You are on page 1of 12

TOURISM AND QUALITY AGRO-FOOD PRODUCTS:

AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THE SPANISH


COUNTRYSIDE
XOSÉ A. ARMESTO LÓPEZ & BELÉN GÓMEZ MARTÍN
Dpt. de Geografia Física i Anàlisi Geogràfica Regional, Facultat de Geografia i Història, Universitat de
Barcelona. C/ Baldiri Reixac s/n, Barcelona 08028, Spain. E-mails: armesto@ub.edu, bgomez@ub.edu

Received: October 2004; revised April 2005

ABSTRACT
This paper describes the relationships between tourism and the agricultural production of
traditional products, the latter having achieved new levels of appreciation in recent years as a result
of quality designations. In this context, agro-food products can be considered as gastronomic
tourism resources that enable tourism both to be developed and itself become a tool for promoting
and commercialising quality agro-food products. These two circumstances merge around a single
aim: the local development of areas traditionally regarded as marginal within the regional context.
These facts are showed in the Catalan region of Priorat (Spain) where wines support the local
development.

Key words: Gastronomy, tourism, quality foods, local development, agriculture, Spain.

INTRODUCTION ation of cultural aspects from a more recreational


or entertainment perspective are all features
In recent years the development of tourism in that illustrate new approaches to tourism (Antón
various areas has shown a number of particular 2000; Boniface 2003). Indeed, the leading role
characteristics that have come to be seen as acquired in recent years by some forms of cul-
symptomatic of change and which mark the tural tourism that were previously regarded as
start of a new stage in the history of this key complementary, such as gastronomic tourism,
economic and social phenomenon. This stage, can only be understood within the framework
regarded as beginning at the end of the 1980s of these renewed trends.
and referred to as post-Fordist, is characterised In gastronomic tourism, food products and
by new processes of tourism production and culinary specialties become the vehicle for a
consumption in which geographical space takes closer understanding of cultures in that they
on renewed value and a different dimension. act as markers of peoples and territories. This
The new observable trends in the production new way of approaching the culture of a place,
and consumption of cultural tourism are in- region or country is more active, experiential,
extricably linked to the new tourism paradigm entertainment-based and celebratory than
(Urry 1990; Nuryanti 1996, cited in Antón 2000). previous forms and, a priori, seeks sustainable
In this regard, the singularisation of tourism development by: (i) ensuring the maintenance
space through the productive and symbolic of tourism resources; (ii) improving the welfare
valuing of those elements of cultural heritage of the population involved in producing and
which provide territorial identity, a renewed commercialising products; and (iii) assuring
interest in all forms of culture, or the appreci- a satisfactory tourism experience by offering

Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie – 2006, Vol. 97, No. 2, pp. 166–177.
© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG
Published by Blackwell Publishing Ltd., 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK and 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA
TOURISM AND QUALITY AGRO-FOOD PRODUCTS 167

quality. This satisfaction through quality is fre- determined to define as globalised. Desig-
quently linked to the presence and promotion nations of origin for agricultural products,
of food products bearing quality labels. through the various forms of protection they
Food quality is one of the key features of the offer, are able to strengthen the geographical
redefined Common Agriculture Policy (CAP). relationship between production, place, pro-
This new perspective is a direct result of the situ- ducers, preparers and consumers. Therefore,
ation that arose following the Second World it seems clear that links between these types of
War, in which a war-ravaged Europe was in need registered products and the consumer are
of a rapid economic recovery and so increased established not only in the supermarket but also
all areas of production, including, of course, through the leisure-related mobility of an urban
agriculture. However, this situation led to large population that finds further appeal in the gas-
surpluses being accumulated, saw a progressive tronomy and typical products of a given area.
reduction and loss of social structure in rural This paper is divided into three sections: the
populations and soon resulted in deterioration first focuses on the development process of
of the environment. Consequently, in the 1980s gastronomic tourism in Spain; the second deals
European policy-makers began to discuss and with the link between gastronomy tourism and
develop proposals with the aim of off-setting the promotion of quality products; and the
these imbalances. third shows, in a global way, how the integration
The Spanish countryside is currently deter- of those activities can be configured into a strat-
mined by European policy, which nominally egy for local development.
seeks to base itself on three premises: the main- The sources used to complete this analysis
tenance of productive function; the conside- were the following:
ration of the rural world as the social basis of
• Documentation provided by the General
Europe; and the protection and improvement of
Subdirectory of Agro-Food Quality and
the environment. Quality falls under the first
Promotion of the Spanish Ministry of
of these objectives, and appears as a key feature
Agriculture, Fishing, and Food.
of the new European agriculture that seeks to
• Documentation provided by the General
replace the search for increased production.
Secretary of Tourism of the Ministry of
This new situation, in which an attempt is
Industry, Tourism, and Commerce.
made to consider the rural environment as a
• Documentation provided by the Regulatory
whole and not just in terms of agricultural pro-
Councils of the Denominations of Origin
duction, has led some authors to argue that the
(DO).
European countryside is in the midst of a post-
• A sample of local, provincial, and regional
productivist transition. New demands that com-
tourist brochures targeted directly to the
bine tradition and innovation are being made of
consumer.
today’s countryside, and thus, the rural environ-
• Semi-structured indepth interviews with the
ment is increasingly asked to provide urban
Regulatory Councils, tourist agents, operators
markets not just with food but also with other
registered in the Regulatory Councils, tourists
non-material assets such as nature, landscape,
and those on outings, and organisations that
territorial balance, culture, health, gastronomy
operate at the local level.
and tourism, all of which are contemplated
from the point of view of the consumer and
situated within the conceptual framework of CULTURAL TOURISM AND GASTRONOMY
post-Fordism and postmodernism (Rubio 1999). IN SPAIN
It is within this philosophical context that the
general idea of sustainable rural development The socio-economic transformations undergone
should be placed, quality products being one of over the last two decades have affected the way
the instruments used to attain it. in which the concept of cultural heritage is
In sum, the needs of consumers in terms of understood. The previous notion has been
rural space, centred round the search for qual- extended and now includes monuments, groups
ity in the widest sense, lead to a strong resur- of buildings and historic places (UNESCO
gence of place and region in a world we seem 1972), new elements linked to what is referred

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


168 XOSÉ A. ARMESTO LÓPEZ & BELÉN GÓMEZ MARTÍN

to as popular and traditional culture. Thus, important role in the process of purchase
cultural heritage is nowadays understood as ‘all decisions made by the tourist/consumer (Chon
natural and cultural elements, tangible or 1990). Indeed, according to a recent review by
intangible, which are inherited or newly cre- Gallarza & Calderón (2002) of 25 TDI (tourism
ated, because through these elements social destination image) studies, gastronomy is one
groups recognise their identity and commit of the most important attributes used by poten-
themselves to pass it on to future generations tial tourists in forming images of a tourism
in an improved and enriched form’ (UNESCO destination (occupying fifth place in a ranking
1998). of twenty variables), and also one of the most
The concept of cultural tourism has developed influential in terms of visitor satisfaction.
alongside that of cultural heritage. Gastronomy, In the context of Spanish tourism, gastro-
understood as the cultural value assigned to nomic tourism is one of the emerging products
foods or the way in which they are prepared showing most development in recent years. This
in a given place or social group, is one of the is clearly illustrated both by the large quantity
elements with close links to the new concept of of tourism products based mainly on gastro-
cultural heritage and one of the most highly nomic resources (in this regard the notable
valued tourism resources in recent years, due to increase in gastronomic tourism routes is par-
its ability to meet the new consumer needs ticularly noteworthy) and the constant rise in
associated with the demand for cultural tourism. the number of eating establishments. Accord-
Gastronomy, as a tourism resource, is not only ing to figures from the Spanish federation for
appreciated for its intrinsic value but also on a the hotel and catering trade for 2002, there
symbolic level, in that it is representative of were 254,802 bars, 54,520 restaurants and
peoples and territories. In this regard, identity 12,696 cafés in Spain, the figure for all these
should be seen as taking on prime importance establishments having practically doubled since
in a globalised society, where culture itself has 1985. Likewise, comparative figures showed the
undergone a process of standardisation (Grande restaurant subsector to have grown much more
2001). This homogenisation, that in gastron- rapidly than the other tourism subsectors: for
omy could be identified with the process of the period 1975–2000, the number of beds
McDonaldisation and Coca-Colarisation or with US offered by the accommodation subsector only
culinary imperialism (extended under the old increased by a little over 50 per cent whereas the
Fordist paradigm), has generated a longing for number of dining places in restaurants tripled
the authentic and traditional (post-Fordism) during the same period (AECIT 2002, 2003).
(Ritzer 1998; Moulin 2000). This desire has This increasing development is based on the
led both to a growth in restaurants offering potential resources on offer in Spain: the coun-
traditional cuisine and quality local products try’s geographical and cultural diversity provide
and to the consolidation of a new subcategory a wide range of foods and ways of preparing
of tourism: gastronomic tourism. them and, consequently, shapes and gives
Another way in which gastronomy is appre- content to concepts of local cuisine, regional
ciated as a tourism resource is through its cooking, or the cuisine associated with large
compatibility with new trends of cultural con- geographical areas.
sumption. Gastronomy enables people to In today’s Spain, gastronomic aspects have
approach culture in a more experiential and come to be regarded as complementary tourism
participative way (postmodernist), one that is resources or as basic resources to be used in
not merely contemplative. Moreover, exploited developing tourism products. In the former
in certain ways it is able to generate tourism case, gastronomic resources are not in them-
products of high added value and, occasionally, selves seen as the reason behind tourist journeys
an exclusive nature (post-tourism). but add value to the destination’s image, help
All these aspects, of interest in the new system distinguish it from competitors and play a key
of tourism production and consumption, mean role in evaluating levels of visitor satisfaction
that gastronomy often becomes a factor of (Bernard & Domínguez 2001). Restaurants,
attraction and a key element in the image of understood as all those establishments special-
a tourism destination, thus coming to play an ised in offering traditional dishes of local and

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


TOURISM AND QUALITY AGRO-FOOD PRODUCTS 169

regional cuisine (Vallée 1992) are the tool that Thematic routes – These appear on different
brings people into contact with the gastronomic scales and consist of itineraries that seek to
resources of a given place, and thus a tourist’s explore a given place through short visits based
evaluation of this place will depend on the around a single gastronomic aspect or theme.
number and quality of such establishments. It Routes may revolve around a particular product
is no idle speculation to say that the growth in or specific dishes. Gastronomic routes offer a
the number and range of restaurants in Spain series of pleasurable moments and activities
has been particularly driven by tourism activity related to the distinctive elements of a given
and the wish to exploit this complementary itinerary: trying products or dishes, guided
resource. Indeed, the greatest increase in both tours to learn about the agro-industrial produc-
the number of eating establishments and growth tion of the resource (either in situ or through
percentages is to be found in those regions museum reproductions), purchases in specialist
of Spain most closely associated with tourism. shops and visits to traditional markets, etc. It
For example the correlation coefficient between should be borne in mind that such routes
the number of restaurants and nights spent in enable a product to include elements that, indi-
tourist establishments by Autonomous Commu- vidually, could only be presented as comple-
nity shows a solid result of r = 0.70. mentary resources of other modes of tourism,
Gastronomic resources and the tools used in but which taken together form the backbone
deploying them help to shape an image of qual- of and create a final product of great value.
ity for the destination that is revealed through Wine tourism, which in Spain has become a
various promotional materials: both the images highly important part of gastronomic tourism,
and text that appear in Spanish tourism leaflets is one of the products that have traditionally
place great emphasis on the type and range of been commercialised in the form of routes: for
gastronomy on offer as being a fundamental example, there are routes through the vine-
part of the tourist experience. It is no accident yards of areas such as La Rioja, Ribera del Duero
that the information regarding gastronomic and Alt Penedès.
resources and/or the range of products avail-
able is either presented in a separate section of Trips to a destination – In these cases tourists
general leaflets and/or appears in a specific travel, either independently or in organised
leaflet dedicated exclusively to gastronomy (for tours, to destinations of recognised gastronomic
example Wines and Food from La Rioja or The prestige where there are a wide range of restau-
Guide to Food and Drink in the Basque Country). rants. These places tend to use gastronomic
In the second case, gastronomic resources products as the main attraction, although they
become the protagonists and play a decisive role also include other elements of cultural or nat-
in drawing tourists towards certain geographi- ural appeal and of recognised value. These trips
cal areas. Foods and/or ways of preparing may be offered throughout the year, as in the
them are here the basic elements of the tourism case of Segovia with its suckling pig, or the
product, and so restaurants, a small trade in Iberian cured hams of the Huelva Sierra; at
traditional products and the presence of small times, however, they are closely linked to the
and medium-sized thematic museums take on seasonal nature of raw materials (for example,
fundamental importance in the tourism experi- autumn visits to the Catalan Pyrenees to enjoy wild
ence. Indeed, tourists in this category dedicate mushrooms or springtime trips to Pontevedra
most of their budget to the food area, one which (Galicia) to try lamprey).
includes not only local consumption but also
the purchase of food products as souvenirs or Events – These include thematic festivities (tra-
for later consumption back home. ditional fairs, markets and festivals celebrating
The thematisation of tourism products typical customs and products) whose influence
around gastronomy is thus another strategy goes beyond the strictly local area and which
for diversifying what is on offer and adapting attract large numbers of visitors from outside.
it to the new tastes of potential tourists. In the Galicia is particularly noteworthy in terms of
Spanish market these basic resources are in- the organisation of this type of event: examples
corporated in three different ways. here include festivities celebrating mussels,

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


170 XOSÉ A. ARMESTO LÓPEZ & BELÉN GÓMEZ MARTÍN

octopus, goose barnacles, oysters and the tradi- demonstrations (for example, the one organised
tional pies known as empanadas (Lois & Santos in 2003 by the local authorities of Cordoba
2001). Festivities in other regions of Spain entitled Cordoba: The Taste of a Culture) and tourist
include the traditional slaughter of pigs (in the guidebooks specialised in gastronomy.
town of Burgo de Osma), the outdoor barbecues This key role of gastronomic aspects in the
of Catalan spring onions known as calçotades, development of tourism is also evident in a
and the snail festivals in Lleida. Many of these number of initiatives undertaken in Spain in
celebrations bear the Declaration of Tourist In- recent years.
terest, a distinction awarded to those festivals or
events deemed to illustrate cultural values and Creation of quality labels to highlight food
popular traditions, especially in terms of their products from a traditional range with close ties
ethnological characteristics, and which are of to a consolidated route or tourism region –
special interest as a tourist attraction. Once The most well known example of this is the
again, Galicia can be seen to place special quality label Tradition along the Road developed
emphasis on these resources in its tourism to highlight traditional food products associ-
system: of the 22 festivals held in Galicia but ated with the legendary Road to Santiago.
declared to be of tourist interest for the whole Making traditional products from three coun-
of Spain, five are based around gastronomy. tries (France, Spain and Portugal) are 635
Likewise, of the 35 festivals regarded as being companies grouped into 16 associations corre-
of tourist interest for Galicia (a regional decla- sponding to 11 clearly differentiated regions,
ration) 16 relate to typical products and/or which launched this brand onto the European
dishes of the region. market. This quality label, a brand of brands, is
designed to highlight those foods produced
The three forms of commercialisation described along the Road to Santiago which, either for
show common elements in terms of the trend their intrinsic quality or the traditional produc-
presented by these types of product, namely, tion methods used, remain faithful to the typi-
one that is moving towards an entertainment- cal style associated with certain geographical
based or dramatised approach to resources and and historical features (gathers together prod-
space (in order that they be enjoyed and experi- ucts carrying Designations of Origin or foods
enced first-hand), as well as more participative assigned Protected Geographical Indications, as
interpretation (so as to provide the creative and well as products included under the category of
enriching experiences so much in demand recognised organic foods or, simply, traditional
from today’s tourists). products monitored by external inspections).
When these resources become the protago- Its objectives include fostering regional gastro-
nists, then the tourism image of a country, nomic traditions as part of the culture of the
region or destination is associated with gastro- Road to Santiago, developing new forms of
nomic aspects, a feature that is directly reflected promotion and distribution in tourism and
in tourism slogans and logos. This, for example, cultural markets, and creating new jobs, partic-
is the case of Asturias, whose campaign slogan ularly in rural and mountain areas that lie off
(or generic brand of the Principality) is Asturias the usual economic circuits.
– A Natural Paradise and whose product slogan
(or sub-brand) is Get a Taste for Asturias. Foundation of specialised public/private asso-
The important role played by gastronomic ciations in order to develop tourism in a given
aspects can be clearly seen in the promotional place by means of gastronomy – For example,
stands set up by some of Spain’s autonomous in 2002 the Catalan tourist board set up the
communities, provinces and destinations in Gastronomy Club with the aim of promoting the
tourism fairs (such as Fitur in Madrid, ITB in country through gastronomy. The club involves
Berlin, and SITC in Barcelona), where they various groups of chefs and restaurant owners
display and give visitors the opportunity to try from across Catalonia, organisations such as the
their main products and culinary specialities. Catalan Institute of Cuisine, producers, profes-
Moreover, it is reflected in the large numbers sionals from the world of culture and science,
of specific leaflets, travelling exhibitions/ and several tourist agents. One of the main

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


TOURISM AND QUALITY AGRO-FOOD PRODUCTS 171

contributions of the Gastronomy Club has been (Dedeire 2001). Ilbery & Kneafsey (2000) argue
the production of the Gastronomic Diary of that agro-food quality is approached from three
Catalonia. distinct perspectives: (i) that of the institutions,
where the parameters defining quality are
Signing agreements in order to promote quality closely linked to the concept of hygiene; (ii)
tourism linked to gastronomy – The Spanish that of producers, whose definition of the term
Secretary of State for Trade and Tourism, the is centred around the raw materials and pro-
Spanish Federation for the Hotel and Catering duction methods; and (iii) that of consumers,
Trade, the Spanish Nutrition Foundation and who basically understand the concept in terms
the Spanish Academy of Gastronomy have of their experience over time and who intro-
signed an agreement aimed at attracting quality duce the dimension of trust and risk.
tourism to Spain. One of the best ways of doing Quality emerged as an objective to be sought
this, and a key element in meeting the objective, by consumers, institutions and producers at the
is to promote Spanish cuisine abroad as an same time as the most important food scandals
expression of the country’s culture. The project came to light. Hence, it is this aspect which in
involves the development and introduction of recent years has received most attention from
actions for setting standards and instruments European countryside researchers (Goodman
for recognising and promoting quality Spanish 2003). In Spain, many consumers have become
cuisine in overseas establishments. The first more wary following events such as: the contami-
planned action to result from the agreement is nated rapeseed oil disaster in the 1980s that
the Gastronomic Excellence Project, the aim being caused numerous deaths and left permanent
to highlight Spanish restaurants abroad that sequelae in hundreds of people; the frequent
reach a certain level of quality and which trans- cases of food poisoning, particularly during the
mit a sense of what Spain is about. Other com- summer months, due to salmonella bacteria;
panies and organisations from the world of food and, in recent years, the outbreak of bovine
and tourism that support this initiative may join spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) or mad cow
in signing the agreement, thus contributing to disease (Armesto 2003).
the shared benefit of the whole sector. Quality products can be defined as those with
links to a place of reference and which, in addi-
THE LINKS BETWEEN QUALITY AND tion and from a cultural point of view, respect
PLACE well-established traditions in terms of the way
they are obtained or produced. These circum-
The development of gastronomic tourism is stances confer upon them particular qualitative
based on the presence of certain products and characteristics that serve to distinguish them from
a distinctive cuisine. The identification of these possible competitors (Gómez & Armesto 2002).
products and this singular cuisine is frequently The European Union (EU) has become
linked to tradition and the existence of foods aware of the cultural wealth and development
characterised by their quality. opportunities provided by production methods
The concept of agro-food quality is currently that recover traditional aspects and which are
one of the most widely studied issues in research more environmentally friendly. With the aim of
on agriculture and the rural environment promoting and protecting them, two related
(Goodman 2003). Quality can be defined as regulations (No. 2081/92 and No. 2082/92)
superiority in a given category, that is, a state were introduced in 1992 and defined the three
that defines the optimum condition of a food essential legal concepts for assessing value in
product. Implicit within the internal quality of agriculture: Protected Designation of Origin
a product are the following forms: (i) hygienic (PDO), Protected Geographical Indications
quality, which refers to the absence of chemical (PGI) and Traditional Specialities Guaranteed
toxicity; (ii) nutritional quality, related to dietary (TSG). Subsequently, in 1999, Regulation (EC)
balance; (iii) organoleptic quality, defined in No. 1493/99 was passed in order to regulate and
terms of sensations of taste, smell, texture or describe the production system for quality wines
appearance; and (iv) quality of use, that is, produced in specified regions (qwpsr). Previ-
aspects related to conservation and ease of use ously, Regulation (EEC) 2092/91 had been

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


172 XOSÉ A. ARMESTO LÓPEZ & BELÉN GÓMEZ MARTÍN

Table 1. Number of PDOs and PGIs according to the Table 2. Distribution of the main Designations of Origin
MAPA classification ( January 2004). in Spain (2004).

Type of production Number of PDO PGI qwpdr Total


Protected
Products Andalusia 13 2 4 34
Aragon 3 3 5 17
Virgin olive oils 19 Canary Islands 2 0 8 11
Rice 3 Cantabria 3 1 0 4
Fresh meat 14 Castile and Leon 3 10 5 26
Condiments and spices 2 Castile–La Mancha 6 3 7 21
Cold cuts and other meat products 5 Catalonia 7 9 12 29
Fruit 12 Autonomous 4 5 4 16
Vegetables 10 Community of Valencia
Cured hams 4 Extremadura 9 2 2 14
Pulses 4 Galicia 2 4 5 14
Honey 3 Balearic Islands 2 1 2 11
Cheese and dairy products 20 La Rioja 0 2 2 9
Turrón, marzipan and sweet products 2 Madrid 0 2 1 4
Miscellaneous 4 Navarre 3 4 3 11
Total 102 Basque Country 1 0 5 6
Principality of Asturias 2 2 0 5
Source : <www.mapya.es/alimentacion/pags/Denomin Murcia region 4 0 3 10
acion/resultado.asp>. MAPA (2004). Total 64 50 68 242

Source : <www.mapya.es/alimentacion/pags/Denomin
acion/resultado.asp>, MAPA (2004).
introduced to regulate organic production. In
Spain, these new EU regulations meant that the
various levels of government had to adapt their regional guarantee issued by the respective
instruments, and in 1994 the Spanish Ministry Autonomous Community, or which despite hav-
of Agriculture, Fisheries and Farming (MAPA) ing no official quality label are widely acknowl-
brought their old designations of origin and edged and prized by consumers.
specific designations into line with the PDOs and One issue which is of clear interest in the
PGIs. In addition, a new law on wines and vineyards minds of consumers is the identification of
was introduced in 2003, completely replacing foodstuffs protected by one of the legal con-
the previous legislation which dated back to 1970. cepts, what Sage (2003) calls ‘good food’. Con-
The last ten years in Spain have seen a pro- sumers interpret origin as a sign that enables
liferation of quality indicators for foodstuffs, them to attribute a qualitative value to a product,
these being especially promoted by the Autono- a fine quality that is free from risks (Dedeire
mous Communities and at times reflecting the 2001). These better or healthier products are
abovementioned European legislation. This is directly linked to defined regions, localities or
well illustrated by the rise in the number of places where they are cultivated, raised or pro-
designations of origin: in 1987 there were 12, duced. In the case of Spain, agro-food protec-
in 1992 twenty-six, in 1997 the figure had risen tion concepts most commonly appear at local
to 49, while by 2002 there were 88 PDOs and level (Gómez & Armesto 2002). This same idea
PGIs. Figures for the beginning of 2004 show of quality associated with a return to the local
that Spain boasts a total 102 products covered features as one of the central arguments in a
by these two basic legal concepts (see Table 1), recent report by Winter (2003).
it being one of the European Union states with In terms of the territorial distribution of
the highest numbers of such concepts. In addi- these products in Spain the Autonomous Com-
tion to foodstuffs whose quality is recognised by munities in which they are most abundant are
the EU there is a whole host of parallel food Andalusia, Catalonia, and Castile and Leon (see
products which either come accompanied by a Table 2). There are various reasons why there

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


TOURISM AND QUALITY AGRO-FOOD PRODUCTS 173

is such a noticeable imbalance between these tourism resources which until recently had not
three regions and those with fewer legal con- been used to this end. The recognition of
cepts of geographical protection, namely, gastronomic products positions them in the
Madrid, Cantabria and Asturias. Both Castile market and aids the process through which
and Leon, and Andalusia are regions covering specialised tourism resources can be based on
a vast area with a great variety of agricultural them. This is illustrated by the fact that the
landscapes (this is particularly the case of Anda- development of gastronomic tourism in Spain
lusia) and this results in there being a large has gone hand in hand with the development
number of distinct products. In addition to of the different legal concepts for valuing and
these geographical factors the – to an extent – protecting agro-food products.
peripheral nature of the economy in the rural
areas of the two communities has had a decisive DISCUSSION. THE INTEGRATION OF
influence in terms of their maintaining forms AGRICULTURAL ACTIVITIES AND
of production already discarded in other places. TOURISM: STRATEGIES FOR LOCAL
Although Catalonia does not share these char- DEVELOPMENT. THE CASE OF PRIORAT
acteristics, in that it is a medium-sized region, (CATALONIA)
it is, geographically speaking, very varied in
terms of agro-food production: in addition to The connection between the agricultural and
an important internal market and a strong com- tourism sectors in largely rural areas has led to
mercial presence beyond its borders, it has very the development of bidirectional quality stan-
modern and technologically-advanced agricul- dards: had this qualitative perspective not been
tural and food sectors, an important network introduced such a link would be almost impossi-
of rural initiatives and a much smaller active ble. The idea that survival of the countryside was
agricultural population than in the other cases. totally dependent on rural activity being plural
The common feature of these regions with less in nature was raised at the Cork conference on
presence in this issue is their smaller size (none rural development back in 1996, and continued
of them extends beyond 11,000 km2). In the to form part of the Salzburg Declaration of 2003.
context of differentiated agricultural production It seems clear that in the coming years the intro-
the case of Madrid is somewhat special in that duction of primary and tertiary activities into the
its rate of urbanisation is higher than any other same family or business environment will be one
region, and its agricultural assets reach only of the factors that sees the European countryside
residual levels (0.3%); it therefore seems logical becoming increasingly multi-functional.
that it is an Autonomous Community with This kind of association is directly fostered by
fewer declared Designations of Origin. The the rural development policy that has been
other two areas mentioned, Asturias and advocated by the EU since the end of the 1990s;
Cantabria, are, from a physical point of view, it would form part of what Jouen (2001) calls
relatively homogenous in that they are bounded the extrovert view of rural development, or to
at a similar latitude by the high peaks of the put it another way, an approach that fundamen-
Cantabrian Mountains and the Cantabrian tally seeks to import modernity in the form of
Sea; they also border one another. However, this economic development programmes for tertiary
relative homogeneity, particularly when com- (tourism, cultural heritage) or primary (agricul-
pared with other autonomous regions of Spain, ture, fishing) activities, improved quality and the
is not in itself sufficient to explain the lesser commercialisation of traditionally-produced
presence of geographical designations of quality; agricultural products. These approaches are
another key factor is the regional governments consistent with that set out in the EU initiative
themselves and their decisions regarding the LEADER which, together with the PRODER
promotion of typical products. programme, is one of the key strategies of
All these products bearing a quality label modern European rural development policy.
provide the basis for the development of gastro- However, Esparcia (2001) argues that the im-
nomic tourism. Indeed, it can be argued that portance of these programmes is relative in that
the recognition offered by one of these legal although they are more territorially-focused
concepts consolidates and shapes gastronomic they are not more quantitatively important. The

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


174 XOSÉ A. ARMESTO LÓPEZ & BELÉN GÓMEZ MARTÍN

total amount spent on sectorial approaches and specialist magazines, cook books and tourist
accompanying measures is much greater than information leaflets dedicated to regional pro-
the budget of the two programmes mentioned ducts, thus illustrating the growing interest being
above. shown across Europe in this issue (Voth 2001).
The first rural development actions within Assigning value to agricultural products plays
the framework of the LEADER programme a key role in the different stages of the European
were implemented in 1991, and for the first LEADER initiative and the PRODER pro-
three years were focused precisely on the devel- grammes. Indeed, there are numerous exam-
opment of rural tourism and the re-appreciation ples of such actions within Spain: for example,
of agricultural products, among other impor- sheep’s milk cheese and lamb have been valued
tant issues such as the promotion of traditional in the district of La Serena (Extremadura) for
production methods and professional training. over ten years; in several districts of Andalusia
Linked to this first initiative were two further (Sierra Morena, Serranías de Ronda and
and similar programmes which, until 1999, were Grazalema, etc.) large game animals, such as
known as LEADER II and PRODER (Esparcia wild boar and deer, have come to form the basis
2003). In this second period the majority of of a differentiated gastronomy with tourist
actions concerned tourism activities, the pro- appeal; also in Andalusia, in Sierra de Aracena,
motion of small industrial and service compa- cured ham bearing the PDO of Jamón de Huelva,
nies, and the development and improvement of together with wild mushrooms, serves as a
firms producing and commercialising agricul- core feature around which much of the area’s
tural resources; these three categories alone tourism is promoted.
accounted for three-quarters of the total invest- Gastronomic tourism, as well as being an end
ment (Alario Trigueros 2001). The third phase in achieving local development, is also a basic
of the initiative, which got underway in 1999, is tool for promoting and distributing the local
called LEADER + and has three basic objectives: agro-food products which likewise need to be
(i) the appreciation of both natural and cul- commercialised for this development to take
tural heritage; (ii) improving rural economies off. This is understandable if one considers that
through job creation; and (iii) improving the one of the defining characteristics of this type
organisational capacity of rural communities. of product is their local nature and links to
In addition, the PRODER programme also has small businesses, the latter facing difficulties in
a second stage which, as in the case of LEADER, promoting and selling their products. This is
will take it through to 2006. why: (i) basic tourism infrastructure (restaurants,
The concept of rural development currently rural houses, hotels, etc.) is developed in order
includes a series of features that until recently that foodstuff producers use these establish-
had not seemed remotely necessary. For example, ments to market their products; (ii) museums,
aspects such as respect for the environment, wine centres and educational centres are estab-
social equity, the recovery and maintenance of lished, and events and markets are organised,
culture and the interrelatedness and multi- to enable the public to learn more about the
functionality of jobs and the economy are now assets of a given area; and (iii) tourism promo-
seen as absolutely essential for the survival of tion in a particular area is linked to the existence
the rural environment. Economic sectors can of quality agro-food products, this becoming a
no longer remain isolated but must comple- basic strategy for such promotion. Indeed,
ment, promote and provide feedback to one tourists and day trippers may become the
another, this being the basis of the relationship saviours of small businesses, not only by helping
between gastronomic tourism and quality agri- to make their products more widely known
cultural products. Thus, it is increasingly com- but also by facilitating self-commercialisation,
mon to find restaurant menus in rural Spain that is, by enabling producers listed in the
that include not only a description of the dishes official designation of origin registers to sell
on offer but also complementary information their products directly. It is hoped that this sales
regarding their protected designation. This strategy will be able to consolidate a potential
strategy of differentiation has led to an increase market of mid- to high-level consumers. Indeed,
in the number of trade fairs, local festivities, the development of thematic tourism implies

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


TOURISM AND QUALITY AGRO-FOOD PRODUCTS 175

the specialisation of a target public (those in- and in 2003 it climbed to 45, with 54 in opera-
terested in gastronomic issues) that, by chance, tion today. In the same way, wine production has
coincides with the real or potential market of also increased from 13,419 hl in 1998 to 21,000
these quality foodstuffs. in 2003. The number of winemakers has also
One of the cases that best illustrates this situ- increased from 425 in 1998 to 600 today.
ation is that of the Priorat region (Catalonia). This new push based on wine has a trans-
This is a good example of how a product that lation in the regional economy and society as
is distinguished for its quality, in this case wine, can be seen in the evolution of the following
can serve as an attraction for a significant measures. The importance of wine is such that
number of visitors, offering the territory oppor- for the year 2003, 46.3 per cent of the agrarian
tunities for endogenous development. The fact GDP came from this product. The population
that the region possesses production that is of citizens younger than 44 that, until 1996, lost
managed in an efficient and modern way means almost three per cent of the total every five
that the quality label enjoys a good position in years, seems to have stabilised at 48 per cent
the market and, therefore, strengthens the rest of (this proportion did not change from 2001 to
the local economy directly linked to the product. 2003, and the stratum that corresponds to those
The success of this territory linked with the younger than 15 years has experienced a slight
Denomination of Origin has coincided with the rebound such that it is now about where it was
benefits of a rural development group, LEADER ten years ago).
II (1994–99), which contributed 4,722,000 $ The labour market, which until a very short
and later Leader + (currently functioning), time ago was the same as any marginal agrarian
which has a budget of 3,606,072 $ from the region shows clear signs of improvement: the
government which is supplemented with private unemployment rate (4%) is lower than the
investment that takes the total to 9,720,000 $. averages for Catalonia (6%) and Spain (9%),
The data clearly reflect this position since the while the working population increased by
majority of the 50 initiatives that have been 24 per cent from 1996. The distribution of jobs
completed are directly related with the world of in the municipalities of the DO clearly show the
wine, high-end agro-food products, restaurants, importance of the DO, according to the last
and tourism. population census (2001), 34 per cent of the
In the Priorat region, the success of the jobs are directly related to wine production,
revaluation of the product from the agrarian sales in specialised establishments, and hospi-
perspective can be seen by looking at the fol- tality. In fact, in the last four years the beds in
lowing numbers: the increase in the area dedi- tourist lodgings have increased by a factor of 15
cated to viticulture in the municipalities that and restaurants, food businesses, and agro-food
make up the Denominación de Origen is more businesses have not stopped increasing in
than notable, it went from 890 hectares in 1998 number (see Table 3).
to 1,600 in 2005; the number of bodegas in 1990 Furthermore, as a consequence of this relative
was scarcely 10, while in 1998 it was already 23 dynamism, the territory has begun to receive

Table 3. Evolution of tourist lodging beds, establishment of restaurants, businesses, industries and small-business
specialised agro-fish products in the Priorat region.

1975 1986 1992 1996 2000 2001 2002

Hotels 76 87 95 174 174 174 174


Camping 0 0 0 0 475 475 853
Rural accommodation 0 0 0 0 115 162 177
Restaurants na na na 24 29 29 30
Specialised shops na na 83* 83 97 95 92
Agrofood industries na na 46* 46 75 79 82

* Data from 1994.


Source : Institut d’Estadística de Catalunya. <www.idescat.net>.

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


176 XOSÉ A. ARMESTO LÓPEZ & BELÉN GÓMEZ MARTÍN

immigration, an estimated five per cent of on the basis of quality products. The two issues
the resident population is not Spanish-born (in discussed in this paper quality production and
1996 the foreign population was only 0.7% of tourism, therefore serve as tools which, through
the total). Similarly, land prices increased by gastronomy or other sales channels, contribute
a factor of ten in the last decade and, in terms to the rural development of numerous regions
of housing prices and in spite of the limited and localities that seek to participate in patterns
volume, it is following the Catalan trend average of consumption increasingly linked to urban
(an increase of 19% in the last year). environments.
The above data reference the majority opinion In the Priorat region the improvement of the
of the agents involved. According to the data principal economic and social indicators and of
gathered in our surveys, the majority of those the opinion of the agents involved show how the
interviewed partially attributed the economic and existence of a trademark and agricultural
social development of the region to the Denomi- promotion become an important local develop-
nation of Origin. For this reason, the following ment tool which transcends the production
questions appear which are totally or partially area. The change in relative employment figures
linked to the success of the wine DO of Priorat: and their link with the wine sector, together
with the area defined by the Denomination of
• The creation of new work opportunities for
Origin and the number of related companies
young people in the region.
are clear indicators of this fact. In the same way,
• Increases in family incomes.
statistics from the tourist phenomenon show
• Attraction of foreign investment.
how this has evolved in parallel to reinforce the
• Promotion of the territory abroad.
Denomination of Origin; currently, there are
• Attracting tourists.
numerous business initiatives in the region that
• Recovering popular culture.
link these two sectors.
• The promotion of the unique products and
In sum, quality agro-food products and all
gastronomy of the region.
aspects related to them are the driving force
• Increase in the prices of land and housing.
behind a number of rural development projects
• Putting land that had been abandoned under
implemented in recent years in many areas that
cultivation.
had previously been considered marginal from
• Creating new regions similar to this one.
an economic point of view. These projects are
injecting new life into these regions, not only
SOME FINAL REMARKS economically but also by strengthening them
socially.
In recent years, new forms of tourism have
clearly emerged in certain geographical and
Acknowledgements
market areas that had previously been overlooked
by tourist agents and, therefore, by consumers. This paper has been written as part of the research
At the same time, the Spanish countryside has project Territorial Imbalances: Labour Markets and Mar-
eagerly sought to assert the value of its products ginal Areas in Catalonia, funded by the CYCIT (project
through the protection offered by legislation BSO2001-3095) and through a research grant ( Ajut
that establishes a direct relationship between de Suport a la Recerca dels Grups Consolidats del II Pla de
quality and the geographical origin of products. Recerca) awarded by the Autonomous Government of
The result of these intertwined processes has Catalonia (2001SGR-00016).
been feedback between two productive sectors,
the primary and the tertiary joining forces in REFERENCES
order to take up a strong position in a market
where tradition plays a key role. Aecit (2002), La Actividad Turística Española en 2001.
The links developed between the production Castellón de la Plana: Asociación Española de
of quality agro-livestock products and these new Expertos Científicos en Turismo.
forms of tourism have led to the appearance of Aecit (2003), La Actividad Turística Española en 2002.
a gastronomy which both recovers traditional Castellón de la Plana: Asociación Española de
methods and is able to offer innovative proposals Expertos Científicos en Turismo.

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG


TOURISM AND QUALITY AGRO-FOOD PRODUCTS 177

Alario Trigueros, M. (2001), Las Políticas de Grande Ibarra, J. (2001), Análisis de la Oferta de
Planificación y de Desarrollo de los Espacios Turismo Cultural en España. Estudios Turísticos 150,
Rurales. In: F. García Pascual, ed., El Mundo Rural pp. 15–40.
en la Era de la Globalización: Incertidumbres y Ilbery, B. & M. Kneafsey (2000), Producer
Potencialidades, pp. 213 –265. Madrid: Ministerio de Constructions of Quality in Regional Speciality
Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación. Food Production: A Case Study from South West
Antón Clavé, S. (2000), Turismo, Territorio y Cultura. England. Journal of Rural Studies 16, pp. 217–230.
In: G. Morales Matos, ed., Turismo y Ciudad, pp. 29– Jouen, M. (2001), La Europa Rural al Principio del
41. Las Palmas de Gran Canaria: Ayuntamiento de Tercer Milenio. La Palabra Clave: Diversidad.
Las Palmas de Gran Canaria y AGE. LEADER Magazine 25, pp. 5–12.
Armesto López, X.A. (2003), Agricultura Ecológica Lois, R.C. & X.M. Santos (2001), Seafood
y Postproductivismo: Un Estudio Comparado de Consumption and Galicia’s Image. A Cultural
Cataluña y Galicia (Ph. D. thesis, University of Geography Approach. In: F. Molinero, E. Baraja
Barcelona). & M. Alarid, eds., II Simposio Anglo-Español de
Bernard, A. & Domínguez, P. (2001), Rutas de Arte Geografía Rural. Valladolid: Universidad de
y Gastronomía: Una Propuesta Inexplorada. Valladolid. CD-ROM edition.
Estudios y Perspectivas en Turismo 10, pp. 76 –90. Moulin, C. (2000), Gastronomy and Tourism: Must
Boniface, P. (2003), Tasting Tourism: Travelling for Every Tourist Wish be our Command?. Revue du
Food and Drink. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing. Tourisme 1, pp. 19–24.
Chon, K.S. (1990), The Role of Destination Image Ritzer, G. (1998), The McDonaldization Thesis. London:
in Tourism: A Review and Discussion. Revue du Sage.
Tourisme 2, pp. 2–9. Rubio, P. (1999), El Postproductivismo en los
Dedeire, M. (2001), L’appropriation de Signaux de Espacios Rurales. In: R. Galdós & E. Ruiz, eds.,
Qualité et l’attribution de Valeur aux Produits Postproductivismo y Medio Ambiente, Perspectivas
Ruraux: Une Conjonction du Temps et de l’espace. Geográficas Sobre el Espacio Rural. Vitoria-Gasteiz:
In: A. Berger, ed., Dynamique Rurale, Environnement Informes Técnicos No. 82, Departamento de
et Stratégies Spatiales, pp. 425–437. Montpellier: Agricultura y Pesca, Gobierno Vasco.
CNRS-Université Paul Valéry. Sage, C. (2003), Social Embeddedness and Relations
Esparcia Pérez, J. (2001), Las Políticas de Desarrollo of Regard: Alternative ‘Good Food’ Networks
Rural: Evaluación de Resultados y Debate en Torno in South-West Ireland. Journal of Rural Studies 19,
a Sus Orientaciones Futuras’. In: F. García Pascual, pp. 47–60.
ed., El Mundo Rural en la Era de la Globalización: Unesco (1972), Convention Concerning the Protection of
Incertidumbres y Potencialidades, pp. 267–309. Madrid: the World Cultural and Natural Heritage. Paris:
Ministerio de Agricutura, Pesca y Alimentación. Unesco.
Esparcia Pérez, J. (2003), Valoración y Balance de Unesco (1998), Conferencia Intergubernamental Sobre
PRODER. Versión Original. LEADER. Revista de Políticas Culturales Para el Desarrollo. Estocolmo:
Desarrollo Rural 22, pp. 16 –19. Unesco.
Gallarza, M., I. Gil & H. Calderón (2002), Vallée, A. (1992), Identitat Cultural i Alimentació.
Destination Image: Towards a Conceptual Revista Catalana de Geografía VII, pp. 61–70.
Framework. Annals of Tourism Research 29, pp. 56–78. Voth, A. (2001), La Revalorización del Origen
Gómez Martín, B. & Armesto López, X.A. (2002), Regional de Productos Agrarios. Forma y Función del
Turismo, Gastronomía y Territorio. Actas del XI Territorio en el Nuevo Siglo, pp. 504 –508. Oviedo:
Coloquio de Geografía Rural 1, pp. 139–147. Universidad de Oviedo.
Goodman, D. (2003), The Quality Turn and Winter, M. (2003), Embeddedness, the New Food
Alternative Food Practices: Reflections and Economy and Defensive Localism. Journal of Rural
Agenda. Journal of Rural Studies 19, pp. 1–7. Studies 19, pp. 23 –32.

© 2006 by the Royal Dutch Geographical Society KNAG

You might also like