Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EXTENDED FAMILIES
JAMES M. HARPER AND SUSANNE FROST OLSEN
Therefore shall a man leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife: and they
shall be one flesh. —Genesis 2:24
(Page 327) Nathan and Catherine had been married less than a year when it was time
for the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays. Because they lived close to both sets of parents,
they had to decide how to spend the holidays. Catherine's parents told them they wanted them
to come to their home for Thanksgiving dinner, Christmas Eve dinner, and on Christmas
morning to open presents. Nathans parents asked them to dinner on Thanksgiving and
Christmas. Nathan and Catherine were presented with decisions they had never had to make
before; they loved their families and wanted to be with them, but they also hoped to establish
their own family traditions.
One of the major opportunities the formation of a new marriage offers is that of
negotiating relationships between the families the spouses grew up in and the partnership they
create through marriage. In this chapter we discuss the commandment that newly married
couples should leave their parents and cleave unto their spouses. We also discuss establishing a
marital identity, accepting differences, and including new spouses in the extended family
ACCEPTING DIFFERENCES
Marrying into a family that is different from yours or has different values can be a
challenge. Demonstrating humor, exercising patience, overlooking small irritations, and looking
for the positive can help in dealing with differences.¹⁵ One woman said: "When I met [his]
parents … I didn't agree with them on religion, politics, or even on how to cook a pot roast. I
really wasn't even sure if I liked them. But then l had to remember they had raised [my
husband] and I loved him, so there must be something good about them. At that point, I began
to enjoy their differences, and to love them, too."¹⁶
Mothers-in-law usually discover early that their daughters-in-law are not like them, and
in some cases, this may be upsetting. Parents who are more enmeshed with their children hold
expectations that their children-in-law will be like them. A more realistic expectation is that
children-in-law will bring new perspectives into the family, and the family can learn from these
differences and be complemented by them. This may be especially difficult when a child
marries someone who is less active or not a member, or a child marries someone who is the
only member of the Church in his or her family. Parents who can work toward inclusion of a
new son- or daughter-in-law and who show increased love and support have the best
relationships with their married children and more influence in the lives of their
grandchildren.¹⁷
Difference is something that can be anticipated and even looked forward to because of
its potential for creating growth in family members. Prayer, fasting, and loving long-suffering
are the best remedies when differences of children-in-law bother us.¹⁸ Where there are strong
differences, personality clashes, or even past offenses, it is important to lay those aside at
extended family gatherings and treat each other with politeness, dignity, and respect. Paul's
statement to the Corinthians is relevant: "For as the body is one, and hath many
members,…and the eye cannot say unto the hand, I have no need of thee: nor again the head
to the feet, I have no need of you" (1 Corinthians 12:12, 21–23).
CONCLUSION
In summary, parents-in-law will do well to accept differences; encourage marital
identity by helping develop and maintain the marital boundary of the children; avoid intrusion;
offer advice only when it is sought; be accepting rather than critical; and work toward
developing a personal, positive relationship with a son- or daughter-in-law by creating
opportunities to spend time one-on-one. The good news is that when parents-in-law
understand inclusion and exclusion issues, the necessity of monitoring and managing their need
for control, the loyalty tugs, and the importance of helping a new couple establish a solid
marriage boundary, in-law relationships are improved.³⁰
If you are in an estranged relationship as a child-in-law or a parent-in-law, forgiveness
may be necessary before you can do some of the things mentioned in this chapter. Forgiveness
means you let go of consuming feelings of animosity, bitterness, and hatred.³¹ Improved
relationships will require time, effort, patience, and a willingness to communicate about issues
and past offenses with love and concern. Some things may not be resolved in this life. Trusting
in Christ and His timetable will help each prepare to do all they can do to mend troubled
relationships.
Extended family relationships can do much to support and strengthen family members.
The guidelines discussed in this chapter for relating to in-laws and for how parents should treat
married adult children will help family members fulfill the proclamation's charge, "Extended
families should lend support when needed."³²
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
James M. Harper is director of the BYU School of Family Life, associate dean in the
College of Family, Home, and Social Sciences, a Zina Young Williams Card Endowed University
Professor, and a marriage and family therapist. He is a former president of the BYU 21st Stake
and of the Korea Pusan Mission, and he currently serves as Gospel Doctrine teacher in the
Timpanogos Park Second Ward.
Susanne Frost Olsen is associate director of the School of Family Life and a faculty
member in the Marriage, Family, and Human Development program. She currently serves as
Primary president In the Orem Utah Suncrest Tenth Ward.
ADDITIONAL READING
Extending family relationships (1986, October), Ensign, 16(10), 57.
M. O. Richardson (2005, April). Three principles of marriage, Ensign. 35(4), 20–24.
Patricia Russell (2000, March), Building good in-law relationships, Ensign, 30(3), 53.
NOTES
1. Oxford English Dictionary, 2d ed. (1989), s.v. "cleave."
2. Marvin J. Ashton (1974, January). He took him by the hand, Ensign, 4(1), 101.
3. Extending family relationships (1986, October), Ensign, 16(10), 57.
4. Spencer W. Kimball (2002, October), Gospel classics: Oneness in marriage, Ensign,
32(10), 40. 5.
5. Extending family relationships (1986), 57.
6. J. S. Wallerstein and S. Blakeslee (1995), The Good Marriage: How and Why Lim Lasts
(Boston: Houghton Mifflin).
7. L. R. Fischer (1983), Mothers and mothers-in-law, Journal of Marriage and the Family,
45(1), 187-192.
8. P. Cotterill (1994), Friendly Relations? Mothers and Their Daughters-in-law (New York:
Taylor and Francis).
9. B. H. Limary (2002), The Mother-in-law/Daughter-in-law Dyad: Narratives of Relational
Development among In-laws; doctoral dissertation, University of New Mexico
(Albuquerque. NM).
10. Spencer W. Kimball (1976, March), The blessings and responsibilities of womanhood,
Ensign, 6(3), 70.
11. L. L. Ades (2003), Predictors of the Quality of the Relationship between Daughters-in-law
and Mothers-in-law (marital), Dissertation Abstracts International-B, 63(1), 4909.
12. G. C. Horsley (1997), The In-law Survival Manual: A Guide to Cultivating Healthy In-law
Relationships (New York: John Wiley &: Sons).
13. G. Lundberg and J. Lundberg (2000, January), The marriage balancing act, Ensign, 30(1),
54.
14. D. D. Forbis (1998, July), Harmony among grown children, Ensign, 28(7), 49.
15. P. Russell (2000, March). Building good in-law relationships, Ensign, 30(3), 53.
16. Horsley (1997), 46.
17. Name withheld (2000, July), The only member in my family, Ensign, 30(7), 16.
18. Forbis (1998), 49.
19. Horsley (1997); Limary (2002).
20. Horsley (1997).
21. R. Marotz-Baden and D. Cowen (1987), Mothers-in-law and daughters-in-law: The
effects of proximity on conflict and stress, Family Relations, 36(4), 385-390.
22. L. S. Averick (1996), Don't Call Me Mom: How to Improve Your In-law Relationships
(Hollywood, FL: Lifetime Books).
23. G. C. Horsley (1996), In-laws: Extended family therapy. The American Journal of Family
Therapy. 25(1), 18–27; Horsley (1997), 47.
24. Richard G. Scott (1992, May), Healing the tragic scars of abuse, Ensign, 22(5), 31.
25. Name withheld (1994, October). Remove my bitterness, Ensign, 24(10), 66.
26. Horsley (1997).
27. M. J. Turner and T. S. Killian (2003), Factors related to the quality of relationships
between sons- and daughters-in-law and fathers- and mothers-in-law, The
Gerontologist, 43, 51.
28. Turner and Killian (2003). 51.
29. Limary (2002).
30. L. Berg-Cross and J. Jackson (1986), Helping the extended family: In-law growth and
development training program, Psychotherapy in Private Practice, 4(1), 33–50.
31. For specific information about forgiving a family member, please refer to J. M. Harper
and M. Butler (2000), Repentance, forgiveness, and progression in marriage and
families; in D. C. Dollahite, ed., Strengthening Our Families: An In-Depth Look at the
Proclamation on the Family (Salt Lake City: Bookcraft), 154–166.
32. First Presidency and Council of Twelve Apostles (1995, November), The family: A
proclamation to the world, Ensign, 25(11), 102.
Originally published in Craig H. Hart, Lloyd D. Newell, Elaine Walton, and David C Dollahite,
2005, Helping and Healing Our Families, Deseret Book Company. Reformatted by BYU-Idaho for
accessibility purposes, July, 14, 2017.