Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spirals
Article Index
Chapter E. Spirals
2. Applications
3. Nomenclature & Parts
4. Stationing
5. Deflection Angle Method
6. Five- or ten-chord spiral
7. Example
8. Staking a Spiraled Horizontal Curve
9. Power Series Method
10. Spirals and Coordinates
11. Spreadsheet
12. Summary
All Pages
1. Concepts
Spirals were mentioned in the Basic Concepts section of Chapter C. Horizontal
Curves. In this chapter, we will go into more detail.
Recall that a spiral arc, Figure E-1, has a constantly changing radius.
Figure E-1
This characteristic has advantages in route applications, discussed in the next
section, as well as presenting computational challenges. While a more complex
geometric curve than a circular arc, a few reasonable assumptions can simplify its
calculation.
2. Applications
a. Direction transition
Because curvature is introduced progressively, the driver gradually changes the
steering wheel angle allowing a more natural direction transition.
Figure E-2
Steering wheel angle along a spiral
b. Force balancing
A vehicle traveling a curved path at constant velocity is subject to a centrifugal force,
CV, pushing it (and its occupants) to the outside of the curve, Figure E-3(a). If the
pavement cross-slope is flat, only the friction between the tires and road surface
prevents the vehicle from sliding off the curve, Figure E-3(b). In low friction situations
(rain, snow, etc), sliding will occur at lower speeds. Banking the pavement cross-
slope into the curve, Figure E-3(c), allows part of the vehicle weight to work with
friction to offset the centrifugal force. This banking is called superelevation, e.
Figure E-4
Cross-section along a spiral
It is primarily because of this force balancing characteristic that spirals are used in
high-speed railroad alignments. More on that in the to-be-developed Superelevation
chapter.
c. Design flexibility
Combining spirals with (or without) intermediate circular arcs allows greater design
flexibility particularly in limited spaces and where large directional changes are
involved. Consider the two alignment segments in Figure E-5(a) which are to be
connected via a cloverleaf interchange. Traveling North to West, the directional
change is 270° degrees. Figure E-5(b) shows three alternative curve systems to
connect the two alignments. This interchange type is used extensively in high speed
situations where the driver must decelerate, negotiate a large direction change, then
accelerate to match traffic. It should be a smooth and surprise-free driver
experience.
Equation E-2
The original circular arc's central angle is reduced by the spirals', Equation E-3.
Δc: Reduced arc central angle
Equation E-3 Δ: Total central angle
Δs: Spiral central angle
And its shortened length is determined from Equation E-4 (modified from Chapter C.
Horizontal Curves Equation C-2).
Equation E-4
Location of the TS from the PI along with tangent distances and offsets from the TS
to the OBC and SC are shown in Figure E-9.
(a) (b)
Xo: Tangent distance to OBC
LCs: Spiral long chord
o: Tangent offset to OBC
A: Spiral deflection angle
X: Tangent distance to SC
Ts: Spiral tangent
Y: Tangent offset to SC
Figure E-9
Tangent Distances
The distances and offsets are computed using Equations E-5 through E-10
Equation E-5
Equation E-6
Equation E-7
Equation E-8
Equation E-9
Equation E-10
Because spirals are short and very flat, arc distances are often used to approximate
chord distances. The is the case with Equations E-5 through E-7: the spiral length,
Ls, is used for the spiral chord, LCs. In most cases, this assumption will be fine,
however, we'll discuss a more exact, though more complex, spiral computing method
also.
4. Stationing
Referring to Figure E-7, curve endpoint stations are determined using Equations E-
11 through E-15.
Equation E-11
Equation E-12
Equation E-13
Equation E-14
Equation E-15
As with a regular horizontal curve, a station equation exists at the point where the
curve system exits onto the tangent at the ST.
The arc distances between the points (ie, Staj - Stai) are used as chords. While this
does introduce some error, because of the spiral's geometry, the error is relatively
small.
Figure E-10
Deflection Angle Method
General calculations are based on these spiral properties for any point referenced to
the flat end:
Figure E-11
Deflection Angle Geometry
For any spiral point i:
Equation E-16 Arc distance
Deflection angle,
Equation E-20
degrees
Although not needed for the traditional deflection angle method, the tangent distance
and offset to a curve point, Figure E-12, can be computed using Equations E-21 and
E-22.
Equation E-21
Equation E-22
Figure E-12
Tangent Distance and Offset
Tangent distances (xi) and offsets (yi) can be used to compute radial chords from the
TS to the respective curve point, Figure E-13 and Equation E-23.
Figure E-13
Radial Chord
Equation E-23
As with the point-to-point condition, generally the arc distances can be used as radial
chord distances. We see this shortly in an example.
a. Set up
A N75°00'00"E tangent intersects a S60°00'00"E tangent at station 43+31.10. A
circular arc with a 9°00'00 degree of curvature will be used together with 300.00 ft
entrance and exit spirals.
Compute radial stake out notes using 5-chord spirals and arc half stations.
b. Spiral components
e. Five-chord spiral
Length of each chord:
Set up the curve table and solve ai for each curve point. Indicate appropriate math
checks.
Chord Num li, ft ai
1 60.00 0°10'48"
2 120.00 0°43'12"
3 180.00 1°37'12"
4 240.00 2°52'48"
5 300.00 = Ls 4°30'00" = Δs/3
Set up and solve Equations E-21 through E-23 for radial chords:
Notice that the radial chord to each point is the same as its spiral distance. Because
the spiral is short and flat, spiral arc and radial chord distances are (essentially) the
same. That simplifies spiral computations and staking considerably: use arc distance
as radial chord for each point.
a. Establish TS and ST
Set TS and ST points at distance Ts from PI along each tangent.
Figure E-15
Spiral Total Deflection Angles
To correctly orient an instrument at the SC, the surveyor would, Figure E-16:
Figure E-16
Staking the Circular Arc
Equation E-24
Equation E-25
δi in Equations E-24 and E-25 is in radians; it is computed with Equation E-18.
Although both equations have an infinite number of terms, each term is substantially
smaller so only the first three need be used.
Radial chords are computed using Equation E-23 and deflection angles using
Equation E-26.
Equation E-26
b. Example
Using the spiral of the previous example, set up and solve the spiral curve table.
Compare this curve table to the first table in Section 7e. The results of this "more
exact" calculations are basically the same as those based on approximations.
Should a much longer spiral or one with a great radii difference be used, the
approximations may be might introduce measurable error in which case the power
series equations should be used.
10. Spirals and Coordinates
As with most surveying stake out operations, having point coordinates makes for
more flexible field operation.
Starting with directions of the incoming and outgoing tangents along with the PI
coordinates, the process to compute point coordinates are:
Figure E-17
TS and ST Coordinates
These are computed using Equations E-27 through E-31.
Figure E-18
Arc Coordinates
Arc points are computed using equations E-38 through E-40. Right deflection angles
are positive, left are negative.
Math check? The coordinates of the CS computed from the SC should match those
computed from the ST.
11. Spreadsheet
An Excel spreadsheet to perfom basic spiral computations can be downloaded here.
It uses Visual Basic for Applications script so Excel must have macros enabled when
loading the sheet.
12. Summary
Although more geometrically complex than circular arcs, spirals are relatively easy to
compute using approximate relationships. The argument against their use due to
computation complexity really isn't valid as shown by the example.
However, despite their transportation applications advantages, spiral use is limited
primarily to railroads. Trains have a mechanical connection between wheel flanges
and rails, in essence, infinite friction. Because the train's wheels cannot slip across
the rails as can tires on pavement, lateral force is directly imparted to the rails as the
train enters and travels around a curve. If a simple curve is used, then maximum
centrifugal force is instantaneously introduced at BC the since the train must follow
the tracks. A spiral's changing radius allows the centrifugal force to gradually
increase (entrance) then decrease (exit), balancing the forces. Running a train over
an simple horizontal curve over time will eventually shift the rail alignment into a
spiraled configuration because of the forces.
In high speed highway designs, horizontal circular curves are typically long and flat,
making for smooth tangent-curve-tangent transitions, minimal centrifugal force, and
lower superelevation rates. Spirals aren't needed in these situations. Spirals can be
used beneficially in case of large direction changes over limited areas, such as
interchanges.
Spiral use is up to the designer but as shown in this Chapter, they are no more
difficult to understand or compute than circular arcs.