Chapter 9 Database Design

Chapter 9

Database Design
Discussion Focus

What is the relationship between a database and an information system, and how does this
relationship have a bearing on database design?

An information system performs three sets of services:

 It provides for data collection, storage, and retrieval.
 It facilitates the transformation of data into information.
 It provides the tools and conditions to manage both data and information.

Basically, a database is a fact (data) repository that serves an information system. If the database is
designed poorly, one can hardly expect that the data/information transformation will be successful, nor is
it reasonable to expect efficient and capable management of data and information.

The transformation of data into information is accomplished through application programs. It is

impossible to produce good information from poor data; and, no matter how sophisticated the application
programs are, it is impossible to use good application programs to overcome the effects of bad database
design. In short: Good database design is the foundation of a successful information system.

Database design must yield a database that:

 Does not fall prey to uncontrolled data duplication, thus preventing data anomalies and the
attendant lack of data integrity.
 Is efficient in its provision of data access.
 Serves the needs of the information system.

The last point deserves emphasis: even the best-designed database lacks value if it fails to meet
information system objectives. In short, good database designers must pay close attention to the
information system requirements.

Systems design and database design are usually tightly intertwined and are often performed in parallel.
Therefore, database and systems designers must cooperate and coordinate to yield the best possible
information system.

What is the relationship between the SDLC and the DBLC?

The SDLC traces the history (life cycle) of an information system. The DBLC traces the history (life
cycle) of a database system. Since we know that the database serves the information system, it is not
surprising that the two life cycles conform to the same basic phases.

Suggestion: Use Figure 9.8 as the basis for a discussion of the parallel activities.

106
 Chapter 9 Database Design

What basic database design strategies exist, and how are such strategies executed?

Suggestion: Use Figure 9.14 as the basis for this discussion.

There are two basic approaches to database design: top-down and bottom-up.

Top-down design begins by identifying the different entity types and the definition of each entity's
attributes. In other words, top-down design:
 starts by defining the required data sets and then
 defines the data elements for each of those data sets.

Bottom-up design:
 first defines the required attributes and then
 groups the attributes to form entities.

Although the two methodologies tend to be complementary, database designers who deal with small
databases with relatively few entities, attributes, and transactions tend to emphasize the bottom-up
approach. Database designers who deal with large, complex databases usually find that a primarily
top-down design approach is more appropriate.

In spite of the frequent arguments concerning the best design approach, perhaps the top-down vs.
bottom-up distinction is quite artificial. The text's note is worth repeating:

NOTE
Even if a generally top-down approach is selected, the normalization process that revises
existing table structures is (inevitably) a bottom-up technique. E-R models constitute a top-
down process even if the selection of attributes and entities may be described as bottom-up.
Since both the E-R model and normalization techniques form the basis for most designs, the
top-down vs. bottom-up debate may be based on a distinction without a difference.

Problem Solutions

107
 Chapter 9 Database Design

1. The ABC Car Service & Repair Centers are owned by the SILENT car dealer; ABC services
and repairs only SILENT cars. Three ABC Car Service & Repair Centers provide service and
repair for the entire state.

Each of the three centers is independently managed and operated by a shop manager, a
receptionist, and at least eight mechanics. Each center maintains a fully stocked parts
inventory.
Each center also maintains a manual file system in which each car’s maintenance history is
kept: repairs made, parts used, costs, service dates, owner, and so on. Files are also kept to
track inventory, purchasing, billing, employees’ hours, and payroll.

You have been contacted by the manager of one of the centers to design and implement a
computerized system. Given the preceding information, do the following:

a. Indicate the most appropriate sequence of activities by labeling each of the following steps
in the correct order. (For example, if you think that “Load the database.” is the
appropriate first step, label it “1.”)

_10__ Normalize the conceptual model.

_4___ Obtain a general description of company operations.
_11__ Load the database.
_9___ Create a description of each system process.
_7___ Test the system.
_1___ Draw a data flow diagram and system flowcharts.
_5___ Create a conceptual model, using ER diagrams.
_2___ Create the application programs.
_8___ Interview the mechanics.
_3___ Create the file (table) structures.
_6___ Interview the shop manager.

108
 Chapter 9 Database Design

b. Describe the various modules that you believe the system should include.

We have illustrated the Information System's main modules in Figure P9.1B.

Figure P9.1B The ABC Company’s IS System Modules

(The Inventory module will include the Parts and Purchasing sub-modules. The Payroll Module
will handle all Employee and Payroll information. The Work Order module keeps track of the car
Maintenance history and all work orders for maintenance done on a car. The Customer module
keeps track of the billing of the work orders to the customers and of the payments received from
those customers.)

c. How will a data dictionary help you develop the system? Give examples.

(The data dictionary makes it easier to check for the existence of synonyms and homonyms, to
check whether all attributes exist to support required reports, to verify appropriate relationship
representations, and so on. Therefore, the data dictionary’s contents will help us to provide
consistency across modules and to evaluate the system’s ability to generate the required reports.)

109
 Chapter 9 Database Design

d. Name and describe at least four reports the system should have. Explain their use. Who will
use those reports?
REPORT 1
Monthly Activity – A summary of service categories by branch and by month. Such reports may
become the basis for forecasting personnel and stock requirements for each branch and for each
period.
REPORT 2
Mechanic Summary Sheet – A summary of work hours clocked by each mechanic. This report
would be generated weekly and would be useful for payroll and maintenance personnel scheduling
purposes.
REPORT 3
Monthly Inventory – A summary of parts in inventory, inventory used, parts reorder points, and
information about the vendors who will provide the parts to be reordered. This report will be
especially useful for inventory management purposes.
REPORT 4
Customer Report – Breakdown of customers by location, maintenance activity, current balances,
available credit, and so on. This report would be useful to forecast various service demand
factors, to mail promotional materials, to send maintenance reminders, to keep track of special
customer requirements, and so on.

2. Suppose you have been asked to create an information system for a manufacturing plant that
produces nuts and bolts of many shapes, sizes, and functions. What questions would you ask,
and how would the answers to those questions affect the database design?
 Do you want to develop the database for all departments at once, or do you want to design
and implement the database for one department at a time?
 Do you want to develop one module at a time, or do you want an integrated system?
 Do you want to keep track of the nuts and bolts by lot number, production shift, type, and
department?
 Do you want to keep track of the suppliers of each batch of raw material used in the
production of the nuts and bolts?
 Do you want to keep track of the customers who received the batches of nuts and bolts?
 What kind of report do you require?

These will all affect the conceptual and logical database design, the database’s implementation, its
implementation, its testing, and its subsequent operation.

a. What do you envision the SDLC to be?

Planning, Analysis, Detailed systems design, Implementation, and Maintenance.

b. What do you envision the DBLC to be?

Database initial study, Database design, Implementation and loading, Testing and Evaluation,

110
 Chapter 9 Database Design

Operation, and Maintenance and evolution.

3. In a construction company, a new system has been in place for a few months and now there is a
list of possible changes/updates that need to be done. For each of the changes/updates, specify
what type of maintenance needs to be done: (a) corrective, (b) adaptive, and (c) perfective.

a. An error in the size of one of the fields has been identified and it needs to be
updated status field needs to be changed.

Corrective

b. The company is expanding into a new type of service and this will require to
enhancing the system with a new set of tables to support this new service and
integrate it with the existing data.

Perfective

c. The company has to comply with some government regulations. To do this, it will
require adding a couple of fields to the existing system tables.

Adaptive

4. You have been assigned to design the database for a new soccer club. Indicate the most
appropriate sequence of activities by labeling each of the following steps in the correct order.
(For example, if you think that “Load the database” is the appropriate first step, label it “1.”)

_10__ Create the application programs.

_4 __ Create a description of each system process.
_11__ Test the system.
_9 __ Load the database.
_7 __ Normalize the conceptual model.
_1 __ Interview the soccer club president.
_5 __ Create a conceptual model using ER diagrams.
_2 __ Interview the soccer club director of coaching.
_8 __ Create the file (table) structures.
_3 __ Obtain a general description of the soccer club operations.
_6 __ Draw a data flow diagram and system flowcharts.

111