Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VHDL
Pros:
Strongly typed language.
Dealing with signed and unsigned numbers is natural, and there’s less chance of
making a precision mistake or assigning a 16-bit signal to a 4-bit signal.
Ability to define custom types.
A VHDL state machine can be coded naturally using the actual state names (e.g.
wait, acknowledge, transmit, receive, etc.), not binary state numbers (e.g. 00, 01, 10, 11).
Record types.
Define multiple signals into one type.
Natural coding style for asynchronous resets.
Easily reverse bit order of a word.
Logical statement (like case and if/then) endings are clearly marked.
Cons:
Extremely verbose coding.
VHDL modules must be defined by a prototype and declared before they’re used,
causing you to change code in at least 3 places if you want to make a change to the interface.
The use of the keyword “downto” in every bit vector definition is tedious.
Sensitivity lists.
Missing a single signal in the sensitivity list can cause catastrophic differences
between simulation and synthesis.
Each process must have a sensitivity list that may sometimes be very long.
Type conversions.
Signal types that are clearly related (e.g. std_logic and std_logic_vector) cannot
be simply used together and must be converted to another type.
Verilog
Pros:
Compact language.
Small code footprint.
Familiar language conventions similar to C.
Mixing and matching signals is very easy.
Reduction operators.
Perform logical tests on an entire array of bits with a single operator.
Low-level descriptions closer to actual hardware.
Instantiate gates directly.
Explicitly declare wires and registers directly.
Compiler directives.
Cons:
Weakly-typed language.
Code is more error prone due to accidental combination of differing signal types.
Possible to create signal with a typo.
No sensitivity lists.
Less of a chance of design synthesis and simulation problems arising from
coding.
No support of custom types.
State machine coding is more difficult because states must be numeric values
with a static bit widths (techniques exist to ease this problem).
Confusing signal declarations.
Signal declarations are not always required.
The difference between a wire and reg is not always obvious for beginners, and a
reg can sometimes be a wire.
Confusing language conventions for beginners.
The difference between blocking and non-blocking statements is sometimes
difficult to grasp for beginning FPGA programmers.
Reduced support for asynchronous signals.
Using asynchronous signals slows down simulation software.
Language constructs don’t support natural usage of asynchronous signals.