Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
Construction
and Building
Review
a
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Environmental Energy Technologies Division, Mail Stop 70-108B, 1 Cyclotron Road,
Berkeley, CA 94720, United States
b
Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37831, United States
Abstract
An overview of several aspects of the weathering of roofing materials is presented. Degradation of materials initiated by ultraviolet
radiation is discussed for plastics used in roofing, as well as wood and asphalt. Elevated temperatures accelerate many deleterious chem-
ical reactions and hasten diffusion of material components. Effects of moisture include decay of wood, acceleration of corrosion of met-
als, staining of clay, and freeze–thaw damage. Soiling of roofing materials causes objectionable stains and reduces the solar reflectance of
reflective materials. (Soiling of non-reflective materials can also increase solar reflectance.) Soiling can be attributed to biological growth
(e.g., cyanobacteria, fungi, algae), deposits of organic and mineral particles, and to the accumulation of fly ash, hydrocarbons and soot
from combustion.
Ó 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Contents
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
2. Environmental stresses on roofing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
2.1. Sunlight and temperature variations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
2.2. Wind . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
2.3. Moisture: rain, hail, snow, frost, and dew . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
2.4. Atmospheric gases and pollutants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
2.5. Biological growth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 425
3. Photodegradation of polymeric and other organic materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 425
4. Effects of increased temperatures on roofing materials. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 427
4.1. Asphalt shingles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 428
5. Effects of moisture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 428
6. Soiling of roofing. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 429
7. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 431
Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 432
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 432
*
Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 510 486 5278; fax: +1 510 486 7303.
E-mail address: PHBerdahl@lbl.gov (P. Berdahl).
0950-0618/$ - see front matter Ó 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2006.10.015
424 P. Berdahl et al. / Construction and Building Materials 22 (2008) 423–433
For example, corrosion products of iron metal include photo-oxidation can be monitored by measuring the infra-
FeO, Fe2O3, Fe3O4 and FeOOH. Several other important red absorption near 6 lm caused by oxygen-containing car-
minor atmospheric constituents include oxides of carbon, bonyl (C@O) groups or the absorption near 3 lm due to
sulfur, and nitrogen; for example CO2, SO2, and NO2, the hydroxyl (OH) group. One strategy for extending poly-
formed by combustion. When these gases dissolve in water, mer lifetimes is to add UV absorbers to scavenge the UV
acids are formed. These acids can promote corrosive chem- photons. Two common inorganic UV absorber pigments
ical reactions. Another pollutant is soot from combustion. are carbon black and titanium dioxide white. (Both com-
Soot is relatively unreactive but is a strong absorber of sun- mon forms of TiO2, rutile and anatase, switch abruptly
light. The presence of soot on roofing darkens the color, from non-absorptive to absorptive near 400 nm and there-
and leads to undesirable solar heating in warm climates. fore, while they are white in the visible spectrum, they are
‘‘black’’ in the UV spectrum. Nano-particles of TiO2, with
2.5. Biological growth particle size much less than 200 nm, are small enough to be
transparent in the visible spectrum, but are still strong UV
Cyanobacteria, primitive single-cell organisms, are com- absorbers.) Another option is to choose particularly dura-
mon on roofing in humid areas such as the southeastern ble polymers.
and northwestern parts of the United States. The accumu- While TiO2 particles are effective UV absorbers, it
lation of dead colonies of these cyanobacteria (sometimes should be mentioned in passing that tinted organic colors
called algae, but now recognized as a distinct group of (mixtures with TiO2 white) often fade more readily than
microorganisms) is visually evident as dark stains on ‘‘mass tones’’ (colorant without white). Extensive tables
light-colored roofing. One Ref. [3] indicates that the species documenting this fading may be found in the Pigment
Gloeocapsa is prevalent on damp rocks. Research by a Handbook [6]. This observation suggests that the short
roofing granule company [4] has identified Gloeocapsa wavelength part of the visible spectrum (violet, blue) can
magma as the most frequent cause of staining of roofing sometimes be damaging as well.
granules. Doubtless, many other species can be present For polymer coatings on metal roofing, three durable
on roofing, including other cyanobacteria, algae, lichens, materials are polyester, silicone-modified polyester, and
mildew, moss, etc. A lichen is a symbiotic combination of PVDF (polyvinylidene fluoride) [7]. Polyester is inexpen-
algae with a fungus; a fungus is a primitive plant-like sive, and can be used to form hard, scratch-resistant coat-
organism that lacks chlorophyll. Mildew (e.g., on wood) ings. However, exposure to UV does cause some chalking.
is due to various species of fungi. Other examples of fungi (Chalking is due to surface erosion, which produces small
are mushrooms, yeasts, rusts, and molds. Generally, a use- particles of polymer, and thereby causes a dark surface to
ful test for identifying biological growth is the application look whiter. An empirical scale of 0–10 is sometimes used
of a fresh bleach solution. Inorganic stains such as soot to characterize chalking [8].) Polyester formulations with
and iron oxide are little affected by bleach, but most biolog- longer polymer chains (higher molecular weight) are more
ical stains are lightened by bleach [5]. UV resistant than shorter chains. Polyester fabrics are also
used in roofing (and in sails for sailboats). Single-ply roof-
3. Photodegradation of polymeric and other organic ing membranes include a polyester fabric for mechanical
materials strength. Silicone-modified polyesters can provide some-
what improved chalking resistance and gloss retention rel-
Many polymeric materials are subject to photodegrada- ative to unmodified formulations. For factory coating of
tion. Energetic UV photons have sufficient energy to dis- metal materials (coil coating), PVDF polymers occupy a
rupt chemical bonds in many materials. Polymers consist premium place in the marketplace. Pure PVDF powder is
of long chains of similar subunits. The absorption of UV mixed with about 30% acrylic copolymer to aid in disper-
energy can cause the breaking and/or crosslinking of the sion during the coating process. Product specifications
polymer chains, leading to altered chemical and mechanical [9,10] indicate the weathering performance expected with
properties. After disruption of the initial chemical state, the 10 years 45° south facing Florida exposure: less than
polymers are likely to react with oxygen and/or water 5 DE color change (1 DE is the threshold for visual discrim-
vapor causing additional changes. Another type of photo- ination of differences in lightness or color), 50% minimum
degradation can occur due to photoabsorption by inor- gloss retention, 8 maximum chalk, 10% maximum film
ganic pigment particles such as TiO2. An electron–hole erosion. Fence post exposures in Florida confirm that
pair is formed in the pigment particle. A photo-excited hole PVDF-based metal roof coatings are highly durable [11].
then, for example, can migrate to the particle’s surface and The palette of colors exposed by several manufacturers in
cause a deleterious chemical reaction in the polymer. For south Florida prove that the PVDF-based coatings are
this reason, white TiO2 pigment particles intended for out- very resistant to climatic soiling as demonstrated by the
door use are usually given thin coatings of passivating lay- marginal loss in solar reflectance (less that 5%) incurred
ers such as aluminum hydroxide. for 15–35 years exposures (Fig. 1). Since the PVDF-based
Many polymer materials are too readily degraded by metal roof coatings are among the most durable polymeric
UV energy to be used in outdoor applications. Typically, materials, the above specifications are a good indication of
426 P. Berdahl et al. / Construction and Building Materials 22 (2008) 423–433
Fig. 1. Solar reflectance of PVDF painted metals acquired from south Florida field exposures for BASF, Atofina, Akzo Nobel and Solvay Solexis.
the present day state of the art. The same specifications [9] dizes during exposure to UV light in air. Infrared spectros-
indicate that accelerated testing procedures do not corre- copy on microtomed slices of the polymer quantifies the
late well with actual outdoor exposure tests. presence of carbonyl (C@O) groups. While the reaction
In PVDF coating systems, a primer coat of an urethane- with oxygen requires the presence of UV light, the extent
based polymer is used to ensure good adhesion. As poly- of oxidation is limited by oxygen diffusion from the surface
urethanes are readily degraded by UV radiation, it is into the interior. Fig. 2 shows how the oxidation proceeded
necessary to ensure that the PVDF topcoat system is a as a function of accelerated testing exposure time. Results
good UV absorber, as can be accomplished with suitable for samples containing an UV absorbing additive were sim-
pigments. This is an example of a general strategy. If outer ilar, but the depth of the penetration of oxygen is dimin-
coatings are sufficiently UV absorbing, more UV sensitive ished. The oxidized surface region is brittle and cracks
materials can be used underneath. For example, the use readily, when the polypropylene film is stretched. After
of high chroma colors in automotive finishes can be longer exposures, the surface region cracks spontaneously,
enabled with an UV absorbing clear topcoat. Another indicating that the oxidized region is both brittle and under
example is the asphalt shingle. The color bearing roofing tensile stress.
granules must absorb UV efficiently, so that UV damage Wood shakes and shingles are popular as roofing in
to the asphalt is minimized. some parts of the world. Wood is largely composed of cel-
Single-ply roofing membranes are usually based on lulose, a biopolymer. The cellulose fibers provide strength,
polymer coatings on a polyester fabric. Polymers used and lignin, another biopolymer, acts like an adhesive to
include EPDM, PVC, and TPO. EPDM is a synthetic rub- bind the fibers into a matrix. Exposure to UV radiation
ber termed ethylene propylene diene monomer. That is, it is from the sun changes the wood’s color, with light-colored
three monomers (E, P, and D) polymerized together. PVC wood becoming darker, and some darker woods becoming
is the ubiquitous polymer polyvinyl chloride. TPO is the lighter. This color change is attributed to minor compo-
industry designation for thermoplastic polyolefin. Polyeth- nents of wood termed (water soluble) extractives [5]. Lignin
ylene and polypropylene are examples of TPOs. Three
types of additives are used to enhance the outdoor stability
of single-ply roofing membranes. First, UV absorbing pig-
ments such as carbon black or titanium dioxide white can
be added. Also designated as UVA (UV absorber) are spe-
cial organic compounds such as benzophenone and
hydroxyphenyl triazine [12]. The use of UV absorbers, of
course, does not protect the surface region of the polymers,
because a certain thickness is required to effect absorption.
Important additional types of additives that can help pro-
tect the polymer including the surface region are hindered
amine light stabilizers (HALS). HALS molecules do not
themselves absorb UV light, but they react with free radi-
cals (molecular groups with unpaired electrons) formed
by UV absorption and thereby interfere with the photo-
oxidation process.
One study of accelerated weathering of polypropylene is
prototypical of how many polymeric materials change as Fig. 2. Oxidation (carbonyl) profiles measured during accelerated UV
they weather [13]. The surface region of the polymer oxi- aging of polypropylene, after [13].
P. Berdahl et al. / Construction and Building Materials 22 (2008) 423–433 427
at a high temperature in air during the manufacturing pro- of wood and faster corrosion of metal. Wood shake and
cess. If free of reactive and water soluble impurities, these tile roofs often incorporate roof underside ventilation as
materials are extremely stable and understandably immune an integral part of the design.
to moderate changes in temperature. Pigments that are In a study of the aging of paving asphalts [33], the
metal oxides and mixed metal oxides are likewise rather authors concluded that oxidation is a key factor in asphalt
inert. Polymeric materials often have the advantage of flex- hardening in hot climates, and cited further evidence that
ibility and elasticity, which helps them resist tearing. Expo- the rate of thermal oxidation is approximately doubled
sure to cold temperatures reduces this elasticity and thus for every 10 K rise in temperature.
can lead to brittle failure. The failure of an O-ring in the Since photodegradation is a complex process that
space shuttle was a catastrophic example of this problem. depends upon material type, including additives and impu-
Materials degradation usually involves chemical reac- rities, it is difficult to generalize about how photodegrada-
tions, and most chemical reactions progress more rapidly tion should be altered by increased temperatures.
at higher temperatures. The phenomenological law describ- Generally, we expect that higher temperatures may assist
ing the temperature dependence of chemical reactions is photodegradation. Here, we will simply cite one example,
often attributed to the Swedish chemist Arrhenius [rate a study that investigated the durability of unprotected
proportional to exp( A/T), with A a constant and T the polyethylene [14]. Two sets of samples were exposed to sun-
absolute temperature]. It is not unusual for reaction rates light in Dharhan, Saudi Arabia. One set was maintained at
to double with as small a temperature increase as 10 K 25 °C, while the other was exposed to outdoor air at higher
(10 °C, 18 °F). temperatures. The sample extensibility was measured as a
In addition to an inherent temperature dependence of function of time. Extensibility is the extent of elongation
chemical reactions, many degradation processes involve before tearing. Samples maintained at 25 °C lost 50% of
in- or out-diffusion of low-molecular-weight components. their original extensibility after six months. Corresponding
Diffusion usually proceeds more rapidly at higher temper- samples at higher outdoor temperatures lost 50% extensi-
ature, often with an Arrhenius temperature dependence. bility after only two months. Thus, in this specific case,
photodegradation proceeded more rapidly at highly
4.1. Asphalt shingles temperatures.
Thermoplastics such as polyvinyl chloride, polyethylene,
The thermal aging of asphalt roofing shingles provides a and polypropylene become soft and can deform at high
good example of the effects of oxygen diffusion and temperatures. In hot sunny climates, dark-colored roofing
reaction with oxygen. For a well-designed shingle, UV reaches temperatures approaching the boiling point of
photo-oxidation is not likely to be very important since water. Manufacturers formulate roofing materials with
the granules absorb most of the incident UV radiation. the maximum roof temperatures in mind, and may restrict
For oxidation to occur, atmospheric oxygen must diffuse the application of certain dark-colored materials in hot
through the asphalt matrix in order to react in the interior. climates.
Terrenzio et al. [29] discuss the thermal aging of the
asphalt in roofing shingles as follows: In the diffusional 5. Effects of moisture
model of asphalt aging, heat first promotes the diffusion of
(lower molecular weight) oils out of the bulk of the asphalt. Moisture can cause decay of wood and hasten corrosion
Then, some of the oils evaporate, and others are washed of metal. Two other deleterious effects of moisture are efflo-
away because of photo-oxidation and subsequent solubility rescence, a sort of surface staining, and freeze–thaw
in water. Finally, oxygen diffuses into the system, resulting damage.
in the formation of more heptane-insoluble, polar molecules ‘‘Dry-rot’’ of wood requires the presence of significant
known as asphaltenes. As the aging progresses, these diffu- quantities of water. The fiber saturation point, the maxi-
sion processes may lead to final failure of the system (typi- mum moisture content reached by wood in humid air but
cally cracking) as the asphalt becomes harder and stiffer. no liquid water, is usually about 25%–30% by weight.
Further details are provided in a recent publication [30]. Wood with less than about 20% moisture is considered
The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturer’s Association immune to dry rot [34]. Rot is the result of fungal infection.
(ARMA) recommends that asphalt shingles not be applied There are several types of fungi that stain and infect wood,
directly over thermal insulation [31]. The basic reason is and fungal spores are usually widely dispersed in ambient
that (solar) heat build up, which is typically a result of air. Surfaces infected with actively growing fungi show
inadequate ventilation, may accelerate weathering, and thread-like features (hyphae) under microscopic examina-
reduce the anticipated life of the asphalt shingles. Thus, it tion. Some species of fungi consume just the cellulose por-
is clear that excessively high shingle temperatures are detri- tion of wood, some the lignin, still others both primary
mental. Roof venting is useful, and not merely for heat dis- wood components. After decay, the wood is much less
sipation. It can also avoid moisture build up [32], which is dense and fractures readily. After sufficient fungal growth,
important for many types of roofing. Excessive water fruiting bodies such as toadstools form that release new
vapor and/or condensation lead to swelling and rotting spores into the air.
P. Berdahl et al. / Construction and Building Materials 22 (2008) 423–433 429
Corrosion of metals is caused by chemical reactions with to the cleansing effects of rainwater, one expects that
environmental substances, particularly the formation of deposits on roofing may be depleted of water soluble com-
metal oxides. Rusting of steel is a prototypical example. ponents. Of course, rainwater can transport small insoluble
Modern steel used in roofing generally has a protective, particles as well.
sacrificial coating of zinc or a zinc–aluminum alloy to pre- Suppose a substrate has a clean reflectance denoted R0,
vent rust. Then the metal alloy is further protected from which is coated with a thin uniform soil layer with absorp-
chemical reactions with a polymeric coating. Nevertheless, tance a and reflectance r. In view of the assumption that the
most metals occur in mineral form only as combinations layer is thin, we take both a and r as small, compared to
such as metal oxides, hydroxides, sulfides, carbonates, unity. (The extension to thicker soil layers is straightfor-
etc., and tend to revert to their mineral forms over time. ward, for example, by recursion.) Then, it is not difficult
Many of the corrosive reactions involved are electrochem- to show that the change in reflectance R of the soiled sub-
ical in nature and require the presence of an aqueous elec- strate is given, to first order in r and a, by
trolyte – a solution of salts in water. Liquid water may be R R0 = 2R0a + (1 R0)2r. Thus soil absorptance
in direct contact with the metal in question or may be reduces R and soil reflectance increases R. Here we can also
extracted from moist air due to the presence of hygroscopic see that a will be more important if R0 is large and r will be
dust. Thus, it is not surprising that metallic corrosion pro- more important if R0 is close to zero. Thus, we expect that
ceeds more rapidly in humid climates in which moisture is highly reflective materials tend to lose their reflectance as
readily available [35]. Also, it is noteworthy that dissolved they are soiled, with the reflectance loss determined by
salts increase the electrical conductivity of water, making it absorption of the soil. Very dark materials tend to become
a more effective electrolyte. This may be the primary reason lighter as they are soiled, with the reflectance increase
that seaside salt air promotes corrosion. caused by light scattering by soil. Finally, if the ratio r/a
Efflorescence is the occurrence of light-colored stains on is such that 2R0a = (1 R0)2r, then R R0 = 0 and soil
the surface of a porous material. It is caused by water seep- deposits do not change the reflectance.
age/diffusion through the material. Dissolved salts are Ebert et al. [39] studied airborne aerosols in the size
transported along with the water, and are deposited on range of 0.1–25 lm, collected in Germany, by means of
the surface when the water evaporates. A test for potential high resolution scanning electron microscopy and energy-
efflorescence of clay roof tiles is to immerse one end of the dispersive X-ray microanalysis. By combining particle mor-
tile in distilled water for seven days in a drying room [36], phology data with chemical microanalysis, they recognized
and then inspect for staining. Efflorescence is a common several characteristic particle types. Particles of silica and
issue for concrete items, particularly if they are dark in mixed oxides of silicon and aluminum were common, and
color. Water transports calcium hydroxide to the surface, appeared to have two distinct origins. Large irregular frac-
and calcium carbonate is then formed by reaction with tured particles were thought to be crustal in nature,
the CO2 in air [37]. These white deposits can be prevented whereas spherical particles in the sub-micron and micron
by the use of a polymeric coating that seals the surface [38]. size range were identified as fly ash. Particles were classified
Alternatively, the deposits can be removed by washing with as metal oxides/metal hydroxides if they were low in silicon
dilute acid. If left in place, the calcium carbonate stains content and contained additional metals such as Fe, Mn,
often weather in about 2 years, restoring the original Zn, Al, Ti, Cu, Ni, and Pb. These particles could likewise
appearance. be spherical fly ash or irregular dust particles. Calcium sul-
Freeze–thaw cycles are associated with the spallation of fate particles could be identified by the high Ca and S con-
concrete and the premature failure of clay tiles. For this tent and a plate-like morphology. Soot particles were
reason, ASTM standards for clay roof tile limit the permis- identified by their fractal-like morphology: branched
sible water absorption by the tiles [36]. For grade 1 tile, chains of 50 nm spheres. Some biological particles had rec-
that provides resistance to severe frost action, maximum ognizable morphologies, such as fungal spores. Other bio-
cold water absorption is limited to 8% in any one tile and logical particles were identified by > 25%C, plus
to 6% average in a sample of 5 tiles. For grade 3 tile, that characteristic signatures of the minor elements Na, Mg,
provides negligible resistance to any frost action, the per- P, S, Cl, K, and Ca. Two further particle types were sea salt
missible water absorption values are about twice as large. and ammonium sulfate, both of which are water soluble
and will not be discussed further here.
6. Soiling of roofing Overall, of the elements heavier than sodium (Na), the
most abundant elements were Al, Si, and S. Elements pres-
Deposits on roofing originate with dry and wet (rainwa- ent in roughly 10 times lower concentration were Na, Mg,
ter) deposition from the atmosphere. Clearly, one expects P, Cl, K, Ca, and Fe. Other elements were even less abun-
crustal dust (soil) to be present. Products of combustion dant. If the lighter elements were detectable in this partic-
such as soot, unburned hydrocarbons, and fly ash are ular analysis, we would expect to see large contributions
expected as well. Sea salt is expected (in coastal areas) as from H, C, N, and O as well.
are organic compounds emitted by vegetation (such as The optical properties of the aerosols in the particle size
terpenes) and spores produced by plants and fungi. Due range 0.1–3 lm were compiled based on an analysis of the
430 P. Berdahl et al. / Construction and Building Materials 22 (2008) 423–433
phase composition of the particles. The complex refractive and Cr have colored or black oxides and other compounds
index thus derived is useful in computing light scattering and therefore may reduce roof reflectance slightly. Of these
and absorption in the atmosphere, and by extension, may elements, iron is the most abundant. To obtain a semi-
be useful in the optical properties of deposits on roofing. quantitative estimate of the maximum possible optical
They found that the real part ranged from 1.54 to 1.72 absorption of iron, we can assume that 60 mg m 2 of iron
and the imaginary part from 0.001 to 0.086. The lower val- are present in the form of strongly absorbing small
ues were associated with unpolluted rural air masses, and (0.27 lm diameter) hematite (Fe2O3) pigment particles.
the higher values, with polluted urban air. The higher val- Hematite is a strong absorber of the short wavelength part
ues of the real part are identified with higher concentra- of the solar spectrum (300–550 nm) with a coefficient of
tions of the metal oxide/hydroxide particles, and the roughly 4 m2/g [41]. Thus, such a hematite layer could
higher values of the imaginary part are identified with absorb a measurable portion (20%) of the short wavelength
increased concentrations of soot. If the imaginary part is component. Most likely, however, the iron mineral parti-
zero, optical absorption is absent; only scattering occurs. cles present are in the form of larger particles that are less
Thus soot is the primary absorber in atmospheric aerosols. efficient than the sub-micrometer particles of our example.
As part of our present ongoing investigation on solar- The role of elemental carbon (i.e., soot) is potentially
reflective roofing, we have examined deposits that have more dramatic. Fig. 4 shows the expected [42] solar reflec-
formed on exposed roofing samples at several locations in tance and visible reflectance as a function of soot concen-
California [40]. Selected results are shown in Table 1. Since tration, as a fraction of the high initial reflectance R0.
the samples were taken in the spring, after California’s win- The sample exposed at Richmond has the most elemental
ter rainfall, the deposits were affected by rainfall and are carbon (1.3 mg m 2), but this amount is insufficient to
less extensive than would have been the case if the samples markedly reduce its reflectance.
were obtained in September, after the dry California sum- Like hematite, the effect of organic carbon is expected to
mer. Thus, the observed solar reflectance values were about be largest at shorter wavelengths, but published absorption
the same as for unsoiled samples. For example, three sam- coefficients (roughly 0.6 m2 g 1 at 550 nm) [43] suggest that
ples with initial solar reflectance of 0.57 had reflectance of it is less important than elemental carbon (14 m2 g 1 at
0.54 ± 0.02 after 19 months. Sulfur is not found in high 550 nm) [43] for equivalent masses per unit area.
abundance, which may be attributed to the absence of As far as biological growth on roofing surfaces is con-
coal-fired power plants in California. Calcium is found in cerned, it is clear that a large variety of species is expected
rather high abundance, except for the remote McArthur to be present. For example, some of the species of fungi
site in northeastern California. Due to the small amount that occur in soil may be expected to be present. However,
of sulfur present, the calcium is likely to be in the form the ultraviolet radiation incident on roofing can kill many
of carbonate (rather than sulfate). The first five metals in organisms. We have noted earlier that the cyanobacteria
Table 1 all have white oxides, and are unlikely to reduce Gloeocapsa infests mineral roofing granules, leading to
the reflectance of highly reflective roofing. (They are, of black colored stains. In a study of biomass accumulation
course, expected to raise the reflectance of black roofing.) on single-ply roofing membranes exposed in Oak Ridge,
The relatively abundant transition metals Fe, Mn, Cu, Tennessee [44], it was found by phospholipid fatty acid
Table 1
Concentrations of several abundant elements and organic/elemental carbon in mg m 2, collected on samples of roofing materials exposed for 19 months
(until April, 2005) at several California locations [40]
California location
Shafter McArthur Sacramento El Centro Corona Colton Richmond
Coordinates 35.50°N 41.02°N 38.59°N 32.79°N 33.88°N 34.07°N 37.94°N
119.27°W 121.65°W 121.51°W 115.56°W 117.56°W 117.31°W 122.34°W
on mineral materials in cool damp climates, and fungi on [10] Greigger PP, Wilson P. High-performance fluoropolymer coatings.
polymeric materials. Springdale, (PA), PPG Industries, http://corporate.ppg.com/PPG/
PAF/Coraflon/WhatsNew/whitepaper.htm.
[11] Miller WA, Kriner S, Parker DS. Cool metal roofing is topping the
Acknowledgements building envelope with energy efficiency and sustainability. In: RCI
foundation conference, ‘‘cool roofs: cutting through the glare,’’
M.D. Cheng of Oak Ridge National Laboratory Atlanta, (CA, USA); May 12–13, 2005.
(ORNL) kindly provided results for Table 1 in advance of [12] Website of Ciba Specialty Chemicals (http://www.cibasc.com/),
subject of light stabilizers.
publication. A. Desjarlais of ORNL, S. Wiel of Lawrence [13] Schoolenberg GE, Vink P. Ultraviolet degradation of polypropylene:
Berkeley National Laboratory and C. Scruton of the Cali- 1. degradation profile and thickness of the embrittled surface layer.
fornia Energy Commission provided technical and manage- Polymer 1991;32:432–7.
ment advice. Many individuals in the roofing materials [14] Andrady AL, Hamid SH, Hu X, Torikai A. Effects of increased solar
industry provided us with expert advice including C. Gross, ultraviolet radiation on materials. J Photochem Photobiol B
1998;46:96–103.
J. Jacobs, P. Fleming, 3M Corp.; J. Reilly, R. Sypowics, [15] Knaebe M, Carll C. Wood shakes and shingles for roof applications;
American Rooftile Coatings; R. Schichili, BASF and con- tips for longer life. Forest Products Laboratory finishing factsheet,
sultant to Custom-Bilt Metals, M. Shiao, L. Terrenzio, Cer- US Department of Agriculture Forest Service; January 1998.
tainTeed Corp; T. Chiovare, Custom-Bilt Metals ; L. Hahn, [16] Akbari H, Levinson R, Berdahl P. Review of residential roofing
K. Tellman, Elk Manufacturing, Corp.; R. Abrams, R. materials, part I: a review of methods for the manufacture of
residential roofing materials. Western Roofing Insulation and Siding
Blonsky, J. Dunn, I. Joyce, K. Loye, D. Swiler, Ferro 2005:54–7. Jan/Feb.
Corp.; M. Desouto, K. Srinivasan, GAF Materials Corp.; [17] Akbari H, Levinson R, Berdahl P. Review of residential roofing
I. Joedicke, ISP Minerals Corp.; Y. Suzuki, MCA Clay Tile; materials, part II: a review of methods for the manufacture of
J. Vanderwater, MonierLifetile; S. Graveline, K. Foley, residential roofing materials. Western Roofing Insulation and Siding
Sarnafil Corp.; J. Nixon, T. Steger, Shepherd Color Co.; 2005:52–8. Mar/Apr.
[18] Tropsha Y, Andrady A. Photodegradation of asphalt and its
M. Vondran, Steelscape: and K. Watkins, Watkins Saw- sensitivity to the different wavelengths of the sunlight spectrum. In:
mills Ltd. This work was supported by the California En- Polymeric materials science and engineering, Vol. 66, Spring Meeting
ergy Commission through its Public Interest Energy of the American Chemical Society, Division of Polymeric Materials;
Research Program. Lawrence Berkeley National Labora- 1992. p. 305.
tory is managed by the University of California for the [19] Huang J, Yuro R, Romeo Jr GA. Photooxidation of Corbett
fractions of asphalt. Fuel Sci Technol Int 1995;13:1121–34.
US Department of Energy under Contract No. DE- [20] Petersen JC. A dual, sequential mechanism for the oxidation of
AC02-05CH11231. Oak Ridge National Laboratory is petroleum asphalts. Pet Sci Technol 1998;16:1023–59.
managed by UT-Battelle, LLC, for the US Department of [21] Pascoe R. Phthalocyanine green pigments. In: Lewis PA, editor.
Energy under contract DE-AC05-00OR22725. Pigment handbook, properties and economics. 2nd ed., vol. I, New
York: John Wiley and Sons Inc.; 1988. [Chapter I-D-1-2,
table 5].
References [22] Herbst W, Hunger K. Industrial organic pigments. Weinheim
(Germany): Wiley-VCH; 1998.
[1] Levinson R, Berdahl P, Akbari H, Miller W, Joedicke I, Reilly J, et al. [23] Hamid SH, Amin MB, Maadhah AG, editors. Handbook of polymer
Methods of creating solar-reflective nonwhite surfaces and their degradation. New York: Marcel Dekker Inc.; 1995.
application to residential roofing materials, Sol Energ Mat Sol C [in [24] Rabek JF. Polymer photodegradation. London: Chapman & Hall;
press]. 1995.
[2] Joshi AA, Pagni PJ. Fire-induced thermal fields in window glass. II- [25] Scott G. Polymer degradation and stabilization. London: Elsevier
experiments. Fire Safety J 1994;22:45–65. Applied Science Publishers; 1990.
[3] T. Futcher. Columbia Union College, Takoma Park (ML, USA,) [26] Wypych J. Weathering handbook. 2nd ed. Toronto, (Canada):
http://www.cs.cuc.edu/~tfutcher/Cyanophyta.html. Chemtec Publishing; 1995 (Despite the title, this reference is exclu-
[4] 3M roofing granules, http://solutions.3m.com/wps/portal/_l/en_US/ sively concerned with polymers.).
_s.155/115625/_s.155/117267. [27] Andrady AL, Hamid SH, Hu X, Torikai A. Effects of increased solar
[5] Williams RS. The finishing of wood. Wood handbook: wood as an ultraviolet radiation on materials, [Chapter 7.] In: Environmental
engineering material. Forest Products Laboratory, Madison, (WI, effects of ozone depletion, 1998, assessment of the United Nations
USA,) [Chapter 15]. http://woodworking.about.com/gi/dynamic/off- Environmental Programme, http://www.gcrio.org/UNEP1998/.
site.htm?site=http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/. [28] Cash CG. Estimating the durability of roofing systems. In: Ketola
[6] Lewis PA, editor. Pigment Handbook, properties and economics, 2nd WD, Evans JD, editors. Durability 2000: accelerated and outdoor
ed., vol. I. New York: John Wiley and Sons Inc.; 1988. weathering testing, STP 1385. Philadelphia (PA, USA): ASTM; 2000.
[7] Reed R. Painted metal: from fluoropolymers to polyesters, sorting out p. 165–9.
the issues in coil coatings. In: Metal roofing; August–September 2003. [29] Terrenzio LA, Harrison JW, Nester DA, Shiao ML. Natural vs.
[8] ASTM Standard D 4214-98. Standard test methods for evaluating the artificial aging: use of diffusion theory to model asphalt and
degree of chalking of exterior paint films. ASTM International, West fiberglass-reinforced shingle performance. In: Proceedings of the
Conshohocken, (PA, USA); 1998. fourth international symposium on roofing technolology, Gaithers-
[9] ASCA 96 specification as listed at http://www.products.arkema- burg; September 1997. p. 66–74.
group.com/pdf/techpoly/ASCA_96.pdf. See also Arkema, ATO- [30] Shiao ML, Nester DA, Terrenzio LA. On the kinetics of thermal
FINA Chemicals, Inc., Philadelphia, product brochure on Kynar loads for accelerated aging, roofing research and standards
500 PVDF resin-based metal coatings. Cited ASTM standards are development. In: Rossiter WJ, Wallace TJ, editors. ASTM interna-
Hunter color change D 2244, chalking D 4214 and D 659, and gloss D tional, vol. 5, ASTM STP 1451. West Conshohocken, (PA, USA);
523. 2003.
P. Berdahl et al. / Construction and Building Materials 22 (2008) 423–433 433
[31] ARMA technical bulletin, application of asphalt shingles over [42] Berdahl P, Akbari H, Rose LS. Aging of reflective roofs: soot
insulation or insulated decks, ARMA form number 209-RR-86; July deposition. Appl Opt 2002;41:2355–60.
1996 (Revised). [43] Kirchstetter TW, Novakov T, Hobbs PV. Evidence that the spectral
[32] ARMA technical bulletin, ventilation and moisture control for dependence of light absorption by aerosols is affected by organic
residential roofing, ARMA form number 211-RR-94; November carbon. J Geophys Res-Atmos 109(d21): D21208; 12 November 2004.
1997 (Revised). [44] Miller WA, Cheng MD, Pfiffner S, Byars N. The field performance of
[33] Kemp GR, Predoehl NH. A comparison of field and laboratory high-reflectance single-ply membranes exposed to three years of
environments on asphalt durability. Asphalt Paving Technol weathering in various US climates, Oak Ridge National Laboratory,
1981;50:492–555. report prepared for, and available from, the Single-Ply Roofing
[34] Baker MC. Decay of wood, Canadian Building Digest, CBD-111. Institute, Needham, (MA, USA); 2002.
(originally published in 1969), http://irc.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/cbd/ [45] Gaylarde CC, Gaylarde PM. A comparative study of the major
cbd111e.html. microbial biomass of biofilms on exteriors of buildings in Europe and
[35] Corrosion of zinc, ‘‘Knowledge Article’’ from www.Key-to-Met- Latin America. Int Biodeter Biodegr 2005;55:131–9.
als.com. [46] Dupuy P, Trotet G, Grossin F. Protection des monuments contre les
[36] ASTM Standard C 1167-03. Standard specification for clay roof tiles. cyanophycees en milieu abrite et humide. In: Rossi-Manaressi R,
[37] Buchner G, Kundgen U, Bayer AG. An anniversary – 25 years of editor. The conservation of stone I, Centro per la Conservazione delle
outdoor weathering of pigmented building materials, Beton- Sculture all’Aperto, Bologna; 1976. p. 205–19.
werk+Fertigteil Technik; July 1996. [47] Ortega-Calvo JJ, Ariiio X, Hernandez-Marineb M, Saiz-Jimenez C.
[38] Bayer Chemicals, inorganic pigments group, reduction of efflores- Factors affecting the weathering and colonization of monuments by
cence on concrete paving blocks by impregnation with a plastic phototrophic microorganisms. Sci Total Environ 1995;167:329–41.
emulsion, technical information from Bayer AG; May 2002. Also, [48] Webb JS, Nixon M, Eastwood IM, Greenhalgh M, Robson GD,
removing efflorescence and soil from the surface of concrete pavers; Handley PS. Fungal colonization and biodeterioration of plasticized
May 2002. polyvinyl chloride. Appl Environ Microb 2000;66:3194–200.
[39] Ebert M, Weinbruch S, Hoffmann P, Ortner HM. The chemical [49] Narayan SB et al. Method of inhibiting algae growth on asphalt
composition and complex refractive index of rural and urban shingles, US Patent: 5,356,664; 1994.
influenced aerosols determined by individual particle analysis. Atmos [50] Joedicke IB. US Patent: 7,060,658; 13 June 2006.
Environ 2004;38:6531–5. [51] Levinson MR, Berdahl P, Berhe AA, Akbari H. Effects of soiling and
[40] Cheng MD, Miller WA, Berdahl P, Pfiffner S. Composition and cleaning on the reflectance and solar heat gain of a light-colored
effects of atmospheric particles on the performance of steep-slope roofing membrane. Atmos Environ 2005;39:7807–24.
roofing materials, [in preparation]. [52] Coulthwaite L, Bayley K, Liauw C, Craig G, Verran J. The effect of
[41] Levinson R, Berdahl P, Akbari H. Solar spectral optical properties of free and encapsulated OIT on the biodeterioration of plasticised PVC
pigments-part II: survey of common colorants. Sol Energ Mat Sol C during burial in soil for 20 months. Int Biodeter Biodegr
2005;89:351–89 [Figure 1, Film R03.]. 2005;56:86–93.