ROLL NO: 32 DIVISION: A PURPOSE OF THE PROJECT Gravity dam on Narmada river near Navgam, Gujarat Purpose-hydroelectricity and irrigation Aim-irrigate more than 18000 sq.km most of it drought prone areas of Kutch and Saurashtra Total installed capacity - 1450 MW The project aims at supplying 3571 MLD of drinking water (2900 MLD for domestic consumption & 671 MLD for industrial consumption) to 8215 villages & 135 towns in Gujarat Aims to provide drinking water facilities to a population of about 13.71 lakh in 1107 villages & two town in Jallore & Barmer districts of Rajasthan. BENEFITS OF THE PROJECT Potential to feed as many as 20 million people, provide domestic and industrial water for about 30 million, employ about 1 million Provide valuable peak electric power in an area with high unmet power demand Dam’s spillway discharging capacity (30.7 lakh cusecs) would be 3rd highest in the world (indicates flood discharge of the river) With 1133 cumecs (40,000 cusecs) capacity at the head regulator and 532 km length, the Narmada Main Canal would be the largest irrigation canal in the world The project envisages irrigation to 17.92 lakh ha land of Gujarat covering 3360 villages of 62 talukas in 14 districts. BENEFITS CONTINUED… Tribal area in Maharashtra and the drought-prone areas in Rajasthan will also get irrigation benefits. The project will generate between 856 to 1007 million units per year of cheap and eco-friendly indigenous hydro power. The project will benefit areas like Bhal affected by high impact of saline soil water. Benefits to three sanctuaries. COMPANY BACKGROUND Narmada Control Authority (NCA) has been setup under the final orders and decision of the Narmada Water Disputes Tribunal (NWDT) The authority started functioning from 20th December, 1980 Secretary to the Govt. of India, Ministry of Water Resources- Chairman All expenses of the authority shall be borne by the State Governments of Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Maharashtra and Rajasthan in equal shares LOCATION OF THE PROJECT COST INCURRED DURING PROJECT Financial cost Projected cost: Rs. 6406.04 crores in 1986-87 Actual cost: Rs. 45673.86 crores ('Working Group on Water Resources for the 11th Five Year Plan') Can go up by Rs. 70000 crores by 2012
Human Displacement Cost
Project cost: Disbursement of land to affected families Monetary value - NIL Actual cost: Cash for Land suspended by NCA
Source: TISS report on Narmada dam
COST INCURRED DURING PROJECT Environmental Cost Non-reimbursable : 13000 hectares forest land and11000 hectares agricultural land submerged Loss of biological and acquatic diversity NAME TYPE CONDITION Teak Plant Declining Bamboo Plant Declining Anjan Plant (eaten by wild ass) Declining Mohua Plant Declining Tenu Plant Declining Salai Plant Declining Radermachera Plant Rare Spernadictyon Plant Rare Cochlospermum Plant Rare Blackbuck Bird Rare Wild Ass Mamal- Donkey-family Endangered (2000 in the world) Wolf Mammal (dog) Declining Houbara bustard Bird (Turkey-like) Declining Lesser florican Bird One of the 50 rarest in the world Desert lark Bird Declining Desert courser Bird Declining Indian gazelle Smallest Asiatic Antelope Declining Nevan Bird Declining Freshwater Crocodile Reptile Severely Declining Source: TISS report on Narmada dam Mahsa Freshwater fish Severely Declining RECOVERY OF PROJECT Promised to build 3200 dams along 1200 km Narmada river Irrigation Efficiency Project documents to be 60% Domestic water usage 2.35 million people in 8235 villages in 135 towns Power Efficiency 100 MW powerhouse at dam and 250 MW powerhouse at canal Tourism Facility Beneficiary Gujarat Govt OPPONENTS Adivasis- Bhils, Bhillais, Dhangar etc. Narmada Bachao Andolan -Medha Patkar , Baba Amte Supporters - Arundhati Roy, Aamir Khan, Ali Kazimi, Anand Patwardhan World Bank Narmada Water Disputes Tribunal(NWDT) Various Environment Saving NGOs, Independent bodies working for same. REVENUE Accoding to Lahiri, Chairman, Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam: daily revenue of 7 crore at Rs. 2 per unit 6 major dams and 20 medium dams are either ready or on the verge of completion. Revenue through the means of tourism - GoG Exact figures unknown but hydroelectricity will be major revenue generation means of the project CONCLUSION & RECOMMENDATIONS Strongly recommended that dam height should not be raised Sky rocketing costs of total project needs to be reviewed Rehabilitation to locals and tribal is a major concern. Loss due to high waterlogging and land undergoing dam water needs to be verified. Environmental damage is high and non reimbursable. Honest comparison of benefits v/s damage is essential THANKYOU