COMPARE METHODE OF INSTALLATION NEW POLE & LAMP LED AT NEW ROAD

PT ASTRA DAIHATSU MOTOR PE BUILDING

PRODUCTION ENGINEERING - BUILDING AND FACILITY SECTION 21-Nov-19

NO ITEM CURRENT DESIGN NEW DESIGN 1 NEW DESIGN 2 NEW DESIGN 3

C B A
C B C
A C B B A
A
1 DESIGN

POLE LAMP BEFORE DRAINAGE POLE LAMP AFTER DRAINAGE POLE LAMP AFTER DRAINAGE POLE
POLELAMP
LAMPAAFTER
CROSSDRAINAGE
THE ROAD

'* Total Pole Lamp = 40 pcs '* Total Pole Lamp = 40 pcs '* Total Pole Lamp = 40 pcs '* Total Pole Lamp = 40 pcs
* Foundation lamp : 600x600x1000 * Foundation lamp : 600x600x500 * Foundation lamp : 600x600x500 * Foundation lamp : 600x600x500
* Concrete foundation K250 * Concrete foundation K250 * Concrete foundation K250 * Concrete foundation K250
* Excavation soil for foundation * Demolish concrete for rebar foundation * Demolish concrete for rebar foundation * Demolish concrete for rebar foundation
* Formwork bataco (no need demolish) * Formwork wooden (need demolsih after curring) * Formwork wooden (need demolsih after curring) * Formwork wooden (need demolsih after curring)
* Additional stek to current structure * Additional stek to current structure

2 SAFETY
* Position of pole lamp is secure from potential hit by truck or dolly /
O * Position of pole lamp potential hit by truck or dolly / towing X * Position of pole lamp potential hit by truck or dolly / towing X * Position of pole lamp potential hit by truck or dolly / towing X
towing (Need protection pipe for cover pole of lamp LED) (Need protection pipe for cover pole of lamp LED) (Need protection pipe for cover pole of lamp LED)
3 0 0 0
* Lux pole lamp fullfill standard government * Lux pole lamp fullfill standard government
* Lux pole lamp fullfill standard government * Lux pole lamp fullfill standard government
(Standard Government 5 - 20 Lux) (Standard Government 5 - 20 Lux)

3 QUALITY
(Standard Government 5 - 20 Lux)
Lux test :
O (Standard Government 5 - 20 Lux)
Lux test :
O Lux test :
A : 23 Lux -> OK
Δ Lux test :
A : 23 Lux -> OK
O
A : 11 Lux -> OK A : 23 Lux -> OK
B : 61 Lux ->OK B : 61 Lux ->OK
B : 23 Lux -> OK B : 61 Lux ->OK
C : 91 Lux -> OK C : 91 Lux -> OK
C : 57 Lux -> OK C : 91 Lux -> OK
3 3 * Reduce width of Road so potential distrub trafic of truck 1 3
Potential Additional cost : Potential Additional cost :
'- Additional reinforcement foundation : 8,7 miill
Δ - Additional formwork : 10 mill X '- Additional formwork : 10 mill X O
- Additional protecton pole :80 mill - Additional protecton pole :80 mill
- Need Rent Boom Lift 1 year/1x : Rp 18,9 Jt (rent 1 week)
4 COST - Additional for modification cansteen : 15 mill - Additional for modification cansteen : 15 mill - NO additonal cost
for total lamp (40 pcs) if any problem Lamp
- Additional demolish floor for steking : 10 mill - Additional demolish floor for steking : 10 mill
- Need Additional steel conduit : 25 mill - Need Additional steel conduit : 25 mill
1 0 0 3
TOTAL : ± Rp 148,7 Mill / 5 year = 29,74 Mill/year TOTAL : ± Rp 140 Mill / 5 year = 28 Mill/year

- Excavation Soil ±5 day / 40 point -Demolish floor existing ±5 day / 40 point -Demolish floor existing ±5 day / 40 point -Demolish floor existing ±5 day / 40 point
- Install formwork bataco 2 point/day/MP
(total 5 day/40 point with 4 MP)
O - Install formwork wooden 2point/day/MP
(total 5 day/40 point with 4 MP)
O - Install formwork wooden 2point/day/MP
(total 5 day/40 point with 4 MP)
O - Install formwork wooden 2point/day/MP
(total 5 day/40 point with 4 MP)
O
5 DELIVERY

TOTAL SCHEDULE : 3 month
- Dificult to maintenance because position lamp upper drainage
- Maintenance activity every 1 year/1x or every any problem lamp
6 MAINTENANCE
LED so need boom lift to support maintenance process (Need Rent
Boom lift)
TOTAL SCHEDULE : 3 month
3 3
Δ - Easy to maintenance because position lamp upper concrete
road
- Maintenance activity every 1 year/1x or every any problem
lamp LED so need mobile lifter to support maintenance process
1 (Using mobile lifter ADM)
TOTAL SCHEDULE : 3 month TOTAL SCHEDULE : 3 month
3 3
- Easy to maintenance because position lamp upper concrete
O - Easy to maintenance because position lamp upper concrete
road
O road
- Maintenance activity every 1 year/1x or every any problem
X
- Maintenance activity every 1 year/1x or every any problem lamp LED so need mobile lifter to support maintenance
lamp LED so need mobile lifter to support maintenance process (Using mobile lifter ADM)
3 process (Using mobile lifter ADM) 3 *Cable of lamp potential interference with access new 0
factory (in future)

TOTAL 11 9 7 9
CONCLUSION :
Based on SQCDM result, we propose to choose current design for method of installation foundation pole Lamp
LED at New Road