Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CURRENT
OPINION Female sexual pain disorders: dyspareunia and
vaginismus
Chiara Simonelli a, Stefano Eleuteri a, Filippo Petruccelli b, and
Roberta Rossi c
Purpose of review
To analyze literature on sexual pain disorders and to review and summarize the articles published
throughout 2013 which contribute to the current knowledge on this subject.
Recent findings
By age 40, 7.8% of women reported vulvar pain. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders,
fifth edition, has combined vaginismus and dyspareunia into the same diagnostic label. The research
reviewed in this article seems to differently point toward two conditions, focusing on different aspects both
on the etiological and on the treatment area. Higher levels of partner-perceived self-efficacy and lower
levels of partner catastrophizing were associated with less pain intensity in women with entry dyspareunia,
independent of women’s pain perception and self-efficacy. Alexithymia and fear were found to be
important etiological factors in vaginismus.
Summary
The present findings did not provide clear evidence in support of the superiority of any treatment and
highlight the need for randomized, placebo-controlled trials that compare treatments in the future. A lot of
work remained to be done to understand such a complex and multifaceted disturbance as genital sexual
pain, but the articles examined showed that we are slowly adding more knowledge on the etiological
cause and treatment models for such conditions.
Keywords
dyspareunia, sexual disorder, sexual pain, vaginismus
woman’s well-being. It can impact her mental and condition within the medical community [6 ],
physical health, relationships, ability to work this review could be important to gain a compre-
and more; additionally, women with provoked hensive understanding of this condition.
vestibulodynia (PVD) report significantly lower
levels of sexual functioning in comparison with
control women [3]. As most people in the general a
Sapienza, University of Rome, bUniversity of Cassino and Southern
population – and many healthcare professionals Lazio and cInstitute of Clinical Sexology, Rome, Italy
(HCPs) – are unaware of the severity and wide- Correspondence to Professor Chiara Simonelli, Sapienza, University
ranging effects of dyspareunia, affected women of Rome, Via Savoia 78, 00198 Rome, Italy. Fax: +39 06 85356118;
may have a difficult time obtaining support. A recent e-mail: chiara.simonelli@uniroma1.it
survey [4], for example, revealed that physicians are Curr Opin Psychiatry 2014, 27:406–412
moderately comfortable treating vulvodynia within DOI:10.1097/YCO.0000000000000098
0951-7367 ß 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins www.co-psychiatry.com 407
Sexual disorders
Women with dyspareunia reported more limi- Recent studies have focused on different etio-
& && &
ted sexual desire and lubrication and fewer positive logical factors for dyspareunia [15 ,16 ,17,18 ,
& && &&
penetration-related cognitions compared to the 19,20] and for vaginismus [1 ,21 ,22 ].
women with vaginismus; they also reported greater
sexual anxiety than the control group [13].
In general, several guidelines should be kept in Dyspareunia and vulvodynia
mind when assessing these conditions. HCPs should An association was found between dysmenorrhea
encourage their patients to begin by describing how and noncyclic pelvic pain, suggesting that men-
and when they noticed their pain developing, strual pain is an etiological factor in noncyclic pelvic
&
how it progressed and what their current set of pain [15 ].
symptoms looks like. Rating the severity on a scale Moreover, two important studies revealed that
from 0 (no pain at all) to 10 (worst pain ever felt) is aspects of sexual self-schema (negative self-image
useful for assessment as well as for treatment cognitions about vaginal penetration, negative
monitoring. It is also relevant to discern how the body image and negative genital self-image) are
patient has already tried to alleviate the pain. In associated with increased pain intensity, sexual dys-
&&
addition to ascertaining a woman’s current pain function and sexual distress [16 ,17].
&
profile, HCPs should establish what situations are Three Canadian studies [18 ,19,20] examined
most likely to cause pain. For all women with the role of partner-perceived self-efficacy and
vulvodynia, there might be certain external factors
that trigger the pain, such as stressors or mood. For Table 2. Physical conditions causing genital sexual pain
women with GVD, it is important to know whether
their pain is constant or fluctuating and when those Physical condition Effect on sexual pain
fluctuations are most likely to occur. For women
Endometriosis Predominant cause of deep dyspareunia.
with PVD, it is important to know whether their
Pelvic inflammatory Abdominal adhesions with chronic pain
pain is evoked by certain types of contact/penetra-
disease including deep dyspareunia.
tion (e.g., manual vs. phallic, intercourse position,
Estrogen deficiency Common cause of dyspareunia in
arousal/anxiety levels). Identifying such factors postmenopausal women due to
assists in selecting treatment options and goals that vulvovaginal atrophy.
target each woman’s particular pain profile. Pelvic organ prolapse, Do not seem to affect sexual function,
Although a woman’s self-reported symptoms and urinary incontinence but patients should be informed about
history are the most relevant source of such infor- potential deleterious impacts
mation, HCPs should take care to confirm their after surgery.
reports, whenever possible, either through medical Interstitial cystitis Commonly reported in patients with
records, performing their own physical examin- dyspareunia.
ation, or through third-party informants (e.g., a Female genital Aside from dyspareunia, other severe
mutilation adverse effects occur and for many
woman’s partner). In addition to identifying pain
women, lifelong suffering.
characteristics and history, it is important to isolate
Gynecological cancer Pelvic radiation and chemotherapy causes
other psychosocial factors that might exacerbate the therapy fibrosis and atrophy of the lower genital
pain. The identification of such factors could be tract, hampering lubrication and
ascertained during both clinical interviews and causing dyspareunia.
&
the administration of validated questionnaires [6 ]. Cancer chemotherapy Causes atrophy of the vaginal mucosa;
local estrogen therapy is cautioned in
women with breast cancer.
ETIOLOGY Graft vs. host reaction Reported adverse effect in the vagina after
The etiology of GPPD is multifaceted. Psychosocial, systemic immunosuppressive treatment.
cultural, sexual and biological factors can, inde- Malformations Vaginal septum, congenital abnormalities.
pendently or in combination, cause the establish- Hidradenitis Chronic scarring in severe cases.
&
ment and maintenance of GPPD [1 ]. No single suppurativa
etiology has been identified, and different women Uterine fibroid Pressure pain of the bladder and intestine,
mainly deep dyspareunia.
suffering from similar pain presentations will often
Irritable bowel Comorbid in women with localized
describe very different pain development patterns.
syndrome provoked vulvodynia.
Similarly, those describing parallel etiologies may
& Pelvic radiation Causes atrophy, agglutination, decreased
report very different pain presentation [6 ]. lubrication and dryness, superficial as
To provide an overview of the most common well as deep dyspareunia.
somatic disorders causing genital sexual pain see
&
Table 2. Adapted from [1 ].
partner catastrophizing in the experience of pain, is partly or completely absent. In contrast, the
sexual functioning and sexual satisfaction of cumulative percentage of alexithymic and border-
women with entry dyspareunia and with PVD. line scores in the control group was just 18%, sig-
Higher levels of partner-perceived self-efficacy and nificantly lower than in the patient group. In terms
lower levels of partner tragic attitude were associ- of relative risk, women suffering from vaginismus
ated with less pain intensity in women with entry thus have a 3.8 times higher probability of showing
dyspareunia, independent of women’s pain percep- alexithymia than healthy women. The subanalysis
&
tion and self-efficacy [18 ]. Rosen et al. [19], studying showed a significant difference between the groups
women with PVD, found that participant’s tragic for TAS-20 subscale F1 (difficulty identifying feel-
feeling and self-efficacy partially mediated the ings), F2 (difficulty in expressing feelings) and F3
association between higher participant-perceived (externally oriented thinking). Women with vagi-
solicitous responses and higher pain intensity. nismus essentially demonstrated poor cognitive-
Similarly, partner catastrophizing and self-efficacy emotional processing, which seemed to be indica-
partially mediated the association between higher tive of a tendency to somatization. This group also
partner-perceived solicitous responses and tended to have a concrete, logical cognitive think-
higher pain intensity in women with PVD. Solici- ing style not mediated by any reflective function.
tous partner responses may have opposing effects. However, there was no significant difference
On one hand, they can generate cognitions that between the groups in describing feelings, such as
the pain is uncontrollable and may lead to further joy or uneasiness, to others. Because of the high
avoidance of sexual activity: partner solicitousness incidence of alexithymia, it must thus be considered
may encourage avoidance of sexual intercourse as a risk factor in some patients affected with vagi-
and/or exacerbate vulvovaginal pain by increasing nismus, as this personality trait could exacerbate
catastrophizing and decreasing self-efficacy. On the and perpetuate this psychogenic sexual dysfunc-
other hand, solicitous responses may lead to greater tion.
&&
sexual satisfaction because women interpret these Melles et al. [22 ], supporting the importance of
responses as reflecting partner sensitivity and under- fear in vaginismus, found that women with such
standing of their pain, resulting in greater sexual dysfunction showed relatively stronger fear associ-
satisfaction. In contrast, women may interpret nega- ations with sexual stimuli at the subjective (delib-
tive partner responses as a lack of sensitivity to their erate) level but not at the more automatic level. The
pain, thereby creating a detrimental context for initial (automatic) appraisals are proposed to follow
sexual activity, resulting in lower sexual satisfaction. from the direct activation of simple associations in
Dyadic adjustment partially mediated the associ- memory, whereas the more deliberate appraisals are
ation between higher participant-perceived solici- assumed to be the result of more controlled, reflec-
tous responses and higher sexual satisfaction, and tive processes. Moreover, women with vaginismus
fully mediated the association between higher also showed less positive self-reported global affec-
participant-perceived negative responses and lower tive associations with sexual stimuli, whereas at the
sexual satisfaction. automatic level, they showed similarly positive
A third study [20] labelled male partner global affective associations with sexual stimuli as
responses to painful intercourse into three different women without vaginismus.
kinds of responses: solicitous (attention and sym- Vaginismus, in contrast to superficial vulvody-
pathy), negative (hostility and frustration) and nia, is probably best described as a phobic defense
facilitative (encouragement of adaptive coping). mechanism – perhaps often elicited by psychosex-
&
The findings suggest that facilitative male partner ual negative experiences [1 ].
responses may improve sexual functioning, whereas
solicitous and negative responses may be detrimen-
tal. IMPLICATIONS FOR TREATMENT
Literatures have been studied and different treat-
ment issues have been proposed for dyspareunia
Vaginismus & & & & & && && &
[1 ,2 ,6 ,18 ,23 ,24 ,25 ,26 ,27 ] and for vaginis-
&
0951-7367 ß 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins www.co-psychiatry.com 409
Sexual disorders
&
strategy [1 ]. Almost half of these women never seek cognitions or behaviors, have a difficult time
&
treatment [23 ], and more than 50% of them who emotionally and/or experience sexual and relation-
sought care with known healthcare access received ship difficulties. There are many different types of
&
no diagnosis [2 ]. psychotherapy that could be applied to vulvodynia,
&
Nguyen et al. [23 ] tried to investigate one although few have received rigorous research
of the possible causes that could lead women attention. In general, a flexible treatment approach
not to seek care for chronic vulvar pain: the per- that addresses both pain and sexuality issues
ceived stereotyping. The hypothesis was that should be applied, as each patient brings a unique
perceived stereotyping regarding vulvar pain pain profile, and may experience the impact of
&
sufferers, which may ultimately lead to stigma, the pain in varying ways [6 ].
could contribute to estrangement from healthcare The practice of mindfulness-based cognitive
providers. The results of the study do not suggest therapy has also garnered attention in the treatment
&&
that the perception of stereotyping from physicians of dyspareunia [25 ]. Techniques that help patients
or other people was the barrier to seeking care. In remain in the moment and find ways to tolerate and
fact, women who sought care were more likely to accept their pain have been growing in popularity.
have a poor perception of physicians’ stereotyping Such approaches also assist patients to become more
opinions. These findings suggest that other causes attuned to the factors that increase or decrease their
influencing the failure to seek care for chronic pain and encourage them to also attend to positive
vulvar pain should be investigated. events in their life and relationship. Finally, some
&&
A Canadian study [24 ] was carried out to assess patients would greatly benefit from sex or couples
changes over a 2-year period in pain, depressive therapy. Ideally, the therapy would target the
symptoms and sexual outcomes in women with pain in a collaborative manner. Such a practice
PVD and examine changes based on treatment(s) could involve improving communication, reducing
type. They took into consideration various types of feelings of guilt or shame and building positive
treatment (physical therapy, sex therapy/psycho- sexual encounters while managing pain. Partners
therapy, medical management, surgery, acupunc- can be instructed in assisting with mindfulness
ture, other, multiple, no treatment) finding that or distraction to cope with the pain. Elements of
all treatments except acupuncture, which showed couples therapy could be incorporated into indivi-
a minor efficacy, were associated with significantly dual therapy if the patient does not wish to have her
lower pain levels after 2 years, including the ‘no partner present at every session. Addressing dyadic
treatment’ group. factors early in the management course of entry
Considering that there appears to be a signifi- dyspareunia may improve the success of therapeutic
&
cant advance in pain over time without treatment, interventions [18 ].
it is imperative that randomized trials yield an There is limited evidence that antidepressants
improvement above and beyond what appears to and anticonvulsants are helpful for women with
& &
be the natural progression of PVD. Although pain vulvodynia [26 ,27 ]. Some have hypothesized that
reduction is an important goal in treatment of PVD, such medications might be more useful for women
once the pain is reduced, further treatment tailored with GVD as their pain is more constant, and others
to the individual or couple may be needed to suggest that further research is required to deter-
improve other aspects of quality of life. This may mine particular combinations of medical therapy to
be a way in which some of the treatments outper- treat specific pain presentations. If a patient has a
form the no treatment group, as the no treatment comorbid mood and/or anxiety disorder, the admin-
group did not progress significantly on any psycho- istration of appropriate medication may assist in
sexual measures, whereas other treatment groups reducing symptoms of those disorders, which might
did. in turn improve a patient’s pain experience. It is
A multimodal pain-driven management model optimal to offer pharmacotherapy in concert with
&
is recommended, although the treatment literature psychotherapy [6 ].
is still sparse. Treatment aims should be decided
upon collaboratively and may extend beyond pain
relief. Vaginismus
Psychotherapy can be used to target specific Psychotherapeutic techniques targeting phobias
cognitive, emotional, relational and behavioral can be adapted to situations that evoke such a fear
goals related to the experience of chronic pain. It response and avoidance in women with vaginismus
&
is of particular benefit as it is noninvasive and does [6 ]. Although there is currently no conclusive evi-
not cause unwanted side-effects. Psychotherapy dence on this area of debate, the reasonable
is recommended if patients report unwanted evidence that cognitive behavioral therapy may
2. Harlow BL, Kunitz CG, Nguyen RH, et al. Prevalence of symptoms consistent
alleviate or eliminate ‘vaginismus’ appears to & with a diagnosis of vulvodynia: population-based estimates from 2 geographic
support the relationship between vaginismus and regions. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2014; 210:40.e1 –40.e8.
A large study taking into consideration data from two different geographic regions
phobia. Fear of pain should be addressed as it can be in the US.
an important component of vaginismus. Further- 3. Smith KB, Pukall CF, Chamberlain SM. Sexual and relationship satisfaction
and vestibular pain sensitivity among women with provoked vestibulodynia.
more, screening for depression and anxiety is J Sex Med 2013; 10:2009–2023.
&
recommended [1 ]. Counselling could help explore 4. Phillips AM, Large E, Bird TM, et al. Vulvodynia in Arkansas: a survey of
Arkansas gynecologists’ practice experience and management of vulvar pain.
the alexithymic trait as part of an integrated J Ark Med Soc 2013; 109:206–208.
&&
treatment regime for vaginismus [21 ]. Exposure 5. Michetti PM, Silvaggi M, Fabrizi A, et al. Unconsummated marriage: can it still
be considered a consequence of vaginismus? Int J Impot Res 2014; 26:28–
therapy was found to be very effective in reducing 30.
symptoms of vaginismus and in amplifying the self- 6. Dargie E, Pukall C. Chronic genital pain. In: Kirana PS, Tripodi F, Reisman Y,
Porst H, editors. The EFS and ESSM syllabus of clinical sexology. Medix;
reported global positive affective associations with &
0951-7367 ß 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins www.co-psychiatry.com 411
Sexual disorders
24. Davis SN, Bergeron S, Binik YM, Lambert B. Women with provoked vesti- 27. Spoelstra SK, Borg C, Weijmar Schultz WCM. Anticonvulsant pharmacother-
&& bulodynia experience clinically significant reductions in pain regardless of & apy for generalized and localized vulvodynia: a critical review of the literature.
treatment: results from a 2-year follow-up study. J Sex Med 2013; 10:3080– J Psychosom Obstet Gynecol 2013; 34:133–138.
3087. An important review synthesizing data on anticonvulsant pharmacotherapy in the
An important study comparing results from different kind of treatments for treatment of vulvodynia.
vestibulodynia. 28. Ter Kuile MM, Melles R, de Groot HE, et al. Therapist-aided exposure for
& women with lifelong vaginismus: a randomized waiting-list control trial of
25. Rosenbaum TY. An integrated mindfulness-based approach to the treatment
efficacy. J Consult Clin Psychol 2013; 81:1127–1136.
&& of women with sexual pain and anxiety: promoting autonomy and mind/body
A study highlighting the effect of exposure therapy for vaginismus.
connection. Sex Relation Ther 2013; 28:20–28.
29. Ozdel O, Tumkaya S, Levent N, et al. Effects of sex therapy based on cognitive
A criticism on the treatment approach for women with sexual pain.
behavioral methods on sexual problems of women with vaginismus and their
26. Leo RJ, Dewani S. A systematic review of the utility of antidepressant spouses. Anadolu Psikiyatri Derg 2013; 14:129–135.
& pharmacotherapy in the treatment of vulvodynia pain. J Sex Med 2013; 30. Reissing ED, Armstrong HL, Allen C. Pelvic floor physical therapy for women
10:2497–2505. & with lifelong vaginismus: a retrospective chart review and interview study.
This is a systematic review on the utility of antidepressant pharmacotherapy in the J Sex Marital Ther 2013; 39:306–320.
treatment of vulvodynia. A preliminary study proposing pelvic floor physical therapy for vaginismus.