RUBRIC FOR BKF3731 UNIT OPERATION LAB 2018/2019-II

UNIT OPERATION LAB

(BKF3731)
2019/2020 Semester I

Title of Experiment :
Date of Experiment :
Instructor’s Name :

Group of Member :
Name ID
1. K
2. K
3. K
4. K

Group No. :
Section :
Marks :

FACULTY OF CHEMICAL AND NATURAL RESOURCES ENGINEERING

UNIVERSITI MALAYSIA PAHANG

Please keep for student reference.

Submitted by; Received by;

( )
( )

Subject Code : BKF3731

Title of Experiment : Date Submitted:
1

Item Assessed
Organization and Format x 1
Keywords: Front page, Content,
Page No., Total page <15 pages,
Arrangement
Abstract x 2
Keywords: Introduction, Objective,
Method, Result, Conclusion,
Suggestion, 1 page
Introduction x 1
Keywords: Related Theory,
Principles, Process Background
Methodology Flowchart x 2
Keywords: Experiment Procedure,
List of Equipment, Specify the
value, Make as flow chart
Data Processing & Analysis x 2
Keywords: Data calculation, graph
presentation, table presentation
Instruction: Please assess each item using the given scales. Fractional marks will be given for each category.
Unacceptable
(0)
Not follow FKKSA laboratory
report format. Not well
organized. Contents show lack of
knowledge.
No abstract
Very little background
information or information is
incorrect OR, does not give any
information about what to expect
in the laboratory report
No flowchart of the method is
presented.
Missing several important
explanations of materials and/or
methodology. Not sequential.
Most steps are missing or are
confusing. Some procedural
components generally described
but are not replicable.
Calculations not shown or totally
wrong. No table or graph are
present.
REPORT EVALUATION RUBRIC
Acceptable
(1)
Partially follow FKKSA
laboratory report format.
Contents show enough of
knowledge but still a few concept
and ideas are loosely connected.
Abstract misses one or more
major aspects of laboratory
report.
Some introductory information,
but still missing some major
points. OR, gives little
information
Method flowchart is nearly
complete but still missing some
important experimental details.
Calculation was provided but
with some error.
RUBRIC FOR BKF3731 UNIT OPERATION LAB 2018/2019-II
Good
(2)
Follow FKKSA laboratory report
format of writing; all needed
sections present. Well organized.
Abstract contains most major
aspects of laboratory report but
the writing style can be further
improved.
Introduction is nearly complete,
missing some minor points.
Method flowchart is explained
with sufficient detail; some lack
detail or are confusing. Mostly
easy to follow.
Corrected calculation.
Incomplete or in adequate data
organization in term of table or
graph form.
Very Good
Score
(3)
Follow FKKSA laboratory report
format of writing; all needed
sections present. Tables and
figures are correctly drawn and
numbered. Excellent organized
and easily followed
Abstract contains references to
all major aspects of laboratory
report i.e. main purpose of the
experiment, its importance,
methodology/ approach, most
significant results or findings,
main conclusions and/or
recommendation.
General audience easily
understands abstract.
Introduction is complete and well
written; provides all necessary
background principles and theory
for the experiment. Present a
concise lead-in to the laboratory
experiment.
Method flowchart is complete.
Logical and easily followed.
Description of procedure is
complete, ensuring that it can be
replicated.
Correct and complete calculation.
Data was organized well in term
of table or graph.
2

Item Assessed
Results Discussion x 2
Keywords: Experiment Summary,
Recommendation
Conclusions and recommendations
x1
Keywords: Experiment Summary,
Recommendation
References x 1
Keywords: Book Reference, Journal
Reference, Website Reference;
Reliable
Appendices x1
Keywords: Raw result and proper
data collection
Grammar and Spelling x1
Keywords: Language
Timeliness x 1
Keywords: Punctuality
Unacceptable
(0)
Only mention the results
without meaningful
discussion
.
No conclusions given. No
recommendation given to
improve the experiment.
No citations in the text but
showed a list of reference Some
citations in text are not available
in list of reference.
Appendices not available in
laboratory report.
Numerous spelling and/or
grammar errors. Transitions
confusing and unclear.
Laboratory report handed in more
than one week late
Acceptable
(1)
Attempt to discuss
but failed miserably
Conclusion missing the important
points. Or
Conclusion is too general.
Several recommendations have
been given but they are too
general and not contributing to
the experiment’s improvement.
Some citations in text are not
available in list of reference. OR
ununiformed referencing
system OR more than 80%
references from internet or
wikipedia
Only a few appendices available
in laboratory report.
Still many spelling and/or
grammar errors. Few or weak
transitions, often wanders and
jumps around.
Up to one week late
RUBRIC FOR BKF3731 UNIT OPERATION LAB 2018/2019-II
Good
(2)
Elucidation of result but
contains some flaws
Conclusions regarding major
points are drawn, but many
are misstated, indicating a
lack of understanding Several
recommendations have been
stated and they are partially
contributed to the experiment’s
improvement.
All citations in text are available
in list of reference but some of
the reference is not reliable.
Appendices available in
laboratory report but poorly
constructed
Occasional grammar/spelling
errors. May have a few unclear
transitions.
Handed in one day late
TOTAL MARKS (45 Marks)
Very Good
Score
(3)
Elucidation and supported by
proper references or logical
explanations.
All the important conclusions
have been clearly made.
Conclusion is precisely stated
and relates the study to general
interest, other studies that have
been conducted.
Recommendations given are
significantly contribute to the
experiment’s improvement
All citations in text are available
in list of reference. All references
from variety sources and reliable.
Appendices available in
laboratory report in structured
manners, clearly and precise
Minimal to no spelling mistakes.
Spell checked and proofed
throughout. Good sentence and
paragraph structure and
transitions.
Laboratory report handed in on
time
3
RUBRIC FOR BKF3731 UNIT OPERATION LAB 2018/2019-II