RUBRIC FOR BKF3731 UNIT OPERATION LAB

UNIT OPERATION LAB

(BKF3731)
2019/2020 Semester II

Title of Experiment : Short Path Distillation

Date of Experiment : 10th March 2020
Instructor’s Name : Dr Nurul Sa'aadah Binti Sulaiman

Group of Member :
Name ID
1. MUSTAF MOHAMED KA15301
2. GILLIAN ROSE BRYANT HERNAEZ KA17080
3. WAN NURTHAHIRAH BINTI WAN KAMARUDIN KA17182
4. ZUHAIRI BIN YUSRI KA17230

Group No. : 02
Section : 03
Marks :

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING, DEPARTMENT OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING

UNIVERSITI MALAYSIA PAHANG

Please keep for student reference.

Submitted by;
Received by;

( MUSTAF MOHAMED )
( )

Subject Code : BKF3731

Title of Experiment : Short Path Distillation Date Submitted: 10th March 2020
1
RUBRIC FOR BKF3731 UNIT OPERATION LAB

2
 RUBRIC FOR BKF3731 UNIT OPERATION LAB

REPORT EVALUATION RUBRIC

Instruction: Please assess each item using the given scales. Fractional marks will be given for each category.

Unacceptable Acceptable Good Very Good

Item Assessed Score
(0) (1) (2) (3)
Organization and Not follow Partially follow Follow FKKSA Follow FKKSA laboratory
Format x 1 FKKSA laboratory FKKSA laboratory laboratory report report format of writing; all
report format. Not report format. format of writing; needed sections present.
Keywords: Front page, well organized. Contents show enough all needed sections Tables and figures are
Content, Page No., Contents show lack of knowledge but still present. Well correctly drawn and
Total page <15 pages, of knowledge. a few concept and organized. numbered. Excellent
Arrangement ideas are loosely organized and easily
connected. followed
Abstract x 2 No abstract Abstract misses one or Abstract contains Abstract contains
more major aspects of most major aspects references to all major
Keywords: laboratory report. of laboratory report aspects of laboratory report
Introduction, but the writing style i.e. main purpose of the
Objective, Method, can be further experiment, its importance,
Result, Conclusion, improved. methodology/ approach,
Suggestion, 1 page most significant results or
findings, main conclusions
and/or recommendation.
General audience easily
understands abstract.

Introduction x 1 Very little Some introductory Introduction is Introduction is complete

background information, but still nearly complete, and well written; provides
Keywords: Related information or missing some major missing some minor all necessary background
Theory, Principles, information is points. OR, gives little points. principles and theory for
Process Background, incorrect OR, does information the experiment. Present a
1-2 page/s not give any concise lead-in to the
information about laboratory experiment.
what to expect in
the laboratory
report
Methodology No flowchart of the Method flowchart is Method flowchart is Method flowchart is
Flowchart x 2 method is nearly complete but explained with complete. Logical and
presented. still missing some sufficient detail; easily followed.
Keywords: Experiment important some lack detail or Description of procedure is
Procedure, List of Missing several experimental details. are confusing. complete, ensuring that it
Equipment, Specify the important Mostly easy to can be replicated.
value, Make as flow explanations of follow.
chart, 1-2 page/s materials and/or
methodology. Not
sequential. Most
steps are missing
or are confusing.
Some procedural
components
generally described
but are not
replicable.
Data Processing & Calculations not Calculation was Corrected Correct and complete
Analysis x 2 shown or totally provided but with calculation. calculation. Data was
wrong. No table or some error. Incomplete or in organized well in term of
Keywords: Data graph are present. adequate data table or graph.
calculation, graph organization in term
presentation, table of table or graph
presentation form.

3
 RUBRIC FOR BKF3731 UNIT OPERATION LAB

Unacceptable Acceptable Good Very Good

Item Assessed Score
(0) (1) (2) (3)
Results Discussion x 2 Only mention the Attempt to discuss Elucidation of result Elucidation and supported
results but failed miserably but by
Keywords: Experiment without meaningful contains some flaws proper references or logical
Summary, discussion explanations.
Recommendation .

Conclusions and No conclusions Conclusion missing Conclusions All the important

recommendations x 1 given. No the important points. regarding major conclusions have been
recommendation Or points are drawn, clearly made. Conclusion
Keywords: Experiment given to improve Conclusion is too but many is precisely stated and
Summary, the experiment. general. Several are misstated, relates the study to general
Recommendation, 1-2 recommendations indicating a interest, other studies that
page/s have been given but lack of have been conducted.
they are too general understanding Recommendations given
and not contributing to Several are significantly contribute
the experiment’s recommendations to the experiment’s
improvement. have been stated and improvement
they are partially
contributed to the
experiment’s
improvement.

References x 1 No citations in the Some citations in text All citations in text All citations in text are
text but showed a are not available in list are available in list available in list of
Keywords: Book list of reference of reference. OR of reference but reference. All references
Reference, Journal Some citations in ununiformed some of the from variety sources and
Reference, Website text are not referencing reference is not reliable.
Reference; Reliable available in list of system OR more than reliable.
reference. 80% references from
internet or wikipedia
Appendices x1 Appendices not Only a few appendices Appendices Appendices available in
available in available in laboratory available in laboratory report in
Keywords: Raw result laboratory report. report. laboratory report but structured manners, clearly
and proper data poorly constructed and precise
collection
Grammar and Numerous spelling Still many spelling Occasional Minimal to no spelling
Spelling x1 and/or grammar and/or grammar grammar/spelling mistakes. Spell checked
errors. Transitions errors. Few or weak errors. May have a and proofed throughout.
Keywords: Language confusing and transitions, often few unclear Good sentence and
unclear. wanders and jumps transitions. paragraph structure and
around. transitions.

Timeliness x 1 Laboratory report Up to one week late Handed in one day Laboratory report handed
handed in more late in on time
Keywords: Punctuality than one week late

TOTAL MARKS (45 Marks)

4
Scanned by TapScanner
Scanned by TapScanner
Scanned by TapScanner
6.0 REFERENCES

1. Geankoplis, C.J. (2003(4th Edition )). Transport Process and Separation Process Principles.

New Jerdey: Pearson Education Inc.

7.0 APPENDICES