You are on page 1of 7

XIII.

Parallel 1st-Order Reactions:

A. Observed:

A famous physical organic chemist made the following observation...


H(D)
H-atom Ph
abstraction
Me
(D)H H(D)
Ph H(D)

Me
Me

cyclization
H(D)
H(D)
Ph

When the rate of formation of the products were monitored independently,


it was found that...

kH/kD = 2.1 in both cases!!


XIII. Parallel 1st-Order Reactions:

B. Given:
k1
A P1
!!!
k2
A P2
!!!

• This case is central to the control of selectivity, but it can be deceptive.

C. Rate Equation:

1. Species A:

-d[A]/dt = k1[A] + k2[A] = (k1 + k2)[A]

[A] = [A0] e ( 1
" k + k2 ) t

!
XIII. Parallel 1st-Order Reactions:

2. Species P1 and P2:

d[P1]/dt = k1[A] = k1[A0] e"( k1 + k2 ) t

Integrate... (CRC #12)


!
k [A ]
[P1 ] = 1 o (1" e"( k1 + k2 )t ) (1)
k1 + k2

Similarly...

! k2 [Ao ]
[P2 ] =
k1 + k2
(1" e"( k1 + k2 )t ) (2)

!
XIII. Parallel 1st-Order Reactions:

D. Graphics:

k1
[P1] A P1
[X] !!!
[P2] k2
A P2
[A] !!!

time
1. Starting Material A:
Let...
f(x) = aebx
such that...
f(x) = [A] x=t a = [A0] b = -(k1 + k2)
XIII. Parallel 1st-Order Reactions:

2. Products P1 and P2:

Let...

f(x) = a(1 - ebx)

such that...

f(x) = [P1] or [P2]

a = k1[A0]/(k1 + k2)

(or k2[A0]/(k1 + k2))

b = -(k1 + k2)

• The values of k1 and k2 can be extracted from the values of


adjustable parameters a and b. However...
XIII. Parallel 1st-Order Reactions:

E. Caveat:

Recall, for a 1st-order reaction...

[P] = [A0] - [A] = [A0] - [A0] e-kt = [P∞](1-e-kt)

f(x) = a(1 - ebx)

• Therefore, formation of the products in parallel 1st-order reactions follow the


same mathematical form as a single 1st-order reaction. However, in a parallel
reaction, b = -(k1 + k2). The difference appears in the pre-exponential term, a.

• If you monitor the formation of either P1 or P2 and analyze the data as a simple
first-order reaction, you will get the same rate constant!

• If either k1 or k2 has a kinetic isotope effect, the rate of formation of both


products will show a kinetic isotope effect. Moreover, formation of P1 and P2 will
exhibit the same kinetic isotope effect if treated as a simple (rather than parallel)
1st-order reaction! Mechanistic branch points can be deceptive, and an
undetected parallel pathway could be very misleading.
XIII. Parallel 1st-Order Reactions:

k1
A P1
!!!
F. Selectivity: k2
A P2
!!!
By dividing through the integral
forms of the rate equations (eq (1) and eq (2))...

[P1]/[P2] = k1/k2

Alternatively, the integration can be skipped...

d[P1]/dt k1[A] k1
[P1 ]/[P2 ] = = =
d[P2]/dt k2 [A] k2

You might also like