Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1, FEBRUARY 2007
Abstract—This paper discusses a repetitive-based controller for a class of reference commands without a steady state error if
an uninterruptible power supply (UPS) inverter. It is shown that the generator (or the model) of the reference is included in the
a bank of resonant filters, used as a refinement term for harmonic stable closed-loop system. It is well known that the generator of
compensation in earlier works, is equivalent to a repetitive scheme
a sinusoidal signal, i.e., containing only one harmonic compo-
with a particular structure. The latter is implemented using a
simple feedback array with a delay line, thus making the imple- nent, is a harmonic oscillator, that is, a resonant filter. It is then
mentation relatively easy. More precisely, the repetitive scheme clear that, there would be as much harmonic oscillators as har-
takes a negative feedback structure plus a feedforward path when- monics to compensate, which may represent a drawback in the
ever the odd harmonics are considered for compensation only. case where highly distorted loads are considered. Another ap-
The repetitive scheme, equivalent to the bank of resonant filters, proach that has shown promising results is the repetitive control
acts as a refinement term to reject the harmonic distortion caused [7]–[10]. This technique arises as a practical and simple solution
by the unbalanced and distorted load current, and thus, allowing
the UPS inverter to deliver an almost pure sinusoidal balanced to the tracking or rejection of periodic signals. See [11]–[13],
voltage. Experimental results in a 1.5 KVA three-phase inverter and the references therein for applications of repetitive control
are included to show the performance of the proposed controller. on power electronic systems such as rectifiers, inverters and ac-
Index Terms—Delay lines, harmonic distortion, repetitive con-
tive filters.
trol, uninterruptible power systems. In the UPS inverter application, either the inductor current
or the capacitor current measurements can be used for the con-
troller implementation. It has been pointed out that the perfor-
I. INTRODUCTION mance of UPS inverters can be considerably improved if the ca-
pacitor current is effectively controlled [14], [15]. The above is
inductance;
capacitance;
dc voltage source;
, weights for and ;
capacitor voltages vector ;
control vector ;
inductor currents vector ;
capacitor currents vector ;
load currents vector ;
Fig. 1. Three-phase three-wire UPS inverter system. combined currents vector ;
where parameters , , and are all assumed unknown
constants. The actual control input represents the duty ratio
values. It has been observed, however, that preserving a ratio of a pulse-width modulation (PWM) switching sequence at a
of 10:1 (giving 10 turns for the capacitor current and 1 turn for relatively high frequency. Parameters and are the known
the load current) between these two parameters yields an accept- weights to form the combined current . Current
able response. The expression of this controller, which is briefly is an unbalanced periodic signal which can be expressed
described here, is very close to the conventional one, i.e., it in- as the combination of a fundamental component at the fixed
cludes a proportional term on the output voltage error, plus a
fundamental frequency , and its harmonics of higher order.
proportional term on the current, and, in contrast to the conven-
The control objective consists in tracking a purely balanced
tional one, it includes a bank of resonant filters tuned at the fre-
sinusoidal voltage reference of amplitude given by
quencies of the harmonics under compensation. This controller
was obtained following adaptive techniques which gave, in prin-
ciple, a stable and robust controller, aimed to guarantee an al-
most perfect sinusoidal balanced voltage at the output despite
of the presence of a distorted and unbalanced load current.
In this paper, it is shown that the bank of resonant filters of
the controller proposed in [3] has an alternative expression in in spite of the presence of unbalanced periodic disturbances. No-
terms of a single delay line. It is shown that, in case that only tice that this reference is composed by the positive sequence
odd harmonics are considered for compensation, this expression fundamental component only, where represents the funda-
can be easily built with a pure delay line in a negative feed- mental frequency. In fact, the control objective includes two
back configuration plus a feedforward path, which coincides problems, namely, reference tracking to a purely balanced sinu-
with the repetitive scheme recently presented in [18]. In other soidal signal, and disturbance attenuation of higher harmonics
words, the whole bank of resonant filters can be replaced by
induced by the load. Here and in what follows will be used
a simpler repetitive scheme, thus, reducing the computational
for references and for values in the equilibrium.
load, while preserving, and even improving, the performance.
Let us rewrite the system dynamics (1)–(2) in terms of the
The resulting controller will have a familiar and simple form
combined current , this yields
which is suitable for implementation, where the introduction of
the repetitive scheme is the most relevant feature. Therefore, the
proposed controller represents an alternative implementation to (4)
the controller based on resonant filters. Finally, the proposed
control scheme has been implemented and tested in a 1.5 KVA (5)
three phase UPS inverter. The experimental results are presented
here to assess the performance of the proposed scheme. The equilibrium trajectories of the overall system by forcing
are given by
(7) (11)
(13)
It is recommended in [18] to include a gain (14)
as shown in Fig. 4. The aim of this modification is to limit the
amplitudes of the peaks and, at the same time, to reinforce the Second, to tune parameters and , the repetitive scheme
stability. In such case, the peaks have a magnitude limited to is manipulated as follows:
and the notches have a magnitude not smaller
than .
Remark IV.1: In [18], the introduction of a simple low pass
filter (LPF) is also recommended to restrict the bandwidth of the (15)
controller in an analog implementation. In the present paper,
however, only the introduction of the gain has been consid-
ered because the controller is implemented digitally and the where has been defined, with a positive param-
sampling time is small compared with the bandwidth recom- eter relatively small.
mended for the LPF, thus making it unnecessary. The hyperbolic tangent in the previous expression has also
Moreover, recalling that the following equivalent expression [19]:
for all , and using the fact that
, a simpler expression
for the proportional gain on the voltage error can be obtained,
which is given by (16)
Since is chosen very close to 1, then is arbitrarily small,
and thus, the in the numerator and the term in the denom-
inator are negligible in the range of frequencies of interest, this
yields
The block diagram of the overall proposed repetitive-based
controller is shown in Fig. 5. Notice that, the bank of resonant
filters has been replaced by the proposed repetitive scheme. No- (17)
tice also that, a gain has been introduced to allow control
over the gain produced in the peaks, in conjunction with gain Notice that, the expression on the RHS defines a bank of
. Hence, gains and should be combined to obtain the bandpass filters (BPFs). In what follows, only the BPF tuned
appropriate frequency response. at the fundamental component, i.e., , is considered to ob-
tain expressions for and . In this case, the gain at the
V. CONTROL PARAMETERS SELECTION resonant frequency and the corresponding quality-factor are
Regarding the selection of controller parameters, a set of rea- given by
sonable approximations can be used for an initial setting of their
values.
508 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 54, NO. 1, FEBRUARY 2007
(18)
Fig. 6. Load current: (top) current signal i (only one phase) in time domain
By proposing a quality factor considerably large, then the (x-axis 200 ms/div, y -axis 5 A/div) and (bottom) its corresponding frequency
above expression can be approximated as spectrum (x-axis 62.5 Hz/div, y -axis 20 dB/div).
Fig. 8. Output voltage steady state response v (t) in black, and the corre-
sponding reference v (t) in gray (only one phase). (top) Conventional con-
troller based on i measurements and (bottom) proposed controller with repet-
itive-based harmonic compensation (x-axis 4 ms/div, y -axis 100 V/div).
Fig. 10. (top plot) Steady state response of the three output voltages v , v ,
v (x-axis 4 ms/div, y -axis 100 V/div) and (three bottom plots) distorted and
unbalanced load currents i , i , i (x-axis 4 ms/div, y -axis 10 A/div).
Fig. 11. Transient responses after the nonlinear and unbalanced load is con-
nected. (top) Output voltage v (x-axis 20 ms/div, 100 V/div) and (bottom)
Fig. 9. Frequency spectrum of the output voltage v (t). (top) Conventional load current i (x-axis 20 ms/div, y -axis 5 A/div).
controller based on i measurements, and (bottom) proposed controller with
repetitive-based harmonic compensation (x-axis 62.5 Hz/div, y -axis 20 dB/div).
Fig. 10 shows, for the proposed controller, the steady state
response of the output voltages for the three phases , ,
uses the measurement of and does not provide harmonic (top plot), which are balanced and almost sinusoidal, de-
compensation. Notice that the proposed controller significantly spite of the distorted and unbalance load current. The last three
exceeds the performance of the conventional one, even though, plots represent the three phase load currents , , .
for the conventional controller the gains have been adjusted to Fig. 11 shows the transient response of the output voltage
reach the best possible response. The corresponding voltage ref- (upper plot) when the nonlinear unbalanced load is connected
erences is included (in gray) in the same plots to put in evidence to the inverter under the proposed controller. The corresponding
the better tracking reached with the proposed controller. Fig. 9 current load is shown in the bottom plot (only one phase is
shows the frequency spectrum of (top plot) the conventional shown for the sake of space limitations). Notice that after a rel-
controller and (bottom plot) the proposed controller. Notice that, atively small transient the voltage keeps the desired sinusoidal
in the proposed controller, the odd harmonics have been elimi- shape and amplitude.
nated almost completely by the repetitive-based harmonic com-
pensator, leading to an output voltage mainly composed by a VII. CONCLUDING REMARKS
fundamental component despite of the presence of highly non- In this paper, a repetitive-based controller was designed to
linear loads. allow a three phase inverter to deliver an almost sinusoidal and
510 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 54, NO. 1, FEBRUARY 2007
balanced voltage, despite of the existence of distorted and un- [17] P. C. Loh, M. J. Newman, D. N. Zmood, and D. G. Holmes, “A com-
balanced load currents. The idea behind the repetitive scheme parative analysis of multiloop voltage regulation strategies for single
and three-phase UPS systems,” Trans. Power Electron., vol. 18, no. 5,
is to compensate for the odd harmonic components of a pe- pp. 1176–1185, Sep. 2003.
riodic distortion induced in the output voltage due to the dis- [18] G. Escobar, J. Leyva-Ramos, and P. R. Martínez, “Repetitive con-
torted load current. The key observation here is that, the repet- trollers with a feedforward path for harmonic compensation,” IEEE
Trans. Ind. Electron., to be published.
itive scheme is equivalent to a bank of resonant filters. More [19] I. S. Gradshteyn and I. M. Ryzhik, Table of Integrals, Series, and Prod-
precisely, since only odd harmonics were considered for com- ucts, 6th ed. New York: Academic, 2000.
pensation, the repetitive scheme involved a negative feedback
G. Escobar (M’00) received the Ph.D. degree from
structure plus a feedforward path. Moreover, a discussion has the Signals and Systems Laboratory, LSS-SUP-
been included to give some guidelines on the selection of the ELEC, Paris, France, in May 1999.
controller parameters. Finally, experimental results have been He was a Visiting Researcher at the Northeastern
University, Boston, MA, from August 1999 to June
presented to exhibit the improved performance of the proposed 2002. In July 2002, he joined the Research Institute
controller in comparison with the conventional one. of Science and Technology, San Luis Potosí, México
(IPICYT), where he holds a Professor-Researcher
position. His main research interests include mod-
eling and control of power electronic systems,
specially active filters, inverters and electric drives.
REFERENCES