Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Environment 2004 Hrvatski
Environment 2004 Hrvatski
Environmental protection
T-HT Group
Contents:
!! Introduction
Policy and strategy
Environmental Protection Policy and goals
Communication
! Legislative framework
Acts and regulations of the Republic of Croatia important for T-HT
Environmental Protection and Energy Efficiency Fund - ecological fees
! Environmental management
Environmental Management System (EMS) according to ISO 14001
Environmental Management System in T-Mobile
Introduction
Lately the issue of environmental protection has gained reputation and improvement of competitive edge, because
importance in the world and nowadays it is a significant nowadays, in order to be successful in the market it is, as al-
factor of economic success. Governments, consumers and ready said, extremely important to have a reputation of an
civil society groups expect more and more from corporate ecologically sensitive and responsible company. Although
performance with respect to environmental protection, our Company does not belong to the group of those the acti-
whilst international financial markets also start taking eco- vities of which significantly pollute the environment, dur-
logical risks more seriously. There are strong proofs that ing the previous years T-HT has been taking care of the en-
the companies with a higher level of performance in the vironment and has implemented a number of different pro-
area of environmental protection are, in a long run, also tection activities. The previous Business Unit Mobile (today
more successful in terms of finance and that the investors T-Mobile Hrvatska) has done most with respect to environ-
start preferring such companies. It is a generally known mental protection. So far, it is the only unit that has man-
fact that telecommunications are means of development, in aged to unify its efforts related to environmental protection
the first place with respect to sustainable development. If into an integrated environmental management system in
we consider the issue of environmental protection in the compliance with the international ISO 14001 standard and
light of the definition of sustainable development, which, in to receive a certificate for it. But the performance and
simple terms, says that the present growth must not endan- achievements realized in that field in entire T-HT have not
ger the chances for the growth of the future generations, it been systematically measured or presented to the public,
is easy, taking into consideration the existing telecommuni- except occasionally. This report is the first attempt to
cations technologies, information transmitted by them in change the situation and to present data on our approach
all forms and the scope in which they can provide solutions to environmental protection to our employees and a wider
for the problems related to environmental protection, to public and we have selected the indicators that describe
prove almost an organic connection between these two the areas in which we can exercise the greatest influence
seemingly different areas. Although it is beyond dispute on the environment in our regular business operations as a
that telecommunications are an environmental friendly telecommunications operator. The indicators are in compli-
business, there is no human or business activity that does ance with the indicators used by other European operators.
not influence the conditions of the natural environment. Thus we can define our position in relation to other opera-
Thus, T-HT, as a telecommunications operator that runs its tors with respect to our environmental performance at the
everyday regular activities and provides services to its cus- international level. The monitoring, comparison and pub-
tomers, is no exception to this rule. This impact has both, lishing of these indicators will enable us to constantly work
positive and negative effects on the environment. The nega- on the improvement of our performance, because if we can-
nd
tive effects are mostly manifested as the consumption of not measure it, we cannot improve it, as well. The 2 chap-
natural resources and the production of different types of ter is an outline of environmental protection policies and
rd
emissions and waste through our regular business activi- goals of the T-HT Group. The 3 chapter is a summary of
ties. The positive ones are related to an increase in the use the T-HT Group profile in which its business lines, organiza-
of information and communications technologies (ICT) and tion and responsibilities related to environmental protec-
applications which reduce the need for traveling and, con- tion are described, as well as basic data on human re-
th
sequently, for the use of fossil fuels, and dematerialization sources, networks and financial operations in 2004. The 4
of business operations resulting from the replacement of chapter describes legal framework for environmental pro-
th
written communications, in which paper is used as a medi- tection, whilst the 5 chapter offers an outline of environ-
um, by e-communications. T-HT understands the importan- mental management in the T-HT Group. Environmental
ce of environmental protection and its role in it and, there- impact indicators are presented collectively and classified
th
fore, it has set environmental protection among its highest as per groups of eco-efficiency in the 6 chapter.
priorities, integrating it into its key business processes and
organizational structure. In that way, apart from reducing th
the actual impact of its activities on the environment, T-HT At its 25 session held on August 17, 2005 the Management
has provided an opportunity to achieve significant benefits Board of T-HT passed a decision on adoption of the Report on
manifested as the reduction of operating costs, increase of environmental protection for T-HT Group for 2004.
Basic data
HT-Hrvatske telekomunikacije d.d. is the leading
provider of telecommunications service in Croatia, the
only one that provides the entire scope of services:
fixed telephony, mobile telephony, data transmission,
Internet and international communications.
The core business of the company HT-Hrvatske teleko-
munikacije d.d. and its affiliated company
T-Mobile Croatia LLC, i.e. the T-HT Group consists of
the provisioning of telecommunications services and
designing and construction of communications net-
works in the territory of the Republic of Croatia.
Apart from providing fixed network services (access
and traffic over fixed telephone lines and additional
fixed network services), the Group also provides
Internet services, data transmission services (leased
lines, ATM, X25 and Frame Relay) and operates with
GSM and UMTS mobile telephone networks.
HT-Hrvatske telekomunikacije d.d. is a joint stock com-
pany in the majority ownership of Deutsche Telekom
AG. It was founded on 28 December 1998 in the
Republic of Croatia in line with the provisions of the
Law on Separation of Hrvatska poπta i telekomunikaci-
je to Hrvatska poπta and Hrvatske telekomunikacije. In
that way, the business operations of the previous com-
pany Hrvatska poπta i telekomunikacije (“HPT s p.o.”)
were separated and transferred to two new joint stock
companies: Hrvatske telekomunikacije d.d. and
Hrvatska poπta d.d., which started their business on 01
January 1999.
During 2002 HT Mobile Communications LLC was
founded as a separate company and an affiliated com-
pany fully owned by Hrvatske telekomunikacije d.d. Its
main line of business is the provisioning of mobile com-
munications services.
During 2004 the T-HT Group implemented a rebranding
process and introduced a new corporate identity as of
01 October 2004, which had made the T-HT Group a
part of the global “T” family of Deutsche Telekom. The
change of the corporate identity was followed by the
forming of trademarks of two separate Group seg-
ments, T-Com and T-Mobile.
In 2000 the strategic and partnership connection
between the T-HT Group and Deutsche Telekom result-
ed in a stronger development of T-HT. T-HT became a
modern telecommunications group that wanted to use
all the advantages of the global trademarks in order to the world enables our customers to be available also
further improve its business and strengthen its compet- outside the borders of their parent network. T-Mobile
itive edge. has strengthened its leading position in the Croatian
The strategy of T-HT is still based on service quality, mobile communications market by reaching the market
customer satisfaction and further development of share of 53.7%. By the end of 2004 T-Mobile was grant-
broadband access and value-added services related to ed a UMTS network concession.
the broadband access.
Low indebtness rate, developed technological infra- Internet
structure that enables further development of services, T-HT as Internet service provider is a backbone of con-
and own human and expert potential are the guarantee tinuous growth and development of the Croatian
of further growth and increase of potentials in T-HT. Internet market. The introduction of MAXadsl broad-
Today T-HT is with right considered one of the band Internet access has had the strongest positive
strongest economic entities in the state and, as such, it impact on T-Com to keep its leading market position. A
is one of the key drivers of economic growth in Croatia. special attention is paid to the production of contents
in the Croatian language on T-Portal, which has
become the most visited Croatian portal with 150,000
visits a day, as well as to the support to e-commerce.
Business operations
The T-HT Group in Croatia provides all telecommunica- Data transmission
tions services - fixed telephony, mobile telephony, data Business customers have been offered various data
transmission, Internet and international communica- transmission services since 1987, through managed
tions. X.25 networks, Croline, ATM, unmanaged leased lines,
telex and telegraph which are still used by certain cus-
Service segments tomers.
Fixed telephony
Since the core business of T-HT is to take care of fixed
telephony services, the Company, apart from core tele-
phone services such as installation of lines and call Organization
routing, also enables customers to use different servic- Business operations of the T-HT Group are divided into
es with added value, like televoting, carrier services three business segments, which are organized in two
and free of charge universal access number. Fixed net- business units (fixed network and Internet) and brand-
work is still the largest source of telecommunications ed as T-Com, and a separate legal person, T-Mobile, and
revenue. In the area of technologically more advanced supported by four corporate units (CEO Corporate
services, HT started introducing the ISDN technology Unit, Financial Corporate Unit, Human Resources
in April 2000. Corporate Unit, Group Services Corporate Unit).
One of the main elements of the T-Com strategy is the
development of broadband Internet access. The imple-
mentation of the T-Com ADLS introduction strategy at
a national level started at the beginning of 2004 with Environmental protection organization and
the ADSL service launch. responsibilities
In this report period the environmental protection tasks
Mobile networks were not organized at the T-HT Group level. The
T-HT introduced the first GSM digital network in the Regulations on Organization regulate only that the waste
Croatian market in 1996. management tasks shall be performed by the Warehouse
Today mobile networks of T-Mobile cover over 98% of and Transportation Department (later on by the Procu-
the territory of the Republic of Croatia, whilst interna- rement and Logistics Department), where a special group
tional roaming with more than 200 GSM operators in for waste management was formed for that purpose.
Some tasks related to environmental protection were of the working group members. The environmental man-
also performed in the Work Safety Section, Personnel ager shall also be in charge of reporting to the Member of
Administration Department. Only by the end of the previ- the Management Board for environmental protection on
ous year an initiative for amendments to the Regulations the status of the System.
on Organization of HT d.d. was started. Pursuant to these
amendments, the tasks related to coordination and
organization of environmental protection in T-HT should
be assigned to the Network Strategy Department, Service Human Resources
Corporate Unit. The same amendments to the said The process of organizational development and improve-
Regulations provide that the Group Chief Services ment of business efficiency of T-HT had an impact on the
Officer shall be responsible for environmental protection, development of human resources function at the corpo-
whilst Regional Network Directors shall be responsible rate level. T-HT is aware of its responsibility towards cus-
for operational tasks in that field. tomers, but also towards shareholders, wider community
and, especially, towards its employees. The responsibili-
ty towards employees, the most valuable asset of our
T-Mobile Company, is designed and promoted through sustainable
Within the introduced Environmental Management development of human resources. T-HT is aware that the
System T-Mobile defined the structure of and responsibil- employees are an inevitable part of its success and that it
ities for environmental protection activities in its busi- cannot face numerous future challenges without commit-
ness. The responsibility starts from the Management ted and motivated workers who are going to implement
Board of T-Mobile, whereby the Management Board the necessary changes. On 31 December 2004 the HT
appointed one of its Members to the position of the Group had 8,862 employees. That number included 577
Management Board representative for environmental workers whose employment contracts were terminated
protection. The environmental manager shall be respon- as of 01 January 2005. Aware that our Company must be
sible to report to the Management Board on the opera- customer-oriented, because soon it will compete on an
tion of the Environmental Management System, so that entirely liberalized market, during 2004 T-HT focused on
the Management Board could appraise and improve the the improvement and education of the employees who
System pursuant to the mentioned report. The worked in direct contact with customers. 450 workers
Management Board shall ensure the resources necessary who communicated directly with the end customers on
for the implementation and follow-up of the daily basis (Sales, Customer Care) went through an
Environmental Management System, which shall include improvement program, which also encompassed the
the employees, the technologies and the financial majority of field workers who, as a part of their working
sources. The Management Board shall also establish the tasks, were in direct contact with customers. These
general objectives of environmental protection. efforts will certainly result in a higher level of customer
The directors of departments shall be responsible for the satisfaction. In order to achieve and maintain a high level
implementation and maintenance of the Environmental of ecological awareness among its employees, T-Mobile
Management System, for implementation of the general constantly conducts internal trainings. New employees
and individual objectives, for implementation of work are trained on how to implement environmental protec-
control, for supervision of processes related to significant tion, whilst all other employees participate in periodical
environmental aspects, for employees training process, additional trainings. Aware of its responsibility for the
for cost monitoring regarding environmental protection maintenance and improvement of its position in the mar-
and for a whole range of additional procedures which ket for a longer period of time, T-HT, in line with the val-
shall be described in more detail in the Manual and asso- ues it promotes and supports, provided support to its
ciated procedures. employees regarding the acquisition of practical techni-
The Management Board appointed the working group for cal knowledge at a global level.
construction, maintenance, documentation and improve-
ment of the Environmental Management System. The
Management Board also appointed an environmental
manager. The environmental manager shall also be the
working group leader and shall coordinate the activities
Donations The table below shows the capacities of and the real-
ized traffic in the T-HT Internet network in 2004:
By combining telecommunications and environmental
protection, two inseparable components of its business, Total number of mobile subscribers (in 000) 1.533,8
T-HT enabled the high school students on the island of Number of prepaid customers, T-Mobile 1.233,6
KorËula to participate in the UN videoconference on the Number of postpaid customers, T-Mobile 293,4
World Environmental Protection Day on 05 June 2004. Number of NMT customers, T-Mobile 6,9
Market share, T-Mobile (%) 53,7*
T-HT was the main partner to the non-profit organization
Mobile network penetration (%) 64,4*
“Dupinov san” in the implementation of the project MOU (minutes of use per average subscriber) 1.864
“Green 2004”, the goal of which was to actively promote ARPU (average revenue per user) in HRK 157,5
social awareness about preservation of natural values of * Vip results estimated for October - December
the Adriatic coast. That action raised funds for the plant-
ing of 10,000 olive seedlings and 15,000 pine and cypress
seedlings along the Croatian coast. With a desire to par-
Main financial indicators
ticipate in the protection of the environment and the liv-
ing world around us in a more engaged and efficient man- Revenue per business segments (in mil. HRK) in 2004
ner, T-Mobile has supported a number of ecological proj- Fixed network revenue 4.148
ects by providing considerable funds and conducting Carrier operations revenue 514
activities. Data services revenue 247
Internet services revenue 300
Mobile network revenue 2.909
Total revenue 8.118
Other revenue 231
Main network indicators Total core-business revenue 8.349
Total core-business expenditures 6.238
The main indicators of the status of the fixed telecommu- Staff expenditures 1.595
nications network capacity owned by T-HT at the end of EBITDA 3.522
2004 as well as of the traffic realized in the said network Added value (EBITDA + staff expenditures) 5.117
Core-business profit (EBIT) (in mil. HRK) 2.111
in the same year are shown in the following table:
Profit from regular activities before taxation 2.406
Profit of the financial year (in mil. HRK) 1.924
Total number of lines in the fixed network (in 000) 1.676,5
Comment: Financial data from the T-HT Annual Report 2004
POTS (including FGSM) 1.549,2
ISDN 127,3
ADSL 24,3
Number of channels (including FGSM) 1.887,6
Network digitalization (%) 100 As to 31 December inclusive, the total consolidated
Fixed line penetration (%) 37,8 revenue from core business of the T-HT Group in 2004
Total traffic (in 000 minutes) 5.912.363 amounts to HRK 8,349 million. Consolidated profit
National calls 4.854.452 from core business was HRK 2,111 million and the prof-
Calls to national mobile networks 730.556
Calls to value added services 62.837
it of the financial year 2004 reached HRK 1,924 mil-
Calls to international fixed networks 185.662 lion.
Calls to international mobile networks 41.773 Consolidated revenue in 2004 reached HRK 8,118 mil-
Other traffic 37.083 lion, which was an increase of 3.5% in relation to 2003.
Revenues increased only in those parts of market
The table below shows the capacities of and the real- where, apart of T-HT, also competition was active.
ized traffic in the T-HT Internet network in 2004: Group revenue increased mostly thanks to the segment
of mobile communications and, to a lesser degree,
Dial-up users (in 000) 562,8 thanks to data and Internet services. Those business
Fixed line Internet access subscribers (in 000) 0,6 segments covered 42.6% of the total Company revenue.
VPN points (in 000) 0,1 The increase of revenue in the said segments compen-
ADSL users (in 000) 24,3 sated for the decrease of revenue in the fixed network
Dial-up Internet access penetration (%) 25,9
(-0.7%) and carrier operations (-27.3%)
Total number of on-line minutes for dial-up users 2.642.664
(in 000 minutes)
Legislative framework
Environmental management
1. Environmental management policy, with the HRN EN ISO 14001:1996 standard, an Environ-
2. Environmental aspects, mental Management System that identified and defined
3. Statutory and other requirements, goals related to environmental protection to be achieved
4. General and individual objectives, and the manner in which to achieve them. In the same
5. Environmental management program, year the system was certified by Cro Cert, authorized cer-
6. Structure and responsibilities, tification company. The ISO 14001 certificate shows that
7. Training, awareness and competence, T-Mobile Croatia is actively involved in environmental
8. Communication, protection, but it is also a proof that T-Mobile is systemi-
9. Environmental management system documentation, cally and dedicatedly committed to ecological issues. T-
10. Document management, Mobile continuously adjusts every part of its business to
11. Processes and activities management, the latest European and world ecological standards.
12. Emergency preparedness and response,
13. Monitoring and measurement,
14. Non-compliance, corrective and preventive actions,
15. Records,
16. Environmental management system audit,
17. Management Board review.
Compliance with the stated requirements asks for an
objective proof used to assess whether the Environmen-
tal Management System functions properly and in line
with the standard. The ISO 14001 standard can serve for
internal purposes to ensure to the organization and its
management certain security (verification of compliance
with statutory provisions), savings (reduced consump-
tion), or for external purposes as support to a publicly
declared policy regarding work on environmental protec-
tion and improvement of the Company's image. ISO
14001 is a standard, based on which the organization can
require an audit of its Environmental Management Sys-
tem by an independent certification body, which can
then guarantee compliance of the system with the requi-
rements of the standard by issuing an "ISO 14001 certifi-
cate". Certification is not required by the standard, but
many organizations opted for it since an independent
verification brings higher credibility. Daniel Gagnier, Pre-
sident of ISO/TC 207, said: “Business entities directed
towards the future must be committed to sustainability The Environmental Management System introduced in
as a strategic goal. It means to apply a good environmen- T-Mobile Croatia is based on the Environmental Manage-
tal management practice, without polluting and destroy- ment Policy, including defining of significant aspects and
ing the environment, to reduce waste and efficiently use impact on the environment in the area of the mobile com-
resources, by observing the concerns of buyers, sharehol- munications, constant analysis of the environmental
ders, employees, local community, legislator and the soci- aspects, permanent harmonization with the valid acts
ety as a whole in relation to the environment. ISO and subordinate legislation, undertaking of measures to
14001:2004 and ISO 14004:2004 provide a map for reach- reduce possible harmful impact on the environment, and
ing that strategic goal.” constant improvement and prevention of harmful
impacts on the environment.
To achieve these goals T-Mobile trains the management
Environmental Management System in
and the workers permanently with the purpose of their
T-Mobile skills and environmental protection consciousness,
In September 2002 T-Mobile Croatia introduced, in line implements the new ecologically acceptable technologies
modern and functional office premises, in the design and results in gases that contribute to the greenhouse effect,
construction of which special attention was paid to ener- and there is also a substantial risk in transport and stor-
gy savings in the use of the facility. A central surveillance age, considering the possibility of oil spillage resulting in
and management system was installed for the complete pollution of the ground and watercourses. The heating
thermal and technical equipment and installation: surve- fuels used by the T-HT Group are: highly combustible fuel
illance of heating and ventilation, air-conditioning, heat- oil and gas, or central heating for the district is used. The
ing stations, fault and status detection for all pumps, pre- T-HT Group does not use coal for heating, as this is the
ssure, sprinklers, elevator status, fire alarm, access con- heaviest polluter of all energy sources. From the aspect
trol, video-surveillance of the entire building, lighting ma- of CO2, SO2 and NO2 emission, fuel oil is contributing
nagement, status control of the electricity cabinets, etc. most to pollution.
also deteriorate the appearance of the local landscape. By dioxide (SO2) which contributes to the generation of win-
removing the overhead networks that are obsolete and ter smog and acid rain, and nitric oxides (NO and NO2)
were devastated during the war, and by construction of which contribute to the generation of summer smog and
underground access networks, T-HT is exerting a positive acid rains. The main sources of waste gas in T-HT are the
impact on the improvement of the appearance of the local car pool and the boiler rooms (stationary sources) used for
landscape. In its regular operation, T-HT is using facilities, heating of working premises. A part of the air emissions of
the number and total space of which has changed in time. the T-HT car pool, related to CO2 emission, has been calcu-
The Company is using its own facilities, leased facilities, lated on the basis of fuel consumption and factors for the
but also facilities that do not fall in either of these catego- individual fuel types (1 l Diesel = 2,62 kg CO2,
ries. Roughly, we are speaking about an area of 380 thou- 1 l Gasoline = 2,32 kg CO2 - Source: The 2004 Human
sand m2 of net developed space used for offices, sales Resources and Sustainability Report).
points, accommodation of equipment, warehouses, gara- Emission Units 2004. 2003.
ges and the like. Of this, 180 thousand m2 of space is Com- CO2 t 6.540 8.029
pany-owned. The Company is also using open spaces for CO2 per km g / km 190 265
warehouses and parking lots of approx. 240 thousand m2.
A significant reduction of CO2 emission can be noted,
which is the result of the renewal of the car pool and of
the reduction of the total fuel consumption in spite of the
Emissions and waste increase of mileage. On occasion of registration of its
Waste gas emission cars, T-HT is paying a special environmental fee for
Waste gas as a result of T-HT operations, which are emit- motor-driven vehicles which is, as prescribed by law,
ted into the air are: carbon dioxide (CO2) which con- payable to the Environmental Protection and Energy
tributes to the generation of the greenhouse effect, sulfur Efficiency Fund. Pursuant to legal regulations,
the emission of pollutants into the air from stationary ly disposal of old NMT handsets returned by the custo-
sources is being measured in regular time intervals at mers. In the Company, paper, glass, PET and cardboard
each outlet of the stationary emission source. Measure- containers are separated and collected, and then deliv-
ments are performed by authorized organizations, and ered for recycling or ecologically friendly disposal. At T-
reports are regularly sent to the County Offices for En- Mobile, quantities of collected paper are measured, while
vironmental Protection that are keeping the environmen- T-HT is measuring only the paper from old telephone dire-
tal emission inventory prescribed by law. The inventory ctories which has been collected in one turn and deliv-
data are the basis for payment of fees for emissions into ered for recycling. T-Mobile also disposes in an ecological-
the air by stationary sources. For the time being, the ly friendly way all electronic waste generated in internal
Environmental Protection and Energy Efficiency Fund is use - old mobile handsets, battery chargers and batteries
charging fees for SO2 and NO2 emissions. of mobile handsets, IT equipment (old computers, moni-
tors), as well as all used toners (taken over by an author-
Waste ized company which exchanges them for office supplies).
In general, waste puts a significant pressure on the envi-
ronment, impacting the quality of air, water and ground Waste quantity (excluding household waste) Unit 2004.
Collected paper t 320,9
to an extent that depends on the method of disposal Copper cable t 2.093,1
and/or recycling. The largest quantity of waste at T-HT is Tires t 30,6
generated in processes of improvement, renewal and re- Industrial waste t 1.108,2
construction of parts of the telecommunications network Rechargeable batteries and batteries t 85,1
Electronic parts t 15,2
and its regular maintenance, also when individual net-
Motor oils t 15,6
work platforms or technological units are put out of oper- Oiled packaging t 3,1
ation, when the dismantling of equipment generates spe- Other waste t 81,3
cific quantities of superfluous equipment or other materi- Toners (printer, telefax machine, ..) pcs. 279
al. A part of such equipment can be reused within T-HT Mobile handsets pcs. 2.620
Total quantity of waste t 3.753,1
(for original use or for spare parts) or sold, while part of
the obsolete, unnecessary or destroyed telecommunica-
Noise
tions equipment and other material assets is declared wa-
Noise does not have a palpable effect on the environ-
ste (mainly electric or electronic waste) which needs to be
ment, but due to its nature it does disturb living beings
handled in the appropriate way, for prevention of detri-
(humans and animals) that are exposed to it. Sources of
mental effects on the environment. Pursuant to the Waste
noise in the regular operation of T-HT can be motor vehi-
Act (Official Gazette 178/04), this waste is classified in a
cles and pieces of machinery within the T-HT car pool,
group of separate waste categories, since some of its parts
and air-conditioning systems. In the course of 2004 no
or components may contain substances which qualify it as
complaints were registered from citizens regarding noise
toxic waste. Waste management from the point of view of
caused by T-HT activities. By the renewal of the car pool
environmental protection is a process which has a signifi-
by procurement of vehicles that produce less noise, T-HT
cant impact on the environment, therefore this topic is
is reducing the overall level of emitted noise.
given special attention within the T-HT Group. The hierar-
chy of waste management is being observed, so that the 6.3.4. Non-ionizing electromagnetic radiation
primary target is to reduce generation of waste and reduc- Similar to noise, electromagnetic emissions are not pal-
tion of its toxic properties. If this is impossible, part of the pable. According to present knowledge, non-ionizing
waste is being reused as raw material (recycling), so that electromagnetic radiation poses neither a hazard for
only such waste that cannot reasonably be used will be humans nor does it represent an ecologic issue, although
disposed in a non-detrimental manner, in line with legal a certain level of concern is present in the public. The
regulations, and delivered to companies that are registe- current legal restrictions are based on the heat effect
red for such waste disposal. The Procurement and Logi- and take the principle of precaution into account.
stics Department has worked out a Waste Disposal Proce- Within the T-HT Group, T-Mobile Croatia has a license
dure within T-HT. During the year 2004, preparations we- for operation of a GSM system and provision of mobile
re performed for the shutdown of the analog NMT net- communications services, and it was also granted a
work of the first generation mobile communications sys- license for construction of a third generation network
tem. T-Mobile prepared a campaign of ecologically friend- (UMTS) and provision of respective services.
In Croatia, the Regulation on Protection from Electroma- forms of transport, while on the other hand, it means the
gnetic Fields, passed by the Ministry of Health, is in force use of hardware in form of terminal equipment and infra-
(Official Gazette 204/2003). All telecommunications structure that consumes energy and in the end, produces
equipment is subject to the provisions of the Regulations waste.
on Maximum Permittable Electromagnetic Fields for How can telecommunications promote sustainable devel -
Radio Equipment and Telecommunications Terminal opment of the society?
Equipment (Official Gazette 183/2004). The internation- The strong expansion of telecommunications services
al standard for limits of exposure to time-varying elec- and services based on Information Communication Tech-
tric, magnetic and electromagnetic fields (up to 300 GHz) nology (ICT) in the previous period, especially in the area
has been issued by the International Commission of Non- of Internet applications, has induced hopes that their wi-
Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP). These safety lim- de application will lead to reduced needs for natural re-
its have been accepted by the UN World Health sources (less transport - less consumption of fossil fuels,
Organization for the whole world, and as such they are less consumption of paper and the like). In reality, how-
applied by T-Mobile Croatia. However, compared to ever, it turned out differently. Their capacity to reduce
these standards, the Croatian Regulations are stricter by pressure on the environment was almost imperceptible,
2,5 times. The base stations of the T-Mobile GSM network while in some cases the impact was even reverse (the in-
have been developed, tested and put into operation in crease of orders per Internet caused in some cases an in-
line with the international standards and requirements. crease of physical transport of material goods, e.g.
T-Mobile gets certificates from its suppliers, proving that books). The telecommunications services by themselves
the bases stations comply to the ICNIRP safety require- neither promote sustainability nor are they well disposed
ments - and to a series of standards for product safety, to the environment. It all depends on how they are used.
electromagnetic compatibility and general technical reg- The study and investigation of the ecologic relevance of
ulations. Furthermore, all base stations are certified to telecommunications services produces results that prove
be compatible with a series of European and worldwide that they certainly can contribute to raising social effici-
standards (EN 60950, EN 60215, EN 50358, EN 301 489-1 ency in the use of natural resources. Below please find a
V1.4.1, EN 301 489-08 V1.1.1 and V1.2.1, EN 301 502); couple of examples of IT and TC services indicating how
the respective Certificates are issued by the Croatian and under what conditions they can have a favorable
Telecommunications Agency. All former studies on bio- effect on the environment. The examples are results of
medical effects of electromagnetic radiation in mobile studies conducted by DT in the year 1999 for some of
communications systems show that there are no health their services.
hazards for humans. T-Mobile, being a responsible teleco- Videoconference
mmunications company, supports and encourages com- Videoconference becomes ecologically rational for dis-
prehensive and detailed scientific research and monitors tances of 10 km between the participants, provided that
the investigations of a whole series of organizations, in- the railway is used for travel to the location of the meet-
dependent groups, expert teams and scientists on the im- ing. In the case of travel by car, this distance is halved. In
pact of electromagnetic radiation. Keeping updated on such context, videoconference may consume up to 25
these results, T-Mobile is contributing to a better under- times less energy than a business trip, which depends on
standing of the electromagnetic radiation issue. In addi- the distance between the participants and the means of
tion to independently performed measurements, T-Mobi- transport used for travel.
le also performs measurements in cooperation with com- e-commerce
panies authorized for measurement activities (authoriza- In the case of purchase of books via e-commerce, it beco-
tions issued by the Ministry of Health). mes evident that electronic ordering is ecologically supe-
rior to the conventional purchase in a bookstore. An im-
portant precondition is that the recipient is at home at
the moment of delivery, so that the postman/delivery
Products and services person does not have to repeat the delivery.
Telecommunications services are based on electronic da- Teleworking
ta transfer which, on one hand, has a favorable effect on Teleworking can also produce a significant relief for the
the environment due to the quantitative reduction of da- environment. An important prerequisite for a favorable
ta transferred in material form and the need for physical effect on the environment is that there is no "double
equipping" with computers, printers and the like in the into the society by electronic media will call for tremen-
worker's office, tele-center or home. Moreover, the tele- dous efforts. Even now there are more Internet users in
worker should live at a distance of approx. 20 km from every big city in Europe than in many developing coun-
the office, and he should use teleworking on at least tries. A reason for optimism is provided by the fact that,
three days a week. although these countries have only a small number of res-
Mobile telephony idential users with Internet access, public assess points
In rural areas, mobile telephony may support the eco- are being installed in villages with a very low price for
nomic growth of the local population. There are many the access. In the future, the assessment of Internet avail-
positive examples, e.g. from India or Bangladesh. ability in poor countries will no longer be based on the
These examples show possible contributions of the number of lines, but rather on the access availability to
telecommunications industry to the de-materialization, the population.The global expansion of telecommunica-
and therefore to a better sustainability in the society. tions networks will also be linked to a huge consumption
Nowadays, planners are more and more integrating of natural resources, especially of energy. In this aspect,
telecommunications services into the planning of future both the equipment manufacturers and the network
cities. But, admittedly there are many obstacles to such a operators are facing the challenge to use all their innova-
development scenario. One of the biggest challenges is to tion capacities in order to make the production and oper-
avoid the "digital gap", which means that the society may ation of the respective technologies as environment-
divided into two groups, one that has access to electronic friendly as possible. Both the manufacturing industry
media and is able to use them, and the other who has no and the telecommunications industry have made signifi-
access to the new media and, consequently, cannot use cant efforts to adjust their operation to the environment,
them. The integration of a large number of poor people bur these efforts must be even intensified in the future.
People in the industrial world are becoming more and reducing and controlling pollution. Therefore, to get an
more aware that natural resources cannot be exploited impartial insight into the environmental behavior of a
indefinitely. Even more important is the growing company, the environmental damage caused by the
awareness that quality of life is not increasing with the operations of the company must be put in relation to
quantity of consumed resources. It can also increase by the added value it has produced in this process.
a quality growth and sustainable management of Eco-efficiency is designed as a generic concept involv-
resources, and this is the exact point where intelligent ing four different variants depending on how the issue
and environment-friendly use of ICT-based services can is considered; if the focus is primarily on the highest
be of maximum use. possible production output, then the production value
by environmental impact unit can be monitored, or the
Eco-efficiency of the T-HT Group impact on the environment by production unit. If the
Simply monitoring environmental indicators in the con- primary goal is to improve environmental impact, then
text of ecological discussions focused on the topic of the costs by environmental improvement are moni-
sustainable development will not be sufficient, as they tored, or the cost-efficiency of environmental improve-
provide only little information on the performance of a ment. In principle, the definition of the company's eco-
company in the area of environmental protection. The efficiency is a ratio between two elements: the detri-
responsibility of the company lies in a sustainable mental environmental effect and the added value gen-
development strategy which is focused on meeting the erated by the company. The eco-efficiency is higher to
requirements of the current economic and technologi- the extent to which the generated added value is pro-
cal development, and at the same time preserving and portionally higher than the damage inflicted on the
using natural resources to a minimum extent, while environment, or to the extent to which the damage is
lower than the generated added value. A higher figure me) and for a reduction or, at least, retention of the
of this indicator indicates a better performance of the present energy consumption level.
company, or, respectively, a more positive impact on
the environment.
For the calculation of eco-efficiency indicators, the
value of the telecom operator's production and its
Units 2004. 2003.
impact on the environment needs to be assessed. In the Billed traffic minutes in mobile
mil. min 11.234 10.700
T-HT Group, and in a similar way in other telecommu- and fixed networks
nications operators, the best indication of the produc- Total traffic equiv. mil Gbit 38,1 35,1
Traffic eco-efficiency bit / J 83,0 78,2
tion value would be by means of the billed and collect-
Added value mil. HRK 5.117 4.864
ed telecommunications traffic, while the impact on the Financial eco-efficiency HRK / MJ 11,2 10,8
environment can best be seen through total energy con-
sumption.
Telecommunications traffic consists of all bits of infor-
mation transferred through the net and charged to the
customers (non-collected traffic receivables are not EBITDA: Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation
considered a part of the production value). Traffic is and Amortisation
measured in time units [billed minutes] and multiplied Added value: EBITDA + staff costs
with the frequency bandwidth or with the directly col-
lected traffic volume [bit] receivables. Minutes billed to
customers are converted into equivalent bits by appli- Note of the Corporate Reporting Department: EBITDA
cation of conversion factors: 64 kbits/s for PSTN, or and staff costs do not necessarily have to match the
13,6 kbits/s for GSM. ADSL traffic is billed by the real- reports sent to DT within the scope of regular reporting
ized traffic volume [Mbit/month]. Considering the vari- to DT (deviations of approx. ±2% allowed) due to the
ous tariff models and the complexity of the bill, the differences in reporting standards and structures.
average number of minutes per customer in the mobile
network is used in the calculation.
For the measurement of environmental impact with
telecommunications operators, the total consumed
energy, expressed in Joule [J], is applied. The total con-
sumed energy required for business operation of the
telecommunications operator (telecommunications net-
work, heating/air-conditioning, transport) is applied.
Therefore, the telecommunications operator's eco-effi-
ciency is calculated as financial added value (EBITDA
+ staff costs) per total energy consumption [HRK/MJ]
or as the total number of bits (production value) per
consumed energy [bit/J].
In the year 2004, the T-HT Group realized 11,2 HRK
per MJ of consumed energy (total energy excluding
vehicle energy), and the traffic volume was 83 bits per
J of consumed energy. This means that the financial
eco-efficiency has remained almost the same in com-
parison to the previous year, whereas the production
eco-efficiency shows a slight increase. The cause of this
increase is the increase of total traffic expressed in
equivalent Gbits due to increasing volume of ADSL
services. The T-HT Group will strive for further
improvement of its eco-efficiency, by means of
increased added value (transfer of higher traffic volu-
Sources:
Specific data and information taken over from:
Prepared by:
Ljubica AniËiÊ, B.Sc.
Miroslav Bijele, M.Sc. E.E.
Translated by:
Anamarija Vranjeπ VuËiniÊ, B.A.
Mladen ©ipek, B.A.
Publisher:
HT - Hrvatske telekomunikacije d.d.
Savska cesta 32, 10000 Zagreb
Network Strategy Department, Environmental Protection Section
Editor in chief: Milena ©upe; Graphic editor and designer: Dragan Majdov;
Language editor: Vesna Privrat; Print: Aeroba; Edition: 500 issues