Professional Documents
Culture Documents
et al.
352 International Journal of Consumer Studies, 29, 4, July 2005, pp352–358 © 2005 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
J.-S. Horng et al. • Creative teachers and creative teaching strategies
GreaTeach award of creative instruction in Integrated Combining an analysis of all the findings above led to
Activities. The Integrated Activities course includes the the development of guidelines for effective creative
original subjects of home economics, counselling guid- instructions.
ance, group activity and boy/girl scout, as well as the
cross-field curriculum contents. The analyses of their
Results and discussion
interviews are anonymously presented.
Research started with the interviewing of 12
What makes a creative instructor?
GreaTeach award-winning teachers. They were invited
to a focus-group interview, sharing their experiences From the interviews of the three subjects, it is apparent
and possible elements of successful creative instruc- that the successful creative instructions of Integrated
tions. Based on this interview, a semi-structural outline Activity are subject to several factors: teachers’ person-
for the three subjects is constructed and modified. alities, family backgrounds, learning processes, life
The three subjects were interviewed individually experiences, education beliefs, diligence and motiva-
twice; each time lasting for one and half hours. The tions. These factors may exercise different influences
interviews were recorded with the subjects’ consent. from person to person, but are closely related and mutu-
Following analysis of the transcriptions of the first inter- ally affected.
views, further specific questions were pinpointed for
the second in-depth interviews. The transcriptions Personality traits
were compared and contrasted, leading to the final Many studies have evidenced the influences of person-
conclusions. alities and developments of creativity.5–8 The common
In addition to the interviews, the subjects were video- personality traits of subjects are: self-confidence, open-
taped in class; and an attempt was made to analyse their ness to experience, fantasy oriented, imagination, emo-
teaching styles, strategies and interactions with students. tional sensitive, drive and ambition, norm doubting
Finally, they were assessed against several measures: (questioning established norms), nonconformity, attrac-
Thinking Pattern Measure (Sternberg and Wagner, tion to complexity, aesthetic orientation, flexibility of
unpublished test), Creativity Development Measure2, thoughts and risk taking, consistent with the viewpoint
Innovative Teaching Strategies Measure3 and Creativity of Feist,9 Sternberg and Lubart.1
Fostering Teacher Index.4 The results of these mea- The three subjects in the interviews showed their per-
surements confirmed that all subjects are highly severance in dealing with difficulties, desire to learn and
creative. absorb new experiences, self-confidence,10 and strong
This research is qualitative rather than quantitative. desires to acquire new knowledge. By participating in
The analyses of the interviews and classroom observa- in-service educational workshops, these subjects con-
tions formed the main body of the research. Documents stantly absorbed new information, reinforcing their pro-
such as designs of teaching activities, teachers’ reflection fessionalism and investing more creativity in their
logs, students’ in-class assignments, homework and instructions.
feedbacks, and the collection of references, syllabi, vid- The interviews suggest that the three subjects were
eos of teaching activities, are minutely analysed, in an also good at creating original ideas. They all possessed
attempt to reveal how teachers develop a grasp of cre- a sense of keen observation, perception and sensitivity.
ative instructions as well as the references, syllabi and On discovering novel ideas, the subjects were easily able
strategies they adopt. Meanwhile, students are also to infuse these skills into their instruction.
highly valued; feedback, fresh ideas and the way they Another distinctive quality of the three subjects is
deal with creativity were analysed. The collected data the habit of thinking. Thinking is a process of combin-
were analysed qualitatively and the results of the inter- ing information, lighting up the flame of creativity. In
views were triangulated with the results of interviews, the analyses of the subjects’ lesson plans, implementa-
observations, and the researchers’ field notes and tions of creativity and novelty were found to be
reflection. impressive.
© 2005 Blackwell Publishing Ltd International Journal of Consumer Studies, 29, 4, July 2005, pp352–358 353
Creative teachers and creative teaching strategies • J.-S. Horng et al.
Though humour was never mentioned by the subjects their childhood, they liked to explore nature, using their
during interviewing, it was observed in class that videos imagination to create stories and games. The subjects
with a humorous aspect were capable of easing stu- connected their experiences with nature and observa-
dents’ pressure and encouraging active responses. The tion of all life forms to creative instructions. Without an
subjects interacted with students in a humorous tone, exposure to nature and the freedom allowed by their
catching every student’s attention and letting them parents, the subjects’ creativity would have failed to
know that learning can be enjoyable. emerge.
Humour is highly valued in Western societies. In the However, it needs more than childhood inspiration
study of Getzels and Jackson11, the high-creativity stu- for creativity to blossom. Unlike some geniuses who are
dents ranked sense of humour 3rd out of 13 qualities, able to self-develop their creativity in early childhood,
whereas high-IQ was ranked 9th;12 this study again evi- most creative instructors consider their learning experi-
denced the relation between humour and creativity. In ences and school education during adolescence to have
another study by McGreevy (1990)13 students list the nourished their creative power. One of the subjects said
qualities of creative teachers, with humour ranked first. that as a pupil, she liked to have brainstorming sessions
This indicated a teacher’s humour could not only be with her fellow classmates, but what brought about her
attention-grabbing, but can also significantly impress devotion to education were the indirect influences of
students. her teachers. The subjects all felt obliged to be a role
All the qualities discussed above helped the subjects model for their students and insisted on the best teach-
with creative instructions, encouraging them to learn ing and creative instructions. Feldman15 indicated that it
and innovate. No matter what obstacles they faced, they is taken for granted that teachers, mentors, schools and
were able to approach the challenges with humour, per- other preparation for later creative work are critical to
severance and confidence, creating a fun, easy learning its success.
environment.
Peer interaction
The subjects’ creativity is supported by small group
Family factors interaction with their colleagues. One subject plays an
The three subjects all grew up with their parents’ sup- innovation brainstorming game with office mates during
port, and they were given the freedom to explore them- class break in order to refresh their minds. The other
selves. No punishments were imposed when they made two subjects join a group study of curriculum develop-
mistakes. Under these circumstances, children are able ment and contribute new ideas to inspire one another.
to learn from their errors, fostering their creativity. Gardner’s research16 indicated that personal and profes-
When children’s strengths and interests emerged in the sional relationships with peers are able to help peoples’
family context, they were supported and encouraged. creativity and careers development.
The subjects indicated that their parents had inspired
their creativity. Sternberg and Lubart14 believe parents Beliefs in education
can be a model of creative thinking and can demon- The three subjects shared common beliefs about educa-
strate to their children the importance of fostering cre- tion: self-expression, sharing and communication. To
ativity and applying it to daily life. A family’s (a) social- communicate these values to students, the subjects
economic status, structure and compositions, (b) par- adopted diverse approaches and real-life issues, listened
ents’ education beliefs, relation and expectations with carefully to every student’s opinions, and gave freedom
children and (c) relations among siblings are the factors to their imagination and creativity. Their instructions
that fashion a person’s creativity.10 demonstrated their beliefs in humanistic education. The
feedback from parents indicated that they felt their
Growing up and learning experiences children had learned from our subjects to become inde-
When asked how creativity was developed, the subjects pendent thinking, be willing to share, be able commu-
referred to their childhood as a critical period. During nicate with others and be patient.
354 International Journal of Consumer Studies, 29, 4, July 2005, pp352–358 © 2005 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
J.-S. Horng et al. • Creative teachers and creative teaching strategies
© 2005 Blackwell Publishing Ltd International Journal of Consumer Studies, 29, 4, July 2005, pp352–358 355
Creative teachers and creative teaching strategies • J.-S. Horng et al.
tion being given the case despite opposition from their Use of multi-teaching aids assistance
school. The three subjects analysed are good at using multi-
To conclude, what influences creative instructions are: teaching aids to assist their instructions. They inge-
personalities, family backgrounds, growth and learning niously used creative teaching aids, such as paper
experiences, beliefs in education, dedications to educa- crusher, toy block, hammer, student writing script,
tion, motivations and schools. Among these factors, power-point, computer and multimedia to excite stu-
beliefs in education, dedications to education and moti- dents thinking, broaden the viewpoints and encourage
vations account for the results of implementing creative further discussion. After viewing videos, students are
instructions. given open questions, such as ‘What will be your reac-
tion if you were the character?’ Tan26 showed that vid-
eos are proved to effectively improve students’
Strategies for creative instructions
creativity. According to Strom and Strom,25 lessons
The following strategies of creative instructions are con- facilitated with videos are more attractive, interesting
cluded from the interview, observation and analysis of and easier for students to remember. Computers, vid-
lesson plans of Integrated Activities. eos, slide shows, transparencies and advance organizers
are considered stimulating and attractive. In addition,
Student-centred learning the popular cartoon ‘Doraemon’ and movie ‘Harry Pot-
The subjects used student-centred strategies in their ter’ can trigger students’ interests in learning.
creative instructions. The role of teachers is as facilitator Modern students grow up with computers and high-
rather than lecturer, helping students with self- tech devices. Simplicio18 emphasized education by
reflection, group discussion, role play, drama pre- means of modern technology. The Ministry of Educa-
sentation and group activities. Questions for group tion in Taiwan, is upgrading teachers’ computer literacy,
discussions and presentations are prepared. Students schools’ internet access, as well as promoting info-tech
are given freedom to choose from what perspective they applications to education and net-accessible lesson
will study an issue. Throughout the class, teachers act as plans. Computer literacy is a prerequisite for creative
a learning partner, inspirer, navigator and sharer, while instructors and an access to abundant education
students transform from passive listeners to observers, resources on the internet.
performers and colearners. The subjects allow students
to choose their own topics for individual or group Class management strategies
projects. In the instruction, creativity is encouraged in The subjects showed sophisticated management, cre-
order to explore ideas that students find interesting. ated friendly interactions and treated students with
Collins and Amabile20 believe children’s intrinsic moti- recognitions of their individualities and needs. They are
vation and creativity might be enhanced if their teachers more like friends to their students, speaking with gentle
engage them in discussions about the intrinsic excite- tones and body language. When students express ideas,
ment and joy of learning. they would not interrupt nor give judgements immedi-
Many studies showed that cooperative learning effec- ately. Instead, they gave guidance, more open questions,
tively helps students develop independent thinking as or conveyed their personal experiences as references.
well as imagination and creativity.6,18,24–26 Simplicio18 Throughout the class, humour bridges the gap between
indicated that before acquiring decent knowledge of teachers and students, providing a relaxed learning
new instruction strategies, teachers will fail to meet stu- environment.24
dents’ needs. Therefore, sufficient knowledge and care- In recent years, worldwide studies stress that learn-
ful design must be made before implementation. The ing environments as key to successful creative
subjects always informed their students of rules to be instructions.6,7,18,21,24 The ability to create friendly inter-
observed and the tasks to finish before the class took actions with students is the most important quality for
place. This guaranteed the efficiency and effectiveness creative instructors, who usually adhere to the philoso-
of cooperative learning. phy of humanism. They believe in students’ ability of
356 International Journal of Consumer Studies, 29, 4, July 2005, pp352–358 © 2005 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
J.-S. Horng et al. • Creative teachers and creative teaching strategies
self-discipline, focus on communication and democratic lead to more chances.’ The three subjects showed their
spirits and help students fashion their individualities. concern of life education in their beliefs in education
Unlike creative instructors, traditional instructors and lesson plans.
observe students from a moral perspective, and high-
light hierarchy and authority in the class. Open questions and encouragement of creative thinking
Petrowski7 raised several guiding principles for con- In lesson plans and materials, the three subjects
structing a creative learning environment: (a) provide designed open questions for their students that stirred
every possible chance to choose and discover; (b) sup- students’ creative thinking. Esquivel6 identified open
port any attempt to create; (c) implement sophisticated questions as a characteristic of creative instructions.
management strategies. The three subjects also followed Besides, creative instructors always encourage students
these guiding principles. to create and imagine in group discussions. Related
When students are taught and their achievements are studies showed that teachers can have more positive
then assessed in a way that values their creative ability, influences on students by encouraging them to ‘be
their creative performance improves.1 creative’.27
© 2005 Blackwell Publishing Ltd International Journal of Consumer Studies, 29, 4, July 2005, pp352–358 357
Creative teachers and creative teaching strategies • J.-S. Horng et al.
creativity development teachers will be instilled with 14 Sternberg, R.J. & Lubart, T.I. (1995) Defying the Crowd:
more creative thinking and will gain the momentum to Cultivating Creativity in a Culture of Conformity . Free
accommodate the changed approach to education. Press, New York.
15 Feldman, D.H. (1999) The development of creativity.
In Handbook of Creativity (ed. by R.J. Sternberg),
References pp. 169–186. Cambridge University Press, New
York.
1 Sternberg, R.J. & Lubart, T.I. (1999) The concept of 16 Gardner, H. (1994) Multiple intelligence theory. In
creativity: prospects and paradigms. In Handbook of Encyclopedia of Human Intelligence (ed. by R.J.
Creativity (ed. by R.J. Sternberg), pp. 3–15. Cambridge Sternberg), pp. 740–742. Macmillan, New York.
University Press, New York. 17 Torrance, E.P. (1987) Future career image as a predictor
2 Wang, W.C. & Cheng, Y.Y. (2000) Development and item of creative achievement in the 22-year longitudinal study.
response analysis of the creativity development inventory. Psychological Reports, 60, 574.
Annual Journal of Test, 47, 153–173. 18 Simplicio, J.S.C. (2000) Teaching classroom educators
3 Yeh, Y.C., Wu, J.J. & Cheng, Y.Y. (2000) The how to be more effective and creative teachers. Education,
development of inventories for factors that influence 120, 675–680.
creativity development for personnel in technology and 19 Weisberg, R.W. (1999) Creativity and knowledge: a
information industries. Journal of Taiwan Normal challenge to theories. In Handbook of Creativity (ed. by
University, 45, 39–63. R.J. Sternberg), pp. 226–250. Cambridge University Press,
4 Soh, K.C. (2000) Indexing creativity fostering teacher New York.
behaviour: a preliminary validation study. Journal of 20 Collins, M.A. & Amabile, T.M. (1999) Motivation and
Creative Behaviour, 34, 118–134. creativity. In Handbook of Creativity (ed. by R.J.
5 Amabile, T.M. (1988) A model of creativity and Sternberg), pp. 297–312. Cambridge University Press,
innovation in organizations. Research in Organizational New York.
Behaviour, 10, 123–167. 21 Trunnell, E.P., Evans, C., Richards, B. & Grosshans, O.
6 Esquivel, G.B. (1995) Teacher behaviours that foster (1997) Factors associated with creativity in health
creativity. Educational Psychology Review, 7, 185–202. educators who have won university teaching awards: A
7 Petrowski, M.J. (2000) Creativity research: implications modified qualitative approach. Journal of Health
for teaching, learning, and thinking. Reference Services Education, 28, 35–41.
Review, 28, 304–312. 22 Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1990) The domain of creativity. In
8 Woodman, R.W. & Schoenfeldt, L.F. (1989) Individual Theories of Creativity (ed. by M.A. Runco & R.S. Albert),
differences in creativity: an interactionist perspective. In pp. 190–214. Sage, Newbury Park, CA.
Handbook of Creativity (ed. by J.A. Glover, R.R. Ronning 23 Williams, W.M. & Yang, L.T. (1999) Organizational
& C.R. Reynolds), pp. 77–92. Plenum, New York. creativity. In Handbook of Creativity (ed. by R.J.
9 Feist, G.J. (1999) The influence of personality on artistic Sternberg), pp. 373–391. Cambridge University Press,
and scientific creativity. In Handbook of Creativity (ed. by New York.
R.J. Sternberg), pp. 273–296. Cambridge University Press, 24 Fleith, D.S. (2000) Teacher and student perception of
New York. creativity in the classroom environment. Roeper Review,
10 Sternberg, R.J. (ed.) (1988) The Nature of Creativity: 22, 148–153.
Contemporary Psychological Perspectives. Cambridge 25 Strom, R.D. & Strom, P.S. (2002) Changing the rules:
University Press, New York. education for creative thinking. Journal of Creative
11 Getzels, J.W. & Jackson, P.W. (1962) Creativity and Behaviour, 36, 183–200.
Intelligence. Wiley, New York. 26 Tan, A.G. (2001) Singaporean teachers’ perception of
12 Sternberg, R.J. & O’hara, L.A. (1999) Creativity and activities useful for fostering creativity’. Journal of
intelligence. In Handbook of Creativity (ed. by R.J. Creative Behaviour, 35, 131–148.
Sternberg), pp. 251–272. Cambridge University Press, 27 O’Hara, L.A. & Sternberg, R.J. (2000–2001) It doesn’t
New York. hurt to ask: effects of instructions to be creative, practical,
13 McGreevy, A. (1990) Darwin and teacher: An analysis of or analytical on essay-writing performance and their
the mentorship between Charles Darwin and professor interaction with students’ thinking styles’. Creativity
John Henslow. Gifted Child Quarterly, 34, 5–9. Research Journal, 13, 197–210.
358 International Journal of Consumer Studies, 29, 4, July 2005, pp352–358 © 2005 Blackwell Publishing Ltd