patients with a living donor. Each of these patients
received the complete post-operative treatment according to the institutional
guideline for liver transplantation (14). However, two of those with a cadaver donor
did not have procalcitonin levels, due to the unavailability of the test on the dates
on which their procedures were performed. Of these two patients, one had a
prolonged stay in intensive care, as a non-infectious complication, and the other
4
patient did not have non-infectious complications. None of the patients had
infection or mortality.
Among the transplanted patients, the average age was three years, and 50% were
within the range of 1 to 11 years, with a ratio of 1.4 females for every male,
spanning all age ranges, with a minimum of 0.8 and a maximum of 17 years. The
patients also had a varied PELD score, with a median of 14 and a range of 7 to 30.
The majority were eutrophic. The main reason for transplantation was cholestatic
disease, with a third of the patients receiving a transplant from a living donor.
The rest of the demographic characteristics of the patients are expressed in Table
1.
During surgery, the intervention time had a mean of 6.5 hours, in 50% of patients
the time was 5.3 to 7.6 hours.
Less than 10% of patients required an additional extra-hepatic procedure. All
patients received immunosuppression with methylprednisolone, and three required
an additional medication.
5
In the postoperative period, the PRISM III score showed intermediate risk in 46%
and high risk of mortality in 20%, which is a reflection of the complexity of these
patients. Following surgery, the patients had a mean lactate of 2.2. Half of the
patients had an intensive care stay of less than seven days, with ventilated time
less than three days. The rest of the characteristics of the postoperative variables
are found in Table 2.
With regard to infection, eight children out of the total number of patients (17.7%)
met one of the criteria, pulmonary infection being the most common with 37.5% of
the cases, and blood stream infections with 25%. Of these eight patients, seven
developed sepsis criteria.
6
Figure 1 shows the median of procalcitonin levels for each of the first seven days,
according to each type of complication and in patients without complications,
evidencing, as described in the literature, an initial increase, followed by a
decrease in the first days. However, in patients with non-infectious complications,
the increase continues, or there is no decrease following the second day.
Grouping the patients with non-infectious complications and comparing them with
patients who did not develop this complication (Figure 2), a variation in the time of
descent of the levels can be seen in the first patients, towards the second day, with
a lack of descent or a lower speed of descent, similar to what was seen previously.
FIG 1. The different bars express the median and distribution of values for each day, beginning
after surgery, or on day 0. A similar behavior is observed in the four groups, with an initial
elevation and a progressive descent which begins on the second day for patients with infection
(n=7) and without complications (n=7), while in those with non-infectious complications (n=30), the
elevation persists until the second day. Only one patient had both types of complications.
7
FIG 2. The different bars express the median and distribution of values for each day, beginning
postoperatively, or at day 0, between patients with non-infectious complications and the rest of
the patients. It shows more clearly a persistent elevation or a much lower delta between 24 and 48
hours postoperatively.
Table 3 shows the results of the bivariate analysis in relation to the presence of
non-infectious complications, within which, the variables that were seen to be
related were: increased resistance in the graft duplex, with an OR of 0.19 (95% CI
0.1-0.03, p0.03), chronic malnutrition, OR of 0.14 (0.28-0.7 p0.017), and a
procalcitonin delta between days 2 and 1 >1 for primary graft dysfunction, with an
OR of 21.6 (95% CI 1.8-250.2 p0.014).
For the other variables, no association was found with the development of the
outcome of non-infectious complications, including isolated procalcitonin values on
the different days. OR was not calculated for the whole set of non-infectious
complications, since one of the values in the table is zero.
8
Nutritional State
Eutrophic 21 7
Acute malnutrition 6 1 2 (0.2-19.6) 0.55
Chronic malnutrition 3 7 0.14 (0.28-0.7) 0.017
Etiology
Cholestasis 19 11 1.44(0.24-8.75)
Acute Liver Failure 5 2 2.31(0.23-23.4) 0.68
Metabolic 4 1 1.15(0.93-14.2) 0.47
Others 2 1 0.90
Type of transplant
Living Donor 9 6
Cadaver Donor 21 9 0.68(0.16-2.93) 0.61
Extra-hepatic procedure
Yes 3 1
No 27 14 0.6 (0.18-2.0) 0.71
9
Immunosuppression
Methylprednisolone (MTP) 28 14 0.71
MTP+Basiliximab 2 1 0.75 (0.17-3.1)
Graft duplex
Normal 30 12
Increased index 0 3 0.19 (0.1-0.03) 0.03
significant association was found with the other variables, except having a PRISM
score higher than 20, for organ dysfunction, with an OR of 7.69 (95% CI 1.2 -
41.2 p 0.042)
The possible relationships of the mortality variable with the different pre- and post-
operative variables were also explored, finding an association with a PRISM III
mortality prediction score greater than 30, with an OR of 28 (95% CI 2.4 -
326.7 p0.008). Graphically, a decrease in procalcitonin delta was also found
between days 1 and 2. However, when the delta greater than 1 between these
days was analyzed, an OR of 2.57 was obtained (95% CI 0.49 - 13.4 p0.26),
which was not statistically significant.
DISCUSSION
Recently, PCT has been described not just as an important marker for infection,
but also as a predictive factor for non-infectious complications in patients at risk for
presenting reperfusion ischemia injuries, such as patients with extensive burns
(19), severe trauma (20), and in cardiovascular surgery (21)(10). In this last group
of patients, it has proven to be a predictor of systemic inflammation associated with
organ failure, including ARDS, kidney, and cardiovascular failure. Likewise, a
prospective study carried out on this same group of patients found that high levels
in the first two days postoperatively had a greater risk of complications unrelated to
infection, such as cardio-respiratory arrest, length of stay in intensive care, duration
of mechanical ventilation, and requirement of inotropic support (11). These
patients also had higher lactate levels, and underwent a longer time on
cardiopulmonary bypass, a longer aortic clamp time, and longer surgery time.
No difference was found between the absolute values or the procalcitonin descent
delta in patients who had a diagnosed infection, probably due to the use of broad
spectrum antibiotics in these patients, which, as they controlled the infection led to
a decrease in the microbiological triggers which generally increase the production
of PCT. Likewise, although there was a similar tendency, there was no statistically
significant association to establish the procalcitonin delta as a predictor of
mortality.
These findings agree with what we found in our study, in the sense that a delta
between the second and first day greater than 1 ng/mL is correlated with non-
infectious complications which should be investigated, given that a decrease in
levels in infected patients may be produced due to the favorable progress of the
infection after beginning antibiotic therapy.
The other variables that showed an association were nutritional status, with a
negative OR for patients with chronic malnutrition, which could be explained by the
diminished immunological response and capacity for production of PCT in these
patients. Likewise, an increased resistance index in the graft duplex showed a
negative OR, which could be an incidental finding, due to the small number of
patients who had it.
The main limitations of our research are that due to the small number of patients
who presented primary dysfunction, the results must be interpreted cautiously, and
prospective studies are needed to corroborate these findings. Being a
retrospective cohort analysis, it could have an information bias. However, the
analysis and data collection from the electronic chart is the same for all the cases,
and the same technique and sample processing time was used for all processed
test samples. Moreover, being a surgical event with a relatively low frequency, the
sample size is greater than in other pediatric liver transplant studies.
CONCLUSIONS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
- Pediatric Liver Transplant Group, Fundación Cárdio Infantil
- Team of nurses and residents of the Pediatric Intensive Care Unit, Fundación
CárdioInfantil
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Kelly D a. Current issues in pediatric transplantation. Pediatr Transplant.
2006;10(6):712–20.
2. Berg CL, Steffick DE, Edwards EB, Heimbach JK, Magee JC, Washburn WK,
et al. Liver and intestine transplantation in the United States 1998-2007. Am
J Transplant. 2009;9(4 PART 2):907–31.
13
12. Zant R, Melter M, Schlitt HJ, Loss M, Ameres M, Knoppke B, et al. High
levels of procalcitonin in the early phase after pediatric liver transplantation
indicate poor postoperative outcome. Hepatogastroenterology.
14
2014;61(133):1344–9.
17. Dellinger RP, Levy MM, Rhodes A, Annane D, Gerlach H, Opal SM, et al.
Surviving Sepsis Campaign. Crit Care Med. 2013;41(2):580–637.
18. Jhanji S, Pearse RM. The use of early intervention to prevent postoperative
complications. Curr Opin Crit Care. 2009 Aug;15(4):349–54.
26. Yu X-Y, Wang Y, Zhong H, Dou Q-L, Song Y-L, Wen H. Diagnostic Value of
Serum Procalcitonin in Solid Organ Transplant Recipients: A Systematic
Review and Meta-analysis. Transplant Proc. 2014;46(1):26–32.
16