Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: To better understand the dynamic properties of expansive clay treated with lime, a series of laboratory tests were
conducted using a dynamic triaxial test system. The influential factors, including moisture content, confining pressure,
vibration frequency, consolidation ratio, and cycle number on the dynamic characteristics were discussed. Experimental
results indicate that specimens at low moisture contents tend to damage along the 30 shear plane and they present brittle
failure, while saturated specimens show swelling phenomenon and plastic failure. A reduction in cohesion has been observed
for unsaturated samples at large number of cycles, while it is opposite for the internal friction angle. For the saturated
specimens, both the cohesion and internal friction angle decrease with increasing number of cycles.
Key words: expansive soil; lime-treated soil; dynamic characteristics; low lime proportion
20 °C only CAH was formed. Higher temperature Quantitative analysis by thermal method indicates that
accelerates the pozzolanic reaction, resulting in a rapid the lime contains 72.54% CaO and 1.06% MgO.
soil strength development. In addition, many 2.2 Samples preparation
researchers have also examined the static strength Kong et al. (2010) reported that the optimum lime
characteristics. It was found that the shear strengths proportion was 3% through laboratory tests. Given the
were improved significantly after lime stabilization, high heterogeneity for lime mixing in the construction
and lime-treated expansive soil could maintain a site, a lime consumption of 1% is adopted to simulate
higher stable strength, even under the saturated the field condition. In order to determine the
condition (Guo et al., 2007; Kong et al., 2010). A controlling indices of samples of lime-treated
number of experiments were carried out to evaluate expansive soils, compaction tests were carried out
the influence of lime treatment on the microstructure according to Test Methods of Soils for Highway
and subsequently on the hydraulic conductivity of Engineering (JTG E40—2007), China. The controlling
compacted silt (Ranganatham, 1961; Nalbantoglu and indices of samples of lime-treated expansive soil are
Tuncer, 2001). The most common finding was that soil given in Table 3.
treatment led to an increase in hydraulic conductivity The soil and lime were mixed in dry state to obtain
of soils (from highly expansive clays to low plasticity a uniform distribution, and then distilled water was
silts; Cuisinier et al., 2011). Rao et al. (2001), Guney added until reaching the optimum water content. The
et al. (2007), and Cuisinier and Deneele (2008) soil-lime-water mixture was thoroughly kneaded by
observed that the swelling potential of lime-stabilized hand until it was homogeneous. After mixing,
soil increased when it was subjected to wetting-drying specimens were tightly encased in a hermetic plastic
cycle. The clay content of the cyclic samples increased, bag and stored at room temperature for 24 hours for
which in turn affected the liquid limit, plastic limit, moisture homogenization.
shrinkage limit and swelling potential. Au and Chae To gain a required dry density, the mixture was
(1980) and Akoto and Singh (1986) carried out compacted in a special cylindrical mold (100 mm long,
column resonant tests and dynamic triaxial tests 50 mm in diameter) in a special mold. In order to
respectively to study the influence of water content,
obtain homogeneous soil samples, the samples were
curing time and lime proportion on dynamic elastic
prepared by compaction in 5 layers. After that, the
modulus.
compacted soil samples were immediately sealed with
Up to now, few studies have been systemically
plastic film and then put into moisturizing devices to
reported to the dynamic properties of lime-treated
minimize water loss. All samples were cured for 28
expansive clay. However, it is imperative to better
days.
understand the dynamic properties of lime-treated soil
due to the boom of high-speed railways. In this study,
a series of laboratory tests were conducted to 3 Dynamic triaxial tests
understand the influences of different factors, such as
water content, confining pressure, vibration frequency, In this study, traffic load was simplified as
consolidation ratio and cycle number, on the dynamic sinusoidal load. This test was performed as a
characteristics of clayey soils. consolidated undrained triaxial one, where the cyclic
loading was removed when the maximum dynamic
2 Preparation of the samples strain reached 5%.
In order to identify the influence of different factors
2.1 Soil and lime on dynamic modulus, damping ratio, etc., three water
The soil adopted in the study is Jingmen expansive contents (w), 25.2% (saturated), 19% and 17%, were
clay sampled in Hubei Province, China. Table 1 gives adopted. The vibration frequency (f ) was 3, 5 and 9
the mineral compositions and particle components of Hz, respectively. The main consolidation ratio (Kc)
the soil sample. It is composed of clay minerals (80%), was 2. Confining pressure (3) varied from 25 to 100
like illite (35%), kaolinite (40%), smectite-illite kPa. Experimental scheme of dynamic modulus (Ed)
mixture (5%), and non-clay mineral like quartz (20%). and damping ratio () are given in Table 4.
Physical properties of the tested soil are given in Table 2. In the tests of dynamic strength, the parameters
354 Min Wang et al. / J Rock Mech Geotech Eng. 2012, 4 (4): 352–359
considered are as follows: (1) three water contents: confining pressures: 100, 150 and 200 kPa. The
25.2% (saturated), 19% and 17%; (2) vibration experimental scheme of dynamic strength is given in
frequency: 3 Hz; (3) consolidation ratio: 1.5; and (4) Table 5.
25 20–50
25.2 50 3, 5, 9 20–100
100 20–200
25 20–50
2 19 50 3, 5, 9 20–100
100 20–200
25 20–50
17 50 3, 5, 9 20–100
100 20–200
100
25.2 150
200
150
19 200 1.5 3
250
150
17 200
250
Min Wang et al. / J Rock Mech Geotech Eng. 2012, 4 (4): 352–359 355
160
d 0
d (2) 0.000 0.002 0.004 0.006 0.008
1 / Edmax d / dmax Dynamic strain d
(b) w=25.2%, f=9 Hz, Kc=2.
where Edmax and dmax are the maximum axial
dynamic modulus and stress, respectively.
Dynamic modulus Ed (MPa)
200
Assuming that a 1 / Edmax and b 1 / dmax , ω=17%
Eq. (2) can be rewritten as 150 ω=19%
ω=25.2%
d d / (a b d ) (3) 100
1 / Ed a b d (4) 0
0.000 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004
Thus Edmax can be determined through the curve of Dynamic strain d
140
120 Kc =2, f=3 Hz
Dynamic modulus
Damping ratio λ
0.08
20
0 0.06
0 100 200 300 400 500 0.04
Cycle number
0.02
(a) w=25.2%,3=150 kPa, Kc=1.5, f=3 Hz, d=60 kPa.
0.00
0.000 0.002 0.004 0.006 0.008
0.30
Dynamic strain d
0.28
0.26
Damping ratio λ
Damping ratio λ
0.16
0.14 0.10
0.12 0.08
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 0.06 3 = 50 kPa
Cycle number 0.04 3 = 100 kPa
0.02 3 = 200 kPa
(b) w=25.2%, 3=100 kPa, Kc=2, f=3 Hz, d=56 kPa.
0.00
Fig. 2 Cycle number-dynamic modulus curves and cycle 0.000 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 0.005
number-damping ratio curves. Dynamic strain d
(b) w=25.2%, f=9 Hz, Kc=2.
ω=25.2%
growth of normal stress, thus the shear strength is 0.16 ω=19%
elevated. 0.14 ω=17%
Damping ratio λ
0.12
(3) A high vibration frequency implies a high 0.10
loading speed. As the stress-strain behavior is 0.08
0.06
time-dependent, there is no enough response time for 0.04
0.02
each cycle under high vibration, which leads to an 0.00
elevated strength. 0.000 0.002 0.004 0.006 0.008
Dynamic strain d
(4) The increase of consolidation ratio strengthens (c) 3=50 kPa, Kc=2, f = 5 Hz.
the compaction ratio, and thus bearing capacity is
Fig. 3 The dynamic damping ratio-strain curves.
enhanced.
4.2 The dynamic damping ratio-strain curves
samples gradually become loose under the action of
Damping corresponds to all kinds of frictions or
shear stress, therefore rubbing effect grows and it
other actions that gradually reduce the degree of free
consumes more energy. Subsequently, damping ratio
oscillation and vibration in engineering. Damping
grows with dynamic strain. However, the rise of water
ratio, one of the parameters to represent the content accelerates the loose effect caused by shear
hysteretic effect under dynamic load, reflects the stress. Thanks to the increase in consolidation ratio
hysteresis loops in the relationship of dynamic and confining pressure, the energy loss rises when the
stress-strain curves. same strain is reached.
The result of Fig. 2(b) reveals that for saturated 4.3 The dynamic strength
samples, damping ratio increases thanks to the growth Dynamic strength of soil is the dynamic stress under
of number of cycles, when d 56 kPa. Damping which the failure strain can be obtained under an
ratio rises with the deformation. In Fig. 3, it can be appointed number of cycles. The damage criterion for
found that, with the growth of vibration frequency and dynamic strength of clay is commonly expressed in
water content, the damping ratio gradually decreases. the form of deformation. K0 consolidated drained tests
When other factors are constant, damping ratio adopt double-amplitude strain of 5% as the terminal
increases with increasing consolidation ratio and condition, while in the anisotropically consolidated
confining pressure. tests, it is the total strain of 10% that is considered.
The corresponding mechanism can be described as According to the Code for Measurement Method of
follows: with the development of dynamic strain, soil Dynamic Properties of Subsoil (GB/T50269 — 97),
Min Wang et al. / J Rock Mech Geotech Eng. 2012, 4 (4): 352–359 357
200
100
y = 0.167 9x + 44.5
100 gradually and then reaches a leveling-off with the rise
50 of vibration number.
0 (2) With the growth of vibration frequency and
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
(kPa) water content, damping ratio decreases gradually.
(b) w=19%. When other factors are constant, damping ratio
150 increasing with increase of consolidation ratio,
confining pressure, and vibration number.
100
(3) It is evident that consolidation ratio has a strong
(kPa)
y = 0.124 2x + 12.3
50 impact on the dynamic properties of lime-treated
clayey soil, and it plays a decisive role. In addition,
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 specimens with low water content present brittle
(kPa) failure, while saturated specimens show plastic failure.
(c) w =25.2%. (4) A reduction in the cohesion of unsaturated
Fig. 6 Dynamic strength envelope curves (failure vibration samples was observed at elevated failure vibration
number is 1 000). number, while it is opposite for the internal friction
angle. As far as saturated specimens are concerned,
Table 8 Dynamic strength parameters of soil. both the cohesion and internal friction angle decrease
Failure vibration
due to the growth of vibration number.
Water content (%) cd (kPa) d ()
number
1996, 42 (4): 223–237. Hardin B O, Drnevich V P. Shear Modulus and damping in soils: design
Clare K E, Cruchley A E. Laboratory experiments in the stabilization of equations and curves. Journal of the Soil Mechanics and Foundation
clays with hydrate lime. Geotechnique, 1957, 7 (2): 97–111. Division, ASCE, 1972, 98 (SM7): 667–692.
Cuisinier O, Deneele D. Long-term behaviour of lime-treated expansive soil Hilt G H, Davidson D T. Lime fixation in clayey soils. Highway Research
submitted to cyclic wetting and drying. In: Unsaturated Soils: Advances Board Bulletin, 1960, 262: 20–32.
in Geo-engineering. Durham, United Kingdom: Taylor and Francis, Kong Lingwei, Zhou Baochun, Bai Hao, Chen Wei. Experimental study of
2008: 327–333. deformation and strength characteristics of Jingmen unsaturated
Cuisinier O, Auriol J C, Tangi L B, Dimitri D. Microstructure and hydraulic expansive soil. Rock and Soil Mechanics, 2010, 31 (10): 3 036–3 042
conductivity of a compacted lime-treated soil. Engineering Geology, (in Chinese).
2011, 123 (3): 187–193. Nalbantoglu Z, Tuncer E R. Compressibility and hydraulic conductivity of a
Diamond S, Kinter E B. Mechanisms of soil-lime stabilization. Highway chemically treated expansive clay. Canadian Geotechnical Journal,
Research Record, 1965, 92: 83–102.
2001, 38 (1): 154–160.
Eades J L, Grim R E. A quick test to determine lime requirements for soil
Rajasekaran G, Rao S N. The microstructure of lime-stabilization marine
stabilization. Highway Research Record, 1966, 139: 61–72.
clay. Ocean Engineering, 1997, 24 (9): 867–878.
Glenn G R, Handy R L. Lime-clay mineral reaction products. Highway
Ranganatham B. Soil structure and consolidation characteristics of black
Research Record, 1963, 29: 70–82.
cotton clay. Geotechnique, 1961, 11 (4): 331–338.
Guney Y, Sari D, Cetin M, Tuncan M. Impact of cyclic wetting-drying on
Rao S M, Reddy B V V, Muttharam M. The impact of cyclic wetting and
swelling behavior of lime-stabilized soil. Building and Environment,
2007, 42 (2): 681–688. drying on the swelling behaviour of stabilized expansive soils.
Guo Aiguo, Kong Lingwei, Hu Mingjian, Guo Gang, Wang Qing. On Engineering Geology, 2001, 60 (1/4): 223–233.
determination of optimum water content of lime-treated expansive soil. Tuncer E R, Basma A A. Strength and stress-strain characteristics of a
Rock and Soil Mechanics, 2007, 28 (3): 517–521 (in Chinese). lime-treated cohesive soil. Transportation Record, 1991, 1 295: 70–79.
Min Wang, Ph.D. candidate in the University of Birmingham, UK, obtained his B.S. degree in Civil Engineering
from China University of Mining and Technology in Jiangsu Province, China, in 2009 and his M.S. in Disaster
Prevention and Mitigation Engineering (Civil Engineering) from Institute of Rock and Soil Mechanics, Chinese
Academy of Sciences, Wuhan, China, in 2012.
His research interests include engineering characteristics of expansive soil and disaster prevention, DEM modeling,
soil dynamics and interaction of pile-soil in liquefiable soil under earthquake events.
Up to now, he has taken part in various research programs, including “Effect of moisture migration rate on
engineering characteristics of expansive soil and instability mechanics of cut slope” (National Natural Science
Foundation of China, No. 10872210); “Mechanical response and subgrade stability of lime-treated expansive soil
under traffic loading” (National Natural Science Foundation of China, No. 40772185) and “Mechanical response and
disaster mechanism of fissured subgrade under high-speed traffic loading” (Knowledge Innovation Program of Chinese
Academy of Sciences, No. kzcx2-yw-150).