Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Summary As vector control of dengue typically targets individual households to eliminate breeding sites or control
adult mosquitoes during epidemics, public spaces are frequently neglected. To investigate the importance
of such places as sources of dengue vectors, a study of Aedes aegypti productivity in a cemetery in
northern Venezuela, using standard entomological indices for assessing dengue vector infestations, was
carried out in the wet season in May 2003. Containers were found on 72.8% of graves; 44% of the
containers held water and in 46.9% of these we found A. aegypti larvae and/or pupae. The average
density of Aedes-infested containers was 39 per hectare. There were no significant differences in
infestation rates between container types (vases, planters or others) or materials (cement, plastic, glass,
etc.). Containers with 1–5 l of water held the greatest proportion of the pupae found in the cemetery
(46.7%); containers with <100 ml of water contained no pupae. The mean number of pupae produced in
the cemetery was estimated at 4185 pupae/ha per 48 h and the daily output of potential vector
mosquitoes from the entire cemetery was calculated at approximately 3000 females per day. These
mosquitoes presumably left the cemetery to feed in the nearby communities, thus thwarting the
environmental management and health education programmes that had reduced household dengue
vector infestations. The study shows the importance of public places as sources of dengue vectors in
urban areas, and the need to include such areas in vector control programmes.
keywords dengue, dengue haemorrhagic fever, urban, transmission, vector control, cemetery,
Venezuela, Aedes
(Schultz 1989), the USA (O’Meara et al. 1992a,b) and taps, located between sectors A and B, were available.
Venezuela (Barrera et al. 1979). Cemeteries are often Meteorological data were provided by the Universidad de
located very close to human habitations. Many los Andes (1.7 km from the cemetery).
cemeteries that were once located at the outskirts of
town have, over time, been surrounded by crowded
Infestation levels
residential areas and may have become important
breeding sites for dengue vectors, potentially supporting Surveys to assess the extent of larval, pupal and egg
vector population refugia during vector control cam- infestation and of adult productivity were carried out daily
paigns. Moreover, cemeteries often adjoin hospitals in for 1 month. Every 10th grave was sampled and its
many parts of the world. O’Meara et al. (1992a) location was recorded using a handheld Global Positioning
investigated the role of cemeteries in Florida in the System receiver (Magellan, CA, USA). Graves were allo-
spread of A. albopictus and found that it was established cated a number and marked with labelled coloured tape.
in many cemeteries long before it was found in sites with Grave type was categorized as ‘monument’ (large polished
discarded car tyres. Clearly, cemeteries are important as stone or cement structure), ‘common’ (rough cement con-
sources of dengue vectors. We investigated and attemp- struction) or ‘ground’ type (without gravestone). Grave size
ted to quantify the vector output from one cemetery in was classed as individual, double, triple, etc., according to
Venezuela. capacity. All containers on every grave sampled were
recorded according to function, water capacity and material
and were classified as follows: vases were any removable or
Materials and methods fixed container for holding cut flowers, made of cement,
metal, plastic or glass (volumes of 0.5–7.5 l); planters were
Study area
narrow cement, metal or stone containers fixed on the edge
The fieldwork was carried out in Trujillo City, between of monument tombs, intended for growing plants and
29 April and 23 May 2003. Trujillo City (population sometimes partially filled with soil (volumes of 2–20 l);
49 000), the capital of Trujillo State in NW Venezuela, ‘others’ included uncommon vessels or spaces ranging from
is located on a northern outlier of the Cordillera de candle holders (0.1 l) to large empty cement spaces intended
Mérida in the Andes mountains, at 922¢ N, 7026¢ W, for a coffin (1200 l). With the exception of vases, which
approximately 800 m above mean sea level. It has a would have been filled also by hand, all containers were
tropical climate with two rainy seasons a year (peaking assumed to be filled with water by rainfall only.
in April and October/November), and temperatures In those containing water, the water volume was
ranging from 16 to 37 C. The dengue incidence rate measured by decanting into a graduated cylinder, and pH
was estimated at 340.2 cases per 100 000 in 2001 was measured with a handheld pH meter (Hanna Instru-
(Trujillo State Ministry of Health 2002). The Buen ments, RI, USA). pH was measured in intervals of half-
Pastor Cemetery is located in the centre of Santa Rosa, units. Larval and pupal infestation (absence or presence)
an urban neighbourhood close to the city centre. A 3 m was assessed and to facilitate counting, the water was
high wall separates the cemetery from the surrounding filtered through netting. The number of Aedes sp. eggs laid
residential areas (Figure 1). The cemetery stretches over in each container was also counted. From each grave where
442 m east–west and 147 m north–south (3.47 ha) on mosquitoes were found, 1–10 larvae were stored in 70%
the eastern base of a mountain. At the time of the study, ethanol for identification. As A. aegypti is by far the
the cemetery administration office estimated the total predominant container-breeding Aedes species in this area
number of graves at 3000–4000. For the purposes of the (Brown & Scorza 1995), all Aedes were assumed to be
study, the cemetery was divided into three sectors, A. aegypti. Culex sp. were not differentiated.
designated A (6830 m2), B (8901 m2) and C (18 905 m2, To measure adult A. aegypti oviposition activity, ovi-
of which 3600 m2 were examined), totalling 19 330 m2. traps (300 ml dark blue plastic cups lined with fabric) were
Limited shade was provided by a few large trees that deployed at intervals of one trap per approximately
were located mainly in sector B, with fewer in sector A 300 m2. The trap was partially filled with 100 ml tap
and virtually none in sector C, where little vegetation of water, placed on a grave for 7 days, when the number of
any kind was growing (Figure 1). Human activity was eclosed and intact eggs in each ovitrap were counted under
generally uncommon, except on two major Christian the microscope. From the positive traps, 10 highly positive
holidays: the Day of the Dead (El Dı́a de los Muertos, traps were selected, re-filled with tap water and held in the
1 November) and Mother’s Day (El Dı́a de la Madre, a laboratory for 3 days, when hatched larvae were counted
moveable holiday falling in April or May). Two water to determine the hatch rate.
Sector A
Sector B
Sector C
Lowest point
N -751m
Chapel
(inactive) Street Residential area
Residential area
100m
Figure 1 The Buen Pastor Cemetery, Trujillo, Venezuela: aerial view from eastern side of mountain (top) and diagram (bottom).
Table 1 Aedes aegypti larval and/or pupal positive rate in the cemetery
Graves Containers
Larval
and pupal Larval
positive positive Pupal positive
Planters were vessels for holding soil; à Water-holding containers including empty coffin spaces and candle holders; § Containers of
marble or polished stone; * P < 0.05.
Table 2 Aedes aegypti pupal counts and densities in different containers in the cemetery
* Minimum ¼ 0 in all cases; Planters were vessels for holding soil; à Water-holding containers including empty coffin spaces and candle
holders; § Containers of marble or polished stone.
There were no significant differences between pupal counts and container types (P > 0.05) or materials, or between pupal densities
and container types or materials (P > 0.1).
counted · 10 (¼sampling interval)/assessed area (ha) ¼ 379 pupae taken from 21 containers was measured. Of 307
809 pupae · 10/1.933 ha ¼ 4185 pupae/ha per 48 h. (81%) emerged adults, 178 (58%) were female Aedes sp.
(the slightly higher female ratio may result from sampling
containers from which the males had already begun to
Egg infestation rates
emerge). Based on these data, a daily emergence rate from
Levels of container infestation with eggs differed signifi- the cemetery was calculated as follows: Total female pro-
cantly between sectors. Of 366 containers examined, 60 duction ¼ 4185 pupae/ha in 2 days · 0.5 · 3.47 ha · 0.81
(16.4%) were egg positive, with a mean infestation level of adults · 0.5 females ¼ 2,940 females per day.
65.8 eggs per container (SD ¼ 65.9). A breakdown of
infestation levels in water-holding and dry containers is
Discussion
presented in Table 3. The highest positive rate was observed
in sector B in both water-holding and dry containers. In fact, Clearly, the Buen Pastor cemetery in Trujillo, Venezuela
egg-positive dry containers were found only in sector B, provides a highly suitable breeding environment and is a
where 9.5% (mainly vases and planters) were infested. major source of A. aegypti in that area of the city. With, at
Cement containers were most commonly found to contain this time of year at least, approximately a quarter of all
eggs, and eggs were never found in metal containers. graves supporting vector breeding, over 40% of containers
Of 128 ovitraps deployed, 125 were collected 7 days later holding water and almost half of these with larvae or
and 61 (48.8%) were positive. The number of eggs per cup pupae (Table 1), vector infestation levels were very high,
ranged from 1 to 179 (mean ¼ 9, SD ¼ 21.6). The trap resulting in a calculated daily output of 3400 female
positivity rates in sectors A, B and C were 50.0%, 51.4% and mosquitoes emerging from the cemetery. The extent of this
36.7% respectively. This difference was not significant. (P > output can be seen when a comparison of the pupal rates in
0.1). Using un-eclosed eggs from 10 highly positive ovitraps, the cemetery (809 pupae/173 graves or 4.7 pupae per
the egg hatch rate was 62.9% (163/259 eggs) over 72 h. grave, Tables 1 and 2) is made with recent data from the
immediately adjacent residential area (113 pupae/219
households or 0.5 pupae per household; A. Lenhart, E.
Adult productivity
Villegas, A. Kroeger, unpublished data 2003). Similarly,
To determine the daily output of potential vector mosquitoes the container index (% water containers with Aedes larvae)
from the entire cemetery, the emergence rate of adults from was 46.3% in the cemetery but only 1.5% in the adjacent
Water-holding containers
Sector
A 45 15 (33.3)* 713 47.5 (22.5)
B 72 28 (39.0)* 2158 77.1 (64.0)
C 43 4 (9.0)* 260 65.0 (43.6)
Container type
Vase 137 39 (28.5) 2468 63.3 (54.1)
Planter 20 8 (40.0) 663 82.9 (50.8)
Othersà 3 0 0 –
Container material
Cement 91 44 (48.4)**** 2969 67.5 (67.5)
Metal 39 0**** 0 –
Plastic 20 2 (10.0)**** 62 31.0
Glass 8 0**** 0 –
Other§ 2 1**** 100 –
Dry containers
Sector
A 44 0* 0 –
B 137 13 (9.5)* 818 62.9 (101.8)
C 25 0* 0 –
Container type
Vase 80 7 (8.8) 108 15.4 (7.8)
Planter 121 6 (5.0) 710 118.3 (134.0)
Others 5 0 0 –
Container material
Cement 163 12 (7.4) 809 67.4 (104.9)
Metal 18 0 0 –
Plastic 19 1 (5.3) 9 –
Glass 3 0 0 –
Other§ 3 0 0 –
Planters were vessels for holding soil; à Water-holding containers including empty coffin
spaces and candle holders; § Containers of marble or polished stone; * P < 0.05,
** P < 0.01, *** P < 0.001, **** P < 0.0001.
residential area (unpublished data 2003). Although com- remains unknown. With planters comprising 69% (254/
parison between such different units should be made with 366) of all containers in the cemetery (Table 1), the total
caution, given that the density of graves is quite signifi- number of cement containers in Buen Pastor cemetery is
cantly higher per unit of area than households, the number estimated at more than 10 000 (numbers from the cemet-
of positive containers is remarkably high in the cemetery. ery administration office). Clearly planters constitute the
Moreover, with little human activity in the cemetery, these most important source of vectors in the cemetery. Whether
mosquitoes must presumably have left the cemetery to feed this is the result of any specific attraction to the material or
in the adjoining residential houses, though this would need colour of the planters or simply because they constituted
to be confirmed. the most available breeding site remains to be determined.
Planters accounted for 12.5% of all water-holding The larger volume cement containers, typically large spaces
containers and held 40% of all pupae (Table 2). Similarly, designed to receive infant-sized or larger coffins, yielded
the results of the egg infestation study suggested a very few eggs or immatures. Schultz (1989) also reported
preference of female A. aegypti for oviposition in cement that both A. aegypti and A. albopictus were found breeding
containers (Table 3) though whether this was associated abundantly in cement vases in cemeteries in Manila.
with the material or some other aspect of the containers Vezzani and Schweigmann (2002) reported that plastic
containers were more frequently infested than any others in comments. The study was supported in part by awards
a Buenos Aires cemetery, where there were no cement from the Sir Halley Stewart Trust and the Simpson
containers. Education and Conservation Trust, UK.
Difference in vector infestation levels between different
sectors within the cemetery appeared to be related to the
References
density of vegetation in each sector. Thus in the centre of
sector C, which was completely exposed, A. aegypti pupae Barrera RR, Machado-Allison CE & Bulla LA (1979) Criaderos,
levels and egg counts were lowest (Tables 1 and 3). densidad larval y segregacion de nicho en tres Culicidae
Conversely, in sector B, where the vegetation was most urbanos (Culex fatigans Wied., C. corniger Theo. y Aedes
abundant, mosquito activity was greatest, as evidenced by aegypti L.) en el cementerio de Caracas. Acta Cientifica
high oviposition rates in ovitraps, high egg infestation rates Venezolana 30, 418–424.
Brown E & Scorza JF (1995) Faunula culicida en el area del estado
in both wet and dry containers and the highest pupal
Trujillo, Venezuela y su importancia vectora. Boletin de la di-
densities. Vezzani et al. (2001) also found similar correla-
reccion de malariologia y saneamiento ambiental 35, 25–29.
tions between vegetation cover and infestation levels in O’Meara GF, Gettman AD, Evans LF & Scheel FD (1992a)
Buenos Aires. Interestingly, in our study, the container index Invasion of cemeteries in Florida by Aedes albopictus. Journal of
(% of containers positive for larval and pupal infestation) the American Mosquito Control Association 8, 1–10.
was similar between sectors, but the pupal- and egg-positive O’Meara GF, Evans LF & Gettman AD (1992b) Reduced mos-
container rates in sector C were lower than in the other two quito production in cemetery vases with copper liners. Journal
sectors. While high mortalities of developing larvae would of the American Mosquito Control Association 8, 419–420.
explain the low pupal rates, the lower egg infestations are PAHO (2003) 2002: Number of reported cases of dengue &
more difficult to reconcile without further investigation. dengue hemorrhagic fever (DHF) region of the Americas (by
country and subregion). http://www.paho.org/english/ad/dpc/cd/
In the communities surrounding the cemetery, environ-
dengue-cases-2002.htm.
mental management and health education programmes
Schultz GW (1989) Cemetery vase breeding of dengue vectors in
have been quite successful in reducing dengue vector Manila, Republic of the Philippines. Journal of the American
populations. Few small containers and no tyres were Mosquito Association 5, 508–513.
found, most discarded containers had been removed and Trujillo State Ministry of Health (2002) Dirección Regional de
domestic water containers were covered. But these data Epidemiologı́a y Estadı́stica Vital. Trujillo State Ministry of
show that the thousands of A. aegypti emerging daily from Health, Venezuela.
the adjacent cemetery may have thwarted these public Vezzani D & Schweigmann N (2002) Suitability of containers
health efforts. In quantifying the output of mosquitoes from different sources as breeding sites of Aedes aegypti (L.) in a
from such a public place, we have shown their potential cemetery of Buenos Aires city, Argentina. Memorias do Instituto
importance as sources of vectors in dengue-endemic urban Oswaldo Cruz 97, 789–792.
Vezzani D, Velázquez SM, Soto S & Schweigmann N (2001) En-
areas and have demonstrated that they must be included in
vironmental characteristics of the cemeteries of Buenos Aires
any vector control programme.
city (Argentina) and infestation levels of Aedes aegypti (Diptera:
Culicidae). Memorias do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz 96, 467–471.
Acknowledgements WHO (1999) Vector distribution and bioecology. In: Prevention
and Control of Dengue and Dengue Haemorrhagic Fever:
We are grateful for the field assistance provided by staff at Comprehensive Guidelines. Regional Office for South-east Asia,
the Centro de Investigaciónes José W. Torrealba, Núcleo New Delhi, pp. 49–52.
‘Rafael Rangel’ Trujillo, in particular to Adalberto Gonz- WHO (2002) No 117: dengue and dengue haemorrhagic fever.
ales, Milagros Oviedo and Carmen Elena Castillo, for their In: Fact Sheet. World Health Organization, Geneva. http://
support. We thank two anonymous referees for their www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs117/en/.
Authors
Mayumi Abe, Philip McCall (corresponding author) and Audrey Lenhart, Vector Research Group, Liverpool School of Tropical
Medicine, Liverpool L3 5QA, UK. Fax: +44 151 705 3369; E-mail: taenia.abe@nifty.com; mccall@liv.ac.uk; alenhart@liv.ac.uk
Elci Villegas, Universidad de los Andes, Nucleo ‘Rafael Rangel’, Centro de Investigaciónes Jose W. Torrealba, Trujillo, Venezuela.
E-mail: elciv@ula.ve
Axel Kroeger, World Health Organization (WHO) Special Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases (TDR) 20
Avenue Appia, 1211 Geneva 27, Switzerland. E-mail: kroegera@who.int