You are on page 1of 6

Donghai Bridge – The First Super Long Open Sea Crossing

in China
Changyu Shao, Chief Eng. of Shanghai Municipal Engineering Design Institute (SMEDI), China, and Zhifang Yang, Prof.-level
Engineer of Shanghai Tongsheng Major Bridge Construction Ltd., China

Introduction 10–20 m, is located at over 130 m thick The numbers of different construc-
loose stratum of the Quaternary Peri- tion elements involved are 5700 piles
The Donghai Bridge is a very impor- od. The current velocity of sea water at driven at open sea using “piling ships”,
tant subsidiary project to the Shanghai the bridge site is generally 2,0–2,5 m/s, 700 bored piles cast-in-situ by off-
Yangshan Deep-water Harbor Proj- and the maximum height of wave in a shore platform, 822 large piers of 300 t
ect. The bridge is the first super long return period of 100 years is 6,19 m. weight each installed by off-shore ope-
bridge crossing open sea in China with The maximum measured wind speed rations, and 670 pieces of box girders
the total length of 32,5 km. It starts at at bridge site is 35,0 m/s. with 1700–2000 t weight each installed
Shanghai Luchao Harbor, and crosses
The bridge site is under great influence by lifting vessels with 2500 t capacity.2
the open sea to the Phase I junction
of such climatic and oceanic conditions The alignment of Donghai Bridge is
of Xiaoyangshan Harbor. The proj-
of an open sea, as wind, wave, current, very long. In addition, there are all
ect is characterized by its large scale,
tide, fog and rain; therefore, the annual kinds of bridge structures with very
the severe environmental conditions,
operable days are 240 days for sub- tight construction schedules. The de-
the high technical difficulties, and the
structures, and 180 days for pier and mand for various construction equip-
short construction duration; therefore,
girder assembly. ments in the area was extensive; the
the design of this bridge brought about
a series of problems which were never number of vessels added up to 200, in-
Bridge Layout cluding the 85 m-tall fully rotating pil-
faced before and required detailed
analysis and study for its solution.1 The bridge is 32,5 km in length, of which ing ships, and two lifting vessels with
The designers worked out the plans about 90% is off-shore as illustrated 2500 t capacity each. Moreover, there
and techniques for safe and efficient in Fig. 1. It includes one main naviga- were also a great number of off-shore
off-shore construction; as a successful tional channel, three auxiliary navi- operation platforms, temporary bridg-
result, the construction of the bridge gational channels, non-navigational es for construction, operational docks,
took merely 40 months from June 2002 spans as well as approach spans for and a 350 000 m2 large scale pre-fabri-
to October 2005. port connection. The general informa- cation site for bridge parts to help push
tion of the bridge is shown in Table 1. through the project.2
Keywords: Donghai Bridge; non-
navigational spans; driven steel pipe; The design of Donghai Bridge adopts
pre-cast pier shaft; pre-fabricated in a traffic speed of 80 km/h and dual
three lanes with typical deck width of
Off-shore Non-navigational
one complete span; cable-stayed bridge;
composite box girder. 31,5 m according to Chinese Express Spans
Way Design Code. The loading of the
Span Arrangement
bridge is designed according to a Chi-
Project Overview nese standard truck lane load (20 t For the design of the non-navigational
standard trucks at 15 m intervals and spans, the bridge designers have taken
Construction Environmental
one special truck with a 55 t axle load) multiple factors into consideration.
Conditions
and checked according to a specialized Numerical analysis indicates that when
The bridge, crossing 26 km of wide container lane load (55 t containers at the span exceeds 50 m, the influence of
open sea with the water depth of 10 m intervals). piers on the tidal current is negligible.

Fig. 1: General view of Donghai Bridge

Structural Engineering International 1/2008 Structures Worldwide 67

x293.indd 67 1/24/08 9:41:14 AM


Bridge Bridge type and span Bridge length Sub-structure Superstructure
location (m) (m)
50 m span
Pre-cast concrete
Prestressed Concrete Cast-in-situ with travelling
Beach area 1300 pipe pile, cast-in-situ
(PC) continuous formwork span by span
pier
girder
60 m span PC
10 700 Driven steel-pipe
Area in continuous girder Pre-fabricated and erected
pile pre-fabricated
open sea 70 m span PC in one complete span
10 780 pier
continuous girder
Main span 420 m Composite box girder
Main Cast-in-situ pile,
cable-stayed bridge 830 symmetrically erected with
channel cast-in-situ pier
with double pylons cantilever method
Main span 2 × 120 m
380
PC continuous girder
Three
Main span 2 × 140 m Cast-in-situ pile, Cast-in-situ with cantilever
auxiliary 440
PC continuous girder cast-in-situ pier method
channels
Main span 2 × 160 m
500
PC continuous girder
Area near 50 m span PC Cast-in-situ pile, Cast-in-situ with launching
400
island continuous girder cast-in-situ pier method
Area at port 50 m span PC Cast-in-situ pile Cast-in-situ with travelling
350
connection continuous girder cast-in-situ pier formwork span by span
Main span 322 m Composite plate girder
Area at port Cast-in-situ pile,
cable-stayed bridge 710 symmetrically erected with
connection cast-in-situ pier
With double pylons cantilever method

Table 1: General information of the bridge

Under this premise, the designers have therefore, considering that easier fabri- strength strands, and the vertical pre-
studied the global effects on this proj- cation, transportation, and installation, stressing adopts 32 mm diameter high
ect by adoption of different spans, the constant depth is adopted for both strength deformed pre-stressing bar.
structural styles, and construction kinds of girders – 3,5 m high for 60 m One piece of 60 m span girder weighs
methods; they conclude that it is most span girders and 4,0 m for 70 m span 1700 t and 70 m span girder 2000 t.
economical to adopt 60 and 70 m span girders. Another important advantage
PC box girders for the superstructure, is that the girders with constant depth The 0,8 m thick cross beam at the end
and 1,5 m diameter steel-pipe piles for can be simply-supported at piers easily, of the side span is pre-fabricated to-
the foundations. The PC box girder and the top plan of piers can provide gether with the girder. As the 1,6 m
is pre-fabricated and installed in one good working place for construction thick cross beam at the middle support
complete span that helps to meet the of the wet joints between the simply- is cast-in-situ with the wet joint later,
construction deadline, decrease off- supported spans at open sea. there is no cross beam pre-fabricated
shore workloads, reduce construction in plant for middle-span girder; there-
risk, and improve project quality. It is The bridge is divided into two separate fore, the measure has to be taken to
a very popular span arrangement that bridge decks transversely. The 60 and enhance torsion stiffness by strength-
six to seven 60 m span or five to six 70 m span girders are single-box struc- ening the end sections of middle-span
70 m span PC box girders form one tures made of high-performance con- girder so as to meet stress requirement
continuous unit. crete with specified strength 32,4 MPa. during girder transportation and in-
The deck is 15,25 m wide and the bot- stallation.
Considering that the tidal current tom slab 7,25 m wide. The cantilever
and the scouring depth increases pro- Sixty and seventy meter box girders
of the top slab extends 4,0 m. The top
gressively from seashore to open sea, are pre-fabricated in one complete
slab is 0,26–0,55 m thick. The web and
and the direction of current is more span at the same pre-fabrication plant.
bottom slab at the centre of the span
variable far from the seashore, the de- All the girders are drawn to the dock
are 0,4 and 0,25 m thick respectively,
signers adopt two different kinds of with sliding method and lifted, and
increasing in thickness at supports ac-
span – 60 and 70 m, especially more of then installed by two different lifting
cording to the stress level. The main
60 m spans than 70 m at areas close to vessels (illustrated in Figs. 2–4).
girder is pre-stressed in all three direc-
the seashore. tions internally; meanwhile, external After a girder is simply-supported at
pre-stressing ducts are reserved for fu- piers, the jacks are used to slightly ad-
Superstructure just the girder into accurate position.
ture use. There are two kinds of longi-
Generally the engineering cost of 60 tudinal pre-stressing specifications, 12 The error must be controlled when
and 70 m span girders with the constant and 17 high strength strands of 15,2 mm the girder is placed. Combined with
depth is only just a little bit more expen- diameter. The transverse pre-stressing the oceanic conditions and the crane
sive than those with the varying depth; adopts three 15,2 mm diameter high performance, the error allowance of

68 Structures Worldwide Structural Engineering International 1/2008

x293.indd 68 1/24/08 9:41:27 AM


tion is 1 : 4,5 and each pile is about 60 m
long. The wall of the steel-pipe pile is
18 mm thick at the bottom, welded in
spiral seam. To withstand larger stress
and to reserve partial corrosive thick-
ness, the steel-pipe pile wall thickness
increases to 25 mm at the top, welded
in straight seam. These piles are pro-
tected from corrosion by the sacrificial
protective layer besides the partially
Fig. 2: 60 m-span girder erected corrosive reserved thickness.
The circular pile cap for a 70 m span
continuous girder has diameter of 11 m.
Eight 1,5 m diameter steel-pipe piles
are evenly arranged in a circle with
7,4 m diameter. Meanwhile, the circu-
lar pile cap for a 60 m span continuous
girder has a diameter of 10 m. One of
seven 1,5 m diameter steel-pipe piles is
arranged at the centre and the rest are
Fig. 5: Pile being driven
evenly arranged on the circumference
of a 6,4 m diameter circle.
Fig. 3: 70 m-span girder erected
The pre-fabricated concrete cofferdam
with 300 mm thick walls is adopted for
the pile cap. While lifting the coffer-
dam to position and casting the bot-
tom-sealed concrete, all construction
loads are taken by the steel-pipe piles.
Each pier has four steel-pipe piles to
support the cofferdam.
In this part, there are 4862 steel-pipe
piles, 510 separate pile caps and 74 in- Fig. 6: Piles driven
tegrated ones.
Fig. 4: Simply-supported girders
As most of the bridge spans are far
from the seashore, the steel-pipe piles
placing a girder should be ±150 mm in are driven with “piling ship” equipped
longitudinal and transverse directions, with the domestic manufacture D125-3
respectively; the final error allowance diesel hammer, and the GPS is used for
of the girder position is ±10 mm in two positioning of the piles. The maximum
directions respectively after accurate length of the steel-pipe pile that can be
adjustment. The error of the elevation driven is 85 m; therefore, all steel-pipe
for the pier should be accurately ad- piles of the bridge are driven up to de-
justed before the girders are installed. sign elevation without any site welding
After girder installation, the wet joints joints (illustrated in Figs. 5–7).
are cast-in-situ and then the continu- Fig. 7: Concrete cofferdam erected
There are about 700 pile caps for the
ous bridge is formed. non-navigational bridge. The construc-
tion of the pile caps is greatly influ-
Substructure must be installed right after cofferdam
enced by wind, wave and flow at open
installation to resist the wave and flow.
Both the 60 and the 70 m span con- sea, so the designers have to adopt the
After bottom sealing concrete is cast,
tinuous girders adopt steel-pipe pile concrete cofferdam with large stiffness,
the concrete pile cap can be cast by
foundations. In order to decrease wave small deformation, and good perfor-
layers in a dry circumstance.
forces from different directions, two mance to resist wave and current forces.
separate decks of the bridge have in- One set of demountable steel bracing The non-navigational bridge has about
dependent circular pile caps. The tall beams with multiple functions is in- 800 piers pre-fabricated and erected in
piers on either side of the navigational stalled within the concrete cofferdam. segments. Each segment is about 12 m
span bridge have many piles because of During construction, the weight of cof- high and weighs about 300 t. The wet
the large forces exerted on their foun- ferdam and bottom sealing concrete concrete joint is cast-in-situ to connect
dations, thus two transversely aligned is transferred to the steel-pipe piles the pre-fabricated box-section pier
piers share one integrated polygon- through the steel beams. The instal- shaft with the pile cap (illustrated in
shaped pile cap. In order to effectively lation of the cofferdam is carried out Figs. 8–10). The cast-in-situ wet joint
resist the horizontal force and to de- during the quiet tide time period (illus- can also cover pre-fabricated pier shaft
crease displacement, the steel-pipe piles trated in Fig. 10); and then the connec- and its reinforcements to improve the
are all inclined. The maximum inclina- tion between the cofferdam and piles structural durability.

Structural Engineering International 1/2008 Structures Worldwide 69

x293.indd 69 1/24/08 9:41:27 AM


the discount of lane loads, which is line of the deck consist of two parallel
equivalent to 0,8 times the Euro Rail- planes separated by 2,0 m. There are 24
way Standard UIC loading of the dou- pairs of stay cables arranged on either
ble-line railway. side of the pylon. They are arranged
with 8 m spacing along the girder and
There are many options for a main 2,2 m spacing along the height of the
girder with this kind of span of cable- pylons. The main pylon is supported on
stayed bridge such as steel box girder, pile foundation, which is composed of
concrete box girder, steel-concrete 38 bored piles, and each pile is 110 m
composite plate girder, and steel- long and 2,5 m in diameter.
concrete composite box girder. After
Fig. 8: Pier pre-fabricated detailed study of the options and con-
sideration of many factors such as con- Superstructure
struction speed, structural stiffness to
resist heavy live loads, service life of The 4,0 m deep main girder is a steel–
deck pavement and bridge engineering concrete structure of three-cell single-
cost, finally, the designers have chosen box section (illustrated in Figs. 12
steel-concrete composite box girder as and 13). The top plate of the girder
the main girder to satisfy the service box, made from concrete of specified
and environmental conditions and to strength 35,5 MPa, is 33,0 m wide with
meet the project deadline as well. two 4,5 m wide cantilevers. The rest of
the box is made from bridge structural
steel with yield strength 345 MPa.
Fig. 9: Pier being transported Configuration
The concrete deck is generally 280
The main navigation channel bridge is mm thick, and increases to 550 mm on
a five-span 73 + 132 + 420 + 132 + 73 m top of the web. The typical steel seg-
(in total length of 830 m) cable-stayed ment is composed of 16 mm thick bot-
bridge with double pylons, single cable tom plates and diagonal web plates, as
plane, and auxiliary piers (illustrated well as 24 mm thick vertical webs and
in Fig. 11). The auxiliary piers are de- web flanges. The plates of other steel
signed to improve the stiffness of the segments at the pylon bottom and on
bridge and reduce stresses applied to top of the side and auxiliary piers are
the girder and pylons. thicker than that of the typical ones.
The bottom plates and webs are stiff-
The main girder is a steel-concrete
ened by 8 mm thick U-shaped ribs. The
Fig. 10: Pier erected composite box structure, while the
diaphragms of the main girder are steel
main pylons are reinforced concrete.
trusses with 24 mm thick top flanges.
The stay cables, which are composed
When the pier is pre-fabricated, it is of galvanized parallel wires of 7 mm For the design of typical steel-concrete
very important to control the bottom diameter, adopt HiAm anchorage sys- box girder, the designers adopt two
surface levelness, pier height and incli- tem. The stay cables along the centre types of shear studs with 22 mm dia-
nation strictly. Six short concrete posts
with inclined surface are installed
accurately on top of pile cap as the 830
guide positioning device, and the pier 73 132 420 132 73
shaft can slide into position along the
inclined surface when it is installed.
After welding some reinforcements
of pile cap and pier together, the pier
can strengthen its stability at once, and
then connect all reinforcements and
cast the wet joint concrete.
Fig. 11: Layout of the main bridge (units: m)
Main Channel Bridge
3300/2 3300/2
Bridge Proposal 50 1425 175 175 1425 50
The main navigational channel bridge
is a 420 m main span cable-stayed 2% 2%
bridge, designed according to the
navigational requirements. The main
400

considerations include managing con-


struction progress, ensuring structural
durability and smooth operation under
traffic loading. The design loading is 450 200 1000 1000 200 450
about 110 kN/m longitudinally distrib-
uted along the bridge after considering Fig. 12: Girder cross section (units: m)

70 Structures Worldwide Structural Engineering International 1/2008

x293.indd 70 1/24/08 9:41:43 AM


structures, (b) assemble the steel struc-
tures with no less than 5 segments at
the same time, (c) cast the concrete
deck after quality of the structure is
verified.

Substructure
Two main pylons are founded on two
pile foundations, each of which is com-
Fig. 13: Composite box girder posed of 38 bored piles of 2,5 m dia-
meter and 110 m length. A pile cap is
28 m wide, 56 m long and 7 m deep.
meter for the connection between the The pylon foundation is designed longi-
steel box structure and the concrete tudinally and transversally according
deck. One type is 450 mm long, set to wave impact and ship impact forces,
at the edge of the top steel flange to respectively.
counteract the transverse bending mo-
ments, and another type is 200 mm The main pylon foundations are con-
long. structed with the assistance of plat-
forms that are designed as the steel-pipe
The main pylons are made from rein- truss structure (illustrated in Fig. 16)
forced concrete with specified strength from the experience of petroleum
of 32,4 MPa. The section above the platform at open sea. A steel coffer-
deck is an inverted “Y” shape. Below Fig. 14: Cantilever construction dam (illustrated in Fig. 17) is adopted
the deck is a box structure with un- for the construction of pile cap. The
even width. In the transversal direction steel cofferdams and the platforms are
of the bridge, the dimensions of the There are 107 segments for the whole
fabricated individually and floated to
upper, middle, and lower part of the bridge, including 96 typical segments,
the site, and then connected to each
pylon are 7, 4,2, and 37–28 m respec- the 8 m long closure segment, eight
other. The pylon foundations are con-
tively, corresponding to a longitudinal 5,0 m long segments near the pylons,
structed in the following sequence:
width of 8 m. and two 6,58 m side span segments
(a) establish guiding piles and steel
(Fig. 15). All the segments are pre-
casings, (b) construct the bored piles,
Steel anchor girders are used for two- fabricated in-factory, except 0,5 m long
(c) cast the bottom sealing concrete,
thirds of the stay cables in the anchor- concrete deck at both ends. These two
(d) cast the concrete of pile caps (illu-
age zone, and rigidly connected to the ends have to be filled with joint con-
strated in Fig. 18).
pylon wall. The other one-third of the crete on-site, as to ensure the quality
cables is anchored directly to the con- of construction. The segments should Since combined structures of steel-
crete pylon wall due to their smaller be fabricated in the following sequ- pipe truss platform and steel coffer-
horizontal component force. ence: (a) fabricate parts of the steel dam provided significant stiffness to
There are a total of 224 stayed cables
that are fabricated with galvanized
parallel wires. Each cable consists of a
maximum of 283 wires or minimum of
121 wires of 7 mm diameter.
The deck segments are fabricated in-
factory and then installed with the can-
tilever method (Fig. 14). The segments
at the top of the auxiliary piers and at
the end of the side spans are floated
and hung by floating cranes. Typical
segments are floated to the site and
then hung and installed by cranes on Fig. 16: Steel-pipe truss
the girder. After the installation of seg-
ment, first the steel structures have to be
connected and then wet joint concrete
between segments has to be cast. There
exists compressive forces applied to the
top concrete deck because of the ten-
sion of stay cables; thus the cables can
be installed and tensioned 1 or 2 days
after casting the joint concrete, and al-
lowing the concrete to reach sufficient
strength to resist the compressive
stresses. It takes approximately 4–5
days to install each segment. Fig. 15: View of main bridge Fig. 17: Steel-pipe truss and steel cofferdam

Structural Engineering International 1/2008 Structures Worldwide 71

x293.indd 71 1/24/08 9:42:00 AM


mostly pre-fabricated and erected References
by the cranes, including the coffer-
dam for the pile cap, the pier shaft of [1] Yang Zhifang. Practices of technical inno-
vation on Donghai bridge. Donghai Bridge J.
300 t weight, and one complete span
5/2004. pp. 8–11.
girder of 2000 t weight; the cast-in-
situ wet joint between the pre-fab- [2] Huang Rong, Guo Zhenwen, Huang Shaow-
ricated pier and the cast-in-situ pile en, Bi Guiping. Integral construction for crossing
sea bridge. Donghai Bridge J. 4/2004. pp. 13–19.
cap can provides good durability; the
error allowance of erection at open [3] Zhou Dongsheng, Xu Wei, Zhou Xiannian.
sea can be controlled accurately; the Construction technology of platform for crossing
sea bridge. Donghai Bridge J. 1/2005. pp. 32–35.
Fig. 18: Casting pile cap
steel-pipe pile, 80 m long, is entirely
driven into the designed elevation
without any site joints. A large num-
resist large wave and flow forces app- ber of tasks originally required to be
SEI Data Block
lied on the foundations, not only the completed off shore are completed on
construction period is saved but also shore, which not only reduce the risk Owner name:
the structure is safer. This method has during project implementation but Shanghai Tongsheng Major Bridge
been widely spread in the course of the also greatly accelerate the progress Construction Ltd., China
engineering construction of the whole of the project, ensuring to keep the
very tight completion schedule. Hav- Other details:
Donghai Bridge.3
ing completed the bridge in less than Concrete overall (m3): 1 600 000
four years, the review of the construc- Steel material overall (t): 340 000
Conclusion tion process clearly indicates that the
Total cost (USD billions): 1,3
technical plan is very successful for
A number of construction methods the first long-span sea-crossing bridge Construction period (months): 40
for this project have been adopted in China. Many thanks are presented Service Date: October, 2005
for the first time in China: the con- to the owner, who provided extensive
crete components of the bridge are data and photographs for this paper.

72 Structures Worldwide Structural Engineering International 1/2008

x293.indd 72 1/24/08 9:42:22 AM

You might also like