Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 Critical Comment
2 Critical Comment
ID: 595245
Critical comment
For many teachers the communication is the best option to students learn a second language
for that reason the article “Communicative language teaching (CLT), Role of grammar and
teacher’s believes” by Muhammad Yousaf, Hazrat Umar and Azhar Habib is very useful for
English teachers in training, it is also interesting because the authors give the importance of
how some teachers think that students learn a second language in the best way and the role of
activities in order to create communication. In the same order, students create a conversation
during classes, but is necessary to consider other aspects as environment, context, topics,
concentration and performance outside the classroom with the reason of having a good fluency
and accuracy.
The main points of this article are about different teachers thoughts about what is the best
way to teach a second language, in this case English. Nevertheless, to teach English is necessary
that students practice the language and one possibility to practice the language is through
language learners, in other words, students have the fluency and accuracy at the moment to
speak with daily things, also to engage with possibilities of negotiation of meaning, while
teachers accept some mistakes, notwithstanding in the process to acquire the English language,
teachers must to know some aspects that are related with this topic as the environment that
students are, different real situation, context, experiences. When students talk about something,
they are in a process of collaboration and cooperation, for that reason communication integrates
the students and pay more attention about the topic or situation. Additionally, teachers have a
instructions and using the natural approach, also using wide range of materials and strategies,
students can use their language performance outside of the class. On the other hand, teachers
will have problems about how the students express the ideas or things like that, maybe because
they do not know the situation or they are not comfortable about that. Other question that
teachers do is about if communication will be related to teach grammar because for some
teacher communication is the most important thing in order to teach english that student are
communicating all the time, but other teachers think that grammar has a relationship with the
communication, it depends on the beliefs of teachers about the best way of teach English.
Most of the time, teachers aspire that their students communicate about different topics in
different context and develop the different competences that mention the authors in the page
119: discourse, linguistic, strategic and sociolinguistic competences but teachers need to create
strategies, methodologies and organize some material in order to students have the interest to
learn, also to have the concentration of each student with wide range of activities that it can
change the objective and the way that students develop it, as students can talk about their
experiences, their knowledge, imagine, suppose about any real situation or imagine situation.
All the same teacher need to organize a process with the objective that students need get a good
communication and to develop their way to express the things or about situations. For that
reason grammar and communication need their own space to study and with the time both are
have a base of how construct the communication, how to create sentences and what rules will
need depend on the situation, context, vocabulary and try to evit mistakes with the reason that
conversations can be understood and sentences are coherent, further students will have a idea
about the topic and can speak about it. For instance, If a teacher wants to explain the topic of
routines, maybe teacher will start with a simple explication about what are the structures that
students need to use, also teacher is going to give some vocabulary, some writing activities or
listening activities in order to students repeat and memorize what are the structures for that
topic. Then teacher organize a communicative activity, when students are going to speak about
their experiences, their knowledge, students also share information and they can help each
other. In this activities students can practice the competences and the language, also to take
into account the mistakes that they do and maybe correct them.
In conclusion, the communication and the grammar have a relationship because if you do not
have grammar is very difficult to communicate and communication is useful to practice the
language in order that students can express their opinions, ideas, experiences, so on. For that
reason is important that teachers give a necessary time to explain grammar and a space to
develop communication and that space are important to improve the level of English and try to
understand each part of the language as uses of some words, vocabulary, grammar, rules,
pronunciation, listening, in this way to avoid or learn from the errors, also students are related
with real situation and things that students are related with their environment.
REFERENCES
Yousaf. M, Umar. H, Habib. A. (2017)Communicative language teaching (CLT), Role of
file:///C:/Users/lenovo/Downloads/article%20for%20critical%20comment%20(1).pdf