You are on page 1of 89

Chapter

 1  
What  Is  Strategy?  
The  AFI  Strategy  Framework  

Jump  to  Appendix  1  long  image  


descrip0on  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Chapter  1  Outline  

1.1 What Strategy Is: Gaining and Sustaining


Competitive Advantage
–  What Is Competitive Advantage?
–  Industry vs. Firm Effects in Determining Firm Performance

1.2 Stakeholders and Competitive Advantage


–  Stakeholder Strategy
–  Stakeholder Impact Analysis

1.3 The AFI Strategy Framework


1.4 Implications for the Strategist  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Learning  Objec0ves  

LO  1-­‐1  Explain  the  role  of  strategy  in  a  firm’s  quest  for  
compe00ve  advantage.  
LO  1-­‐2  Define  compe00ve  advantage,  sustainable  
compe00ve  advantage,  compe00ve  
disadvantage,  and  compe00ve  parity.  
LO  1-­‐3  Differen0ate  the  roles  of  firm  effects  and  
industry  effects  in  determining  firm  
performance.  
LO  1-­‐4  Evaluate  the  rela0onship  between  stakeholder  
strategy  and  sustainable  compe00ve  
advantage.  
LO  1-­‐5  Conduct  a  stakeholder  impact  analysis.  
©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
What  Strategy  Is:  Gaining  and  Sustaining  
Compe00ve  Advantage  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategic  Management  

Strategic  Management:  an  integra0ve  management  


field  that  combines  analysis,  formula0on,  and  
implementa0on  in  the  quest  for  compe00ve  advantage  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  

•  Strategy:  a  set  of  goal-­‐directed  ac0ons  a  firm  takes  


to  gain  and  sustain  superior  performance  rela0ve  to  
compe0tors  
•  To  achieve  superior  performance,  companies  
compete  for  resources:    
–  New  ventures:  for  financial  and  human  capital  
–  Exis0ng  companies:  for  profitable  growth  
–  Chari0es:  for  dona0ons  
–  Universi0es:  for  the  best  students  and  professors  
–  Sports  teams:  championships  
–  Celebri0es:  media  aBen0on  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Elements  of  a  Good  Strategy  

•  Analysis  
–  Diagnosis  of  the  compe00ve  challenge  
•  Formula5on  
–  Guiding  policy  to  address  the  compe00ve  challenge  
•  Implementa5on  
–  A  set  of  coherent  ac0ons  to  implement  the  firm’s  guiding  
policy  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Elements of a Good Strategy: Analysis

•  Analysis
–  Diagnosis of the competitive challenge
–  Accomplished through strategy analysis of the firm’s
internal and external environments
 
Example:  Twi<er  
•  Compe00ve  challenge:  grow  its  user  base  
–  Become  more  valuable  for  online  adver0sers  
–  Also:  Facebook  allows  adver0sers  to  target  their  online  ads  
precisely  based  on  demographic  data  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Elements of a Good Strategy: Formulation

•  Formulation
–  Guiding  policy  to  address  the  compe00ve  challenge  
–  Accomplished  through  strategy  formula0on,  resul0ng  in  
the  firm’s  corporate,  business,  and  func0onal  strategies  
 
Example:  Twi<er  
•  Rather  than  formula0ng  a  guiding  policy  to  grow  ac0ve  core  
users,  TwiBer  defined  its  user  base  more  broadly.  
•  Defined  users  into  3  types  to  compare  with  Facebook  
•  User  types  were  hard  to  track  and  less  valuable  to  adver0sers.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Elements of a Good Strategy: Implementation

•  Implementation
–  A set of coherent actions to implement the firm’s guiding
policy
–  Accomplished through strategy implementation
 
Example:  Twi<er  
•  Different  user  defini0ons  confused  management  and  limited  
guidance  for  employees.  
•  Consequences  of  the  unclear  mission:    
•  Frustra0on  among  managers  and  engineers  
•  Turnover  of  key  personnel  
•  Internal  turmoil  resulted,  including  management  demo0ons  
and  promo0ons  of  CEO  friends.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Compe00ve  Advantage  

•  Compe55ve  Advantage:  a  firm  that  achieves  


superior  performance  rela0ve  to  other  compe0tors  
in  the  same  industry  or  the  industry  average  
–  Always  rela0ve,  not  absolute  
•  To  assess  compe00ve  advantage:  
–  Compare  firm  performance  to  a  benchmark  
•  Performance  of  other  firms  in  the  same  industry  
•  An  industry  average  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Compe00ve  Advantage:  Examples  

•  In  digital  adver0sing:  Google  


–  Google  has  a  compe00ve  advantage  over  Facebook,  
TwiBer,  and  Yahoo  
•  In  smartphones:  Apple  
–  Apple  has  achieved  a  compe00ve  advantage  over  
Samsung,  Microsoa,  and  BlackBerry  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Compe00ve  Advantage:  Key  Points  

•  Compe55ve  Advantage  
–  Superior  performance  rela0ve  to  other  compe0tors  in  the  
same  industry  or  the  industry  average  
•  Sustainable  Compe55ve  Advantage  
–  Outperforming  compe0tors  or  the  industry  average  over  a  
prolonged  period  of  0me  
•  Compe55ve  Disadvantage  
–  Underperformance  rela0ve  to  other  compe0tors  in  the  
same  industry  or  the  industry  average  
•  Compe55ve  Parity  
–  Performance  of  two  or  more  firms  at  the  same  level  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy Is About Creating Superior Value

•  The  rewards  of  superior  value  crea0on  and  capture  


are  profitability  and  market  share.  
–  Sam  Walton  (Walmart):  offered  lower  prices.  
–  Steve  Jobs  (Apple):  “put  a  ding  in  the  universe.”  
–  Mark  Zuckerberg  (Facebook):  made  the  world  open  and  
connected.  
–  Larry  Page  and  Sergey  Brin  (Google):  made  informa0on  
accessible.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategic  Posi0oning  

•  Stake  out  a  unique  posi0on  within  an  industry  to  


provide  value  to  customers,  while  controlling  costs.  
•  The  greater  the  difference  between  value  crea0on  
and  cost:    
–  the  greater  the  firm’s  economic  contribu0on.    
–  the  more  likely  it  will  gain  compe00ve  advantage.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategic Positioning Requires Trade-offs

•  Managers  must  make  conscious  trade-­‐offs.    


–  Enables  compe00ve  advantage  
•  In  the  retail  industry,  for  example:  
–  Walmart:  “everyday  low  prices”  
–  Nordstrom’s:  professional  sales  people  in  a  luxury  sehng  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Unique  Posi0oning  

•  The  key  to  successful  strategy:  combine  ac0vi0es  for  a  unique  


posi0on  in  an  industry  
•  Compe00ve  advantage  has  to  come  from:  
–  performing  different  ac0vi0es  or    
–  performing  the  same  ac0vi0es  differently  than  rivals  

•  Example:  Walmart’s  strategic  ac0vi0es  strengthen  its  posi0on  


as  cost  leader  
–  Big  stores  in  rural  loca0ons  
–  Low  corporate  overhead  
–  Low  base  wages  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy Highlight 1.1 (1 of 2)

•  Threadless:  an  online  design  community  and  apparel  store  


•  Let  consumers   work  for  them    
–  Community  members  vote  on  which  t-­‐shirt  designs  they  like  best.  

•  Leverages  the  wisdom  of  the  crowds  


•  At  Threadless,  the  customers  play  a  cri0cal  role  across  the  
en0re  value  chain.  
–  From  idea  genera0on  to  design,  marke0ng,  sales  forecas0ng,  and  
distribu0on  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  Highlight  1.1  (2  of  2)  

•  Business  model  translates  market  research  and  design  into  


quick  sales.    
–  Good  understanding  of  the  market  
–  Design  contest  par0cipa0on  
•  Threadless  has  sold  every  T-­‐shirt  it  has  printed.    
•  Has  a  cult-­‐like  following  
•  It  is  outperforming  established  companies  
–  American  Eagle,  Old  Navy,  and  Urban  OuiiBers  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
What  Strategy  Is  Not  

1.  Grandiose  statements    


–  Statements  of  desire  
–  Ex:  “Our  strategy  is  to  win”  or  “We  will  be  No.  #1”    
2.  A  failure  to  face  a  compe00ve  challenge  
–  Managers  must  know  whether  they  are  making  progress  
in  addressing  the  challenge.  
3.  Opera0onal  effec0veness,  compe00ve  
benchmarking,  or  other  tac0cal  tools    
–  These  support    compe00ve  strategy,  but  are  not  
sufficient  to  sustain  it.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Industry  Vs.  Firm  Effects  In  Determining  Firm  Performance    
(1  of  3)    

•  Industry  effects:  describe  the  underlying  economic  


structure  of  the  industry.  
–  Determined  by  elements  common  to  all  industries  
–  Examples:    
•  Entry  and  exit  barriers  
•  Number  and  size  of  companies  
•  Types  of  products  and  services  offered  
•  About  20%  of  a  firm’s  profitability  depends  on  the  
industry  it’s  in.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Industry  Vs.  Firm  Effects  In  Determining  Firm  Performance    
(2  of  3)  

•  Firm  effects:  firm  performance  is  aBributed  to  


managerial  ac0ons.    
–  More  important  factor  in  determining  firm  performance  
than  external  environment  forces  
•  A  firm’s  strategy  can  explain  up  to  55%  of  its  
performance.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Industry  Vs.  Firm  Effects  In  Determining  Firm  Performance    
(3  of  3)  

•  Exhibit 1.1

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Stakeholders  and  Compe00ve  Advantage  
Value  Crea0on  for  Society  (1  of  2)  

•  Companies  with  good  strategy  generate  value  for  


society.  
–  Firms  compete  in  their  own  self-­‐interest.    
–  Firms  obeying  the  law  and  ac0ng  ethically    
•  Companies  with  a  good  strategy:  
–  Provide  products  or  services  to  consumers  at  an  affordable  
price  
–  Make  a  profit  
–  Benefit  both  par0es  
–  Make  society  beBer    
©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Value  Crea0on  for  Society  (2  of  2)  

•  Successful  companies  create  value  for  the  economy:    


–  Educa0on,  public  safety,  and  health  care  
•  Superior  performance  allows  a  firm  to  reinvest  some  
of  its  profits  for  growth  
–  More  opportuni0es  for  employment  
•  Example:  Google  
–  Employs  55,000  people  
–  People  rely  on  Google  for  informa0on  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategic  Failure  is  Expensive  

•  HP  has  not  been  able  to  address  the  compe00ve  


challenges  effec0vely:  
–  Stakeholders  suffered  
–  Shareholder  value  was  destroyed    
–  Had  to  lay  off  thousands  of  employees    
–  Customers  no  longer  received  innova0ve  products  
•  Google  and  HP  illustrate  the  rela0onship  between  
individual  firms  and  society  at  large  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Black  Swan  Events  (1  of  2)  

•  In  the  past,  most  people  assumed  that  all  swans  


were  white.  
–  When  they  first  encountered  swans  that  were  black,  they  
were  surprised.    
•  Today,  the  metaphor  of  a  black  swan  describes  the  
high  impact  of  a  highly  improbable  event.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Black  Swan  Events  (2  of  2)  

•  Trust  between  corpora0ons  and  society  have  


deteriorated  because  of  black  swans  .  
–  Accoun0ng  Scandals:  Enron  
–  Real  Estate  Bubble:  2008  financial  crisis  
•  Managerial  ac0ons  can  affect  the  well-­‐being  of  
people  around  the  globe.  
–  Most  black  swan  events  result  from  execu0ve  ac0ons  (or  
inac0ons.)  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Stakeholders  (1  of  2)  

•  Stakeholders:    
•  Organiza0ons,  groups,  and  individuals  
•  They  can  affect  or  are  affected  by  a  firm’s  ac0ons.  
•  Have  a  vested  claim  or  interest  in  the  performance  
and  con0nued  survival  of  the  firm.  
–  Internal  stakeholders:  
•  Stockholders,  employees  (including  execu0ves,  managers,  and  
workers),  and  board  members  
–  External  stakeholders:  
•  Customers,  suppliers,  alliance  partners,  creditors,  unions,  
communi0es,  media,  and  governments  at  various  levels  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Stakeholders  (2  of  2)  

•  Stakeholders  make  contribu0ons,  and  they  also  


receive  benefits.    
–  Employees  
–  Shareholders  
–  Communi0es  
•  The  firm  is  embedded  in  an  exchange  rela0onship  
with  internal  and  external  stakeholders.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Exhibit  1.2  Internal  and  External  Stakeholders  in  an  Exchange  
Rela0onship  with  the  Firm    

Jump  to  Appendix  2  long  image  


descrip0on  
©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Stakeholder  Strategy  

•  Managing  stakeholders  in  order  to  gain  and  sustain  


compe00ve  advantage  
–  Firms  analyze  and  manage  stakeholders  
–  Determine  how  external  and  internal  stakeholders  interact    
–  Stakeholders  can  create  and  trade  value  
•  Exemplifies  how  managers  can  act  to  improve  firm  
performance    
–  Enhances  compe00ve  advantage  
–  Enhances  con0nued  survival  
•  Example:  Target  Corpora0on  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Effec0ve  Stakeholder  Management  Benefits    
Firm  Performance  

1.  Coopera0on  and  informa0on  availability  


2.  Lowered  costs  
3.  Greater  organiza0onal  adaptability  and  flexibility  
4.  More  predictable  and  stable  returns  
5.  Stronger  reputa0on  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
“World’s  Most  Admired  Companies”  

•  Most  managers  care  about  public  percep0on.    


•  Fortune  magazine  publishes  the  “World’s  Most  
Admired  Companies”  annually:    
–  In  2014,  the  top  five  companies  were  Apple,  Amazon,  
Google,  Berkshire  Hathaway,  and  Starbucks.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Stakeholder  Impact  Analysis  (1  of  3)  

•  Primary  stakeholders:  achieve  their  objec0ves  


–  Shareholders  and  investors  
•  Other  stakeholders:  sa0sfy  concerns  
–  Employees,  suppliers,  and  customers  
•  Stakeholder  impact  analysis:  
–  A  decision  tool  
–  Managers  recognize,  priori0ze,  and  address  stakeholder  
needs  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Stakeholder  Impact  Analysis  (2  of  3)  

•  A  five-­‐step  process  recognizing  stakeholders’  claims.    


•  Managers  must  note  three  stakeholder  aBributes:    
–  Power    
–  Legi5macy    
–  Urgency  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Exhibit  1.3  Stakeholder  Impact  Analysis  (3  of  3)  

Jump  to  Appendix  3  long  image  


descrip0on  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Step  1:  Iden0fy  Stakeholders  

•  Focus  on  stakeholders  that  the  firm  has,  or  


poten0ally  can  have  
•  Iden0fy:  powerful  internal  and  external  stakeholders  
and  their  needs    
–  For  public-­‐stock  companies:  shareholders  and  suppliers  of  
capital  
–  Also:  customers,  suppliers,  and  unions  
•  Example:  Boeing  
–  Its  new  787  Dreamliner  will  be  built  in  its  non-­‐unionized  
South  Carolina  factory  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Step  2:  Iden0fy  Stakeholder  Interests  

•  Specify  and  assess  the  interests  and  claims  of  


stakeholders.  
•  Use  the  power,  legi0macy,  and  urgency  criteria.      
•  Shareholders:    
•  Legal  owners  
•  Have  legi0mate  claim  on  a  company’s  profits  
•  Employees  can  be  turned  into  shareholders.  
–  Coca-­‐Cola,  Google,  Microsoa,  Southwest  Airlines,  Starbucks,  
Walmart,  and  Whole  Foods  all  offer  stock  ownership  plans.  
•  Shareholder  ac0vists  put  public  pressure  on  a  company  
to  change  its  strategy,  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Step  3:  Iden0fy  Opportuni0es  and  Threats  

•  Opportuni0es  and  threats  are  two  sides  of  the  same  


coin.  
–  Example:  consumer  boycoBs  can  be  a  credible  threat.  
•  Example:  PETA:  called  for  a  boycoB  of  McDonald’s  due  to  alleged  
animal-­‐rights  abuses.  

•  Managers  should  try  to  transform  threats  into  


opportuni0es.  
–  Example:  Sony  
•  Dutch  government  blocked  PlaySta0on  shipments  due  to  a  toxic  
cable.  
•  Sony’s  response  included  a  redesign  of  its  supplier  management  
system.    

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Step  4:  Iden0fy  Societal  Responsibili0es  

•  “What  economic,  legal,  ethical,  and  philanthropic  


responsibili0es  do  we  have  to  our  stakeholders?”    
•  Corporate  Social  Responsibility  (CSR):  
–  A  framework  to  recognize  and  address  economic,  legal,  
social,  and  philanthropic  expecta0ons  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Exhibit 1.4 The Pyramid of Corporate Social
Responsibility  

SOURCE: Adapted from A. B. Carroll (1991), “The pyramid of corporate social responsibility: Toward
the moral management of organizational stakeholders,” Business Horizons, July-August: 42.

Jump  to  Appendix  4  long  image  


©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.   descrip0on  
Step  5:  Address  Stakeholder  Concerns  

•  Managers  decide  the  appropriate  course  of  ac0on.  


•  The  aBributes  of  power,  legi0macy,  and  urgency  
help  to  priori0ze  legi0mate  claims.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  Highlight  1.2  (1  of  4)  

•  On  April  20,  2010,  an  explosion  occurred.  


–  At  a  drilling  rig  off  the  Louisiana  coastline  
–  Killed  11  workers  
•  The  oil  spill  con0nued  for  over  three  months.  
•  It  released  an  es0mated  5  million  barrels  of  crude  oil  
into  the  Gulf  of  Mexico.  
–  The  largest  environmental  disaster  in  U.S.  history  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  Highlight  1.2  (2  of  4)  

•  The  cleanup  cost  was  $14  billion.  


•  Tony  Hayward,  BP’s  CEO  at  the  0me,  was  fired.  
•  Experts  said  BP’s  problems  were  systemic:  
–  Management  repeatedly  failed  to  put  a  safety  culture  in  
place.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  Highlight  1.2  (3  of  4)  

•  BP  faced  thousands  of  claims  by  many  small  business  


owners.    
–  Mainly  in  the  tourism  and  seafood  industries  
•  Collec0vely,  the  small  business  owners  became  
powerful  BP  stakeholders.  
•  BP  paid  out  over  $25  billion  to  seBle  their  claims.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  Highlight  1.2  (4  of  4)  

•  Total  cost  for  this  incident:  $60  billion  


•  The  Environmental  Protec0on  Agency  (EPA)  banned  
BP  from  any  new  contracts  with  the  U.S.  
government.  
•  This  ban  puts  BP  at  a  major  compe00ve  
disadvantage.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
The  AFI  Strategy  Framework  
 

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Overview  of  AFI  

•  Outlines  ac0ons  that  managers  take  to  gain  and  


sustain  compe00ve  advantage    
•  AFI  helps  managers  craa  and  execute  a  strategy  that  
enhances  the  chances  of  achieving  superior  
performance.    
•  AFI  includes  three  broad  tasks:    
–    Analyze  (A)  
–    Formulate  (F)  
–    Implement  (I)  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
The  AFI  Strategy  Framework  (1  of  2)  

•  AFI:  A  model  that  links  three  interdependent  strategic  


management  tasks  
–  Analyze  
–  Formulate  
–  Implement  
•  This  model  help  managers  plan  and  implement  a  strategy  
that  can  
–  Improve  performance  
–  Result  in  compe00ve  advantage.  
•  Each  of  these  tasks  are  interdependent.  
•  Each  of  these  tasks  can  happen  simultaneously.  
©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Exhibit  1.5  The  AFI  Strategy  Framework  (2  of  2)  

Jump  to  Appendix  5  long  image  


descrip0on  
©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  Analysis  (A)  Topics  and  Ques0ons  

•  Strategic  leadership  and  the  strategy  process:    


–  What  roles  do  strategic  leaders  play?  What  are  the  firm’s  vision,  mission,  and  
values?  What  is  the  firm’s  process  for  crea0ng  strategy  and  how  does  strategy  
come  about?  (Chapter  2)  
•  External  analysis:    
–  What  effects  do  forces  in  the  external  environment  have  on  the  firm’s  poten0al  to  
gain  and  sustain  a  compe00ve  advantage?  How  should  the  firm  deal  with  them?  
(Chapter  3)  
•  Internal  analysis:    
–  What  effects  do  internal  resources,  capabili0es,  and  core  competencies  have  on  
the  firm’s  poten0al  to  gain  and  sustain  a  compe00ve  advantage?  How  should  the  
firm  leverage  them  for  compe00ve  advantage?  (Chapter  4)  
•  Compe00ve  advantage,  firm  performance,  and  business  models:    
–  How  does  the  firm  make  money?  How  can  one  assess  and  measure  compe00ve  
advantage?  What  is  the  rela0onship  between  compe00ve  advantage  and  firm  
performance?  (Chapter  5)  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  Formula0on  (F)  Topics  and  Ques0ons  

•  Business  strategy:    
–  How  should  the  firm  compete:  cost  leadership,  
differen0a0on,  or  integra0on?  (Chapters  6  and  7)  
•  Corporate  strategy:    
–  Where  should  the  firm  compete:  industry,  markets,  and  
geography?  (Chapters  8  and  9)  
•  Global  strategy:    
–  How  and  where  should  the  firm  compete:  local,  regional,  
na0onal,  or  interna0onal?  (Chapter  10)  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  Implementa0on  (I)  Topics  and  Ques0ons  

•  Organiza0onal  design:    
–  How  should  the  firm  organize  to  turn  the  formulated  
strategy  into  ac0on?  (Chapter  11)  
•  Corporate  governance  and  business  ethics:    
–  What  type  of  corporate  governance  is  most  effec0ve?  How  
does  the  firm  anchor  strategic  decisions  in  business  ethics?  
(Chapter  12)  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Implica0ons  for  the  Strategist  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
The  Difference  Between  Success  and  Failure    
Lies  in  a  Firm’s  Strategy  

•  Applying  tools  and  frameworks  can  enable  your  firm  


to  be  more  successful.  
•  You  can  apply  the  strategic  management  toolkit  to  
your  own  career:  
–  To  pursue  your  professional  goals    
–  Reference  the  myStrategy  modules  
•  Strategy  is  the  art  and  science  of  success  and  failure  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Compe00on  Is  Everywhere  

•  Strategic  management  principles  can  be  applied  


universally.  
•  Strategists  work  in:  
–  Small  start-­‐ups  and  large,  mul0-­‐na0onal  companies  
–  For-­‐profit  and  nonprofit  organiza0ons  
–  Private  and  public  sectors  
–  Developed  and  emerging  economies    

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
The  Strategist  Follows  a  Three-­‐step  Process  

1.  Analyze  the  external  and  internal  environments.  


2.  Formulate  an  appropriate  business  and  corporate  
strategy.  
3.  Implement  the  formulated  strategy  through  
structure,  culture,  and  controls.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
The  Role  of  Uncertainty  and  Complexity  

•  Decisions  must  consider  uncertainty  and  complexity.  


•  Maintain  awareness  of  key  stakeholders.  
–  They  can  affect  or  be  affected  by  decisions.  
•  Monitor  and  evaluate  progress  toward  strategic  
objec0ves.    
–  Make  adjustments  as  necessary.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Chapter  1  Summary  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Take Away Concepts (1 of 5)

LO  1-­‐1  Explain  the  role  of  strategy  in  a  firm’s  quest  for  compe55ve  
advantage.  
• Strategy  is  the  set  of  goal-­‐directed  ac0ons  a  firm  takes  to  gain  and  sustain  
superior  performance  rela0ve  to  compe0tors.  

• A  good  strategy  enables  a  firm  to  achieve  superior  performance.  It  consists  
of  three  elements:  
–  A  diagnosis  of  the  compe00ve  challenge.  
–  A  guiding  policy  to  address  the  compe00ve  challenge.  
–  A  set  of  coherent  ac0ons  to  implement  the  firm’s  guiding  policy.  

• A  successful  strategy  requires  three  integra0ve  management  tasks—analysis,  


formula0on,  and  implementa0on.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Take Away Concepts (2 of 5)

LO  1-­‐2  Define  compe55ve  advantage,  sustainable  compe55ve  advantage,  


compe55ve  disadvantage,  and  compe55ve  parity.  
• Compe00ve  advantage  is  always  judged  rela0ve  to  other  compe0tors  or  the  industry  
average.  
• To  obtain  a  compe00ve  advantage,  a  firm  must  either  create  more  value  for  
customers  while  keeping  its  cost  comparable  to  compe0tors,  or  it  must  provide  the  
value  equivalent  to  compe0tors  but  at  a  lower  cost.  
• A  firm  able  to  outperform  compe0tors  for  prolonged  periods  of  0me  has  a  sustained  
compe00ve  advantage.  
• A  firm  that  con0nuously  underperforms  its  rivals  or  the  industry  average  has  a  
compe00ve  disadvantage.  
• Two  or  more  firms  that  perform  at  the  same  level  have  compe00ve  parity.  
• An  effec0ve  strategy  requires  that  strategic  trade-­‐offs  be  recognized  and  addressed—
for  example,  between  value  crea0on  and  the  costs  to  create  the  value.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Take Away Concepts (3 of 5)

LO  1-­‐3  Differen5ate  the  roles  of  firm  effects  and  industry  effects  in  
determining  firm  performance.  
• A  firm’s  performance  is  more  closely  related  to  its  managers’  ac0ons  (firm  
effects)  than  to  the  external  circumstances  surrounding  it  (industry  effects).  
• Firm  and  industry  effects,  however,  are  interdependent.  Both  are  relevant  in  
determining  firm  performance.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Take Away Concepts (4 of 5)

LO  1-­‐4  Evaluate  the  rela5onship  between  stakeholder  strategy  and  


sustainable  compe55ve  advantage.  
• Stakeholders  are  individuals  or  groups  that  have  a  claim  or  interest  in  the  
performance  and  con0nued  survival  of  the  firm.  They  make  specific  contribu0ons  for  
which  they  expect  rewards  in  return.  
• Internal  stakeholders  include  stockholders,  employees  (for  instance,  execu0ves,  
managers,  and  workers),  and  board  members.  
• External  stakeholders  include  customers,  suppliers,  alliance  partners,  creditors,  
unions,  communi0es,  and  governments  at  various  levels.  
• Several  recent  black  swan  events  eroded  the  public’s  trust  in  business  as  an  
ins0tu0on  and  in  free  -­‐market  capitalism  as  an  economic  system.  
• The  effec0ve  management  of  stakeholders—the  organiza0on,  groups,  or  individuals  
that  can  materially  affect  or  are  affected  by  the  ac0on  of  a  firm—is  necessary  to  
ensure  the  con0nued  survival  of  the  firm  and  to  sustain  any  compe00ve  advantage.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Take Away Concepts (5 of 5)

LO  1-­‐5  Conduct  a  stakeholder  impact  analysis.  


 

• Stakeholder  impact  analysis  considers  the  needs  of  different  stakeholders,  


which  process  enables  the  firm  to  perform  op0mally  and  to  live  up  to  the  
expecta0ons  of  good  ci0zenship.  
• In  a  stakeholder  impact  analysis,  managers  pay  par0cular  aBen0on  to  three  
important  stakeholder  aBributes:  power,  legi0macy,  and  urgency.  
• Stakeholder  impact  analysis  is  a  five-­‐step  process  that  answers  the  following  
ques0ons  for  the  firm:    
1.  Who  are  our  stakeholders?  
2.  What  are  our  stakeholders’  interests  and  claims?  
3.  What  opportuni0es  and  threats  do  our  stakeholders  present?  
4.  What  economic,  legal,  and  ethical  responsibili0es  do  we  have  to  our  
stakeholders?  
5.  What  should  we  do  to  effec0vely  address  the  stakeholder  concerns?  
©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Key  Terms  
•  AFI  strategy  framework   •  Industry  effects  
•  Black  swan  events   •  Stakeholders  
•  Compe00ve  advantage     •  Stakeholder  impact  analysis  
•  Compe00ve  disadvantage   •  Stakeholder  strategy  
•  Compe00ve  parity     •  Strategic  management  
•  Corporate  social   •  Strategy    
responsibility  (CSR)    
•  Sustainable  compe00ve  
•  Firm  effects   advantage  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Chapter  1  Cases  &  Exercises  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Chapter  Case  1:  Consider  This…  (1  of  2)  

•  Launched  in  2006  


•  Users  send  short  messages:  “tweets”  
•  Restricted  to  140  characters  
•  300  million  worldwide  ac0ve  users  
•  TwiBer’s  business  model:  
–  Grow  its  user  base  
–  Charge  adver0sers  for  promo0on  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Chapter  Case  1:  Consider  This…  (2  of  2)  

•  Why  is  TwiBer  struggling?    


•  What  role  do  industry  and  firm  effects?    
•  What  grade  would  you  give  Dick  Costolo?  
–  TwiBer’s  CEO  from  2010  un0l  2015  
•  Why  is  craaing  a  good  strategy  at  TwiBer  so  difficult?    

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
My  Strategy  Exercise  

•  Considera0ons  for  your  career  choices  


•  Referencing  Table  1.1:  
–  What  effect  does  industry  growth  play  in  your  career  
choices?  
–  Why  are  growth  rates  an  important  considera0on?    

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Small  Group  Exercise  

•  Hurricanes  Katrina  and  Sandy  highlighted  the  need  


for:  
•  Resilient  infrastructure  and  buildings  
•  More  flexible  &  effec0ve  responses  
•  Each  group  should  search  the  Internet  for  op0ons  
and  plans  to:    
–  (1)  build  more  sustainable  communi0es  
–  (2)  organize  responses  to  black  swan  events    
–  (3)  addi0onal  recommenda0ons  for  policy  makers  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
End  of  Chapter  01  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy  Smart  Videos  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy Smart Videos (1 of 6)

•  Professor  Frank  T.  Rothaermel  


•  Meet  your  textbook  author  -­‐  a  personal  introduc0on  
•  Link:  
–  hBps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SsQfXrFNqo  
•  1:55  Minutes  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy Smart Videos (2 of 6)

•  Professor  Frank  T.  Rothaermel  


•  An  Overview  of  Your  Textbook  
•  Link:  
–  hBps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=85-­‐A8Wz14PU  
•  1:59  Minutes  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy Smart Videos (3 of 6)

•  Professor  Michael  E.  Porter  


•  What  is  Strategy?  
•  Link:    
–  hBps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NY4myVa5Wkw  
•  1:46  Minutes  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy Smart Videos (4 of 6)

•  Professor  Michael  E.  Porter  


•  2  cri0cal  aspects  of  management:    
1.  Have  the  right  goal  -­‐  to  achieve  a  superior  return  on  investment.  
2.  Differen0a0on  -­‐  to  be  beBer  and  unique  from  your  compe0tors.  

•  Link:    
–  hBps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8NZ|cNMrM  
•  1:35  Minutes  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy Smart Videos (5 of 6)

•  An  Interview  with  Warren  BuffeB  


•  Maintaining  the  Compe00ve  Advantage  
•  Link:    
–  hBps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3Qh9iVlLoE  
•  The  first  2:06  minutes  of  an  8:48  minute  video  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Strategy Smart Videos (6 of 6)

•  Doreen  Shanahan,  Professor  of  Marke0ng  at  


Pepperdine  University  
•  7  Steps  to  Crea0ng  a  Compe00ve  Advantage  
•  Link:    
–  hBps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BM4nNsvmRaE  
•  5:29  Minutes  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Chapter  Case  1  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Chapter Case 1: Twitter (1 of 2)

•  TwiBer  is  currently  not  flying  high.  


–  In  2015,  stock  was  50%  what  it  was  in  2013.  
–  Departure  of  CEO  who  served  from  2010-­‐2015  
–  Turmoil  among  execu0ve  ranks  
•  Overview  of  TwiBer  
–  Users  send  short  messages  of  140  characters.  
–  Users  can  follow  each  other.  
–  300  million  ac0ve  users  worldwide  
•  TwiBer  appears  constantly  in  the  mass  media.  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Chapter Case 1: Twitter (2 of 2)

•  Business  model  
–  Grow  user  base  (individual  users  pay  nothing)  
–  Adver0sers  charged  for  promo0on  of  goods/services.  
–  Companies  pay  for  promoted  tweets.  
–  Ads  can  be  delivered  real  0me.  
•  TwiBer’s  current  challenges  
–  Turnover  /  reshuffling  in  management  &  engineering  
–  Struggles  to  grow  its  user  base  
•  TwiBer  =  300  million;  Facebook  =  1.5  billion  
•  User  growth  con0nues  to  slow  
–  Could  it  be  taken  over?  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Appendix  1  The  AFI  Strategy  Framework  
This  image  shows  several  circles,  represen0ng  the  main  themes  from  the  textbook,  as  well  as  how  the  chapters  map  
into  each  theme.  The  important  inside  circle  is  0tled  "Gaining  and  Sustaining  a  Compe00ve  Advantage"  that  is  at  the  
very  center  of  the  image,  with  five  different  circles  on  the  outside  of  it.  Arrows  go  back  and  forth  from  the  center  circle  
to  each  of  the  five  outer  circles.  The  five  outer  circles  are  labeled:  (1)  Gehng  Started,  (2)  External  and  Internal  Analysis,  
(3)  Formula0on:  Business  Strategy,  (4)  Formula0on,  Corporate  Strategy,  and  (5)  Implementa0on.  

Each  of  these  outer  five  circles  have  a  brief  descrip0on  beside  them  to  explain  what  the  circle  means:  

Under  the  first  outer  circle  0tled  "Gehng  Started",  it  says:  Part  1,  Strategy  Analysis,  "What  is  Strategy  (Chapter  1)"  and  
"Strategic  Leadership:  Managing  the  Strategy  Process  (Chapter  2)."  

Under  the  second  outer  circle  0tled  "External  and  Internal  Analysis",  it  says:  Part  1,  Strategy  Analysis,  "External  Analysis:  
Industry  Structure,  Compe00ve  Forces  and  Strategic  Groups  (Chapter  3)",  "Internal  Analysis:  Resources,  Capabili0es  and  
Core  Competencies  (Chapter  4)",  and  "Compe00ve  Advantage,  Firm  Performance,  and  Business  Models  (Chapter  5)."  

Under  the  third  outer  circle  0tled  "Formula0on:  Business  Strategy",  it  says:  Part  2,  Strategy  Formula0on,  "Business  
Strategy:  Differen0a0on,  Cost  Leadership  and  Integra0on  (Chapter  6)"  and  "Business  Strategy,  Innova0on  and  
Entrepreneurship  (Chapter  7)."  

Under  the  fourth  outer  circle  0tled  "Formula0on:  Corporate  Strategy",  it  says:  Part  2,  Strategy  Formula0on,  "Corporate  
Strategy:  Ver0cal  Integra0on  and  Diversifica0on  (Chapter  8)",  "Corporate  Strategy:  Strategic  Alliances,  Mergers  and  
Acquisi0ons  (Chapter  9)",  and  "Global  Strategy:  Compe0ng  Around  the  World  (Chapter  10)."  

Under  the  fiah  outer  circle  0tled  "Implementa0on",  it  says:  Part  3,  Strategy  Implementa0on,  "Organiza0onal  Design:  
Structure,  Culture  and  Control  (Chapter  11)",  and  "Corporate  Governance  and  Business  Ethics  (Chapter  12)."  

Return  to  slide  


©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Appendix  2  Exhibit  1.2  Internal  and  External  Stakeholders  in  
an  Exchange  Rela0onship  with  the  Firm    

This  image  shows  a  firm  in  the  middle,  with  External  Stakeholders  on  the  lea  
side  of  it  and  Internal  Stakeholders  on  the  right.  An  arrow  points  from  the  
firm  to  External  Stakeholders  named  "Benefits,"  and  an  arrow  points  from  
External  Stakeholders  to  the  firm  named  "Contribu0ons."  Under  External  
Stakeholders  are  the  following  sub-­‐bullets:  customers,  media,  suppliers,  
alliance  partners,  creditors,  unions,  communi0es  and  governments.  An  arrow  
points  from  the  firm  to  Internal  Stakeholders  named  "Benefits,”  and  an  arrow  
points  from  Internal  Stakeholders  to  the  firm  named  "Contribu0ons."  Under  
Internal  Stakeholders  are  the  following  sub-­‐bullets:  employees,  stockholders,  
and  board  members.  

Return  to  slide  


©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Appendix  3  Exhibit  1.3  Stakeholder  Impact  Analysis  (3  of  3)    

Step  1  -­‐  Who  are  our  stakeholders?  


Step  2  -­‐  What  are  our  stakeholders'  interests  and  claims?  
Step  3  -­‐  What  opportuni0es  and  threats  do  our  stakeholders  
present?  
Step  4  -­‐  What  economic,  legal,  ethical  and  philanthropic  
responsibili0es  do  we  have  to  our  stakeholders?  
Step  5  -­‐  What  should  we  do  to  effec0vely  address  stakeholder  
concerns?  

Return  to  slide  

©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Appendix  4  Exhibit  1.4  The  Pyramid  of    
Corporate  Social  Responsibility  

This  image  depicts  a  pyramid,  with  four  separate  sec0ons.  The  boBom  (and  
broadest)  sec0on  is  named  Economic  Responsibili0es,  the  next  smaller  one  
up  is  labeled  Legal  Responsibili0es,  the  next  smaller  one  up  is  named  Ethical  
Responsibili0es,  and  at  the  top  of  the  pyramid  is  Philanthropic  
Responsibili0es.  A  brief  clarifica0on  for  each  sec0on  of  the  pyramid  is  
provided:    
Economic  responsibili0es  -­‐  gain  and  sustain  compe00ve  advantage  
Legal  responsibili0es  -­‐  laws  and  regula0ons  are  society's  codified  ethics.  
Define  minimum  acceptable  standard  
Ethical  responsibili0es  -­‐  do  what  is  right,  just,  and  fair  
Philanthropic  responsibili0es  -­‐  corporate  ci0zenship  

Return  to  slide  


©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  
Appendix  5  Exhibit  1.5  The  AFI  Strategy  Framework  (2  of  2)  

This  image  shows  several  circles,  represen0ng  the  main  themes  from  the  textbook,  as  well  as  how  the  chapters  map  into  each  
theme.  The  important  inside  circle  is  0tled  "Gaining  and  Sustaining  a  Compe00ve  Advantage"  that  is  at  the  very  center  of  the  
image,  with  five  different  circles  on  on  the  outside  of  it.  Arrows  go  back  and  forth  from  the  center  circle  to  each  of  the  five  outer  
circles.  The  five  outer  circles  are  labeled:  (1)  Gehng  Started,  (2)  External  and  Internal  Analysis,  (3)  Formula0on:  Business  Strategy,  
(4)  Formula0on,  Corporate  Strategy,  and  (5)  Implementa0on.  

Each  of  these  outer  five  circles  have  a  brief  descrip0on  beside  them  to  explain  what  the  circle  means:  

Under  the  first  outer  circle  0tled  "Gehng  Started",  it  says:  Part  1,  Strategy  Analysis,  "What  is  Strategy  (Chapter  1)"  and  "Strategic  
Leadership:  Managing  the  Strategy  Process  (Chapter  2)".  

Under  the  second  outer  circle  0tled  "External  and  Internal  Analysis",  it  says:  Part  1,  Strategy  Analysis,  "External  Analysis:  Industry  
Structure,  Compe00ve  Forces  and  Strategic  Groups  (Chapter  3)",  "Internal  Analysis:  Resources,  Capabili0es  and  Core  
Competencies  (Chapter  4)",  and  "Compe00ve  Advantage,  Firm  Performance,  and  Business  Models  (Chapter  5)".  

Under  the  third  outer  circle  0tled  "Formula0on:  Business  Strategy",  it  says:  Part  2,  Strategy  Formula0on,  "Business  Strategy:  
Differen0a0on,  Cost  Leadership  and  Integra0on  (Chapter  6)"  and  "Business  Strategy,  Innova0on  and  Entrepreneurship  (Chapter  
7)".  

Under  the  fourth  outer  circle  0tled  "Formula0on:  Corporate  Strategy",  it  says:  Part  2,  Strategy  Formula0on,  "Corporate  Strategy:  
Ver0cal  Integra0on  and  Diversifica0on  (Chapter  8)",  "Corporate  Strategy:  Strategic  Alliances,  Mergers  and  Acquisi0ons  (Chapter  
9)",  and  "Global  Strategy:  Compe0ng  Around  the  World  (Chapter  10)".  

Under  the  fiah  outer  circle  0tled  "Implementa0on",  it  says:  Part  3,  Strategy  Implementa0on,  "Organiza0onal  Design:  Structure,  
Culture  and  Control  (Chapter  11)",  and  "Corporate  Governance  and  Business  Ethics  (Chapter  12)".  

Return  to  slide  


©McGraw-­‐Hill  Educa0on.  

You might also like