Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: A three dimensional selective laser melting process simulation is developed to investigate the melt-pool behavior
Additive manufacturing of a randomly-distributed powder bed with keyhole formation by Nd-YAG laser. In order to simulate a randomly-
Selective laser melting packed powder bed, the discrete element method is introduced to ensure a close match with real conditions.
Discrete element method Also, to show the importance of evaporation during laser melting, the melt pool temperature, melt pool di-
Evaporation
mensions and the surface morphology are used as metrics for comparison. Numerical results show that the
Keyhole formation
keyhole was formed as evaporation occurred, and the shape of the melt pool was narrow and deep, which
implied the main direction of heat transfer had changed to being vertical. Through simulation, the transition
from keyhole formation to the final convex surface at a local area was discovered. The simulation results are
validated via good agreement with the experiment.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: wshwang@mail.ncku.edu.tw (W.-S. Hwang).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2017.11.032
Received 16 July 2017; Received in revised form 5 November 2017; Accepted 17 November 2017
Available online 21 November 2017
0924-0136/ © 2017 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Y.-C. Wu et al. Journal of Materials Processing Tech. 254 (2018) 72–78
Table 1
Composition of H13.
Cr 3.44
Mo 1.34
V 0.30
Si 1.26
C 5.10
Mn 0.31
Fe bal.
Table 2
Thermophysical properties of H13.
Fig. 1. Force determination by DEM.
Parameter Value
predict whether the melt pool is either in conduction mode or keyhole Density 7760
mode by theoretical-experimental validation. Verhaeghe et al. Melting temperature (K) 1773
Solid material specific heat (J/(kg K)) 460
(Verhaeghe et al., 2009) investigated the melt-pool dimension change
Molten material specific heat (J/(kg K)) 480
during material evaporation with low-power laser by both numerical Thermal conductivity (W/m2 K4) 29
and experimental methods. According to their results, evaporation Latent heat of fusion (J/kg) 2.5 × 105
should be considered, despite their model being relatively simple with Latent heat of vaporization (J/kg) 7.34 × 106
limited assumptions. According to some studies, the flow behavior can Boiling temperature (K) 3133
P0 (Pa) 101325
be affected by the keyhole formation, resulting in lower surface quality
Laser absorptivity 0.1
(Bauereiß et al., 2014; Simonelli et al., 2015; Thijs et al., 2013).
However, the keyhole formation can be accepted on a small portion of
the materials, for example: AlSi10Mg, Inconel-718 alloy and Aluminum
alloy (Aboulkhair et al., 2016; Dai and Gu, 2015; Lu et al., 2015). model.
This study investigated the flow behavior during laser melting at the To sum up, the arrangement of the powder bed and keyhole for-
mesoscale, for which few studies have followed this approach. A me- mation during evaporation will directly affect the melt-pool dimensions
soscopic numerical simulation was proposed by Yu et al. (Yu et al., and flow behavior, thereby determining the final surface quality.
2016), which included not only the heat transfer during laser heating, Accordingly, an SLM model should include these two phenomena in
but also the fluid flow after melting. The numerical system employed order to have accurate prediction and conduct investigation. In this
the finite volume method (FVM) to investigate the surface morphology study, two kinds of models were developed. One considers random-
after the aluminum alloy powder was melted; subsequently, surface powder packing with multiple-diameter particles, and the other con-
morphologies were compared under various parameters. Yuan and Gu tinually simulates the laser melting with various phenomena. The fea-
(Yuan and Gu, 2015) also used an FVM model to explore the impact of sibility of DEM calculation for a powder bed and the effects of material
the Marangoni effect on heat transfer and mass transfer. However, the evaporation on the behavior of the melt pool are discussed.
above two models did not consider the random-powder arrangement, so Experimental validation with melt-pool dimensions is also presented.
factors such as higher surface temperature might be reflected. In this
respect, few models have been developed that consider a powder bed
with random packing. Körner et al. (Körner et al., 2013) employed the 2. Mathematical model
Lattice Boltzmann method (LBM) to the electron-beam melting simu-
lation. However, the simulation is based on only two dimensions, which 2.1. Random powder bed generation
may cause temperature errors, thereby affecting the continuity of the
melt track. Lee and Zhang (Lee and Zhang, 2015) introduced the dis- In order to simulate the creation of the powder bed, the discrete
crete element method (DEM) into the simulation system, after which element numerical method (DEM) was used to simulate the motion of a
the influences of a random powder bed could be taken into account. large number of particles, including particle/particle and particle/wall
Meanwhile, they also suggested that under high packing densities, interactions. The powder particles were simplified as elastic spheres
which also takes into account the effects caused by a random powder with different radii, as shown in Fig. 1. Also, a further assumption, that
bed, the Plateau-Rayleigh instability could be reduced. However, the container walls are considered rigid walls, was made with regard to the
recoil pressure and material evaporation were not considered in their powder container. Each particle had three velocity components for
translation in the x, y, and z axes of a Cartesian coordinate system.
73
Y.-C. Wu et al. Journal of Materials Processing Tech. 254 (2018) 72–78
Fig. 3. Validation and examination of the powder-size distribution in Areas A, B, and C to determine if any size segregation occurs.
The normal contact forces were calculated using Eq. (1) below:
Fni = −kdln − ηn (u′⋅n) n (1)
And, the tangential forces were calculated using Eqs. (2) and (3):
Fti = −ηt (u′ − (u′⋅n) n) (2)
Fig. 4. Metallographic image of the H13 melt pool after etching for 60s. 2.2. Energy transfer and conservation equations
74
Y.-C. Wu et al. Journal of Materials Processing Tech. 254 (2018) 72–78
located at the center of the grid. The value ranges between 0 and 1,
where VF = 0 represents an empty grid, and VF = 1 represents a full
grid.
∂VF ⎯→
⎯
+ ∇⋅ ( v VF ) = 0
∂t (7)
In order to consider the phase changes between the solid phase and
liquid phase, an auxiliary equation is used:
h = Cp⋅T + f (T )⋅Lf (8)
where f(T) denotes the volume fraction of the solid/liquid interface as a
function of temperature:
⎧ 0, ifT ≤ Ts ⎫
⎪ T − TL ⎪
f (T ) = , ifTs < T < TL
⎨ TL − TS ⎬
⎪ 1, ifT ≥ TL ⎪ (9)
⎩ ⎭
In this equation, Lf is the latent heat during phase transformation, while
TL and TS denote the liquidus and solidus temperatures, respectively.
To include the influence of the Marangoni effect, the relationship
between surface tension difference and temperature gradient can be
described as:
dσ
Fig. 6. Melt-pool area (red zone) calculated by simulation. (For interpretation of the σ = σ0 − (T − T *)
references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this dT (10)
article.) where dσ
represents the surface tension gradient of H13, which ac-
dT
counts for the Marangoni coefficient.
75
Y.-C. Wu et al. Journal of Materials Processing Tech. 254 (2018) 72–78
After the track is formed, un-melted powder is removed by high pres- 5 × 10−6 m3.
sure air, as shown in Fig. 2(c). To validate the model, whether the calculated powder still main-
To distinguish a clear boundary between the re-melting zone and tains the same distribution in the calculated area must first be con-
the original bulk, post-treatment is required. Firstly, the SLM sample firmed; then, it must be verified that no powder-size segregation in the
was cut in half by a cutting machine; then, the cross section of the specified areas has occurred. Fig. 2 shows t that different colors re-
sample was sequentially ground with #240, #600, #800, #1200, present different powder sizes. According to the color distribution of
#2500 and #4000 sandpaper, and etched by the mixture of 6% HNO3 the entire area, the particles appear to be well dispersed, which means
and alcohol for 60 s, then polished with 1 μm diamond slurry until no no powder-size segregation occurred. Then, the plane was divided into
obvious scratches were visible. Finally, a mechanical vibratory-pol- three small regions, labeled A, B and C, after which the powder-size
ishing machine with 0.05 μm SiO2 was used for 2 h until a mirror-like distribution was respectively calculated. The results are also shown in
surface was achieved. A LEICA DM6000 M optical metallographic mi- Fig. 3, and as can be seen, the powder-size distribution of the three
croscope was used to capture a metallographic image. regions corresponds with the actual powder distribution. Furthermore,
H13 is used as the powder material under a set of fixed laser the distributions from the small areas also match the whole powder
parameters, the composition and the thermophysical properties of H13 bed. This indicates that regardless of which area is chosen, the powder-
(He et al., 2010; Pinkerton and Li, 2005; Tang and Landers, 2010) are size distribution always matches that in the experiment. Therefore, it is
shown in Table 1 and Table 2, respectively. confirmed that this DEM model can be employed to calculate powder
beds with multiple-sized particles.
4. Results and discussion
4.2. Validation of laser-melting model
4.1. Random powder bed validation
Before characterizing the flow behavior of the melt pool, the relia-
In the SLM process, the metal powder was the first component ir- bility of the simulation model must be confirmed. Considering the
radiated by high-power laser beam, making it the key element of heat difficulty in capturing the image and monitoring the temperature field
transfer. Therefore, the type of powder material, powder size distribu- of the melt pool in real time, the dimensions of the re-melting area after
tion and the packing density need to be considered as crucial factors. laser scanning and the surface morphology of melt track are used to
Generally, metal powder beds with different size distributions can be validate the accuracy of the simulation system.
adjusted according to different process requirements in SLM. Thus, trial In Fig. 4, the relatively smooth surface at the center of the figure is
and error by multiple experiments to obtain the optimal process para- the re-melting zone, which was formed by H13 powder and partial
meters is time consuming and expensive. Consequently, developing a bulk. The width and depth of the re-melting were 108 μm and 82 μm,
numerical model to simulate the powder packing is an efficient and respectively. As can be seen, the upper surface of the re-melting zone is
cost-saving way for industrial applications. oval, while the bottom is more circular.
Until now, few studies have integrated a powder bed model into Likewise, for the laser-melting simulation, the initial state of the
their simulation system; moreover, most have assumed the powder bed powder bed was taken from the DEM model and paved on the metal
to be a porous bulk or introduced the powder bed with a single particle bulk, as shown in Fig. 5, for which the same laser parameters were
size. In this manner, not only are errors introduced during temperature employed. Fig. 6 presents the cross section of the melt track by simu-
calculation, but the feasibility of the laser-melting simulation is also lation, in which the red area represents the re-melting zone, while the
reduced. In this study, DEM was used to simulate the powder bed with a blue circular shapes on the surface constitute un-melted powder.
variable-size distribution before the laser-melting model. The com- To clearly compare the results of the simulation and experiment,
mercial H13 powder was examined by particle size analyzer, where the Figs. 4 and 6 are juxtaposed in Fig. 7. It can be clearly seen that the
D10, D50, and D90 of the H13 powder were found to measure 19 μm, contours of re-melting zones match very well, which means the di-
29 μm and 43 μm in diameter, respectively. To better match to the mensions of the melt-pool width and depth are similar as well. More-
experiment conditions, the simulation used the same powder distribu- over, the surface morphology above the substrate can also be simulated
tion as the input parameters. The calculation domain here was set to accurately. Based on these characteristics, it is confirmed that the
76
Y.-C. Wu et al. Journal of Materials Processing Tech. 254 (2018) 72–78
Fig. 9. Temperature distributions during keyhole formation at (a) 0 s; (b) 50 microseconds; (c) 100 microseconds; (d) 150 microseconds; (e) 200 microseconds; and, (f) 250 microseconds.
77
Y.-C. Wu et al. Journal of Materials Processing Tech. 254 (2018) 72–78
Acknowledgement
Fig. 11. Comparison of melt pool volumes for the two cases. References
is narrow and deep, the reason for which is related to the formation of Aboulkhair, N.T., Maskery, I., Tuck, C., Ashcroft, I., Everitt, N.M., 2016. On the formation
of AlSi10Mg single tracks and layers in selective laser melting: microstructure and
the keyhole. This phenomenon often occurs during laser-arc welding, nano-mechanical properties. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 230, 88–98.
which uses a high-power laser as the heat source. According to Anisimov, S.I., Khokhlov, V.A., 1995. Instabilities in Laser-matter Interaction. CRC press.
Fig. 8(d), the maximum temperature of the melt pool is 2676 K, which Bauereiß, A., Scharowsky, T., Körner, C., 2014. Defect generation and propagation me-
chanism during additive manufacturing by selective beam melting. J. Mater. Process.
is much more reasonable. With the simulation model, the physical
Technol. 214, 2522–2528.
phenomena, including keyhole formation during laser melting, can be Dai, D., Gu, D., 2015. Effect of metal vaporization behavior on keyhole-mode surface
investigated (Fig. 9). When the laser is concentrated at a local point, the morphology of selective laser melted composites using different protective atmo-
spheres. Appl. Surf. Sci. 355, 310–319.
surface material starts to gradually evaporate and form a temporary
Fabbro, R., 2010. Melt pool and keyhole behaviour analysis for deep penetration laser
hole surrounded by a melt pool (Fig. 9(b)). Meanwhile, the laser ir- welding. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 43, 445501.
radiates the bottom of the hole. Due to the energy distribution of the He, X., Yu, G., Mazumder, J., 2010. Temperature and composition profile during double-
laser, the shape of the keyhole is like a valley, and so the heat transfer track laser cladding of H13 tool steel. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 43, 015502.
Hirt, C.W., Nichols, B.D., 1981. Volume of fluid (VOF) method for the dynamics of free
changes to being vertical. As the laser moves away, the temperature boundaries. J. Comput. Phys. 39, 201–225.
begins to cool from the substrate to the surface, and the liquid H13 Körner, C., Bauereiß, A., Attar, E., 2013. Fundamental consolidation mechanisms during
condenses simultaneously (Fig. 9(c)). In the final stage, the residual selective beam melting of powders. Modell. Simu.l Mater. Sc.i Eng. 21, 085011.
Khairallah, S.A., Anderson, A., 2014. Mesoscopic simulation model of selective laser
melt generates a convex surface due to the Marangoni effect, and melting of stainless steel powder. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 214, 2627–2636.
eventually solidifies (Fig. 9(d)–(f)). As the direction of the heat transfer King, W.E., Barth, H.D., Castillo, V.M., Gallegos, G.F., Gibbs, J.W., Hahn, D.E., Kamath,
is mainly longitudinal, the width of the single track is relatively smaller C., Rubenchik, A.M., 2014. Observation of keyhole-mode laser melting in laser
powder-bed fusion additive manufacturing. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 214,
and the penetration deeper. In addition, Fig. 10 presents the differences 2915–2925.
in surface morphology of the two cases. As can be seen, the surface Lee, Y.S., Zhang, W., 2015. Mesoscopic simulation of heat transfer and fluid flow in laser
without considering evaporation (red line) is less even, which might be Powder bed additive manufacturing. International Solid Freeform Fabrication
Symposium. pp. 1154–1165 Austin.
caused by the discrepancy in the melt-pool volume. According to pre-
Lu, Y., Wu, S., Gan, Y., Huang, T., Yang, C., Junjie, L., Lin, J., 2015. Study on the mi-
vious research, as the melt-pool volume increases, the surface tends to crostructure, mechanical property and residual stress of SLM Inconel-718 alloy
ripple, resulting in poor surface quality after solidification. Fig. 11 manufactured by differing island scanning strategy. Opt. Laser Technol. 75, 197–206.
Pinkerton, A.J., Li, L., 2005. Direct additive laser manufacturing using gas- and water-
shows the changes in melt-pool volume over time, and clearly indicates
atomised H13 tool steel powders. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 25, 471–479.
that the volume is much larger for the case without considering eva- Simonelli, M., Tuck, C., Aboulkhair, N.T., Maskery, I., Ashcroft, I., Wildman, R.D., Hague,
poration. R., 2015. A study on the laser spatter and the oxidation reactions during selective
These results can also be found in the metallographic image of the laser melting of 316L stainless steel, Al-Si10-Mg, and Ti-6Al-4V. Metall. Mater. Trans.
A 46, 3842–3851.
H13 single track as evidence confirming that evaporation has occurred. Tang, L., Landers, R.G., 2010. Melt pool temperature control for laser metal deposition
Most importantly, the comparison clearly demonstrates the significance processes—part I: online temperature control. J. Manuf. Sci. Engine. 132 (011010-
of considering evaporation in a numerical model when simulating the 011010-011019).
Thijs, L., Kempen, K., Kruth, J.-P., Van Humbeeck, J., 2013. Fine-structured aluminium
SLM process. products with controllable texture by selective laser melting of pre-alloyed AlSi10Mg
powder. Acta Mater. 61, 1809–1819.
5. Conclusions Verhaeghe, F., Craeghs, T., Heulens, J., Pandelaers, L., 2009. A pragmatic model for se-
lective laser melting with evaporation. Acta Mater. 57, 6006–6012.
Yang, J., Han, J., Yu, H., Yin, J., Gao, M., Wang, Z., Zeng, X., 2016. Role of molten pool
In summary, a simulated 3D SLM process at the mesoscale with mode on formability, microstructure and mechanical properties of selective laser
random powder distribution by DEM and FDM was developed. The melted Ti-6Al-4V alloy. Mater. Des. 110, 558–570.
Yu, G.Q., Gu, D.D., Dai, D.H., Xia, M.J., Ma, C.L., Shi, Q.M., 2016. On the role of pro-
influence of incorporating or neglecting the effects of evaporation was
cessing parameters in thermal behavior, surface morphology and accuracy during
also investigated in detail. Conclusions can be drawn as follows: laser 3D printing of aluminum alloy. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 49, 135501.
Yuan, P.P., Gu, D.D., 2015. Molten pool behaviour and its physical mechanism during
selective laser melting of TiC/AlSi10Mg nanocomposites: simulation and experi-
(1) Two simulation models were used for different purposes. One was
ments. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 48, 035303.
for calculating the powder-bed configuration with random packing
78