Euphemisms, Concentration Camps And The Japanese Internment : NPR Ombudsman : NPR 2/11/12 11:08 AM

NPR Ombudsman with Edward Schumacher-Matos

Euphemisms, Concentration Camps And The Japanese
Internment
Categories: Language, Media and Society

03:18 pm
February 10, 2012

by EDWARD SCHUMACHER-MATOS and LORI GRISHAM

Dorothea Lange/Library of Congress

A large sign placed in the window of a store in Oakland, Calif. in 1942. The store was closed
following orders to persons of Japanese descent to evacuate from certain West Coast areas.

Shortly following the bombing of Pearl Harbor, President Franklin Roosevelt issued
Executive Order 9066. In a climate of widespread fear bordering on panic, the order
resulted in the incarceration of more than 100,000 people of Japanese descent living
on the West Coast. They were uprooted from their homes and isolated in 10 hastily
constructed camps, some of them for as long as four years, in what is widely known
as the Japanese-American Internment.

Talk of the Nation's Neal Conan hosted a segment last week about Fred Korematsu,
a civil rights leader who challenged the executive order at the time. Conan's
interview with Korematsu's daughter, Karen, prompted some thoughtful and even
http://www.npr.org/blogs/ombudsman/2012/02/10/146691773/euphemisms-concentration-camps-and-the-japanese-internment Page 1 of 4
Euphemisms, Concentration Camps And The Japanese Internment : NPR Ombudsman : NPR 2/11/12 11:08 AM

evocative replies from listeners, several of whom shared their own personal family
stories.

But one listener disliked Conan and Korematsu's use of the phrase "concentration
camp" to refer to the sites where people were detained. William Medley from
Gallipolis, OH, wrote:

There was a story on a gentleman named Korematsu and his fight against the Japanese
internment camps. The story was interesting and I felt a large degree of empathy for the family. It
was nice to hear that he was being recognized for his fight against the way the American Japanese
were treated.

But then the commentator referred to the Japanese internment camps as "concentration camps." I
cannot imagine a more offensive way to portray the situation. To compare the Japanese internment
camps to the Nazi or communist concentration camps is beyond offensive to the Jewish community
and any reasonably intelligent American. While not Jewish myself, I found it to be terribly offensive.
Words have meaning and to diminish the term "concentration camps" is reprehensible.

We asked Conan to explain his word choice. As seen in his reply and many of his on-
air interviews, Conan appears to like history. He wrote:

"Concentration camp" is a term that predates both Hitler and Communism. The Nazi concentration
camps are more usually, and more accurately described as Death Camps. Stalin's Gulags are
slightly different, as they were prison camps, though the "crimes" and "trials" were often specious.
But a concentration camp, such as those operated by the British during the Boer War, does not in
and of itself suggest atrocity.

His explanation holds up with NPR's dictionary-of-choice, Webster's New World

Fourth College Edition. It defines a concentration camp as, "A prison camp in which
political dissidents, members of minority ethnic groups, etc. are confined."
Somewhat surprisingly, "internment camp" is not listed in the dictionary.

The Oxford English Dictionary supports Conan's historical explanation as well. The
OED defines a concentration camp as, "a camp where non-combatants of a district
are accommodated, such as those instituted by Lord Kitchener during the Boer War
(1899–1902); one for the internment of political prisoners, foreign nationals, etc.,
esp. as organized by the Nazi regime in Germany before and during the war of 1939–
45."

Nazis put Jews, and millions of non-Jews, into about 20,000 camps during the war.
According to the Holocaust Museum, these camps ranged from forced-labor camps
where internees worked as slave labor, transit camps that served as holding pins
http://www.npr.org/blogs/ombudsman/2012/02/10/146691773/euphemisms-concentration-camps-and-the-japanese-internment Page 2 of 4
Euphemisms, Concentration Camps And The Japanese Internment : NPR Ombudsman : NPR 2/11/12 11:08 AM

before sending people off to Auschwitz and other places, and extermination camps,
or death camps, built primarily for mass murder. Today, we often identify the phrase
"concentration camp" with the latter, though the museum itself has a broader
definition, and one that may be clearer than either of the dictionary ones. The
museum says:

The term concentration camp refers to a camp in which people are detained or confined, usually
under harsh conditions and without regard to legal norms of arrest and imprisonment that are
acceptable in a constitutional democracy.

But this debate goes beyond textbook definitions.

Roger Daniels, a historian and author, wrote an analysis for the University of
Washington Press called "Words Do Matter: A Note on Inappropriate Terminology
and the Incarceration of the Japanese Americans." He concludes that, although it's
unlikely society will completely cease to use the phrase "Japanese internment,"
scholars should abandon the term and use "concentration camp." He considers
internment a euphemism that minimizes a tragic time in American history.

President Franklin Roosevelt himself called the relocation sites concentration camps
and Harold Ickes, Secretary of the Interior, told the Washington Evening Star in
1946:

As a member of President Roosevelt's administration, I saw the United States Army give way to
mass hysteria over the Japanese...Crowded into cars like cattle, these hapless people were hurried
away to hastily constructed and thoroughly inadequate concentration camps, with soldiers with
nervous muskets on guard, in the great American desert. We gave the fancy name of 'relocation
centers' to these dust bowls, but they were concentration camps nonetheless.

But Daniels recognizes that many scholars won't agree with him. He quotes Alice
Yang Murray, a professor of history at the University of California and the author of
several books on Asian American history:

The term "concentration camp" may once have been a euphemism for a Nazi "extermination
camp," but I think that over time the two kinds of camps have become inextricably linked in the
popular imagination. In other words, I believe the meaning of the term "concentration camp" has
changed over time. During World War II, officials and commentators could say Japanese
Americans were confined in concentration camps without evoking images of Nazi atrocities. I don't
think that this is true today.

But while Murray be an Asian-American scholar, the Japanese American Citizens

http://www.npr.org/blogs/ombudsman/2012/02/10/146691773/euphemisms-concentration-camps-and-the-japanese-internment Page 3 of 4
Euphemisms, Concentration Camps And The Japanese Internment : NPR Ombudsman : NPR 2/11/12 11:08 AM

League, the oldest Asian-American civil rights group, doesn't agree with her and
sides with Daniels. It calls the camps concentration camps, and has a map of them.
On Conan's program, Korematsu spoke with this Japanese-American view.

So, where does all this leave us? Listener Medley, perhaps without realizing it, has
re-opened a long debate. He also is right that words matter. They frame our view of
the past and influence our destiny for the future. But it seems on balance that
"concentration camp" is at the very least acceptable—and may be appropriate even
today—in referring to the interning of Japanese Americans.

What we all really seem to be seeking is a phrase that doesn't diminish the cruelty of
uprooting and isolating Japanese and Japanese-Americans against their will, but
also doesn't diminish the true horror of Nazi extermination camps. You may have
other words to suggest in striking the balance.

Tags: concentration camps, World War II, Neal Conan

http://www.npr.org/blogs/ombudsman/2012/02/10/146691773/euphemisms-concentration-camps-and-the-japanese-internment Page 4 of 4