GRADING FORM FOR PTH 850 EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE IN PT

SHORT CRITIQUE PAPERS

Date: _____ ______________________________________________
Student: Taylor Mills
Reference: __________________________________________________
Points Comments

Citation Noted in AMA

10 10 Interesting article
Style

Research Question
5 5
Identified

Design and Methods

10 9 See comments on design, generally good

Results Described
10 10 yes

Author’s Conclusions
5 5
Described

Identification of Some of their techniques for analysis, their detailed

10 9
Strengths descriptions and discussion of things such as power

Identification of
10 9 Good, could be a few more points about representativeness
Limitations

Reader’s Conclusions
10 10 Nice and clear

Competing Interests
5 5

Practical Application
5 5

Articulate & Clear

5 5
Presentation

Concise & Relevant

10 10
Choice of Material

Appropriate Length
5 5

Total
97 Dr. Perkins
100