Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
A guide for medical information
searches of bibliographic databases
– psychiatric research as an example
1
Department of Psychiatry, University of Oulu, Oulu, Finland.
2
Medical Informatics Group, University of Oulu, Oulu, Finland.
ABSTRACT
Information overload, demanding work with strict time limits, and the extensive number of
medical bibliographic databases and other research sources all underline the importance of
being able to search for up-to-date information effectively. Medical journals play a key role in
providing access to the latest information in medicine and health and bibliographic databases
play an important role in accessing them. This paper sheds light on the role of the information
search process and discusses how to approach key medical bibliographic databases and informa-
tion sources, using the field of psychiatry as an example. Because of an increasing amount of
information, the constant renewal within the discipline and a variety of services available, those
seeking information must precisely define what kind of information they are looking for and
from which sources the information needed may be found.
(Int J Circumpolar Health 2009; 68(4):394-404)
Defining the research problem and questions can guide you in the next steps of the
formulating the questions search process.
When information is needed, asking certain Background reading can also help to define
questions can help to clarify precisely what the research question. A quick, basic search
kind of information to look for. There are is a good way to become familiar with terms
several key questions to help focus the search. related to the topic and to get a general over-
For example, What is the exact topic? What view of the subject (11). A quick search can
purpose will the information play? Which also provide facts needed in clinical deci-
issues are included and/or excluded? What sion-making or new information related to the
is essential information and what is already subject at hand. For example, a quick search
known on the topic? Is the needed informa- can provide an orientation to a diagnostic term
15
tion general or scientific? The answers to these or an overview of a drug’s side effects.
In addition to the information search process always easy, as some of the material may be
model (Fig. 1), the PICO model can be used to in other bibliographic databases that focus on
transform a clinical question into a searchable different disciplines. This means that restricting
query. The PICO model defines the question on the search to a certain bibliographic database
4 key levels: patients, population or problem; may result in omission of important references
interventions; comparisons; and outcomes (7). (13). When considering the choice of databases
Here is an example of how to use the PICO for an information search, the extent of the data-
model when researching schizophrenia: base’s coverage should be taken into account
(14). For example, when conducting psychiatric
P schizophrenia patients research, information on previous studies can
I new antipsychotic treatment be found in psychological bibliographic data-
C old antipsychotic treatment bases in addition to medical ones. It is therefore
O reduction in adverse events recommended that several bibliographic data-
bases be used in order to cover as much infor-
The electronic tools used in an informa- mation available on the subject as possible (13).
tion search include library databases, refer- Different bibliographic databases also vary in
ence books, various portals and Internet search such areas as types of publications they include
engines. Information can also be hand-searched and the periods of time they cover (14).
by researching hard copies of specific journals. Indexing refers to a description of docu-
Choosing the best articles in those journals can ments using certain rules, vocabularies and key
provide descriptors and keywords that can be words. Thesaurus is a special vocabulary where
used on a database search for other relevant the relations between terms are expressed in a
information (12). When extensive information standardized manner. One should be aware
is needed, the search process should be planned that different databases use different keyword
and conducted systematically. To acquire systems and different levels when indexing
comprehensive knowledge of a subject and to material. The translation of terms from one
keep abreast with the latest developments calls database to another is not the best strategy when
for a systematic and advanced information devising a search strategy (15). A thesaurus
search. is affected when there is rapid development
in a field and recently introduced terms and
Choice of databases concepts in the literature are not included in
Bibliographic databases are extensive compi- the vocabulary quickly enough. Searches may
lations of references to documents. In this take considerably longer in bibliographic data-
context, reference is the information included in bases that emphasize description as compared
the document, such as information on authors, to those whose articles are not indexed exten-
abstract, journal title and year of publication sively and users are expected to utilize the free
(6,7). Many bibliographic databases include a text search (13). A free text search makes use of
link to the full text. freely chosen search words targeting all desired
In the case of health science, the choice fields in the bibliographic database. Some data-
of which bibliographic database to use is not bases, such as Medline, include a function that
automatically maps the natural language terms PsycINFO). According to the study, there are
in the free context search and changes them into several international journals in Europe that
suitable key words. When authors are willing are not indexed in Medline, and the majority
to answer queries concerning their texts, which of psychiatric research in Finland is published
helps to develop key search terms, their articles elsewhere than in journals indexed in EMBASE
become more rapidly available. and Medline. This phenomenon is also common
Nieminen and Isohanni (16) have studied in other minor languages. McDonald et al. (10)
the coverage of Finnish psychiatric research in have compared the coverage of psychiatric jour-
Medline, EMBASE and PsycLIT (cd-version of nals. Their results support the idea of including
Qualified queries using databases like the tion that is accessible to all users. Open access
PubMed Clinical Queries (www.ncbi.nlm.nih. (OA) journals can be searched through the
gov/entrez/query/static/clinical.shtml) can help Directory of Open Access Journals (www.
you select materials. This feature is also included doaj.org) or through the free digital archive of
in Medline (Ovid), EMBASE, PsycINFO and biomedical and life sciences journal literature
CINAHL (Ebsco). In addition to preparing at PubMed Central (www.pubmedcentral.nih.
queries, you can focus the search on certain gov). The Public Library of Science (PLoS)
publication types, such as reviews and meta- (www.plos.org) and BioMed Central (BMC)
analyses, or on publication year or language, or (www.biomedcentral.com) are independent
by using suitable keywords. Vocabularies such OA publishers that offer several freely acces-
as MeSH can improve search performances sible journals and a wide coverage of the field
(31). of medicine.
The Cochrane Library (www.cochrane. There are also different OA repositories,
org) includes evaluated and controlled high- like the Directory of Open Access Reposito-
quality evidence-based information on ries – OpenDOAR (www.opendoar.org) and
reviews and clinical trials. Other information CiteSeer (www.citeseer.ist.psu.edu), both of
sources related to evidence-based informa- which store scientific literature. The advan-
tion are Seek (www.shef.ac.uk/seek), EBM tage of OA journals is that published arti-
Guidelines (ebmg.wiley.com/ebmg), the TRIP cles are freely available and the openness in
database (www.tripdatabase.com/index.html), dissemination is greater (32). According to
SUMsearch (http://sumsearch.uthscsa.edu/), Eysenbach (33), OA has at least 3 advantages:
and BMJ Clinical Evidence (www.clinicalevi- a citation count advantage, an end-user uptake
dence.org/ceweb/index.jsp). DynaMed (http:// advantage and a cross-discipline fertilization
www.ebscohost.com/dynamed) is a clinical advantage. It was found that OA articles are
reference tool for use primarily at the “point- cited earlier and more often than non-OA
of-care” with clinically organized summaries. articles (30).
UpToDate (http://www.uptodate.com) is an
evidence-based, peer-reviewed information Search engines and portals
resource. PIER: The Physicians’ Information The most popular Internet search engine,
and Education Resource (http://pier.acpon- Google (www.google.com), also has a version
line.org/index.html?jhp) provides authorita- for scientific materials, Google Scholar
tive, evidence-based summaries. (www.scholar.google.com), and a version
to search only books (www.books.google.
Access to databases com), Google Books. Google Scholar makes
Bibliographic databases are commercial it possible to search for essays, presenta-
products, which is why not all databases are tions, books, abstracts and articles in various
licensed by individual research organizations. fields and from different sources, such as
PubMed (www.pubmed.gov) is freely avail- academic publishers, associations and other
able on the Internet as is Medline. In addition scientific organizations. These search engines
to licensed material, there is a lot of informa- can access full-text versions of international
academic dissertations and presentations, phrenia and related diseases that are added
which are not necessarily found in licensed weekly from PubMed. This type of search can
databases. Other medical search engines and be achieved with certain keywords. The SRF
link collections include Sum-Search (www. database covers articles from the year 2000
sumsearch.uthscsa.edu), Scirus (www.scirus. onward. A Portal for Mental Health Profes-
com), Medical-Matrix (www.medmatrix.org) sionals (www.psyplexus.com) includes a tool
and the medical pages of Intute (www.intute. for a free search of journals in psychiatry,
ac.uk/healthandlifesciences/medicine). psychology and related disciplines, as well as
More and more people find references the latest headlines from 308 journals, free-
and abstracts included in PubMed by using access review articles and selected websites
Google Scholar (34). According to a study on mental health. Evidence-Based Mental
on the research possibilities provided by Health (http://ebmh.bmj.com) provides alerts
Internet search engines, there are several to important advances in treatment, diag-
approaches to information searches and an nosis, aetiology, prognosis, continuing educa-
increasing amount of material can now be tion, economic evaluation and qualitative
located by using Google and Google Scholar, research in mental health. A wide range of
with no need to be familiar with database- international medical journals are surveyed
specific search methods. The possibilities of with strict criteria for quality and validity.
the Google search engines as aids for physi- Details of essential studies are presented in
cians in making a diagnosis were evaluated in an informative abstract with commentaries
a recent article. Searches yielded the correct on their clinical applications.
diagnosis in 15 out of 26 cases (35). However, Information follow-ups can be provided
it is important to note that when using search through different alert and updating services
engines, search results include a lot of irrel- in most of the databases. For example Eviden-
evant information as well, emphasizing the ceUpdates (http://plus.mcmaster.ca/Eviden-
importance of having a critical approach ceUpdates/Default.aspx) includes free email
when evaluating the information provided. alerts about the best databases. My NCBI
. It is also more difficult to focus on and (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/myncbi/
export citations to reference software when about) is another free service that saves your
using Internet search engines. The relevance searches and sends email alerts and updates.
ranking system can be problematic when it is
important to be aware and to be able to distin- Formulating a search strategy
guish the free Internet sources that are non- Once the research problem is defined and the
federated (e.g., Google) and federated (e.g., database selection is done, the next step is to
TRIP database). formulate a search strategy. A search strategy
There are also several research portals for includes choice of search terms and rela-
mental health and psychiatry. For example, tionships between concepts. Free text words
Schizophrenia Research Forum (SRF) (www. and the thesauri of a database can be used.
schizophreniaforum.org) can search for cita- Boolean Operators (AND, OR, NOT) are used
tions on current papers dealing with schizo- to expand, exclude or to join selected search
terms. The operator AND is used to combine way process. When evaluating the results, it
search terms and search clauses to narrow and is possible that irrelevant information might
make the search more specific. OR is used be identified, or that the search resulted in
to broaden the search by including optional too few references, leading you to decide that
search terms and NOT is for excluding certain a reformulation of the search is necessary.
search terms and topics from the strategy. At that point, new and more relevant search
Other limits such as publication year, type, terms can be included in the strategy.
source and language can be set. It is advisable
to take into account the possible differences
among databases and the database-specific DISCUSSION
search practices when building a strategy.
The role of documentation in the infor- The ever-increasing network of the informa-
mation search is emphasized in dissertations tion search environment has changed the way
and research articles, particularly in system- we work, study and do research and underlines
atic reviews and meta-analyses where search the importance of having strong information
strategies are described in the methods search skills. These skills are described as
section. It is recommended that the search enabling a person to survive successfully in
strategy be documented to make the process an ever-increasing flow of information and to
more thorough and to improve the compre- achieve the goals at hand. In today’s world,
hensiveness and repeatability of research. the ability to locate, evaluate and use relevant
information can be regarded as a basic skill.
Conducting the search and Besides information overload, there has
evaluating search results also been a significant rise in the number of
Evaluating sources and search results is information resources, which has affected the
important in any kind of search. There localization of information. Choosing which
are different definitions and reasons for bibliographic databases in health science to
conducting an evaluation. When evaluating search is not an easy task, as the materials
search results, it is important to pay attention might be located in bibliographic databases
to how the retrieved results cover the subject in different fields (13). While scientific jour-
and how useful the retrieved information is in nals act as a channel for publishing new
the prevailing context. When evaluating the information in medicine, bibliographic data-
scope, it is important to take note of the extent bases play a key role in accessing them. With
of discussion as well as geographic and other the aid of bibliographic databases, the infor-
existing point of views on a subject (36). As mation needed can be used extensively and
well, it is important to pay attention to which economically.
search strategy was used, information sources Information search tools have improved
explored and other things that may have greatly for the benefit of users and will
affected the results. continue to do so. This will lead to changes
As mentioned above, the information in the way information is acquired, but the
search process is not usually a simple one- basic ideas behind the information search
will remain unaltered. The increasing amount 10. McDonald S, Taylor L, Adams C. Searching the right
database: a comparison of four databases for psychi-
of medical information and the services and atry journals. Health Libr Rev 1999;16(13):151–156.
sources that are available means that those 11. Kagolovsky Y, Moehr J. Current status of the evalu-
ation of information retrieval. J Med Syst 2003;27(5):
searching for information must be able to 409–424.
define more precisely what kind of informa- 12. Citation pearl growing. Creighton University Health
Science; c1999 [cited 2008 May 14]. Available from:
tion they are looking for and how the infor- http://newadonis.creighton.edu/HSL/searching/Pearl-
mation needed can be found. An organized, Growing.html
13. Eyers J. Searching bibliographic database effectively.
well-planned and critical approach to an Health Policy Plan 1998;13(3):339–342.
14. Wilczynski N, Haynes R, Team Hedges. Optimal
information search is extremely important search strategies for identifying mental health con-
and will become even more so as our world of tent in MEDLINE: an analytic survey. Ann Gen Psy-
chiatry 2006;23(5):4–10.
knowledge continues to expand. 15. Eady AM, Wilczynski NL, Haynes BR, Hedges Team.
PsycINFO search strategies indetified methodologi-
cally sound therapy studies and review articles for
Acknowledgements use by clinicians and researchers. J Clin Epidemiol
This work was supported by grants from the 2008;61:34–40.
16. Nieminen P, Isohanni M. Bias against European jour-
Emil Aaltosen Säätiö, the Academy of Finland nals in medical publication databases. Lancet 1999;
353(9164):1592.
and the Sigrid Jusélius Foundation. 17. Hopewell S, Clarke M, Lusher A, Lefebvre C, Westby
M. A comparison of handsearching versus MEDLINE
searching to identify reports of randomized con-
trolled trials. Statist Med 2002;21(11):1625–1634.
REFERENCES 18. Stevinson C, Lawlor DA. Searching multiple databas-
es for systematic reviews: added value or diminishing
returns. Complement Ther Med 2004;12(4):228–
1. Gore G. Searching the medical literature. Inj Prev 232.
2003 Jun;9(2):103–104. 19. Brettle A, Long A. Comparison of bibliographic da-
2. Vincent B, Vincent M, Ferreira C. Making PubMed tabase for information on the rehabilitation of peo-
searching simple: learning to retrieve medical litera- ple with severe mental illness. Bull Med Libr Assoc
ture through interactive problem solving. Oncologist 2001;89(4):353–362.
2006;11(3):243–251. 20. Cinahl information systems. Products & services. Ip-
3. Mattox D. Welcome to Archives CME. Arch Otolar- wich: EBSCO Industries Inc; c2005 [cited 2007 May
yngol Head Neck Surg 2000;129(7):914. 15]. Available from: http://www.cinahl.com/prods-
4. Romanov K, Aarnio M. A survey of the use of elec- vcs/prodsvcs.htm
tronic scientific information resources among medi- 21. ScienceDirect info. Amsterdam: Elsevier B.V.; c2007
cal and dental students. BMC Med Educ 2006;9(6): [cited 2007 May 15]. Available from: http://www.in-
28. fo.sciencedirect.com/content
5. Abromitis R, Saghafi E, Folb B. Assessing the infor- 22. EMBASE. Elsevier B.V.; c2007 [cited 2007 May 15].
mation needs of psychiatric residents. Acad Psychia- Available from: http://www.info.embase.com
try 2003;27(2):100–103. 23. Virtual Health Library. São Paulo: Latin-American
6. Birch D, Eady A, Robertson D, De Pauw S, Tandan V. and Caribbean Center on Health Sciences Informa-
Users’ guide to the surgical literature: how to per- tion; c2007 [cited 2007 May 15]. Available from:
form a literature search. Can J Surg 2003;46(2):136– http://bases.bireme.br
141. 24. Fact sheet Medline. Bethesda: United States Nation-
7. Corrall C, Wyer P, Zick L, Bockrath C. How to find al Library of Medicine; c2007 [cited 2007 September
evidence when you need it, part 1: databases, search 9]. Available from: http://www.nlm.nih.gov/pubs/fact-
programs, and strategies. Ann Emerg Med 2002;39 sheets/medline.html
(3):302–306. 25. EBSCOhost. Ipswich, MA: EBSCO Publishing; c2007
8. Timmins F, McCabe C. How to conduct an effective [cited 2007 May 15]. Available from: http://search.eb-
literature search. Nurs Stand 2005;20(11):41–47. scohost.com
9. Theander S. The use of PubMed/Medline in psychia- 26. PSYNDEX. Trier: University of Trier; c2005 [cited
try. 1: Presentation of NLM and PubMed. Nord J Psy- 2007 May 15]. Available from: http://zpid.de
chiatry 2006;60(4):299–304.
27. PubMed. Bethesda: The National Library of Medicine 31. Blocks D, Cunliffe D, Tudhope D. A reference model
and the National Institutes of Health; c2007 [cited for user-system interaction in thesaurus-based search-
2007 November 10]. Available from: http://www.nc- ing. J Am Soc Inf Sci Tec 2006;57(12):1655–1665.
bi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?DB=pubmed 32. Eysenbach G. Citation advantage of open access arti-
28. Scopus Info. Amsterdam: Elsevier B.V.; c2007 [cited cles. Plos Biol 2006;4(5):e157.
2007 May 15]. Available from: http://www.info.sco- 33. Eysenbach G. The open access advantage. J Med Inter-
pus.com net Res 2006;8(2):e8.
29. Web of Science. Thomson Reuters; c2006 [cited 34. Steinbrook R. Searching for the right search – reach-
2008 Oct 9]. Available from: http://scientific.thom- ing the medical literature. N Engl J Med 2006;354(1):
sonreuters.com/products/wos 4–7.
30. Haynes BR. Of studies, syntheses, synopses, summa- 35. Tang H, Ng J. Googling for a diagnosis – use of Google
ries, and systems: the “5S”evolution of information as a diagnostic aid: Internet based study. BMJ 2006;333
services for evidence-based health care decisions. (7579):1143–1145.
ACP Journal Club 2006;145:8−9. 36. Mizzaro S. Relevance: the whole history. J Am Soc Inf
Sci 1997;48(9):810–832.