Professional Documents
Culture Documents
00014
Research Article
Received 02/12/2012 Accepted 07/02/2013
Silica-based superhydrophobic coating by Published online 12/02/2013
a single-step process Keywords: adhesion/coating/contact angle/
superhydrophobicity
Kousaalya, Garg and Kumar
Silica-based superhydrophobic
coating by a single-step process
1 Adhimoolam Bakthavachalam Kousaalya BTech 3 Ravi Kumar PhD*
Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering, Materials Associate professor, Department of Metallurgical and Materials
Processing Section, Indian Institute of Technology Madras Engineering, Materials Processing Section, Indian Institute of
(IIT-Madras), Chennai, India Technology Madras (IIT-Madras), Chennai, India
1 2 3
Silica-based superhydrophobic coatings were produced on glass substrate by dip-coating process. Colloidal solu-
tions containing nanoparticles of silica synthesized via seed growth method (single- and dual-sized particles) and
dispersed in three different solvents, ethanol, silica sol and acidic silica sol, were used. Coatings with dual-sized
particles in ethanol showed superhydrophobicity with a water contact angle of 155°. The coating adhesion was
improved with the use of acidic silica sol as solvent. Coatings prepared from colloidal solution containing 30 wt.%
of dual-sized silica particles of 600 and 800 nm in acidic silica sol, showed hydrophilicity with water contact angle
of 45° before heat treatment due to the presence of –OH groups from acidic sol. After heat treatment at 250°C
for 2 h in atmospheric ambience, the –OH groups reacted to form cross-linked Si-O-Si resulting in superhydropho-
bicity of the coating with water contact angle of 147°. In this work, silica based superhydrophobic coating was
fabricated by adjusting the ratios of the dual-sized silica particles without carrying out any secondary step such as
chemical modification or fluorination process on the coating.
1. Introduction of any material and reducing its surface energy by the addition of
Nature exhibits excellent superhydrophobic surfaces with a high low surface energy materials or (ii) tailoring the low surface energy
contact angle (CA) of greater than 150° in certain plant leaves such material, by creating roughness at micro/nano scales would achieve
as lotus leaves,1 rice leaves and butterfly wings,2 cicada wings,3 the objective.
which are self-cleaning. This has attracted immense research inter-
est to biomimic and fabricate artificial superhydrophobic surfaces, Extensive research has focused on producing superhydrophobic
which are used for numerous applications such as window glasses, coating by using the former (i) method. Table 1 provides details of
solar cell panels, energy conversion and conservation and naviga- coated material systems, and the method used for coating along with
tion of ships to prevent marine fouling.4 the achieved CA. In all the cases, superhydrophobicity was achieved
only due to chemical modification of the coatings using low surface
In the process of preparing superhydrophobic surfaces, a good energy materials such as fluorine and silicone polymer. However, in
control over chemistry coupled with geometry similar to hierar- the case of producing superhydrophobic coating via the later (ii) fluo-
chical geometrical surface structures found in nature are used.5,6 rine- and silicone-based polymers play an important role.5 The use of
For instance, (i) producing geometrically controlled rough surfaces fluorine- and silicone-based materials for superhydrophobic coating
1
Surface Innovations Silica-based superhydrophobic coating by a
single-step process
Kousaalya, Garg and Kumar
Maximum
S. No. Material used for coating Method contact angle Reference
achieved
1 Silica prepared from Stöber process coated and modified with Colloid assembly 160° 7
FAS method
2 Two different sizes of modified silica, coated and modified Drop coating 155° 8
with polydimethylsiloxane layer
3 Polyelectrolyte/silica nanoparticle multilayers, followed by Electrostatic layer- 157° 9
fluoroalkylsilane treatment by-layer assembly
4 Silica-polystyrene sol-gel coated and modified with FAS Dip coating 160° 10
5 Silane (METES and METES/DECYS) precursor with silica Spin coating 158·3° 11
particles
6 Colloidal silica particles and fluoroalkylsilane in TEOS Spin coating 150° 12
7 TEOS/MTMS in different ratios Dip coating 135° 13
8 Silica nanoparticles coated and modified with tridecafluoro- Dip coating 165° 14
1,1,2,2-tetrahydrooctyldimethylchlorosilane
9 Silica obtained from tetramethylsilane or tetramethoxysilane, Plasma-enhanced 160° 15
coated and modified with (heptadecafluoro-1,1,2,2- chemical vapor
tetrahydro-decyl)-1-trimethoxysilane deposition
Silica deposited and modified with trichloro(1H,1H,2H,2H- Layer-by-layer
10 160° 16
perfluorooctyl) silane processing
FAS, perfluoroalkysilane; TEOS, tetraethoxysilane; MTMS, methyltrimethoxysilane.
Table 1. Silica-based coatings with various types of surface modification to achieve superhydrophobicity.
is primarily due to the low surface-free energy exhibited by them. In 2. Experimental methods
general, the surface energy of polymers is typically lesser than water
(72·2 mJ/m2) due to the presence of organic groups, while the lowest
2.1 Synthesis of silica particles
Silica particles were synthesized by the hydrolysis of tetraethyl
is for fluorine-based polymers (12·4 mJ/m2 for polyhexafluoropro-
ester of orthosilicic acid (TEOS): Si(OC2H5)4 (Alfa Aesar, USA) in
pylene, 19·1 mJ/m2 for polytetrafluoroethylene) and silicone-based
ethanol, using ammonia as catalyst, by the following reaction, bet-
polymers (22 mJ/m2 for polydimethylsiloxane). Fluorination of sili-
ter known as seed growth method or “Stöber process.”19
cone polymer will further reduce the surface energy of the material.17
While nature exhibits superhydrophobicity due to the presence of
1. Si(OC 2 H 5 ) 4 + 4H 2O → Si(O) 2 ↓ + 4C 2 H 5OH
waxes containing predominantly –CH2– groups (whose surface
energy is lower than water), concomitant with surface roughness at
Silica seed sol was first synthesized by adding 1-g TEOS, 3-g water
nanoscale, it is reasonable to fabricate low surface energy material
and 3-g ammonia in 4-g ethanol, followed by continuous stirring at
with hierarchical nanostructure to achieve superhydrophobicity.1,5,18
room temperature (25 °C) for 1·5 h. Subsequently, a solution of 2-g
TEOS in 8-g ethanol was added to the reaction mixture and stirred for
Hence, to obtain superhydrophobic surfaces, materials with surface
3 h as explained by Xu et al.7 The precipitated silica particles (hence-
energy lesser than water are generally used, which contain toxic
forth referred to P-SiO2) were centrifuged using Eppendorf centrifuge
chemicals such as fluorine and involve multiple steps in producing
5810R, Germany, at three different speeds (1000, 2000 and 5000 rpm)
the coatings. Development of superhydrophobic surfaces with eco-
for 5 min at 5°C, to separate P-SiO2 of different sizes.
friendly chemicals is required6 and with a single-step process, that
can be made more economical. The current work focuses on develop-
ing such a silica-based superhydrophobic coating using simple dip- 2.2 Preparation of colloidal solutions
coating process with good adhesion, in a single-step process without The colloidal solutions were prepared using two differently sized
any additional processes like fluorination or any type of chemical P-SiO2 mixed in different proportions as solutes: P-SiO2 sepa-
modification, to reduce the surface energy of the coating. The ability rated after centrifugation at 2000 rpm designated as P-SiO2(A),
to alter the particle size distribution helps in introducing nanoscale and P-SiO2 separated after centrifugation at 1000 rpm designated
roughness on the coating resulting in superhydrophobicity. as P-SiO2(B). The following three solvents, ethanol, a silica sol
2
Surface Innovations Silica-based superhydrophobic coating by a
single-step process
Kousaalya, Garg and Kumar
– 20-nm silica in 50% H2O colloidal solution (Alfa Aesar, USA), 2.4 Characterization
and an acidic silica sol were used. The acidic silica sol was pre- The morphology and size of P-SiO2 were characterized using
pared by adding 2·4-g hydrochloric acid (36·5%) and 2-g TEOS in transmission electron microscope (TEM), Philips CM20, The
8-g ethanol followed by continuous stirring for 2 h at 60°C. Netherlands at an accelerating voltage of 200 kV. A small amount
of the precipitated silica particles, obtained before and after centrif-
The colloidal solutions that were prepared are described in Table ugation, were dispersed separately in ethanol and ultrasonicated for
2, in which the column on solute content gives the amount (wt.%) 30 min. A drop of both the solutions was deposited separately and
of P-SiO2(A) and P-SiO2(B) present in the solution. For example, dried over a carbon-coated copper grid and viewed through TEM.
the first solution given in Table 2 has 5 wt.% of P-SiO2(A), no The surface roughness of the etched glass before coating was char-
P-SiO2(B) and the solvent used is ethanol, while the fifth solution acterized using surface profilometer, Mitutoyo SJ-400, Japan. The
in the table has 5 wt.% of P-SiO2(A) and 10 wt.% of P-SiO2(B) as surface morphology of the coatings was studied using field emis-
solute and ethanol as the solvent. The solute, solvent mixtures men- sion gun scanning electron microscope (FEG-SEM), FEI Quanta
tioned in Table 2 were ultrasonicated for 30 min to obtain colloidal 400F, USA. The coatings were sputter coated with a gold layer of
solutions for producing coatings on glass substrates. thickness 5 nm before imaging them using SEM in secondary elec-
tron mode. Optical imaging was carried out in bright field mode
and differential interference contrast (Nomarski DIC) mode using
2.3 Coating procedure
Olympus IX71 inverted microscope, USA. The static CA measure-
The glass substrates were etched with H2SO4/H2O2 (50/50%) solu-
ments of the coated sample, before and after heat treatment, were
tion for 6 h, ultrasonicated for 30 min, rinsed with acetone and
carried out using CA goniometer, Digidrop GBX, France with 2·0–
distilled water. The glass substrates were then coated with the pre-
4·0 µl distilled water droplets at room temperature.
pared colloidal solutions through a dip-coating process using single
dip coater (SDC 2007C, Apex instruments Co., India) using the
following parameters: dipping and withdrawal rate of 50 mm/min 3. Results and discussion
each, holding time of 15 min and drying time of 5 min, and the
cycle was repeated for 10 times. The coated glass substrates were 3.1 Morphology of silica particles
heat treated at 250°C for 2 h in atmospheric ambience to ensure The TEM micrograph of P-SiO2 before centrifugation and P-SiO2
solidification and complete evaporation of the solvent. separated after centrifugation at 1000 rpm is shown in Figure 1(a,b)
and 1(c,d), respectively. Before centrifugation, the presence of debris
on the P-SiO2 is observed. However, after centrifugation, P-SiO2 was
Amount of solute present found to be completely spherical of uniform diameter, free of debris
(wt.%) Solvent and agglomerates. The silica particles with diameter of ~800 nm were
S. No.
used separated out after centrifugation at 1000 rpm for 5 min, while parti-
P-SiO2(A) P-SiO2(B) cles with diameter of ~600 nm were separated out after centrifugation
at 2000 rpm for 5 min. The selected area diffraction pattern shown as
1 5 0
insert in Figure 1d exemplifies that the silica particles are amorphous.
2 0 5 Since the particles separating out after centrifugation at 1000 rpm are
3 15 0 completely spherical, free of agglomeration and debris, only a rep-
Ethanol
4 0 15 resentative TEM image of P-SiO2 is provided here in Figure 1(c,d).
5 5 10 After centrifugation at 5000 rpm, the solution was clear with rather
6 10 5 minimal presence of silica particles for any further consideration.
7 0 5
8 5 0
Silica sol 3.2 Coating and adhesion
9 0 15
The prepared colloidal solutions were coated on glass substrates
10 15 0
with surface roughness (Ra) of ~0·05 µm. The coatings were
11 10 5
found to be transparent, with presence of few silica particles on
12 10 10
Acidic sol the glass substrate when coated with colloidal solution containing
13 15 10
5 wt.% (P-SiO2(A) or P-SiO2(B)) in ethanol/silica sol as solvents.
14 15 15 Hence, the silica content was increased to 15 wt.% (P-SiO2(A) or
Table 2. Composition of colloidal solutions for coating: P-SiO2 P-SiO2(B)) to ensure additional silica particles were available in the
separated after centrifugation at 2000 rpm is designated as colloidal solution for coating.
P-SiO2(A), and P-SiO2 separated after centrifugation at 1000 rpm is
designated as P-SiO2(B). The coatings made using ethanol as solvent exhibited poor adhesion
with the glass substrate, in both cases, before and after heat treatment,
3
Surface Innovations Silica-based superhydrophobic coating by a
single-step process
Kousaalya, Garg and Kumar
(a) (c)
5 µm 100 nm
(b) (d)
Presence of debris
on the silica particle
1 µm 1 µm
500 µm 500 µm
500 µm
(d) (e)
100 µm 100 µm
4
Surface Innovations Silica-based superhydrophobic coating by a
single-step process
Kousaalya, Garg and Kumar
which was clearly evident from the fact that the coating was easy to
remove from the glass substrate while handling. In the case of silica
sol as solvent, the obtained coatings were not stable even during the
coating process. The coatings were found to crack during the drying
time between the coating cycles. Hence, the development of crack
patterns in the coating during drying was viewed through optical
microscope in bright field mode and differential interface contrast
mode. Figure 2 shows the development of cracks with time on glass
substrate coated with colloidal solution of 15 wt.% P-SiO2(A) in
silica sol in bright field mode. Figure 2a shows the optical image
obtained immediately after removal of the glass substrate from the
colloidal solution after dipping the substrate for 15 min. Figure 2b
and figure 2c were obtained after 10 and 30 s, respectively. From
Figure 2a–2c, formation of cracks on the coating with increase in
time is clearly evident. Figure 2d obtained after 90 s shows that the
coating had completely cracked. Figure 2e shows the corresponding
differential interference contrast image. The formation of cracks at a
4/20/2012 HV mag WD det vac mode 3 µm faster rate in the coating with silica sol as solvent could be due to the
5:35:04 PM 30·00 kV 14 000 x 10·5 mm ETD High vacuum Quanta FEG evaporation of water present in the silica sol resulting in spallation
Figure 3. FEG-SEM images of the coating with (10 wt.% of P-SiO2(A) during 5 min of drying time between the cycles.
and 5 wt.% of P-SiO2(B)) in acidic silica sol binder, also showing the
cross-linked adhesive layer. FEG-SEM, field emission gun scanning Hence, subsequently coatings were carried out with acidic silica sol as
electron microscope. solvent using colloidal solutions containing varying amount of solutes
as mentioned in Table 2. Sakka et al.20 has shown that the use of acidic
1 5 0
—
2 0 5
3 15 0 ~36°
Ethanol (after heat treatment)
4 0 15 ~36°
5 5 10 ~155°
6 10 5 ~155°
7 0 5
—
8 5 0
Silica sol (before heat treatment)
9 0 15 ~110°
10 15 0 ~110°
11 Before heat treatment 10 5 ~47°
12 10 5 ~102°
13 Acidic sol 10 10 —
After heat treatment
14 15 10 ~114°
15 15 15 ~147°
Table 3. Wettability of various compositions of colloidal solutions for coating: P-SiO2 separated after centrifugation at 2000 rpm designated as
P-SiO2(A) and P-SiO2 separated after centrifugation at 1000 rpm designated as P-SiO2(B).
5
Surface Innovations Silica-based superhydrophobic coating by a
single-step process
Kousaalya, Garg and Kumar
(a) (b)
CA - 36° CA - 110°
6
Surface Innovations Silica-based superhydrophobic coating by a
single-step process
Kousaalya, Garg and Kumar
(a) (b)
4/20/2012 HV mag WD det vac mode 2 µm 4/20/2012 HV mag WD det vac mode 2 µm
5:11:03 PM 30·00 kV 20 000 x 10·5 mm ETD High vacuum Quanta FEG 5:59:50 PM 30·00 kV 20 000 x 10·5 mm ETD High vacuum Quanta FEG
Figure 6. SEM images of the coated samples (a) coating with single
particle size 15 wt.% of P-SiO2(A) in ethanol and (b) coating with
dual-sized particle distribution 10 wt.% of P-SiO2(A) and 5 wt.% of
P-SiO2(B) in ethanol. SEM, scanning electron microscope.
(a)
(b) (c)
7
Surface Innovations Silica-based superhydrophobic coating by a
single-step process
Kousaalya, Garg and Kumar
and also Medical Materials Laboratory, Department of Metallurgical step sol-gel route. Surface and Coatings Technology 2011,
and Materials Engineering, IIT-M and Polymer Engineering 205, 5338–5344.
Laboratory, Department of Chemical Engineering, IIT-M for car- 14. Shang, H. M.; Wang, Y.; Limmer, S. J.; Chou, T. P.;
rying out contact angle measurement. Takahashi, K.; Cao, G. Z. Optically transparent
superhydrophobic silica-based films. Thin Solid Films 2005,
References 472, 37–43.
1. Barthlott, W.; Neinhuis, C. Purity of the sacred lotus, or 15. Hozumi, A.; Takai, O. Preparation of silicon oxide films
escape from contamination in biological surfaces. Planta having a water-repellent layer by multiple-step microwave
1997, 202, 1–8. plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition. Thin Solid Films
2. Bixler, G. D.; Bhushan, B. Bioinspired rice leaf and butterfly 1998, 334, 54–59.
wing surface structures combining shark skin and lotus 16. Bravo, J.; Zhai, L.; Wu, Z.; Cohen, R. E.; Rubner, M. F.
effects. Soft Matter 2012, 8, 11271–11284. Transparent superhydrophobic films based on silica
3. Nishimoto, S.; Bhushan, B. Bioinspired self-cleaning nanoparticles. Langmuir 2007, 23, 7293–7298.
surfaces with superhydrophobicity, superoleophobicity, and 17. Thanawala, S. K.; Chaudhury, M. K. Surface modification of
superhydrophilicity. RSC Advances 2013, DOI:10.1039/ silicone elastomer using perfluorinated ether. Langmuir 2000,
C2RA21260A. 16, 1256–1260.
4. Bhushan, B.; Jung, Y. C.; Koch, K. Micro-, nano- and 18. Burton, Z.; Bhushan, B. Surface characterization and
hierarchical structures for superhydrophobicity, self-cleaning adhesion and friction properties of hydrophobic leaf surfaces.
and low adhesion. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Ultramicroscopy 2006, 106, 709–719.
Society A 2009, 367, 1631–1672. 19. Stöber, W.; Fink, A.; Bohn, E. Controlled growth of
5. Ma, M.; Hill, R. M. Superhydrophobic surfaces. Current monodisperse silica spheres in the micron size range. Journal
Opinion in Colloid & Interface Science 2006, 11, 193–202. of Colloid and Interface Science 1968, 26, 62–69.
6. Latthe, S. S.; Gurav, A. B.; Maruti, C. V.; Vhatkar, 20. Sakka, S.; Kamiya, K. The sol-gel transition in the hydrolysis
R. S. Recent progress in preparation of superhydrophobic of metal alkoxides in relation to the formation of glass fibers
surfaces: a review. Journal of Surface Engineered Materials and films. Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids 1982, 48, 31–46.
and Advanced Technology 2012, 2, 76–94. 21. Saman, N.; Johari, K.; Mat, H. Effects of synthesis
7. Xu, Q. F.; Wang, J. N.; Sanderson, K. D. A general approach parameters towards morphological properties of silica
for superhydrophobic coating with strong adhesion strength. xerogels. Asian Journal of Applied Sciences 2012, 5,
Journal of Materials Chemistry 2010, 20, 5961–5966. 247–251.
8. Ke, Q.; Fu, W.; Jin, H.; Zhang, L.; Tang, T.; Zhang, J.
Fabrication of mechanically robust superhydrophobic
surfaces based on silica micro-nanoparticles and
polydimethylsiloxane. Surface and Coatings Technology
2011, 205, 4910–4914.
9. Zhao, Y.; Tang, Y.; Wang, X.; Lin, T. Superhydrophobic
cotton fabric fabricated by electrostatic assembly of silica
nano-particles and its remarkable buoyancy. Applied Surface WHAT DO YOU THINK?
Science 2010, 256, 6736–6742.
To discuss this paper, please email up to 500 words to the
10. Xu, Q. F.; Wang, J. N.; Smith, L. H.; Sanderson, K. D.
managing editor at sufi@icepublishing.com
Superhydrophobic and transparent coatings based on
removable polymeric spheres. Journal of Materials Your contribution will be forwarded to the author(s) for
Chemistry 2009, 19, 655–660. a reply and, if considered appropriate by the editor-in-
11. Chen, P.; Hsu, C.; Lee, P.; Lin, C. Fabrication of semi- chief, will be published as a discussion in a future issue of
transparent superhydrophobic surface based on silica the journal.
hierarchical structures. Journal of Mechanical Science and ICE Science journals rely entirely on contributions sent in
Technology 2011, 25, 43–47. by professionals, academics and students coming from the
12. Hikita, M.; Tanaka, K.; Nakamura, T.; Kajiyama, T.; field of materials science and engineering. Articles should
Takahara, A. Super-liquid-repellent surfaces prepared by be within 5000-7000 words long (short communications and
colloidal silica nanoparticles covered with fluoroalkyl groups. opinion articles should be within 2000 words long), with
Langmuir 2005, 21, 7299–7302. adequate illustrations and references. To access our author
13. Ganbavle, V. V.; Bangi, U. K. H.; Latthe, S. S.; Mahadik, S. A.; guidelines and how to submit your paper, please refer to
Rao, A. V. Self-cleaning silica coatings on glass by single the journal website at www.icevirtuallibrary.com/sufi