Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
As oil exploration, industry, and transportation reaches every corner of the globe, so too do the risks of the
inadvertent and hazardous exposure of wildlife to oil based pollutants. Once an accidental release has
occurred and wildlife has been exposed, persons or trained teams may respond to counter and correct the
often lethal affects of oiling. Practical applications of Infrared Thermography have yet to be fully applied to
such events and it is here proposed to be a potentially valuable tool at many of the sequential phases of
wildlife rescue: from recovery, rehabilitation and ultimately to release.
In early 2008 under the direction of US Fish and Wildlife Service, 31 oiled and injured Bald eagles were
transferred from Kodiak Island and admitted to the Bird Treatment and Learning Center, in Anchorage,
Alaska. This impromptu urban opportunity facilitated the first official local application of Infrared
Thermography for Eagle assessment and monitoring, but has since yielded encouraging quantitative data,
comparative digital documentation and baseline procedural recommendations for similar practical
applications.
In light of these developments - radiometric thermal imaging may also be well suited for remote wildlife rescue
scenarios by providing: day or night location of heat emitting survivors; immediate enhanced qualitative visual
assessments of rescued animals; aid in injury diagnosis; quantitative, non-invasive monitoring during
treatment; easily captured and stored digital documentation; and the establishment of species specific
thermal insulating criteria which may be used to validate rehabilitation and ultimate release of treated birds
and mammals.
Figure 1. An oiled Gannet just before being rescued at Prestige Oil spill. This bird and
thousands of others were affected by a tanker spill off the Spanish Coast in 2002 (IFAW Photo)
Did you know that a seemingly harmless glob of oil the size of a dime could kill a bird? Every year
millions of water birds die due to oil from a plethora of sources such a jet skis and outboard motors, to the
very oil washed off our streets after a rain. We remember all too well the devastating effects of those spills
that occur when tankers accidentally loose their cargo, but there are thousands of small spills occurring daily
and around the world that go unreported and unnoticed.
Wildlife inadvertently exposed to oil-based pollutants inevitably find the substance adhering to fur and
feathers; causing matting, separation, loss of thermal insulation, loss of buoyancy and sensitive skin
exposure. Ingestion of the substance frequently follows as the animal’s instinctual response to preen and
clean becomes incessant. This process then accumulates harmful toxins within the body which severely
compromise the internal organs and may lead to death. The rapid response and effective actions of wildlife
rescue teams in the field are critical elements in intercepting this deadly cycle and moving impacted animals
to higher probabilities of survival.
Figure 2. Left - An oiled sea lion awaits treatment Right – example of a Seal Thermogram, Courtesy of the
Alaska Sea Life Center
As in any disaster, an orderly progression of steps and processes can guide the responding groups to their
goals with maximum efficiency. In a wildlife response effort the steps involved are variably stated but
ultimately the same - they entail the initial response by the Oiled Wildlife Care Network (OWCN - activation);
the rescue and retrieval of the affected wildlife(OWCN Search and Collection); the assessment and treatment
(OWCN – Intake and Stabilization); the rehabilitation (OWCN – Cleaning) and the ultimate recovery and
release (OWCN – same). It is through these steps –each one uniquely diversified and incredibly valuable that
I believe Thermal Imaging can and will debut its own uniquely diverse potential. For to see the emitted heat
of a stranded animal as a marker of location; or an indication of injury; or a quantifier of health; a qualifier of
heat loss; or a form of documentation is the future of Infrared in our world. Transferred to us on a
wavelength, invisible but measurable, we have a new integral interpretive tool that represents the temporal
state of an energetic condition in time. Infrared Thermal Imaging can be and will be the next technological tool
to expedite and enhance the future efficiency of our responsible aid to oiled wildlife.
To rescue an animal in need, it must first be located and this is where IR applications can be beneficial as
shown in figure 4. When it comes to locating injured albatross; oiled auklets or wallowing walrus along vast
lineages of coastline, on open oily oceans or hauled out in vegetative debris – thermal imaging which
captures the heat emitted from all bodies, can for most circumstances well exceed our ocular capabilities for
distance, contrast, acuity, cognition and night vision. Thermal imaging requires zero light and actually visible
light is blocked by the lens which allows only certain wavelengths of infrared radiation to enter the receiving
imager or bolometer. So searching at night when time mandates; when the weather is calmer; when
operations dictate; when survival is the issue or when aircraft are available can be a very positive possibility.
Also, at night because of diurnal cooling, the temperature differences widen between the environmental
background and the objects which emit a consistent temperature (such as a mammal or bird) so this
enhances the contrast of objects in the thermal image sometimes making objects/animals more visible – over
greater distances. The ability to see objects more easily over greater distance is always relative to the size of
the object, the contrast rendered by its emitted temperature, the distance from the object and the atmospheric
attenuation relative to that distance and the sky conditions between the imager and the object such as
moisture, dust, smoke etc.
Figure 4. Left--Grebe thermal detection Mono Lake, CA; Center-- Sea Otter Thermal signature; Right-- Thermal
detection of gulls on the beach Alaska
An important limitation to consider is if the target you are looking for is not giving off heat (homeostasis) or
that heat has diminished to an emitted temperature similar to that of the surrounding environment, you will be
challenged to find the target with IR. Experimental imaging of oil coated wildlife also needs to be done so as
to identify the conductive or insulative property of the coating pollutant and make note of what the thermal
signature of that species, in that condition is for future rescue references.
For assessing health and subsequently diagnosing a condition, the IR camera again captures the emitted
heat as received from the surfical layer of the skin (outer 5mm in Humans) and translates the energy readings
into an image that has a facsimile to the animal or person being read. The heat that is detected is a dutifully
transferred byproduct of our largest organ – the skin- which is tasked with thermoregulation throughout the
body. The activity of small sphincter valves throughout the skin removes excess heat from its subsurface
area of responsibility and transfers it to the outer layers of the skin. This transfer can be so accurate and
detailed that occasionally thermal images can “by coincidence” resemble 3D pictures of internal anatomy. The
heat transfer is a response of the sympathetic nervous system, which unifies the messages from many of the
primary systems of the body such as the nervous system; endocrine system; lymphatic system; circulatory
system; and muscular system. The information consolidated and the message conveyed via the IR
Thermogram is truly a real time road map of a body’s current physiologic activity.
Figure 5. Eagle Image in grey scale. Eagle in rainbow palette. Raven Image in IS palette
Applying this then to animal and bird assessments, one need only to incorporate some additional
considerations that will enhance the validity and accuracy of the results. Outermost are the influences or fur,
hair, feathers, scales and shells. Applying heat transfer theory, some of these coverings may be exceptionally
poor conductors of heat from the skin and hence excellent insulators (shell, feathers, fur). What I have seen
so far has been areas of excellent insulation which are still capable of transferring a thermal signature
(readable) to the camera which could be relatively proportional to actual conditions they’re under, while not
being radiometrically correct. Fortunately, when an animal is injured there can be a slight disturbance or
relocation of the normal hair/fur/feather nap in the area. This exterior anomaly in turn can alter the
assessment thermography enough that attention is drawn to the area to make the secondary discovery. This
was the case at the Alaska Zoo when the caribou received their TB shots. I will suggest that every animal and
bird species might have their very own unique thermal signature, likely falling along general patterns of body
form and covering. Also in birds, consistently the largest proportions of heat emitted are from the head and
especially around the eyes, then the legs, followed by the wings to between the shoulder blades. The very
best imaging results and accurate values are achieved when the animal’s exterior is relatively free of dirt and
debris (clean) and especially when they are dry (free of moisture). Moisture tends to alter greatly the
readability of the animal’s thermal signature and it seems unlikely that the wetness is equally-distributed over
the surface at any one time. Imaging river otters in and out of a stream, they were homogenous in
temperature per the camera until patterns of dryness in their pelts developed.
Using thermography as an initial assessment tool will be valuable in research and in setting up data trends
specific to species and circumstance. I don’t suggest that it will surpass palpation, direct observation or blood
work but I do suspect we might begin to find out more than we knew before, if it is applied. In imaging injured
and uninjured wildlife alike – we are more likely to notice bruising, inflammation, infection, small puncture
wounds, broken bones, lack of circulation, head and eye injuries and breathing/nasal imbalances or even
blockages using thermography. Like any other form of imaging, thermography is a screening tool to lead us in
the right direction of closer investigation. Thermography does not diagnose – by law – that is what Doctors
do!
REHABILITATION:
Rehabilitation is an important phase of the Responders process and allows caregivers to take the time
necessary to work directly with the wildlife through care, treatments and controlled conditions, while also
monitoring specific aspects of their health for change. One of the goals of rehabilitation is also to minimize
Should washing of the wildlife be a part of the rehabilitation effort, thermal imaging can and will play a
premiere role in documenting the effectiveness and the needed follow-up to the cleaning process. Figure 7
shows examples of unwashed birds and the washing process. Because the objective of the wash is to allow
the natural restoration of the animals insulating capacity – monitoring with thermography literally documents
the amount of heat escaping and its locations. This allows for a direct treatment and/or focus on problem
areas as the feather or fur realign for maximum protection. Gathering thermal images of un-oiled, healthy
individuals of each species (eg figure 8), under treatment, would eventually allow for cross referencing
verification of progress and the eventual development of standard criteria for future releases to the wild by
species.
It was at this point in the oiled eagle treatment that the impromptu invitation and investigative opportunity
arose to integrate Thermal Imaging into the rehabilitation process. Aside from the new potential discoveries
we might make, it was agreed and known that my previous IR imaging volunteer work at TLC had
accumulated a sizeable collection of eagle thermograms. With these as potential baseline images of clean,
un-oiled eagles we now could start to build a conceptual comparison of how the images would support our
future interpretation of eagles’ heat loss characteristics and in turn assess how clean and in what locations
the feathers may still be oily. Two thermal imaging visits to Bird TLC took place during the rehabilitation phase
of treatment.
After setting the camera up to the appropriate internal environmental conditions of the TLC Bird Center - we
started to apply the Thermal Imaging Camera as an interpretive tool. Because it equally has the ability to
store large amounts of digital thermal imagery as well as color pictures on it memory card, we were also able
to apply it as a documentation tool – recording times, dates, emitted temperatures and the overall infrared
characteristics of each bird on that visit.
Equipment: The thermal images gathered for investigative study and reference by the attending TLC staff
were taken by a certified Level II FLIR Thermographer using a FLIR P-65 handheld radiometric Imager.
Emissivity was set at 0.98 for consistency among birds and gray scale image palette was used to optimize
focus.
Figure 14. Examples of Comparative Thermal Patterns and Delta Temperature Calculations
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author wishes to thank the IBRRC, the OWCN and the Bird Treatment and Learning Center for their
encouragement, support and all of the great pictures shared to make this manuscript graphic and
comprehensive. And a special thanks to Gary Orlove for his patience.