Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Available at www.sciencedirect.com
http://www.elsevier.com/locate/biombioe
I. Agirre*, I. Garcı́a, J. Requies, V.L. Barrio, M.B. Güemez, J.F. Cambra, P.L. Arias
Chemical and Environmental Engineering Department, Engineering School of Bilbao Alameda Urquijo s/n, 48013 Bilbao, Spain
Article history: The acetalization reaction between glycerol and formaldehyde using Amberlyst 47 acidic
Received 17 August 2010 ion exchange resin was studied. These acetals can be obtained from renewable sources
Received in revised form (bioalcohols and bioalcohol derived aldehydes) and seem to be good candidates for
28 April 2011 different applications such as oxygenated diesel additives. A preliminary kinetic study was
Accepted 6 May 2011 performed in a batch stirred tank reactor studying the influence of different process
Available online 31 May 2011 parameters like temperature, feed composition and the stirring speed. A pseudo homog-
enous kinetic model able to explain the reaction mechanism was adjusted. Thus, the
Keywords: corresponding order of reaction was determined. Amberlyst 47 acidic ion exchange resin
Glycerol showed a fairly good behavior allowing 100% of selectivity towards acetals formation.
Formaldehyde However, the studied acetalization reaction showed high thermodynamic limitations
Acetal achieving glycerol conversions around 50% using a stoichiometric feed ratio at 353 K. The
Kinetics product is a mixture of two isomers (1,3-Dioxan-5-ol and 1,3-dioxolane-4-methanol) and
Amberlyst the conversion of 1,3-dioxolane-4-methanol into 1,3-Dioxan-5-ol was also observed.
ª 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
from reactions between alcohols (bioalcohols) and aldehydes. compound like NaOH which can deactivate the catalyst and
In the present study glycerol and formaldehyde were used as hinder the reaction. Therefore, in spite of containing high
reactants. As it is mentioned, large amounts of glycerol are water amounts and 10 wt% of methanol, cheaper and
available as a sub-product of the transesterification reaction. commercially available formaldehyde was used as reagent.
On the other hand, formaldehyde can also have a renewable
origin as it can be obtained from methanol. This alcohol can 2.2. Analysis
be produced from syngas (CO and H2), which can be
obtained from biomass [6,7]. Thus, all the raw materials Both reactants (glycerol and formaldehyde) and reaction
required for this process can be obtained from a renewable products (1,3-Dioxan-5-ol, 1,3-dioxolane-4-methanol and
origin leading into a sustainable process. water) were analyzed by gas chromatography (Agilent 6890N)
However, not all the acetals can be used as diesel or bio- using a flame ionization detector (FID) and a thermal conduc-
diesel additive. Some acetals present low flash points and as tivity detector (TCD). Agilent DB-1 60 m 0.53 mm 5 mm
a result they are not suitable to use as diesel additives. Glyc- capillary column was used with Helium as the carrier gas.
erol acetals fulfill these diesel specifications while acetals of
ethanol require a big aldehyde in order to get an acceptable 2.3. Batch stirred tank reactor (BSTR)
flash point. Lower molecular weight acetals are being used as
surfactants, flavors, disinfectants [3,5], in cosmetics, food, The experiments were carried out in a 1 L glass jacketed stir-
pharmaceutical area or in fragrances [2,8]. red reactor (Fig. 1). The reaction temperature was controlled
In terms of catalyst, acetals can be produced via homoge- by an external thermostat (Lauda RE 304). This thermostat
neous catalytic processes using strong mineral acids as cata- contains an external thermocouple to be placed inside the
lysts such as H2SO4, HF, HCl or p-toluensuphonic acid [9e11]. reacting mixture and allows the reaction temperature
Kaufhold et al. proposed in a patent [10] an industrial process control with an accuracy of 0.02 K. The reactor also is
for acetal production. In this process, apart from connected to a condenser in order to condense and reflux all
a homogeneous strong acid catalyst an entrainer (hexane, the vapours keeping the reaction volume nearly constant
pentane) is used with a normal boiling point between 298 K and avoiding emissions by evaporation.
and 348 K. This entrainer must be water insoluble (<3% The reactants were charged into the reactor (total initial
soluble in water), thus the water is continuously removed volume 0.5 L) and after stabilizing the system to the desired
from the reacting phase shifting the acetalization reversible temperature, the catalyst was added (starting time). At certain
reaction to the desired direction. However, these processes specific time intervals different samples were withdrawn in
entail corrosion problems, are uneconomical and they are order to analyse them by GC. A bit of glass wool was placed in
not environmentally friendly. The use of a heterogeneous the output sampling valve in order to keep the catalyst
catalytic process would overcome most of the previously amount constant in the reactor.
indicated problems. Therefore, several solid acid catalysts
are being tested currently.
Capeletti et al. [5] reported the performance of several solid
acid catalysts, from commercial, natural and laboratory
sources. They concluded that exchange resins show enough
surface acidity to allow reaching equilibrium values much
faster than other less acid solid catalysts.
2.1. Materials
Before adding the catalyst sample, it was previously dried reacts with the aldehyde molecule leading to the formation
at room temperature due to its high moisture content. Thus, of the corresponding hemiacetal and the second one, where
the catalyst had only the equilibrium humidity with the air the two hydroxyl groups of the hemiacetal join to form the
and therefore the weighting could be controlled. corresponding dioxolane, releasing a water molecule. Some
other authors [13] explained a more detailed mechanism for
the reaction between glycerol and acetaldehyde, indicating
3. Results and discussion more in detail all the different steps of the reorganization of
the hemiacetal molecule. In the present case, the mechanism
3.1. Preliminary experiments proposed by Sharma & Chopade [12] was followed. However,
in this case, two acetal isomers can be formed. One glycerol
Before starting the experiments, some tests were performed molecule has three different hydroxyl groups (OH) and
using H2SO4 as catalyst. The reaction behavior was completely depends on which two OH groups join to each other 1,3
comparable to the behavior observed using Amberlyst 47 dioxan-5ol or 1,3-dioxolane-4-methanol can be formed.
acidic ion exchange resins. Besides, no additional byproducts The first step in the formaldehydeeethanol reaction system,
were observed using the sulphuric acid. However, with the which does not require a catalyst, is much faster than the
exception of these initial ones, all the experiments were second one [12]. There are also some evidences that indicate
carried out using Amberlyst 47 resin in order to avoid all the a similar behavior when glycerol and formaldehyde are used
problems associated with the use of corrosive homogeneous as reactants. Just after mixing these compounds at room
catalyst: i.e. catalyst removal and reuse. temperature the mixture temperature increases notably due
Repeating at least three times each experiment using the to the exothermic reaction taking place as a non-catalyzed
same Amberlyst 47 sample very similar results were obtained process. However, some difficulties were found when
and, as a consequence, it was established that the catalyst did analyzing these samples. This fact could be explained by the
not suffer significant deactivation. exothermicity of a non-catalyzed reaction. When the sample
Besides, additional experiments proved that the methanol is injected into the GC (which is at 473 K) the reverse reaction
present in the formaldehyde solution did not influence the occurs due to a high decrease of the equilibrium constant
acetalization reaction selectivity. On the other hand, the with the increasing temperature and as a result most of the
presence of high amounts of water in this solution had some hemiacetal disappears and thus, the sample analysis is not
influence on the equilibrium conversion. representative. Similar problems were gathered when the
reaction between ethanol and butanal was studied [14]. In this
3.2. Reaction mechanism case HPLC/MS analyses of ethanol-butanal mixtures at room
temperature confirmed the presence of the hemiacetal in the
According to Sharma & Chopade [12] the reaction mechanism samples [15]. In addition to this, some authors [16] reported
for acetalization of ethylene glycol with formaldehyde the unstable behavior of hemi-acetals. As a result, this study
involves two reversible steps: the first one where the alcohol only took into consideration the overall reaction (see Fig. 2)
converting glycerol and formaldehyde into acetals. A more Where K1 is the equilibrium constant (Kc) in (mol/L)1.The
detailed analysis including hemiacetal concentrations would formation rate of acetal (AC) could be written as
have been possible only if the reaction mixture could be
analyzed without modifying its temperature. The kinetic d½AC
¼ wk3 ½HA wk4 ½AC½W (2)
analysis that follows fulfill the requirements of the objectives dt
established for this study: provide the kinetic information that Where w is (gcat)/(reacting volume in L)
it is necessary to design industrial processes to produce these k3 and k4 are the kinetic constants. k3in L/(gcat$min) and k4
acetals. in L2/(min$gcat), [ ] indicates concentration in mol/L
The overall conversion was determined measuring the two Substituting [HA] from Eq. (1),
acetal concentrations. Detailed kinetic modeling should take
into account the evolution of both reactant and product
concentrations. For this system, a precise measurement of the d½AC
¼ wk½FHO½Gly wk4 ½AC½W (3)
reactant concentrations is extremely difficult: formaldehyde dt
is fed as a mixture where its dimers or higher polymers could Where k ¼ k3K1 in L2/(gcat$min$mol). At t ¼ 0, the initial
be also present and glycerol and formaldehyde could be conditions are:
present not only as free molecules but also combined as
hemiacetal. ½FHO ¼ ½FHO0
In order to study the kinetics of the reaction, a mixture of ½Gly ¼ ½Gly0
(4)
both acetals, 1,3 dioxan-5ol or 1,3-dioxolane-4-methanol, was ½AC ¼ ½AC0 ¼ 0
taken into account (Fig. 2) without considering possible ½W ¼ ½W0
isomerization reactions between both acetals. As it is
As there are no side reactions when operating with
depicted in Fig. 3 both isomers are primary products but
Amberlyst 47 resin as catalyst the concentration of other
then the dioxalane suffers an isomerization reaction
compounds can be calculated by molar balances:
towards the dioxane formation. This effect was also
observed by Camara et al. (2003) and Da Silva Ferreira et al.
[13,17] in the evolution of the acetals from glycerol and ½FHO ¼ ½FHO0 ½AC ½AC0 (5)
acetaldehyde appearing in Port and Madeira wines. Aksnes
et al. [18] also studied the acetalization reaction between
Gly ¼ ½Gly0 ½AC ½AC0 (6)
glycerol and acetaldehyde and they also observed that 1,3
dioxalane isomers were formed faster but then the reaction
mixture proceeded towards the isomerization equilibrium ½W ¼ ½W0 þ ½AC ½AC0 (7)
generating more 1,3 dioxanes. On the contrary, Ruiz et al.
In the global reaction, the forward reaction is 1st order with
[19] observed the isomerization from dioxanes to dioxalanes.
respect to glycerol and 1st order with respect to formaldehyde.
As the hemiacetal formation and decomposition reaction
The reverse reaction is also 1st order with respect to acetal
rates are so high at the operating temperatures, the hemi-
and water. These orders of reaction will be confirmed later. In
acetal (HA) can be considered to be continuously at equilib-
order to solve the differential equation (3) together with the
rium with glycerol and formaldehyde.
initial conditions (4) and the mass balances (5, 6 and 7)
a fourth order Runge-Kutta integration method was used.
½HA ¼ K1 ½FHO½Gly (1) Thus, minimizing the sum of squares of the difference
between the experimental and the predicted concentrations,
the apparent kinetic constants (k and k4) were calculated.
references
Table 2 e Kinetic constants at different temperatures.
Temperature k (mol1 L2 s1 g cat1) k4 (mol1 L2
[1] Moser BR, Erhan SZ. Branched chain derivatives of alkyl
(K) s1 g cat1)
oleates: tribological, rheological, oxidation, and low
353.15 1.4277E-05 5.0825E-06 temperature properties. Fuel 2008;87(10e11):2253e7.
363.15 2.1885E-05 6.9467E-06 [2] Umbarkar SB, Kotbagi TV, Biradar AV, Pasricha R, Chanale J,
373.15 4.2064E-05 1.1862E-05 Dongare MK, et al. Acetalization of glycerol using
mesoporous MoO3/SiO2 solid acid catalyst. J Mol Catal A:
Chem 2009;310(1e2):150e8.
3642 b i o m a s s a n d b i o e n e r g y 3 5 ( 2 0 1 1 ) 3 6 3 6 e3 6 4 2
[3] Silva PHR, Gonsalves VLC, Mota CJA. Glycerol acetals as anti- [14] Agirre I, Barrio VL, Güemez B, Cambra JF, Arias PL. The
freezing additives for biodiesel. Bioresour Technol 2010; development of a reactive distillation process for the
101(15):6225e9. production of 1,1 Diethoxy Butane from bioalcohol: kinetic
[4] Burtscher H, Matter U, Skillas G. The effect of fuel additives study and Simulation model. Int J Chem React Eng 2010;8:
on diesel engine particulate emissions. J Aerosol Sci 1999; A86.
30(Supplement 1):S851e2. [15] Abad B. Identificación de la presencia de hemiacetal en una
[5] Capeletti MR, Balzano L, de la Puente G, Laborde M, Sedran U. mezcla etanol:butanal (2:1 en moles). Servicio general de
Synthesis of acetal (1,1-diethoxyethane) from ethanol and análisis UPV/EHU, editor. 4-21-2008. SGIKER. General
acetaldehyde over acidic catalysts. Appl Catal A 2000; Analysis Department of the University of the Basque
198(1e2):L1e4. Country.
[6] Hu J, Wang Y, Cao C, Elliott DC, Stevens DJ, White JF. [16] Yadav GD, Pujari AA. Kinetics of acetalization of perfumery
Conversion of biomass-derived syngas to alcohols and C2 aldehydes with alkanols over solid acid catalysts. Can
oxygenates using supported Rh catalysts in a microchannel J Chem Eng 1999;77(3):489e96.
reactor. Catal Today 2007;120(1):90e5. [17] Camara JS, Marques JC, Alves A, Ferreira ACS. Heterocyclic
[7] Munasinghe PC, Khanal SK. Biomass-derived syngas acetals in Madeira wines. Anal Bioanal Chem 2003;375(8):
fermentation into biofuels: opportunities and challenges. 1221e4.
Bioresour Technol 2010;101(13):5013e22. [18] Aksnes G, Albriktsen P, Juvvik P. Cyclic acetal and ketal
[8] Yang S, Wang M, Liang Y, Sun J. Eco-friendly one-pot isomers of glycerol. Acta Chem Scand 1965;19(4):920e30.
synthesis of acetals and ketals by heterogeneously catalyzed 1947-1973.
liquid-solid phase reaction. Rare Met. (Beijing, China) 2006; [19] Ruiz VR, Velty A, Santos LL, Leyva-Pqrez A, Sabater MJ,
25(6):625e9. Iborra S, et al. Gold catalysts and solid catalysts for biomass
[9] Frusteri F, Spadaro L, Beatrice C, Guido C. Oxygenated transformations: valorization of glycerol and glycerol-water
additives production for diesel engine emission mixtures through formation of cyclic acetals. J Catal 2010;
improvement. Chem Eng J 2007;134(1e3):239e45. 271(2):351e7.
[10] Kaufhold M., El-Chahawi M., inventors. Huels [20] Froment GF, Bischoff KB. Chemical reactor analysis and
Aktiengesellschaft, assignee. Process for preparing acetaldehyde design. John Wiley & Sons; 1979.
diethyl acetal. Germany Patent 5527969. 1996 Jun 1996. [21] Chopade SP, Sharma MM. Reaction of ethanol and
[11] Green TW. Protective groups in organic synthesis. New York: formaldehyde: use of versatile cation-exchange resins as
Willey; 1981. catalyst in batch reactors and reactive distillation columns.
[12] Chopade SP, Sharma MM. Acetalization of ethylene glycol React Funct Polym 1997;32(1):53e65.
with formaldehyde using cation-exchange resins as [22] Dhale AD, Myrant LK, Chopade SP, Jackson JE, Miller DJ.
catalysts: batch versus reactive distillation. React Funct Propylene glycol and ethylene glycol recovery from aqueous
Polym 1997;34(1):37e45. solution via reactive distillation. Chem Eng Sci 2004;59(14):
[13] da Silva Ferreira Antonio Cesar, Barbe J, Bertrand A. 2881e90.
Heterocyclic acetals from glycerol and acetaldehyde in port [23] Silva MTM, Rodrigues AE. Synthesis of diethylacetal:
wines: evolution with aging. J Agric Food Chem 2002;50(9): thermodynamic and kinetic studies. Chem Eng Sci 2001;
2560e4. 56(4):1255e63.