You are on page 1of 8

Eye-Movement Disorders in

Brain-Stem and Cerebellar Stroke


Julien Bogousslavsky, MD, Otmar Meienberg, MD

\s=b\ Vertebrobasilar strokes can yield stitutes a solid basis for monitoring half syndrome.5 In partial PPRF
varied disturbances of eye movements, the clinical course of the stroke. An lesions, there can be only a slowing of
by affecting specific centers and path- overview of the most important struc¬ the ipsilateral saccades and, some¬
ways contained in the brain stem and tures of the brain-stem ocular motor times, a "gaze paretic" nystagmus
cerebellum. Unique disorders combining system is given in Fig 1. The physio¬ with an exponentially decreasing
supranuclear, nuclear, and infranuclear- logic correlates of the anatomic struc¬ velocity of the centripetal slow phase.
syndromes may occur. Some eye-move- tures will not be discussed here, as Conjugate palsies of vertical gaze are
ment abnormalities are useful localizing extensive reviews can be found else¬ either due to bilateral lesions of the
signs (eg, gaze palsies, rotatory nystag- where.1"4 The scheme (Fig 1) is con¬ mesencephalic reticular formation, or
mus, and ipsilateral saccadic bias), but fined to those structures the lesion of to a lesion of the posterior commis¬
many others are not. The use of tech- which produces characteristic eye- sure. Nuclear lesions differ from
niques such as magnetic resonance imag- movement disorders of high-localiz¬ lesions of the corresponding cranial
ing may provide new insights in ing value. Although nystagmus fre¬ nerve, since the motoneurons for the
clinicotopographic correlations in pa- quently occurs in acute vascular individual eye muscles may be specifi¬
tients with good recovery, in the absence lesions of the brain stem or cerebel¬ cally grouped, as in the third-nerve
of pathologic verification. lum, its localizing value is generally nucleus6 (Fig 1), or since the motoneu¬
(Arch Neurol 1987;44:141-148) limited. rons are intermingled with interneu-
In the brain stem, the following rons, as in the sixth-nerve nucleus. A
three different levels of involvement caudal lesion of the third-nerve nucle¬
can be defined: the supranuclear, us, for example, can cause a complete
T~)isorders
common
of
in
eye movements
vertebrobasilar
are
nuclear, and infranuclear levels.1'4 At bilateral ptosis with sparing of all
strokes because the brain stem and the supranuclear level, the ocular other extraocular muscles. A lesion of
cerebellum contain a large number of motor subsystems (pursuit, saccadic, the sixth nerve nucleus produces an
structures belonging to the oculomo¬ vestibular, and vergence) can be selec¬ ipsilateral gaze palsy. Infranuclear
tor system. Since many of these struc¬ tively affected. For example, in verti¬ lesions affect the fasciculi of the
tures have specific functions and are cal gaze palsy, voluntary upgaze can third, fourth, or sixth nerves before
relatively small, careful clinical anal¬ be abolished, while the eyes can be they leave the brain stem, and lead to
fully moved upward by the vestibulo- the same eye movement disorder as a
ysis of eye movements often allows
exact conclusions about the localiza¬ ocular reflex (elicited by a fast down¬ peripheral lesion. Therefore, a dis¬
tion and size of a lesion. Such a precise ward movement of the head), or, in tinction between a fascicular and a
topographic diagnosis is particularly internuclear ophthalmoplegia (INO), peripheral lesion is only possible in
useful in the early stage of a stroke, the affected eye cannot adduct during the presence of additional brain-stem
when computed tomography usually lateral gaze, while it can normally signs.
yields normal results, and it also con- adduct during convergence. Intranu¬ MESENCEPHALON
clear ophthalmoplegia, which is, in
fact, a disorder of the internuclear The arterial territories of the upper
Accepted publication Aug 4,1986.
for gaze pathways, is the result of a lesion and lower midbrain are schematized
From the Department of Neurology, Centre of the medial longitudinal fasciculus in Fig 2, top and bottom left. The
Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois, Lausanne,
Switzerland (Dr Bogousslavsky) and the Depart- (MLF). Lesions of the paramedian upper midbrain and the thalamome-
ment of Neurology, Kantonsspital, Basel, Swit- pontine reticular formation (PPRF) sencephalic junction are supplied
zerland (Dr Meienberg). lead to palsies of ipsilateral conjugate mainly by the posterior thalamosub-
Reprint requests to the Department of Neurol- gaze. Lesions that simultaneously thalamic paramedian branches of the
ogy, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois,
1011 Lausanne, Switzerland (Dr Bogousslav- affect the PPRF and the ipsilateral P, segment of the posterior cerebral
sky). MLF produce a so-called one-and-a- artery,78 but the anterior choroidal

Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a New York University User on 05/30/2015


these phenomena.17 Other distur¬
bances of vertical eye movements may
occur, but are usually much less local¬
izing, for example, skew deviation
with usually the ipsilateral eye up,15
seesaw nystagmus,18 palpebrai nys¬
tagmus of Pick, and retraction of the
upper lid or blepharospasm.4·19 A head
tilt may occur if the region of the
contralateral nucleus of Cajal is
involved4 and may incorrectly suggest
a fourth nerve palsy.
Disturbances of horizontal eye
movements may occur, with decrease
of the contralateral saccades, possibly
from involvement of the anterior cor-
ticopontine pathway before its decus-
sation.20·21 The pseudo-sixth-nerve
palsy corresponds to a slow abducting
movement during the horizontal
refixation,22·23 perhaps from an excess
of convergence tone; convergence-
retractory nystagmus is common412;
organic convergence spasm and paral¬
ysis of convergence or divergence have
also occasionally been reported.4
The pupils may also be abnormal,
according to Fisher,5 a moderate dila¬
tation (4 to 6 mm) suggests a large
lesion involving the sympathetic as
well as the parasympathetic fibers,
Fig 1.—Schematic view of paramedian brain-stem structures involved in horizontal and vertical whereas a huge dilatation (7 to 10
(inset) gaze. Fourth-nerve fibers come from contralateral fourth-nerve nucleus, and MLF comes mm) suggests selective parasympa¬
from contralateral sixth-nerve nucleus. MLF indicates median longitudinal fasciculus; riMLF, thetic involvement; dissociation of the
rostral interstitial nucleus of the MLF; PPRF, paramedian pontine reticular formation; and 2 A light-near reflex is a classic finding.
through D refer to sections discussed in Fig 2. While ectopie pupils (corectopia) may
be suggestive of a midbrain stroke,24
oval pupils typically correspond to a
transient phase in progressive injury
artery occasionally contributes to this to bilateral lesions involving the to the oculomotor complex that occurs
supply.9 In the lower midbrain, the region of the rostral interstitial nucle¬ in more diffuse brain damage.25
following five main territories have us of the MLF11 (riMLF, Fig 1) and In this region, there is very little to
been found: the median territory posterior commissure.6 Selective allow the clinician to differentiate a
(third-nerve nucleus, part of MLF), downgaze palsy seems to be related to small hemorrhage from a small
supplied by direct twigs coming off bilateral involvement of the medio- infarct. In hemorrhages with a con¬
the basilar tip, the paramedian (third caudal region of the riMLF.12 On the spicuous thalamic involvement, conju¬
intra-axial fibers), intermediolateral other hand, selective upgaze palsy and gate eye deviation opposite to the
(part of MLF), and lateral (brachium combined downgaze and upgaze palsy lesion (wrong-way eyes) may occur.5
conjunctivum) territories supplied by may occasionally be due to a unilater¬ Also, in hemorrhages, sustained
the short circumferential branches of al iesion of the MRF involving the downgaze may be related to secondary
P„ and the superior or collicular terri¬ laterally spreading fibers of the poste¬ hydrocephalus, not to primary dam¬
tory supplied by the quadrigeminal rior commissure11·1314; at least ten such age due to the MRF.26
(long circumferential) branches of the pathologically studied cases have been Mesencephalic Syndromes
superior cerebellar artery (SCA) and reported.1113 In upgaze palsy due to
of ,.'·8 involvement of the posterior commis¬ Acute vascular lesions limited to
sure, upward vestibulo-ocular re¬ the midbrain are more often infarcts
Thalamomesencephalic than hemorrhages. These infarcts are
Junction Syndromes sponses are preserved because no ves-
tibulo-oculomotor fibers travel in the frequently embolie from the heart.27·28
Small infarcts (due to emboli from posterior commissure.1214 Rarely, dis¬ They may involve selective arterial
the heart or to basilar occlusion10) or sociation of voluntary, pursuit, and territories (Fig 2, top and bottom
hemorrhages limited to the region of reflex movements involvement has right) and give rise to oculomotor
the mesencephalic reticular forma¬ been reported in downgaze palsy.12·14·15 syndromes, which can be supranu¬
tion (MRF, Fig 1) and posterior com¬ Sustained upgaze in downgaze palsy clear (prenuclear), nuclear, and post-
missure give rise to rather specific and sustained downgaze in upgaze nuclear (fascicular), with regard to
oculomotor disturbances, with major palsy are uncommon13·1416; distur¬ the oculomotor complex nucleus.
involvement of vertical gaze. Upgaze bances of vestibular mechanisms by Nuclear lesions of the fourth-nerve
palsy, downgaze palsy, and complete involvement of the nucleus of Cajal nucleus or intra-axial fibers are usu¬
vertical gaze palsy are usually related may be critical for the development of ally associated with third-nerve

Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a New York University User on 05/30/2015


involvement or more extensive pon- have been recently reported in tropic.49 However, this rule is not
tomesencephalic strokes.29·31 patients showing selective downgaze absolute,4 and skew deviation by itself
Prenuclear Syndromes of the Third or upgaze palsy,17·37 in the absence of has little localizing value, since it is
Nerve.—These are related to small rostral MRF involvement. Involve¬ also found in pontine lesions sparing
infarcts in the most caudal territory ment of periaqueductal neurones or of the MLF. Actually, lesions limited to
of the posterior thalamo-subthalamic fibers descending from the MRF the midbrain or medulla can produce
paramedian arteries or of the anterior toward the third and fourth nerve a skew deviation.49 Horizontal gaze
choroidal artery, when this artery nuclei has been implicated. palsies can be due to a lesion of the
contributes to the blood supply of the Isolated Mesencephalic Hemor¬ ipsilateral PPRF or of the abducens
midbrain.9 Typically, a monocular rhages.—These are very uncommon. nucleus.48·50"52 In acute vascular lesions,
paresis of elevation of the eye contra- They usually produce combined conjugate deviation of the eyes con¬
lateral to the infarct is produced, by supranuclear and nuclear distur¬ tralateral to the lesion may be
involvement of the fibers traveling bances of eye movements.38 40 They are present.3·48 In a pure PPRF lesion, the
from the upper midbrain to the ipsi¬ probably due to hypertension or relat¬ eyes can still be moved to the paretic
lateral subnucleus, which innervates ed to small vascular malformations. side with vestibular stimuli, which is
the contralateral superior rectus.3234 Fascicular Syndromes of the Third not possible in a lesion of the sixth-
Internuclear ophthalmoplegia is fre¬ Nerve.—These are related to more nerve nucleus.48·51 In addition, the lat¬
quent, because of involvement of the ventrolateral infarcts. The third- ter is usually accompanied by a
MLF just before it reaches the oculo¬ nerve palsy may be incomplete, with peripheral facial palsy because of the
motor complex nucleus.33 Bilateral pupillary sparing38 and even miosis, close vicinity of the facial nerve
ptosis can occur and is probably relat¬ when the descending sympathetic knee.53 Isolated vascular lesions of the
ed to partial damage to the central pathway is involved.21 Associated neu¬ abducens nucleus and facial nerve
caudal nucleus.33 In rare cases, the rologic impairment is prominent with knee should not be too rare, since one
aspect of a "vertical one-and-a-half either contralateral hemiplegia (para¬ of us (O.M.) has seen three such cases
syndrome" may be produced when the median territory: syndrome of Weber) within a relatively short time. Partial
lesion extends toward the upper mid¬ or contralateral ataxia (intermediola- lesions of the PPRF do not produce a
brain, with upgaze palsy and monocu¬ teral territory: Claude-Nothnagel's gaze palsy, but considerably slow all
lar downgaze palsy, or downgaze palsy syndrome).21·34·41 ipsilaterally directed saccades.3·54 In
and monocular upgaze palsy.32·35 A bilateral destruction of the caudal
monocular paresis of elevation has PONS
PPRF, some reports have suggested
been reported in an ipsilateral infarct that, in addition to horizontal gaze
of the anterior choroidal artery terri¬ There are two main arterial pontine
networks.42·43 One is formed by direct palsy, there is also vertical gaze palsy,
tory,9 but the explanation for that is paramedian branches off the basilar
because of involvement of inputs to
obscure. the mesencephalic reticular forma¬
Nuclear Syndrome of the Third artery and indirect intermediate tion52·55; however, the occurrence of
Nerve.—This is produced by an infarct branches off the short circumferential
arteries. The other network is formed complete ophthalmoplegia from a
in the median mesencephalic territo¬ lesion limited to the pons remains
ry7 and has the very characteristic by lateral branches coming from two controversial. Often, vascular lesions
disturbance of a more or less complete (one on each side) long circumferen¬ involve the PPRF or abducens nucleus
tial arteries, the anterior inferior cer¬
ipsilateral third-nerve palsy associ¬ ebellar artery (AICA) and the SCA together with the ipsilateral MLF (af¬
ated with a paresis of elevation in the ter it has crossed the midline coming
contralateral eye, due to involvement (Fig 2, top right). from the contralateral abducens
of the subnucleus, which innervates Paramedian Pontine Syndromes nucleus). The clinical result is a one-
mainly the contralateral superior rec¬ and-a-half syndrome.5·48·51·56 In a
tus.20·21 The primary position of the Pontine eye-movement disorders review of the literature, 24 of 49 one-
eyes is highly suggestive, with ipsilat¬ due to small ischemie paramedian and-a-half syndromes were of vascu¬
eral exotropia and contralateral lesions are common, particularly in lar origin; 16 one-and-a-half syn¬
hypotropia. This paresis of elevation hypertensive patients. The most often dromes were due to an infarct, and
in both eyes has been called pseudo- encountered syndrome is INO.44·45 eight of them, to a hemorrhage.56 In
Parinaud's syndrome,20 and must be When due to a stroke, INO is general¬ the acute phase, exotropia of the eye
differentiated from upgaze palsy due ly of sudden onset and unilateral, opposite to the lesion may occur (par¬
to supranuclear lesions. Bilateral although bilateral INO of vascular alytic pontine exotropia)54·57; this is
mydriasis and bilateral ptosis may origin is not uncommon.46 Besides a due to the fact that contralateral ocu¬
sometimes occur.21 Associated neuro¬ restriction of adduction with pre¬ lar deviation due to acute paramedian
logic disturbances are usually scarce served convergence, there is often a pontine involvement cannot occur in
(eg, somnolence and mild ataxia), dissociated nystagmus with larger the ipsilateral eye, because of INO,
because of the localization of the amplitude in the abducting eye and a and is, therefore, limited to the con¬
infarct. nystagmus evoked by vertical gaze. In tralateral eye. In the locked-in syn-
Associated Supranuclear and Nuclear bilateral INO, reflex (vestibular) ver¬ drome,42'58-59 tetraplegia and paralysis
Disturbances.—These may occur in tical eye movements may be abol¬ of all lower cranial nerves is due to a
various combinations,27·28 usually in ished, due to involvement of the ves- mainly ventral pontine lesion; the
larger and bilateral mesencephalic tibulo-oculomotor fibers that travel in patient is fully conscious and typically
infarcts. Other neurologic distur¬ the MLF en route toward the oculo¬ can perform only lid and vertical eye
bances are usually prominent, some¬ motor and trochlear nuclei.47·48 Some¬ movements, since the patient also has
times with a mesencephalic "locked- times a skew deviation44·49 is present. bilateral horizontal gaze palsy. When
in" syndrome.36 When skew deviation is due to inter¬ one side of the pontine tegmentum is
Bilateral Infarcts or Hemorrhages of nuclear ophthalmoplegia, the eye ipsi¬ spared, such patients can demonstrate
the Periaqueductal Gray Matter.—These lateral to the lesion is usually hyper- a one-and-a-half syndrome.48 Ocular

Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a New York University User on 05/30/2015


Fig 2.—Schematic transverse cuts from mid¬
brain to medulla with arterial territories. Top
left, Level of third-nerve nucleus; bottom left,
bobbing consists of intermittent midbrain, involuntary vergence move¬ level of fourth-nerve nucleus; top right, level of
downward jerks of the eyes followed ments induced by voluntary horizon¬ sixth-nerve nucleus; bottom right, level of
by a slow return to the midposition.60 tal or conjugate gaze attempts may eighth- (vestibular), tenth-, and twelfth-nerve
In the majority of cases, the patients develop (convergence and divergence
are comatose, quadriplegic, and have synkinesis)55; these synkineses may
bilateral gaze palsy due to extensive occur when pontine centers of gaze
intrapontine hemorrhage or infarc¬ are involved, together with sparing of
tion. However, this clinical picture brain stem association pathways. In bing that is occasionally asymmetric.
may be mimicked by a cerebellar hem¬ vascular pontine syndromes, the A similar syndrome should also occur
orrhage without intrapontine lesion.61 pupils may be small and reactive, after occlusion of lateral penetrating
Rarely, typical bobbing may be inter¬ when the descending sympathetic branches of the SCA with infarction
polated with reverse bobbing (rapid pathways are involved.5 of the lateral brain stem, but infarcts
upward movement followed by a slow in the distribution of the SCA involve
return to the midposition).62 A typical Lateral Pontine Syndrome
mainly the superior part of the cere¬
bobbing with preserved consciousness Hemorrhages limited to the lateral bellum, and brain-stem signs are
and less-marked neurologic deficits tegmentum of the pons produce a rel¬ often not prominent.65 In caudolateral
has been observed in small hemato¬ atively consistent syndrome with con¬ pontine infarcts, corresponding to the
mas of the pons63 and in brain-stem tralateral hemiplegia and sensory distribution of the AICA, oculomotor
compression from a cerebellar hemor¬ loss, ipsilateral limb ataxia, Horner's signs are either absent or suggest
rhage.62 Lesions of the abducens nerve syndrome, and marked eye-movement vestibular involvement.66
fascicle within the pons may be asso¬ disorders.43-51·63 Most of these patients CEREBELLUM
ciated with contralateral brachiocru- have an ipsilateral one-and-a-half
ral hemiplegia (Millard-Gubler syn¬ syndrome, some have an ipsilateral The main supply of the cerebellum
drome).64 In the recovery of paramed¬ fascicular sixth-nerve palsy, and, in comes from the SCA (upper surface of
ian pontine hematomas sparing the the acute stage, some have ocular bob- the vermis and hemisphere) and the

Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a New York University User on 05/30/2015


nuclei MLF and PPRF as in Fig 1. PCA
indicates posterior cerebral artery; SCA,
superior cerebellar artery; AICA, anterior infe¬ cult a precise clinical localization of a and beat toward the contralateral
rior cerebellar artery; and PICA, posterior lesion. side.
inferior cerebellar artery.
Although a number of cerebellar Compared with infarction in the
eye signs have been described,68 only a PICA distribution, cerebellar infarc¬
few of them can be observed clinically tion in the SCA territory is much
in acute vascular lesions of the cere¬ rarer. Such patients, in addition to an
bellum. Horizontal pursuit move¬ acute ataxia of gait, sometimes have
posteroinferior cerebellar artery ments may become superimposed an upbeating nystagmus present on

(PICA) (inferior part of the cerebel¬ with microsaccades (Cogwheel pur¬ gaze straight ahead, due to involve¬
lum).65·67 When the PICA is not well suit).4·69 When infarction in the PICA ment of the superior vermis.65·75
developed, the supply is taken over by territory is confined to the posteroin¬ Hypermetria of the contralateral sac-
the AICA, and vice versa. The overlap ferior part of a cerebellar hemisphere, cades (saccadic lateropulsion) with
of branches in the arterial system of the patient presents with vertigo, hypometria of the ipsilateral saccades
the cerebellum is important and also vomiting, and ataxia.70 74 In such situa¬ is just the opposite phenomenon from
includes branches from the contralat¬ tions, the mistaken diagnosis of an what is seen in PICA-territory
eral hemisphere. Location and size of acute peripheral vestibular disorder infarcts involving the lateral medul¬
infarcts, therefore, are quite variable. might be made. The key differential la.76 In cerebellar hemorrhage, com¬
For example, in some cases, unilateral points are the findings of prominent mon eye-movement disorders include
occlusion of a cerebellar artery gives ipsilateral cerebellar signs together gaze palsy (54%), nystagmus (51%),
rise to a large bilateral infarct, but, in with horizontal nystagmus in both abducens palsy (28%), and skew devi¬
other cases, it causes only a small directions of gaze with larger ampli¬ ation (20% ),77 which are more sugges¬
unilateral infarct. Furthermore, oc¬ tude toward the ipsilateral side of the tive of brain-stem than cerebellar
clusion of the vessels supplying the lesion. By contrast, in an acute dysfunction.
cerebellum often produces associated peripheral vestibular disorder, the The presence of these brain-stem
brain-stem infarction, making diffi- nystagmus would be unidirectional oculomotor disturbances and other

Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a New York University User on 05/30/2015


disorders in a cerebellar stroke do not impairment of fixation.85 A tilt (either culus due to lesion of the restiform
necessarily indicate an associated (90° or 180°) of the visual field may body,86 or to otolith imbalance.4 This
brain-stem infarction, but can also be occur and is very suggestive of lateral ipsilateral bias of ocular movements90
the consequence of brain-stem com¬ medullary infarct8586; sometimes, an also explains the frequent tonic conju¬
pression by a large cerebellar hemor¬ oblique torsion of the visual field may gate deviation of the eyes toward the
rhage or infarction.67·77"80 A reliable be limited to the ipsilateral eye.85 affected side (ocular lateropulsion of
clinical distinction between the two Occasionally, forced tonic deviation of Barré92'95); this lateropulsion may
conditions is generally not possible. the eyes toward the affected side may sometimes be seen with the patient's
MEDULLA be one of the patient's complaints. eyes open, but, more often, it is inhib¬
The arterial supply to the medulla Various objective disturbances may ited by fixation and is observed only
can be divided into three or four terri¬ be found, but are frequently over¬ when the eyes that have been previ¬
tories81 (Fig 2, bottom right) as fol¬ looked if the oculomotor examination ously closed are quickly opened by the
lows: the dorsal and lateral aspects of is not performed carefully. Most signs examiner; examination with a Frenzel
the medulla are supplied by the med¬ can be readily elicited at bedside, and prism may also help elicit this sign.
the interest of electro-oculography is Sometimes a deviation of the corneal
ullary branches of the PICA, and the
medial territory is fed by branches of mainly in quantification of the abnor¬ protuberance can be palpated under
the anterior spinal artery; the olivary malities. Skew deviation (vertical the lids. The ipsilateral pupil is miot-
territory is situated between the lat¬ divergence of Hertwig-Magendie) ic, in relation to Homer's syndrome,
eral and the medial territories and is may be related to damage to otolith- due to disruption of the discending
inconstant.82 oculomotor pathways.49·87 The ipsilat¬ sympathetic fibers.
eral eye is typically down in skew In large infarcts, all of these oculo¬
Lateral Medullary Infarcts
deviation due to lateral medullary motor disturbances may persist indef¬
Infarcts in the lateral medullary infarct. It is typically increased by initely, although some degree of func¬
territory are due to occlusion of the head tilt toward the lesion.85·87 Rotato¬ tional adaptation is usually seen, with
vertebral artery in 75% of these cases, ry or horizontorotatory nystagmus on subjective improvement.88
whereas isolated occlusion of the gaze straight ahead (primary position
PICA is found in less than 15% of Medial Medullary Infarcts
nystagmus) is closely allied to vertigo
these cases.83 When the infarct is and imbalance and is typically related These infarcts are usually related to
related to vertebral artery occlusion, to large lateral medullary infarcts.88 occlusion of the anterior spinal artery;
associated pontine involvement may However, it may occur without com¬ their rarity may be due to the usually
be found, which does not occur in plete destruction of the vestibular bilateral origin of the anterior spinal
cases with isolated PICA occlusion.83 nuclei.83 In left-sided infarcts, the artery96; however, they are still very
Cerebellar infarction is frequently rotatory component of the nystagmus uncommon in bilateral distal occlu¬
associated with the medullary infarct, is clockwise for the examiner, and, in sion of the vertebral artery.97·98 The
and it may be difficult to establish right-sided infarcts, it is counter¬ medial territory is usually involved
which of the oculomotor disturbances clockwise.88 The quick phase of the bilaterally.99
are related to medullary or to cerebel¬ horizontal component is opposite to Oculomotor anomalies are infre¬
lar involvement. Magnetic resonance the lesion, but the direction may quent and are mainly limited to
imaging is able to visualize medullary reverse with the eyes closed.89 Ipsilat¬ upbeat nystagmus, the amplitude of
infarcts without cerebellar involve¬ eral gaze increases the nystagmus, which may increase during upward
ment and may be of considerable help which often becomes predominant in gaze.96-99 Dorsal extension of the
in clinicotopographic studies.84 the ipsilateral eye.88 In rare cases, the infarct toward the MLF seems to cor¬
The lateral medullary syndrome nystagmus may be replaced after a relate with occurrence of this type of
(Wallenberg's syndrome) is one of the few weeks by irregular multidirection nystagmus.96·99 A rotatory nystagmus
most typical clinical syndromes found movements close to opsoclonus.88 A has been reported in one case,84 but
in neurologic practice. However, eye- downward-beating component limited the finding of an occlusion of the
movement disturbances may be very to the ipsilateral eye may sometimes ipsilateral vertebral artery suggests
complex and are often not well as¬ appear during gaze toward the af¬ that the lateral territory was initially
sessed. Various subjective complaints fected side.84·85 Bilateral gaze-evoked involved as well.
may be encountered.85 Vertical or nystagmus has also been reported,90 In the very uncommon hemimedul-
oblique diplopia corresponds to skew but it may have been related to associ¬ lary infarcts, oculomotor abnormali¬
deviation, and fluctuating vertical ated cerebellar involvement. Palpe¬ ties due to lateral medullary involve¬
diplopia occurs when monocular brai nystagmus synchronous with the ment usually coexist.
downward-beating nystagmus ap¬ fast phase of horizontal nystagmus
Medullary Hemorrhages
pears in the ipsilateral eye during (Popper-type of lid nystagmus) has
gaze toward the affected side.85 Diplo¬ been reported in lateral medullary Hemorrhages limited to the medul¬
pia may also increase markedly dur¬ infarct, and is a more accurate localiz¬ la are extremely uncommon, and their
ing gaze toward the nonaffected side, ing sign than the Pick-type of lid origins are not well established. Ocu¬
a phenomenon that is called crossed nystagmus, which is triggered by con¬ lomotor disturbances may mimic
diplopia." Also, tilting of the head to vergence and can occur in various those of lateral medullary in¬
the nonaffected side typically worsens brain-stem and cerebellar lesions.91 farcts100·101 but may also be absent102 or
diplopia and oscillopsia. Oscillopsia is One of the most constant oculomotor suggest a pontine lesion.103
predominantly in the horizontal plane abnormalities of lateral medullary
COMBINED SYNDROMES
and tends to subside within the weeks syndrome is hypermetric saccades
following the stroke. Blurred vision, toward the affected side with hypo- In basilar artery occlusion, it is not
which can be monocular or binocular, metric saccades toward the opposite uncommon to have extensive infarc¬
has been reported in the absence of side.86·90 It may correspond to isolation tion of the brain stem, from the lower
nystagmus; it could be related to of the vestibular nuclei from the floe- pons up to the upper midbrain; the

Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a New York University User on 05/30/2015


deep and superficial territory of the lateral medullary involvement domi¬ downgaze palsy can be regarded as
posterior cerebral artery (PCA) is nate the oculomotor picture, but signs specific of brain-stem stroke, as it is
also commonly involved.22·29 These of lower pontine involvement may not produced by other neurologic pro¬
facts explain why combined oculomo¬ sometimes occur, as sixth-nerve pal¬ cesses. Some eye-movement disorders
tor abnormalities are frequently sy.83 More distal involvement occurs are localizing signs, such as
accurate
present in this condition.29·30 Midlower much more uncommonly than in basi¬ selective horizontal gaze palsies
pons syndromes or upper midbrain lar artery occlusion.55·56 Cerebellar (paramedian pons), vertical gaze pal¬
syndromes usually predominate, ac¬ infarction in the distribution of the sies (upper midbrain), pure rotatory
cording to the level of the occlusion. PICA territory may be extensive, with nystagmus (medulla), or ipsilateral
Embolie occlusion of the basilar prominent cerebellar oculomotor dis¬ saccadic bias (medulla), but many
artery mostly occurs at the distal turbances or secondary pontine dys¬ other eye-movement disorders are not
bifurcation of this artery, and typical¬ function due to compression; in these (eg, skew deviation and most nystag¬
ly produces upper midbrain and PCA cases, primary lateral medullary mus). Because of the poor ability of
syndromes.22 Atherosclerotic occlu¬ involvement may not be recognized. computed tomography to visualize the
sion of the basilar artery usually orig¬ Large brain-stem hemorrhages brain stem properly, progress in
inates more proximally and pontine usually originate in the pons, with understanding clinicoanatomic corre¬
syndromes may predominate, in asso¬ prominent pontine oculomotor distur¬ lations has relied mainly on findings
ciation with usually extensive neuro¬ bances in a usually deeply comatose at autopsy, which is not frequently
logic deficits (locked-in syndrome).29·48 patient.104 performed as most patients recover.
Very often, supranuclear, nuclear, and COMMENT
The development of magnetic reso¬
infranuclear disturbances are associ¬ nance imaging may provide an instru¬
ated,28 but, sometimes, isolated su¬ Few oculomotor disturbances are ment considerably expanding our
pranuclear21 or infranuclear30 eye specific for vertebrobasilar stroke, knowledge of clinicotopographic cor¬
movement disorders may also be and it is their association with other relates in ocular movement distur¬
found. signs and their pattern of develop¬ bances due to small vertebrobasilar
In vertebral artery occlusion, the ment that may suggest a cerebrovas¬ stroke.84
eye movement disturbances due to cular event.105 Indeed, only acute
References

1. Spector RH, Troost BT: The ocular motor 14. Serdaru M, Gray F, Lyon-Caen P, et al: nuclear and supranuclear defects in ocular motil-
system. Ann Neurol 1981;9:517-525. Syndrome de Parinaud et d\l=e'\viationtonique ver- ity: A clinicopathologic study. Arch Neurol
2. Pierrot-Deseilligny C: Circuits oculomo- ticale du regard: Trois observations. Rev Neurol 1978;35:133-137.
teurs centraux. Rev Neurol 1985;141:349-370. 1982;138:601-617. 29. Kubik CS, Adams RD: Occlusion of the
3. Henn V, B\l=u"\ttner-EnneverJA, Hepp K: The 15. Weder B, Meienberg 0: Downgaze paraly- basilar artery: A clinical and pathological study.
primate oculomotor system: I. Motoneurons. II. sis due to brain stem infarction. Neuro-ophthal- Brain 1946;69:73-121.
Premotor system: A synthesis of anatomical, mology 1983;3:29-35. 30. Masucci EF: Bilateral ophthalmoplegia in
physiological, and clinical data. Hum Neurobiol 16. Barontini F, Simonetti C, Ferranini F, et basilar-vertebral artery disease. Brain
1982;1:77-95. al: Persistent upward eye deviation: Report of 1965;88:97-106.
4. Leigh RJ, Zee DS: The Neurology of Eye two cases. Neuro-ophthalmology 1983;3:217-224. 31. Shutt HKR, David MJ, Smith JL: Complete
Movements. Philadelphia, FA Davis Co Publish- 17. Thames PB, Trobe JD, Ballinger WE: bilateral III and IV nerve palsies due to basilar
ers, 1983. Upgaze paralysis caused by lesion of the peri- artery disease, in Smith JL (ed): Neuro-ophthal-
5. Fisher CM: Some neuro-ophthalmological aqueductal gray matter. Arch Neurol mology. Hallendale, Fla, Huffman, 1971, chap 5,
observations. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1984;41:437-440. pp 356-362.
1967;30:383-392. 18. Dehaene I, van Zandijcke M: See-saw jerk 32. Jampel RS, Fells P: Mononuclear elevation
6. Warwick R: Representation of the extraocu- nystagmus. Neuro-ophthalmology 1984;4:261\x=req-\ paresis caused by a central nervous system
lar muscles in the oculomotor nuclei of the 263. lesion. Arch Ophthalmol 1968;80:45-47.
monkey. J Comp Neurol 1953;98:449-504. 19. BrusaA, Massa S, Piccardo A, et al: Le 33. Bogousslavsky J, Regli F, Ghika J, et al:
7. Sieben G, de Reuck J, VanderEecken H: nystagmus palp\l=e'\bral.Rev Neurol 1984;140:288\x=req-\ Internuclear ophthalmoplegia, prenuclear pare-
Thrombosis of the mesencephalic artery: A clini- 292. sis of contralateral superior rectus, and bilateral
copathological study of two cases and its correla- 20. Pierrot-Deseilligny C, Schaison M, Bousser ptosis. J Neurol 1983;230:197-203.
tion with the arterial vascularization. Acta Neu- MG, Syndrome nucl\l=e'\airedu nerf moteur
et al: 34. Bogousslavsky J, Regli F: Nuclear and pre-
rol Belg 1977;77:151-162. oculaire commun: A propos de deux observations nuclear syndromes of the oculomotor nerve. Neu-
8. Zeal AA, Rhoton AL Jr: Microsurgical anat- cliniques. Rev Neurol 1981;137:217-222. ro-ophthalmology 1983;3:211-216.
omy of the posterior cerebral artery. J Neuro- 21. Bogousslavsky J, Regli F: Atteinte intra- 35. Bogousslavsky J, Regli F: Upgaze palsy and
surg 1978;48:534-559. axiale du nerf moteur oculaire commun dans les monocular paresis of downgaze from ipsilateral
9. Viader F, Masson M, Marion MH, et al: infarctus m\l=e'\senc\l=e'\phaliques.Rev Neurol 1984; thalamo-mesencephalic infarction: A vertical
Infarctus c\l=e'\r\l=e'\braldans le territoire de l'art\l=e`\re 140:263-270. 'one-and-a-half' syndrome. J Neurol 1984;231:43\x=req-\
choro\l=i"\dienneant\l=e'\rieureavec trouble oculomo- 22. Caplan LR: 'Top of the basilar' syndrome. 45.
teur. Rev Neurol 1984;140:668-670. Neurology 1980;30:72-79. 36. Meienberg O, Mumenthaler M, Karbowski
10. Castaigne P, Lhermitte F, Buge A, et al: 23. Masdeu J, Brannegan R, Rosenberg M, et K: Quadriparesis and nuclear oculomotor palsy
Paramedian thalamic and midbrain infarcts: al: Pseudo-abducens palsy with midbrain lesions. with total bilateral ptosis mimicking coma: A
Clinical and neuropathological study. Ann Neu- Ann Neurol 1980;8:103. mesencephalic locked-in syndrome? Arch Neurol
rol 1981;10:127-148. 24. Selhorst JB, Hoyt WF, Feinsod M, et al: 1979;36:708-710.
B\l=u"\ttner-EnneverJA, B\l=u"\ttnerU, Cohen B,
11. Midbrain corectopia. Arch Neurol 1975;33:193\x=req-\ 37. Jacobs L, Heffner RR Jr, Newman RP:
et al: Vertical gaze palsy and the rostral intersti- 195. Selective paralysis of downward gaze caused by
tial nucleus of the medial longitudinal fasciculus. 25. Fisher CM: Oval pupils. Arch Neurol 1980; bilateral lesions of the mesencephalic periaque-
Brain 1982;105:125-149. 37:502-503. ductal gray matter. Neurology 1985;35:516-521.
12. Pierrot-Deseilligny C, Chain F, Gray F, et 26. Lapresle J, Said G: D\l=e'\viationforc\l=e'\edes 38. Morel-Maroger A, Metzger J, Bories J, et
al: Parinaud's syndrome: Electro-oculographic yeux vers le bas et en dedans et mouvements al: Les h\l=e'\matomesb\l=e'\ninsdu tronc c\l=e'\r\l=e'\bralchez
and anatomical analyses of six vascular cases oculaires p\l=e'\riodiquesau cours d'une h\l=e'\mor- les hypertendus art\l=e'\riels.Rev Neurol 1982;
with deductions about vertical gaze organization rhagie an\l=e'\vrysmalede la calotte m\l=e'\senc\l=e'\phali- 138:437-445.
in the premotor structures. Brain 1982;105:667\x=req-\ que. Rev Neurol 1977;133:497-503. 39. Durward QJ, Barnett HJM, Barr H: Pre-
696. 27. Biller J, Shapiro R, Evans LS, et al: Oculo- sentations and management of mesencephalic
13. Bogousslavsky J, Miklossy J, Deruaz JP, et motor nuclear complex infarction: Clinical and hematomas. J Neurosurg 1982;16:123-127.
al: Unilateral left paramedian infarction of thal- radiological correlation. Arch Neurol 1984; 40. Roig C, Carjaval A, Illa I, et al: H\l=e'\mor-
amus and midbrain: Clinicopathologic study. 41:985-987. ragies m\l=e'\senc\l=e'\phaliquesisol\l=e'\es:Trois cas diag-
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1986;49:686-694. 28. Reagan TJ, Trautmann JC: Combined nostiqu\l=e'\spar tomodensitom\l=e'\trie.Rev Neurol

Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a New York University User on 05/30/2015


1982;138:53-61. Eur Neurol 1983;23:151-155. imaging. Stroke, in press.
41. Nadeau SE, Trobe JD: Pupil sparing in 63. Kase CS, Maulsby GO, Mohr JP: Partial 85. Hagstr\l=o"\mL, H\l=o"\rnstenG, Silfverski\l=o"\ldBP:
oculomotor palsy: A brief review. Ann Neurol pontine hematomas. Neurology 1980;30:652-655. Oculostatic and visual phenomena occurring in
1983;13:143-148. 64. Miller NR: Walsh and Hoyt's Clinical Neu- association with Wallenberg's syndrome. Acta
42. Plum F, Posner JB: The Diagnosis of Stu- ro-Ophthalmology. Baltimore, Williams & Wil- Neurol Scand 1969;45:568-582.
por and Coma. Philadelphia, FA Davis Co Pub- kins, 1985, vol 2. 86. Esta\l=n~\olB, Lopez-Rios G: Neuro-otology of
lishers, 1966. 65. Kase CS, White JL, Joslyn JN, et al: Cere- the lateral medullary infarct syndrome. Arch
43. Caplan LR, Goodwin JA: Lateral tegmen- bellar infarction in the superior cerebellar artery Neurol 1982;39:176-179.
tal brain stem hemorrhages. Neurology 1982; distribution. Neurology 1985;35:705-711. 87. Silfverski\l=o"\ldBP: Skew deviation in Wal-
32:252-260. 66. Perneczky A, Perneczky C, Tschabitscher lenberg's syndrome. Acta Neurol Scand 1965;
44. Smith JL, Cogan DG: Internuclear oph- M, et al: The relationship between the caudola- 41:381-386.
thalmoplegia: A review of 58 cases. Arch Oph- teral pontine syndrome and the anterior cerebel- 88. Currier RD, Giles CL, De Jong RN: Some
thalmol 1959;61:687-694. lar artery. Acta Neurochir 1981;58:245-257. comments on Wallenberg's lateral medullary
45. Cogan DG: Internuclear ophthalmoplegia, 67. Sypert GW, Alvord EC: Cerebellar infarc- syndrome. Neurology 1961;1:778-791.
typical and atypical. Arch Ophthalmol 1970; tion: A clinicopathological study. Arch Neurol 89. Moberg A, Preber L, Silfverski\l=o"\ldBP, et al:
84:583-589. 1975;32:357-363. Imbalance, nystagmus, and diplopia in Wallen-
46. Gonyea EF: Bilateral internuclear oph- 68. Dichgans J, Jung R: Oculomotor abnormal- berg's syndrome: Clinical analysis of a case and
thalmoplegia: Association with occlusive cere- ities due to cerebellar lesions, in Lennerstrand C, postmortem examination. Acta Otolaryngol 1962;
brovascular disease. Arch Neurol 1974;31:168\x=req-\ Bach-y-Rita P (eds): Basic Mechanisms of Ocular 55:269-282.
173. Motility and Their Clinical Implications. Elms- 90. Kommerell G, Hoyt WF: Lateropulsion of
47. Jenkyn LR, Margolis G, Reeves AG: Reflex ford, NY, Pergamon Press, 1975. saccadic eye movements: Electro-oculographic
vertical gaze and the MLF. J Neurol Neurosurg 69. Malamud N, Satya-Murti S: Cerebellar studies in a patient with Wallenberg's syndrome.
Psychiatry 1978;41:1084-1091. hemorrhage: A review and reappraisal of benign Arch Neurol 1973;28:313-318.
48. Bogousslavsky J, Miklossy J, Regli F, et al: cases. Arch Neurol 1984;41:425-428. 91. Daroff RB, Hoyt WF, Sanders MD, et al:
One-and-a-half syndrome in ischaemic locked-in 70. Duncan GW, Parker SW, Fisher CM: Acute Gaze-evoked eyelid and ocular nystagmus inhib-
state: A clinicopathological study. J Neurol Neu- cerebellar infarction in the PICA territory. Arch ited by the near reflex: Unusual ocular motor
rosurg Psychiatry 1984;47:927-935. Neurol 1975;32:364-368. phenomena in a lateral medullary syndrome.
49. Keane JR: Ocular skew deviation: Analysis 71. Guiang RL Jr, Ellington OB: Acute pure J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1968;31:362-367.
of 100 cases. Arch Neurol 1975;32:185-190. vertiginous dysequilibrium in cerebellar infarc- 92. Barr\l=e'\MJA: Le nystagmus et le syndrome
50. Pierrot-Deseilligny C, Prier S, Masson M, tion. Eur Neurol 1977;16:11-15. vestibulaire dans plusieurs cas personnels de
et al: Enregistrement des mouvements oculaires 72. Samson M, Mihout B, Thiebot J, et al: syndrome de Babinski-Nageotte et de Wallen-
chez l'homme lors de l\l=e'\sionsunilat\l=e'\ralesde la Forme b\l=e'\nignedes infarctus c\l=e'\r\l=e'\belleux.Rev berg. Rev Otoneuroophtalmol 1927;5:945-950.
FRPP. Rev Neurol 1978;134:355-366. Neurol 1981;137:373-382. 93. H\l=o"\rnstenG: Wallenberg's syndrome: III:
51. Pierrot-Deseilligny C, Chain F, Serdaru M, 73. Swiontoniowski M, Biller J, Azar-Kia B, et Oculomotor and oculostatic disturbances. Acta
et al: The one-and-a-half syndrome. Brain al: Cerebellar infarction: Clinical and cranial CT Neurol Scand 1974;50:447-468.
1981;104:665-699. correlations. Eur Neurol 1985;24:338-342. 94. Fris\l=e'\nL: Lateropulsion of the eyes: A
52. Henn V, Lang W, Hepp K, et al: Experi- 74. Tomaszek DE, Rosner MJ: Cerebellar localizing brain stem sign. J Neurol 1978;218:171\x=req-\
mental gaze palsies in monkeys and their rela- infarction: Analysis of 21 cases. Surg Neurol 177.
tion to human pathology. Brain 1984;107:619\x=req-\ 1985;24:223-226. 95. Cambier J, Masson M, Poullot B, et al:
636. 75. Uldry PA, Regli F, Uske A, et al: Ramollis- D\l=e'\viationtonique du regard au cours du syn-
53. Meienberg O, B\l=u"\ttner-EnnerverJA, Kraus\x=req-\ sements c\l=e'\r\l=e'\belleux:Pr\l=e'\sentationclinique et drome de Wallenberg. Rev Neurol 1982;138:839\x=req-\
Ruppert R: Unilateral paralysis of conjugate due \l=e'\valuation en tomodensitom\l=e'\triec\l=e'\r\l=e'\brale. 844.
to lesion of the abducens nucleus: Clinicopatho- Schweiz Med Wochenschr 1986;116:34-41. 96. Ho KL, Meyer KR: The medial medullary
logical case report. Neuro-ophthalmology 76. Ranalli PJ, Sharpe JA: Syndrome of the syndrome. Arch Neurol 1981;38:385-387.
1981;2:47-52. superior cerebellar artery: Contralateral saccad- 97. Caplan LR: Bilateral distal vertebral
54.Bogousslavsky J, Regli F: Exotropie ponti- ic lateropulsion and ipsilateral limb ataxia. Can artery occlusion. Neurology 1982;33:552-558.
que paralytique et non paralytique. Rev Neurol J Neurol Sci 1985;12:209. 98. Bogousslavsky J, Gates PC, Fox AJ, et al:
1983;139:219-223. 77. Ott KH, Kase CS, Ojemann RG, et al: Bilateral occlusion of vertebral artery: Clinical
Bogousslavsky J, Regli F: Convergence and
55. Cerebellar hemorrhage: Diagnosis and treat- patterns and long-term prognosis. Neurology, in
divergence synkinesis: A recovery pattern in ment: A review of 56 cases. Arch Neurol 1974; press.
benign pontine hematoma. Neuro-ophthalmology 31:160-167. 99. Kase CS, Varakis JN, Stafford JR, et al:
1984;4:219-225. 78. Fisher CM, Picard EH, Polak A, et al: Medial medullary infarction from fibrocartilagi-
56. Wall M, Wray SH: The one-and-a-half Acute hypertensive cerebellar hemorrhage: nous embolism to the anterior spinal artery.
syndrome: A unilateral disorder of the pontine Diagnosis and surgical treatment. J Nerv Ment Stroke 1983;14:413-418.
tegmentum: A study of 20 cases and review of the Dis 1965;140:38-57. 100. Kempe LG: Surgical removal of an intra-
literature. Neurology 1983;33:971-980. 79. Labauge R, Boukobza M, Zinszner J, et al: medullary hematoma simulating Wallenberg
57. Sharpe JA, Rosenberg MA, Hoyt WF, et al: H\l=e'\matomesspontan\l=e'\sdu cervelet (28 observa- syndrome. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1964;
Paralytic pontine exotropia: A sign of acute tions). Rev Neurol 1983;139:193-204. 27:78-80.
unilateral pontine gaze palsy and internuclear 80. Khan M, Polyzoidis KS, Adegbite ABO, et 101. Neumann PE, Mehler MF, Horoupian DS:
ophthalmoplegia. Neurology 1974;24:1076-1081. al: Massive cerebellar infarction: 'Conservative' Primary medullary hypertensive hemorrhage.
58. Nordgren RE, Markesbery WR, Fukuda K, managements. Stroke 1983;14:745-751. Neurology 1985;35:925-928.
et al: Seven cases of cerebromedullospinal dis- 81. Gillilan LA: The correlation of the blood 102. Hommel M, Borgel F, Gaio JM, et al:
connection: The 'locked-in' syndrome. Neurology supply to the human brain stem lesions. J Neu- Lat\l=e'\ropulsion ipsilat\l=e'\raleisol\l=e'\epar h\l=e'\matome
1971;21:1140-1148. ropathol Exp Neurol 1964;23:78-108. bulbaire. Rev Neurol 1985;141:53-54.
59. Hawkes CH: 'Locked-in' syndrome: Report 82. De Smet Y, Brucher JM, Gonsette RE: 103. Mastaglia EL, Edis B, Kakulas BA: Med-
of seven cases. Br Med J 1974;4:379-382. L'infarctus du territoire olivaire du bulbe. Rev ullary hemorrhage: A report of two cases.
60. Susac JO, Hoyt WF, Daroff RB, et al: Neurol 1984;140:559-566. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1969;32:221-225.
Clinical spectrum of ocular bobbing. J Neurol 83. Fisher CM, Karnes WE, Kubik CS: Lateral 104. Nakajima K: Clinicopathological study of
Neurosurg Psychiatry 1970;33:771-775. medullary infarction: The pattern of the vascular pontine hemorrhage. Stroke 1983;14:485-493.
61. Bosch EP, Kennedy SS, Aschenbrener CA: occlusion. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol1961;20:323\x=req-\ 105. Minor RH, Kearns TP, Millikan CH, et al:
Ocular bobbing: The myth of its localizing value. 379. Ocular manifestations of occlusive disease of the
Neurology 1975;25:949-953. 84. Bogousslavsky J, Fox AJ, Barnett HJM, et vertebral-basilar arterial system. Arch Ophthal-
62. Brusa A, Firpo MP, Massa S, et al: Typical al: Clinicotopographic correlations of small ver- mol 1959;62:112-123.
and reverse bobbing: A case with localizing value. tebrobasilar infarct using magnetic resonance

Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a New York University User on 05/30/2015

You might also like