Professional Documents
Culture Documents
279-285
This brief research report presents findings from an investigation conducted in an academic writing class for college students
in a tertiary institution in the Philippines. It first describes the role of academic writing in the site of investigation and
proceeds with a description of actualizing principles of critical pedagogy in the classroom. Through the use of meaningful
texts and tasks that sensitizes the learners’ awareness on the use of language to counter existing discourses of dominance,
this research posits that adopting critical pedagogy in the ELT classroom can help students problematize issues imparted
by texts as it applies to the wider context of society.
In recent years, the influence of critical theory in applied resistance against hegemonic/ oppressive beliefs
linguistics and English language teaching (henceforth, ELT) and practices (Pennycook, 1994).
has prompted researchers and practitioners to unravel the • Language learning should be contextualized in
socio-political dimension of the profession. The impact of order to sensitize students’ awareness of socio-
critical scholarship in the field can be attributed to different political issues in society (Kumaravadivelu,
economic, social and cultural factors brought about by 2006).
globalization. As Pennycook (1994) and Phillipson (1992) • Language learning and teaching located within
emphasized, the profession cannot be simply viewed as a critical pedagogy recognizes the fact that
seemingly objective, ahistorical enterprise that promotes knowledge is amorphous and constantly challenged
language learning but rather is an active instrument in (Pennycook, 1999). Moreover, it helps students use
forwarding ideological, cultural and political values which their knowledge of language to recognize the plights
privilege certain groups. For instance, in the Philippine of marginalized groups in society.
context, English language education has been widely
criticized by its stratifying nature—privileging those who However, one problematic area for language teachers
can afford quality education—and disenfranchising those in observing critical pedagogy is its application in the
who cannot (Tupas, 2007). Due to the country’s volatile classroom. Akbari (2008) reiterated that though a critical
economic situation and problematic issues concerning dimension in ELT is necessary, the challenge among
education, the English language is considered as an teachers is actualizing critical language pedagogy given
important commodity that contributes to the success of the unique conditions practitioners face. Specifically,
an individual in society (Gonzalez, 1999; Sibayan, 2000). questions such as: how do I go about espousing critical
Given these realities, scholars advocating critical pedagogy pedagogy considering that I have a prescribed syllabus or
in applied linguistics and ELT posit important perspectives textbook to follow; otherwise, I will be reprimanded by my
for teachers: superior? Dialogue and collaboration between students and
teacher are important, yet I find it a struggle to even let my
• Language teaching should be geared towards students participate or make choices? How is resistance in
the development of counter discourses or means the classroom articulated and how can teachers encourage
to effectively appropriate language to articulate this without sacrificing provisions of the curriculum?
liberation. Because of their determination to prove their Fred used the text to set the distinction between the
boundless capabilities, they are slowly drifting away from expanding role of women in society. Using the phrases
what they are really good at, and that is being a loving “madwoman from the attic and madwoman in the attic”, he
full-time mom and wife. proceeded with claiming that Filipino women in the past
have become confined to limited and demeaning roles in the
family. Their dependence on men has made them objects
of oppressive action. For instance, the Philippine society’s
tolerance of men having several mistresses and even wives
is considered a norm in the country. On the other hand,
women’s infidelity is viewed by Philippine society as taboo,
making such beliefs a clear societal double standard imposed
against women. The open door suggests that women have
become free in terms of the activities they are now allowed
to join. However, despite the apparent freedom, Fred claims,
women are still considered as madwomen for their state of
suppressed emotions and actions.
One reality in the Philippines is the influence of the
politics of gender in society. In a hierarchical society, social
Figure 2. Poster essay by Michael. positions are accorded not only the basis of wealth and
social status but gender as well. Those who are in positions
of power legitimize dominant ideologies to keep them in
Second, some students have taken the interpretation of place. One the other hand, Orendain (2006) asserted that,
the text through the incorporation of literal and experiential
meaning. The work of Fred (Figure 3) depicted a worn out [T]hose who find themselves outside of this class can
open door showing several signs such as “DO NOT LEAVE only be subjected to its control in their day to day material
UNLOCKED” and “FEED TWICE DAILY”, “HELP”, struggle and in their submission to ideas or ways of
thinking which they neither have the time nor preparation
“FAMILY?”. Also, it can be noticed that there are several
to produce or resist (p. 19).
stick figures which represent the number of years the
Filipina woman had been confined with limitations due to
Unequal power relations are evident in gender
her role in the family and society. Fred noted,
segregation. This is seen when men are placed in better
paying jobs while women are assigned to “more insecure,
As the image of the 19th century Filipina was the
“madwoman in the attic,” it is then likely that our view temporary and typically lower waged positions” (Opondo
of them today should be different, albeit very similar; the et al., 2007, p.81). Traditionally, Philippine society has
“madwoman from the attic.” Why? Simply because they accorded the woman with domestic work (rearing for
enjoy more freedom today then they did previously, hence the children and maintaining the household). However,
the “attic”. But this does not mean that they are treated globalization has created a legitimized demand for cheap
equally, mark of the “madwoman. labor export. Filipinos, especially women, leave the country
every year to serve as domestic helpers for other more
powerful nations (Lindio-McGovern, 2003). Similar to
other developing nations, the country is a source of cheap
labor since the masses have very few job opportunities. Such
oppressive reality is more apparent among women because
given rise to a new set of domestic helpers-caregivers, sex compromised. Similar to insights forwarded by advocates
workers, and entertainers. of critical pedagogy, questioning texts does not only help
interrogate hidden assumptions made by writers but allows
Engagement through meaningful dialogue with the text students to critically examine unchallenged ideologies in
A constant theme in the literature concerning critical society (Kincheloe, 2008).
pedagogy is that engagement through meaningful dialogue Overall, the aforementioned observations may be
is important in order for students to continuously challenge considered as manifestations of a counter discourse that
beliefs traditionally upheld by society (Benesch, 2001; actualizes principles espoused by critical pedagogy.
Morgan, 2009). Pennycook (1989) highlighted the need for Specifically, critical pedagogy is realized through students’
teachers to present opportunities for students to critically constant reshaping of beliefs concerning social issues in
engage texts since knowledge production is a political the country. In this case, the students acknowledged that
enterprise. Therefore, in this context, students should oppression on the basis of gender is not only conditioned
not treat texts as dogma but constantly challenged. One by history but is driven by complex forces brought about
indication of problematizing texts is through generative by political, social and economic forces. Also, in keeping
themes where questions are drawn from the text providing with Pennycook’s (1994) assertion that counter discourses
space for constructive debate among students (Kincheloe, should help learners appropriate language skills in more
2008). socially conscious endeavors, the textual and non-textual
Kiko’s piece (Figure 4) did not only use a creative combination manifested in the poster essays provided
combination of adjectives (Bold, innovative, revolutionary, a creative means for students to articulate diverse
riveting, strong, new…) that reveals the empowerment of interpretations of a text. Given that the essay discussed in
women but also the limitless potential as active agents of class delves on a contemporary issue in Philippine society,
change. the poster essay provided an opportunity for learners to
express resistance to oppressive forces that continuously
marginalize women in society. More importantly, the
activity fostered critical pedagogy as it attempted to
maintain a “delicate balance between social change and
cultivating the intellect” (Kilencheloe, 2008, p. 11). In this
context, the poster essays represented a contextual space
which appreciates the diverse experiences and knowledge
that students bring into the classroom. Similar to Morgan’s
(2009) attempt to revitalize the essay in English for
academic purposes, the use of poster essays has become
an active tool for students to engage in social inquiry by
critically examining the social, historical, and cultural
influences of practices and beliefs apparent in society.
REFLECTIONS/ IMPLICATIONS
Figure 4. Kiko’s poster essay. This investigation has revealed that critical pedagogy
applied in the language classroom entails an avoidance
of offering simple critiques resulting “better or alternate
However, skepticism is apparent in Kiko’s explanation. explanations” of existing conditions of Filipino women.
Rather, students through the use of poster essays have
[T]imes have changed, but the Filipina hasn’t failed to
engaged in a meaningful form of critical social inquiry
keep up with the changes as well. Rather, she overcame
her own limits set by the prejudice of others, and proved that carefully examines the intricacies of gender politics
to the world that we should never be biased to any gender. richly embedded in economic, social, and cultural tensions.
Liberated as she may seem, she is only oppressed by her As the world becomes more complex due to the impact of
own trials: is the price of all this effort leave her with no globalization and technology, educational institutions should
self-fulfillment, and with no self-actualization? not only prepare students for the demands of the real world
but should instill a conscious critical stance, prompting
Inferring from the aforementioned interpretation, it is them to be catalysts of change. Moreover, the poster essay
probably safe to say that Kiko believes that the liberation represents a combination of multiliteracies brought about
of women is a constant struggle. Moreover, it can also be by multimodal technologies (Morgan, 2009), rich histories,
inferred that Kiko saw that the empowerment of women struggles, and politics (Pennycook, 1994) which all help
should be taken with caution as certain values may be students shape their understanding of how society shapes
284 THE ASIA-PACIFIC EDUCATION RESEARCHER VOL. 21 NO. 2
texts. However, like other critical investigations such Kincheloe, J. (2008). Critical pedagogy primer (2nd ed.). Frankfurt,
as this, a reflexive stance should be considered. Though Germany: Peter Lang Publishing.
the implementation of the poster essay here accounts for Kumaravadivelu, B. (2006). Understanding language teaching:
the application of a critical orientation in the classroom, From method to post-method. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
Associates.
can other important classroom documents such as the
Lindio-McGovern, L. (2003). Labor export in the context of
syllabus, writing requirements (essays, written exercises) globalization: The experience of Filipino domestic helpers in
and tests serve as counter discourses as well? Considering Rome. International Sociology, 18(3), 513-534.
that industries in the Philippines greatly influence the Morgan, B. (2009). Revitalizing the essay in an English for
kind of training given in schools, do critical practices academic purposes course: Critical engagement, multiliteracies
such as these have any purpose at all since workplaces and the internet. International Journal of Bilingualism and
demand compliance, docility and non-resistance? As Bilingual Education, 12(3), 309-324.
Auerbach (1991) emphasized, inequality in society can Opondo, M., Dolan, C., Wendoh, S., & Kathuri, J. (2007). Gender
always be traced back on how schools reproduce these and employment: Participatory social editing in Kenya.
In S. Kindon, R. Pain, & M. Kesby (Eds.), Participatory
unequal structures. Therefore, it is important for teachers
action research approaches and methods: Connecting
and students to continue critically examining social issues people, participation, and place (pp. 80-87). New York, NY:
through projects that draw diverse understandings of these Routledge.
issues to genuinely create possibilities. Orendain, M. (2006). Using critical thinking to foreground class
and gender. ACELT Journal, 10(2), 10-23.
Pegiña, J. (2009). Portrait of the 21st century Filipina. Cavite,
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Philippines: Kamalayan Publishing.
Pennycook, A. (1989). The concept of method, interested
knowledge and the politics of language teaching. TESOL
I am indebted to Topsie Ruanni Tupas (National Quarterly, 23, 589-618.
University of Singapore) and Brian Morgan (Glendon Pennycook, A. (1994). Cultural politics of English as an
College, York University) for insightful discussions international language. London and White Plains, NY:
concerning the complexities of doing critical pedagogy in Longman.
the ELT classroom. The usual proviso applies. Pennycook, A. (1999). Critical approaches to TESOL. TESOL
Quarterly, 33, 329-348.
Phillipson, R. (1992). Linguistic imperialism. Oxford, UK: Oxford
REFERENCES
University Press.
Richards, J. (2005). Communicative language teaching today.
Akbari, R. (2008). Transforming lives: Introducing critical
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
pedagogy in ELT classrooms. ELT Journal, 62(3), 276-283.
Sibayan, B. (2000). Resulting patterns of sociolinguistic,
Auerbach, E. (1991). Politics, pedagogy and professionalism:
socioeconomic and cultural practice and behavior after more
Challenging marginalization in ESL. College ESL, 1 (1),1-9.
than four hundred years of language policy and practice in
Benesch, S. (1996). Needs analysis and curriculum development
the Philippines. In M.L. Bautista, T. Llamzon, & B. Sibayan
in EAP. An example of a critical approach. TESOL Quarterly,
(Eds.), Parangal cang Brother Andrew: Festschrift for Bro.
30 (4), 723-738.
Andrew Gonzalez on his 60th birthday (pp. 247-262). Manila:
Benesch, S. (1999). Right analysis: Studying power relations in an
Linguistic Society of the Philippines.
academic setting. English for Specific Purposes, 18, 313-327.
Tupas, T.R.F. (2007) Back to class: The ideological structure of
Benesch, S. (2001). Critical English for academic purposes:
the medium of instruction debate in the Philippines. In T.R.F.
Theory, politics and practice. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
Tupas (Ed.), (Re)making society: The politics of language,
Associates.
discourse and identity in the Philippines (pp. 61-84). Quezon
Canagarajah, S. (1993). Critical ethnography of a Sri Lankan
City: University of the Philippines Press.
classroom: Ambiguities in student opposition to reproduction
Vilches, M. L. (2007). Teaching meaning in the English classroom.
in ESOL. TESOL Quarterly, 27, 601-626.
In W. Mei, T.R.F. Tupas, C. Moh Leen, M.L. Sadorra, & C.
Del Rosario, T. (2005). Bridal diaspora: Migration and marriage
Varasprad (Eds.), The English language teaching and learning
among Filipino Women. Indian Journal of Gender Studies,
landscape: Continuity, innovation and diversity (pp. 33-48).
12 (2-3), 253-273.
Singapore: CELC, National University of Singapore.
Gonzalez, A. (1999) Philippine bilingual education revisited. In
M.L. Bautista & G. Chan (Eds.), The Filipino bilingual: A
multidisciplinary perspective: Festschrift in honor of Emy
Pascasio (pp. 11-18). Manila: Linguistic Society of the
Philippines.
CRITICAL ENGLISH LANGUAGE TEACHING VALDEZ, P.N. 285
APPENDIX A
APPENDIX B
Every Filipina woman is an endless source of endless possibility. Her person embraces the role of responsible daughter,
steadfast sister, generous aunt, an indifferent employee, a consistent ex-lover, a bill settler, a person who knows exactly to
uncomplicated matters for each member of the family; yet, she knows not to identify what she has long wanted for herself.
She may have won the battle against men for equal opportunity; but, she has lost and forgotten the sprit that drove her to
win the battle. She can hardly recognize herself, perhaps, who she had been, as an individual who once had an underrated
self-image. But declining economy remains clear to her. Now, her true objective in her display of deliberate obsession to fare
in the formerly man’s world then needs disambiguation. Did she fight for self-actualization because she wanted to pursue
a career in the field of her choice, or, did she fight for the inadequacies of men in her family that cripple its function? Her
present actions seemingly prove her presence for the latter. Perhaps she thinks of herself as messiah, and uses the same
strength and freedom that she has acquired from her battle for equality to save and rescue her family. She has become
indifferent to her needs again-caged, caged in her pretense. She flaunts her strength, her talents, her unwavering confidence
of herself; she uses her resources and takes responsibility of her family; she exercises her freedom to penetrate fields she can
be good at; she works hard for others and forgets about her own self, again. She has turned into an unimaginably powerful
person, who does everything she can possibly think of and defies anyone who challenges her otherwise. She is the spirit
who overshadows even the real person within herself. She has enough compassion for her family; yet, she has not left any
for herself.
Thus she no longer portrays the madwoman in the attic2 since she has finally acknowledged her worth as an individual.
She is now instead the image of the 21st century Filipina, in authentic human flesh and disguised as Overseas Filipino
Worker (OFW), executive in the industry, public official, or in occupation/field where she receives compensation used to
be atypical to and denied of the formerly home-maker, domesticated wife, fragile daughter, the second-class citizen, the
inferior sex: The madwoman from the attic.
1 Taken from the Portrait of the 21st Century Filipina. Cavite: Kamalayan Publishing, Reprinted with permission from the author.
2 A term in feminist criticism from Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar