Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Soybean Foods and Their Bene Ts Potential Mechanisms of Action PDF
Soybean Foods and Their Bene Ts Potential Mechanisms of Action PDF
Special Article
Isoflavones have been proposed to be the active com- The consumption of soy foods may reduce the risk
ponent responsible for the beneficial effects of soy- of cardiovascular disease and cancer, and this effect is
bean foods, and appear to work in conjunction with seen particularly among Asian populations, in whom
the proteins to protect against cancer, cardiovascular consumption of soy foods is high, compared with West-
disease, and osteoporosis. Most of the research activ- ern populations, who eat smaller amounts of soy.1-3 In
ities on the benefits of soybean foods have focused on addition to cancer and heart disease, data suggest that soy
the role these isoflavones play in disease prevention or may also reduce the risk of osteoporosis and help to
treatment; however, there is also some evidence that alleviate menopausal symptoms,3,7,8 both of which are
the benefits are attributable to certain peptides or major health concerns for women. The aim of this review
protein fractions from soybeans. This review will is to discuss current knowledge relating to the possible
focus on some of the potential mechanisms whereby mechanisms by which some of the bioactive components
soybeans exert their protective effects against heart
in soybeans protect against cardiovascular diseases, can-
disease, cancer, and osteoporosis.
cer, and osteoporosis.
Key words: soybean, isoflavones, peptides, cardiovas-
cular disease, cancer BIOACTIVE COMPONENTS OF SOY AND SOY
© 2005 International Life Sciences Institute
FOODS
doi: 10.1301/nr.2005.aug.272–283
274
Reference Population (n) Soy Product Fed, Dose, Duration Outcome
Human Studies
Goodman-Gruen and Postmenopausal women Daily soy isoflavone intake assessed for one Women with moderate and high genistein consumption had
Kritz-Silverstein, (n ⫽ 208) year with questionnaire; average intake of significantly improved HDL cholesterol
200132 genistein was 1.3 ⫾ 2.4 mg/d, range
0–13.9 mg/d
Gardner et al., 200134 Postmenopausal, moderately Soy protein with trace amounts of Total and LDL cholesterol concentrations decreased more
hypercholesterolemic isoflavones (Soy⫺) or 80 mg aglycone in the Soy⫹ group than in the Soy⫺ group; no
women (n ⫽ 94) isoflavones (Soy⫹) per day for 12 weeks significant differences in HDL cholesterol and
triacylglycerol concentrations between the groups
Wangen et al., 200126 Normocholesterolemic and Daily consumption of soy protein isolate High-isoflavone diet reduced plasma LDL cholesterol by
mildly hypercholesterolemic (SPI) beverage powders providing an 6.5% compared with control; low- and high-isoflavone
women (n ⫽ 18) average of 7.1 ⫾ 1.1 (control), 65 ⫾ 11 diet reduced LDL:HDL cholesterol by 8.5% and 7.7%,
(low isoflavone), or 132 ⫾ 22 (high respectively; isoflavone consumption did not
isoflavone) mg isoflavones per day for significantly affect plasma concentrations of total or
three 93-day periods in a randomized HDL cholesterol, triacylglycerol, ApoA–I, ApoB, or
crossover design lipoprotein (a) or the LDL peak particle diameter
Merz-Demlow et al., Normocholesterolemic SPI consumed as a beverage powder with High-isoflavone diet lowered LDL cholesterol by 7.6% to
200027 premenopausal women three levels of soy isoflavones: 10 ⫾ 1.1 10%, total:HDL cholesterol by 10.2%, and LDL:HDL
(n ⫽ 13) (control), 64.7 ⫾ 9.4 (low), and 128.7 ⫾ cholesterol by 13.8%
15.7 (high) mg per day for three
menstrual cycles each in a randomized
crossover design
Mitchell and Collins, Healthy men (n ⫽ 10) Soy milk (1 L/d) for 4 weeks No significant effect of soy supplementation on plasma
199943 cholesterol, triglyceride levels, or HDL:LDL cholesterol
ratios compared with controls
Potter et al., 199830 Hypercholesterolemic, Soy protein (40 mg/d) plus moderate and Non-HDL cholesterol was reduced in both groups fed
postmenopausal women higher concentrations of isoflavones (1.39 moderate and higher concentrations of isoflavone
(n ⫽ 66) and 2.25 mg isoflavone/g protein, compared with controls; HDL cholesterol increased in
respectively) for 6 months the two groups; LDL receptor mRNA was reduced in
the two groups compared with controls
Wong et al., 199831 Normocholesterolemic Soy protein incorporated into the National Plasma concentration of LDL cholesterol and LDL:HDL
(n ⫽ 13) and Cholesterol Educational Program Step I diet cholesterol in both normocholesterolemic and
hypercholesterolemic (constituting ⱖ 75% total protein content) hypercholesterolemic men were significantly lower
(n ⫽ 13) men fed for a total of 10 weeks in a randomized (approximately 6% and 11%, respectively) when soy
crossover design (average daily soy protein protein diet was consumed
consumption approximately 50 g)
Adams et al., 200456 Atherosclerosis-susceptible One of five experimental diets: soy plus Reduced atherosclerosis observed in all mice fed the -
mice, male and isoflavones, -conglycinin (7S globulin, a conglycinin diets compared with mice fed the soy plus
ovariectomized female major soy storage protein), - isoflavones diet; extent of atherosclerosis reduced in
ApoE-null mice, and LDL- conglycinin-devoid soy protein, glycinin ovariectomized female mice fed all soy protein-
receptor-null ApoB (11S globulin, a major soy storage containing diets compared with controls
transgenic mice (n ⫽ 416) protein), or W008 (a soy peptide fraction)
for 4 months
Demonty et al., 200233 Male Sprague-Dawley rats SPI and casein with similar isoflavone Plasma total triglycerides decreased by 26% in rats fed soy
(n ⫽ 36) content (1.82 mg/g protein) for 21 days protein and casein plus isoflavones compared with
control
Fukui et al., 200211 Male Sprague-Dawley rats 20% SPI; 20% isoflavone-free SPI (IF–SPI) Plasma total cholesterol concentrations of rats fed SPI and
(n ⫽ 30) for 2 weeks IF-SPI were comparable and significantly lower than that
of rats fed control diet; higher fecal steroid excretion in
the SPI group
Lucas et al., 200129 Ovariectomized female golden Ethanol extracted isoflavone-depleted SPI ID-SPI lowered serum triglyceride concentrations
Syrian hamsters (n ⫽ 48) (ID–SPI) (240 g/kg of diet) for 70 days compared to controls, no significant differences in serum
HDL concentrations, liver total lipids and liver total
cholesterol
Tsai and Huang, 199910 Male golden Syrian hamsters SPI containing 1.24 mg genistein and 0.61 SPI group exhibited significantly lower serum total
(n ⫽ 24) mg diadzein/g, and ethanol-extracted SPI cholesterol concentration compared with the E–SPI
(E–SPI) low in isoflavones (0.21 mg group; both SPI and E–SPI groups had lower LDL
genistein and 0.06 mg diadzein/g) fed for cholesterol, LDL ApoB, and LDL:HDL cholesterol
10 weeks compared with the controls
275
reducing blood cholesterol levels (particularly the LDL (apart from its isoflavones) may be responsible for lipid
fraction). There is evidence that soy protein increases lowering.40
fecal excretion of bile acids. In rats fed isoflavone-rich
and isoflavone-depleted soy protein, higher fecal steroid Soy Isoflavones and Cancer
excretion was observed in the isoflavone-rich group,
though both groups had lowered total cholesterol com- The consumption of high levels of soy foods has
pared with the control group. The authors concluded that been shown to be associated with a reduced risk of
the cholesterol-lowering effects of soy may be attributed several types of cancer, including breast, endometrial,
to the protein content, with the isoflavones and other and prostate cancers, particularly among Asian popula-
minor constituents playing a role.11 tions.5,6,15,41,42 This is in contrast to Western popula-
Soy isoflavones are also believed to reduce the risk tions, where there is a higher incidence of these cancers.
of heart disease by reducing the susceptibility of LDL to A number of in vivo studies are supportive of a protec-
oxidation via its antioxidant action.16,37 The effects of a tive role for soy foods in cancer and some studies have
soy protein diet enriched with isoflavones and one de- shown that soy isoflavones are responsible for these
pleted of isoflavones on LDL resistance to oxidation protective effects.15 This protective effect appears to be
were compared among 24 healthy subjects in a random- strongest for breast cancer. Administration of soy isofla-
ized crossover design. Plasma concentrations of vones early in life enhances the early maturation and
8-epiprostaglandin F2␣, a biomarker of lipid oxidation, differentiation of the mammary gland of rats, suggesting
were significantly lower after the high-isoflavone diet that exposure in early life may be important.3,7,17 Table
(21.2 mg diadzein, 34.8 mg genistein), showing in- 2 shows a summary of previous studies on the effects of
creased resistance of LDL to Cu2⫹-induced oxidation. soy products on cancer and associated DNA damage.
This antioxidant action may be significant with regard to Several possible mechanisms have been identified
risk of atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease in for the anticarcinogenic activity of soy isoflavones. One
general.16 Similar results were observed in male golden of the mechanisms by which soy isoflavones are believed
Syrian hamsters.10 The resistance of LDL to Cu2⫹- to exert their anticarcinogenic effects is via their antiox-
induced oxidation was greater in hamsters fed isofla- idant properties,14 which result in a decrease in lipid
vone-rich soy protein than in those fed isoflavone- peroxidation16 and oxidative DNA damage,14 both im-
depleted protein, as assessed by the lower concentrations portant risk factors for carcinogenesis. These antioxidant
of thiobarbituric acid reactive substances, another bi- properties are suggested to be related to the chemical
omarker of lipid oxidation, and the longer lag time structure of soy isoflavones. Consumption of soy con-
taining naturally occurring amounts of isoflavones re-
required for the formation of conjugated dienes. The
duced lipid peroxidation in vivo among 24 healthy sub-
isoflavone-enriched group also had significantly higher
jects, as evidenced by lower levels of plasma
serum total antioxidant capacity, particularly ␣-tocoph-
concentrations of 8-epiprostaglandin F2␣, a biomarker of
erol content, showing sparing effects on ␣-tocopherol
in vivo lipid peroxidation.16 In another study to evaluate
contents in both serum and liver. These findings suggest
the effects of soy isoflavone supplementation on markers
that the intake of soy isoflavones enhanced the resistance
of oxidative stress in men and women, soy supplemen-
of LDL to oxidation, contributing to antioxidant defense,
tation was given in the form of Novasoy tablets contain-
and reduced the consumption of ␣-tocopherol in both the
ing 50 mg of isoflavones daily for 3 weeks. There was a
serum and liver of hamsters.10 significant decrease in the levels of 5-hydroxymethyl-2-
Improvement of arterial compliance is another pos- deoxyuridine, a biomarker of oxidative DNA damage;
sible mechanism by which soy isoflavones protect though no significant decrease in lipid peroxidation was
against heart disease.38 Arterial compliance (arterial observed. The results from this study suggest that dietary
elasticity) is an important cardiovascular disease risk supplementation with soy isoflavones can decrease levels
factor that diminishes with age and menopause.39 The of oxidative DNA damage, which is associated with the
effect of soy isoflavones (80 mg daily) on arterial com- process of carcinogenesis.14 A similar decrease in oxi-
pliance was tested in menopausal and perimenopausal dative DNA damage was also observed among men
women over 5- to 10-week periods in a placebo-con- consuming 1 L of soy milk daily for 4 weeks.43
trolled crossover trial.40 Though there was no effect on Another mechanism by which soy isoflavones may
plasma lipids, systemic arterial compliance improved by protect against cancer is through the induction of phase II
26% compared with placebo to about the same extent as enzymes,44 which is associated with cancer chemopre-
that achieved with conventional hormone replacement ventive potential at both the initiation and promotion
therapy (HRT). The fact that plasma lipids were not phases.44 Induced levels of the phase II enzymes gluta-
changed suggests that other constituents of soybean thione-s-transferase (GST) and quinone reductase (QR)
Djuric et al., 200114 Men (n ⫽ 6) and Novasoy tablets containing 50 mg Soy isoflavone supplementation decreased levels of oxidative
women (n ⫽ 6) isoflavones; women took 1 tablet daily DNA damage in men and women, evidenced by decreased
and men took 2 tablets daily for 3 weeks levels of 5-hydroxymethyl-2-deoxyuridine, a biomarker of
Animal Studies
Constantinou et al., Female Sprague- One of five experimental diets for 120 days: SPI⫺ was the most effective diet, significantly reducing
200244 Dawley rats genistein (200 mg/kg diet); diadzein (200 mammary tumor multiplicity by 50%; diadzein and SPI⫹ diet
(n ⫽ 119) mg/kg diet); genistein plus diadzein at also significantly reduced tumor multiplicity by 32% compared
100 mg/kg diet each; 16% soy protein with controls; no significant reduction in mammary tumor
isolate plus isoflavones (SPI⫹); 16% incidence in any diet
isoflavone-depleted SPI (SPI⫺)
Cohen et al., 20006 Rats (n ⫽ 150) 20% intact soy protein (SP), 10% SP, 20% No significant differences in mammary tumor incidence, latency,
isoflavone-depleted SP (IDSP), 10% multiplicity, or volume compared with controls
IDSP for 18 weeks
Applet and Reicks, Female Sprague- Soy containing three levels of isoflavones Rats fed high-isoflavone diet had lower mammary tumor
199945 Dawley rats (0.03, 0.4, 0.81 mg/g diet; low, middle incidence (40%) compared with controls (71.4%); rats fed
(n ⫽ 86) and high level of isoflavones, middle and low isoflavone diet had tumor incidence of 53.3
respectively) for 13 weeks and 57.1%, respectively
277
have been proposed as suitable biomarkers for identify- this reason, soy isoflavones are called selective estrogen
ing compounds likely to inhibit carcinogenesis.45 QR receptor modulators (SERMs), and may be a possible
and GST are enzymes that help the body get rid of the alternative to HRT.7,12
toxic products of oxidative metabolism of aromatic hy- Soy isoflavones have been suggested to alleviate
drocarbons.44 There is evidence to support the mecha- osteoporosis by inhibiting bone resorption and stimulat-
nism of soy isoflavones as antioxidants and as phase II ing bone formation. Evidence that soy isoflavones reduce
enzyme inducers. Soy isoflavones increased antioxidant bone resorption has been demonstrated by a number of
and phase II enzyme activity, especially QR, GST, and studies. Picherit et al.49 investigated the ability of long-
UDP-glucuronosyltransferase, in various tissues of rats term daily intake of soy isoflavones in reversing osteope-
fed a high-isoflavone diet for 2 weeks.45 nia in the adult ovariectomized rat, which was used as a
Similar results were found in a study by Con- model of postmenopausal women. Soy isoflavones re-
stantinou et al.44 comparing the anti-tumor effects of duced the urinary excretion of deoxypyridinoline, a spe-
isoflavone-enriched soy protein isolate and isoflavone- cific biomarker of bone resorption.49 Similar results were
depleted soy protein isolate with those of its isoflavones, also observed among postmenopausal women, in whom
genistein and diadzein. Although the diadzein and isofla- soy protein intake was associated with significantly
vone-enriched soy groups showed significantly reduced lower urinary deoxypyridinoline excretion.50,51
tumor multiplicity compared with the controls, both soy Soy isoflavones appear to stimulate osteoblastic ac-
groups (but not the genistein or diadzein groups) upregu- tivity through the promotion of insulin-like growth fac-
lated transcriptional expression of the antioxidant en- tor-I (IGF-I) production.52 It is well recognized that
zymes QR and GST. These results suggest that the mode IGF-I enhances osteoblastic activity in humans.25 IGF-I
of preventive action of soy protein isolate is distinct from is a protein involved in the bone formation process, and
that of the main isoflavones, and that isoflavone-depleted therefore an increase in IGF-I is indicative of increased
soy may be more beneficial than isoflavone-enriched soy bone formation. In a study by Arjmandi et al.52 using a
in preventing mammary tumors in these experimental rat model of osteopenia, soy increased the gene expres-
animals.44 However, another study evaluating the effects sion of IGF-I, as indicated by higher femoral mRNA
of intact and isoflavone-depleted soy protein on N- levels. Incorporation of soy protein with normal isofla-
nitroso-N-methylurea (NMU)-induced rat mammary tu- vone content (2.3 mg/g protein) had a greater effect on
morigenesis showed no effect on tumor incidence, la- femoral IGF-I mRNA than the isoflavone-depleted soy
tency, multiplicity, or volume. The results from this protein-based diet (approximately 0.1 mg/g protein).
study do not support the hypothesis that the isoflavone This finding indicates that isoflavones may have a role in
components of soy protein, or the soy protein itself, enhancing the synthesis of IGF-I at the bone level.
inhibit chemically induced mammary tumor development.6 There is additional evidence that soy promotes bone
As with animal experiments, studies in human pop- formation. Increased levels of bone alkaline phosphatase,
ulations relating soy consumption to reduced risk of a biomarker of bone formation, was observed among
breast cancer have produced conflicting results, and a perimenopausal women fed an isoflavone-rich soy pro-
few have shown stimulatory effects. Petrakis et al.46 tein diet.18 In the same study, lumbar spine bone mineral
reported that prolonged consumption of soy protein iso- density (BMD) and bone mineral content (BMC) were
late by a group of healthy premenopausal US women assessed at baseline and at the end of the treatment.
increased hyperplastic epithelial cells in duct fluid aspi- There was a significant difference in BMD (5.6%) and
rates, showing a stimulatory effect on the breast. BMC (10.1%) between the isoflavone-rich and control
groups, and the authors concluded that soy isoflavones
Soy Isoflavones and Osteoporosis attenuated bone loss from the lumbar spine in estrogen-
deficient perimenopausal women.18 Similar results were
The ovarian hormone deficiency associated with also observed among hypercholesterolemic, postmeno-
menopause results in an increased rate of bone turnover, pausal women assessed for total and regional BMC and
which causes an imbalance between bone resorption and BMD before and after administration of 40 mg/d of soy
bone formation, thereby accelerating bone loss that leads protein containing moderate and higher concentrations of
to osteoporosis.25,47 HRT is an effective treatment in isoflavones (1.39 and 2.25 mg isoflavone/g of protein,
reducing the rate of bone loss and risk of fracture, though respectively). The high-isoflavone diet significantly in-
not very popular among postmenopausal women because creased both BMC and BMD in the lumbar spine but not
of the undesirable side effects and long-term risks of elsewhere.30 Increased BMD and mechanical bone
breast and endometrial cancer associated with prolonged strength and intestinal calcium absorption were also
use.18,25,47,48 Soy isoflavones have been shown to alle- observed in ovariectomized, osteoporotic rats fed soy
viate osteoporosis without the side effects of HRT.12 For milk.53 Soy is also a rich source of calcium, and this may
tive components that could exert beneficial effects: the of the form of soy foods consumed (fermented, non-
cholesterol-lowering effects of soluble fiber and phytoster- fermented) on different tissues and the possible syner-
ols; the anti-carcinogenic potential of saponins, phytic acid, gistic effects of the many bioactive components of soy.
Bowman-Birk inhibitor, and lecithin; and the cardioprotec- Furthermore, tissue-specific metabolism and biotransfor-
tive effects of omega-3 fatty acids. Furthermore, these mation of soy isoflavones, and the effects and mecha-
components may have synergistic effects. nisms of action of its different metabolites in vivo, will
It is evident that there is still a lot to be learned about go a long way in contributing to the understanding of the
soy foods. A question that remains to be answered mechanisms of action of soy isoflavones.
conclusively is what component of soy foods is respon-
sible for its protective effects against heart disease, ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
cancer, and osteoporosis. This gap in knowledge could
form the basis for more research on the benefits of soy, The authors thank the Natural Sciences and Engineer-
and further elucidation of its mode of action. Other areas ing Research Council of Canada for financial support pro-
worthy of research are the possible variations in effects vided to the research program of Dr. Aluko.