What was the key idea?
The moment a child is born, the mother is also
born. The short film was all about a mother's love.  It
shows how the mother can do everything for her
daughter. They said that the mother's love and care is
unconditional and forever. The short film also shows the
struggles of being a single working mom. It was hard
and never easy. The mother must find time and set
aside work when they chose to spend time to their
children.
What did you think about the quality of sound?
One of the vital elements of film production is a
quality of sound. I believed that audio is more significant
than the video quality because it's important for the
audience to understand the message of a film. I
observed that the short film was more into background
music and had a limited dialogue. It has a good quality
of sound. I liked the chosen background music because
it fits perfectly to the short film. 
Was the lighting good?
I believed that lighting is one of the most
important keys in making a quality video. For the film, it
is not that good. I suggest adjusting the exposure
because for me, it was too warm, and has yellowish
tone. But on the other hand, I also understand if it meant
that way so that it can give a more dramatic effect to
the film.  performance.
What type of audience was it intended for?
All of us can be the audience but I think the target
audience of the film are those single working mom,
mothers, parents and also the guardians of children. I
hope that the short film can be a lesson for those people
and that they should take care of their loved ones
because we don't know what will happen next.  deliver the lesson of it. It is worth watching.
PLOY
What was the key idea?
If the mother's love is unconditional and forever,
the father's love is irreplaceable and eternal. They say
that his love from his child is different, but it always
came from his heart. The silence of love short film shows
how the father can do everything for his daughter. In
spite of his condition, he never shows to his daughter
that it can be a hindrance to support her in life. It was all
What did you think about the camera shots?
Throughout the short film, many camera
movements and shots were used to make it more
dramatic as it is. I noticed that they used pans, tilts,
zoom, long, medium, close-up, high angle, eye level, low
angle and canted shots.  I liked how they play high
-angle shot when the child was about to come with the
strangers. And I also liked the used of canted and tilt
shot when the child was about to get harassed by the
unknown guy. 
Were the effects used suitable?
The discovery of visual effects has a big
advantage for the film makers. It gives more dimensions
and style to the film. As for the short film, the effects
they used like dolly zoom, go motion, stop motion and
etc. were appropriate and suitable. It enhanced the way
they want the audience feel about the specific scene. 
What would you change in the video?
If I have to change something from the video,
maybe it's the scene where the girl who helped Ploy got
tortured by the rapist. For me, that scene was not that
convincing because it's obvious that the guy actor was
not doing anything to the girl who helped Ploy. I think
that it was just inadequate to execute the right
 
Addy any other comments you want to make
It's not my first time to watch the film but every
time I'm watching it, I always ended teary eyed. The film
can have a big impact for those who watched it and it
also has a lesson that worth knowing for the rest of our
lives. The production team of the film succeeded to
 
What did you think about the camera shots?
The camera shots used in the film like medium-
close up, close up, extreme close up, wide shot, bird's
eye level, canted level, low and high level were fall into
places perfectly. I liked how they used the medium and
close up shots when the father brought her daughter to
the hospital and in some instances in the film such when
they focused on the father trying to explain his thoughts
about a father's love.  to his daughter. 

What did you think about the quality of sound? Were the effects used suitable?

The second film is similar to the first one. It has a The effects used in the film was suitable. They
limited set of dialogues and an extreme background used go motion, stop motion, dolly motion and many
music that sets the mood of the audience. The chosen more to improve the film. It gave big advantage to the
background music fits perfectly to the film and I liked it. film makers. They can achieve the way they want the
Overall, it has a good quality of sound.  audience feel about it through the use of different
effects. 

Was the lighting good? What would you change in the video?

Just like the other film, the light is not that good. This one is my favorite rather than the other film. I
Maybe that's the style of their film. I do understand that actually don't know if I have to change something from
it is meant that way so that it can give a more dramatic the video. Maybe it's the lighting. I would enhance and
effect to the film but I want to suggest again to adjust give more color tone to the film because as I've said, I'm
the exposure so that it can cool down.  not satisfied to the lighting of it. But all in all, I don't
have to change it because I liked the way it is. 

What type of audience was it intended for? Addy any other comments you want to make

The audience of the film can be all of us but the It's my first time to watch this film. If in the
main or target audience would be those children who previous film, I got teary eyed, in this film I cried. It's
don't appreciate the sacrifices of their parents. I hope because I'm a daddy's girl. I really love my dad and I
that the short film itself can open their eyes and heart so think I can't do that to him because I don't want to see
they can see all the sacrifices that their parents are him crying just because of me. I hope that people who
doing just to provide for all their needs and wants in life.  have the same attitude as the girl character can watch
this so they can change the way they act and open their
hearts to their loved ones, even if it has a condition in
life. 

Silence of love