Professional Documents
Culture Documents
189
IRORO: JOA Volume 18 Numbers 1 & 2, 2019 189-209
Daniel OBASOOTO
Department of Philosophy, Faculty of Arts,
University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria
Email: impeccabledaniel@gmail.com
Abstract
Sexism is a central issue that engages the attention of many living within
the shore of Nigeria and beyond. There is apparently intractable
disagreement about which individuals, practices and institutions are sexist.
The question of who is oppressing who or who is really the oppressor
cannot be overemphasized. This paper attempts to critique the allege
subjugation of women by men. The feminists assume that the subjugation
of women and the suffering of women are as a result of the patriarchal
society and, therefore, advocate an egalitarian society whereby both the
male and the female gender have equal rights and opportunities. This
paper argues that feminists’ approach to sexism is one-way traffic.
Patriarchy is arguably alleged as the number one enemy of women’s
development in many societies. Giving this to be true for the sake of
argument, can matriarchy be an alternative to patriarchy? Will the
problems faced by women go if they are allowed to take the place of men
in their society? Finally, who is really oppressing who? This paper proposes
one of the ways by which we can have a balanced feminist approach to
sexism which none or few feminists have sufficiently articulated.
Introduction
According to Aina (2012, p. 6),the definition of gender is hinged on
the fact that the situation of men and women must be analysed in
relationship to each other, and not in isolation. However, culturally
and socially constructed differences between female and male
genders based on meanings, beliefs, and practices that are associated
with femininity or masculinity have raised a gender problem. These
perceived differences that are culturally and socially constructed
bring up the range of attitudes, beliefs, policies, laws, and behaviours
that discriminate on the basis of gender. This results in sexism or a
system of gender inequality and power and male hegemony, as it is
190 IRORO: A Journal of Arts
Literature Review
For a better understanding of this paper, three terms: sexism,
patriarchy and feminism, must be clarified before proceeding with
the discussion that connects the three and their application to the
Nigerian situation.
Sexism between the Male and the Female Gender: An Exposition of ... 191
Sexism
According to Acholonu (1995),”masculinity or male chauvinism is
really a disease of the present generation…, which unfortunately is
spilling over to infest women”(p.109).Gender inequalityinNigeria
is influenced by different socio-cultural beliefs and practices. In most
parts of Nigeria, women are considered to be subordinate to their
male counterparts. This is however based on the pervasive cultural
beliefs and practices in the society.
In the pre-colonial era, some customs and practices in the society
are considered antithetical to women’s development and make the
female subjugated to the male. Some of those customs and practices
include: Early Marriage, Marriage, Seclusion of Women, Female
Genital Mutilation, Male Child Preference, Widowhood rite, etc.
Enemuo (1999) opines that “Nigerian communities approve such
practices as preference for male child, payment of bride price, female
circumcision or female genital mutilation, FGM, negative attitude
(to women) towards childlessness, degrading widowhood practices
and inheritance practices that discriminate against women…giving
away girls in marriage early and without their consent”
(p.230).These practices will be further elaborated and discussed in
the course of this paper.
In the colonial era, women were also marginalized and
disadvantaged in relative to men. Although in the pre-colonial
societies, “women were politically active and relatively less exclusive
in decision-making process, the advent of colonial administration
with its anti-women policies gradually transformed a hitherto
politically gender-unbiased to a predominantly male-dominated
political scene” (Awofeso & Odeyemi, 2014, p. 105).For example,
among the policy and decision-makers in the Yoruba land are female
individuals such as the Iyalode and Iyaloja. Another powerful
political force who occupied a very sensitive position in the overall
political hierarchy in northern Nigeria is Queen Amina of Zaria. As
such, the colonial era did not only promote patriarch, the Nigerian
political scene was characterized by patriarchism. (Awofeso and
Odeyemi, 2014).
In the post-colonial era, the men, having tasted political power
and found it appealing, continued to consolidate their position by
fencing out their female counterparts from the mainstream political
activities where the real power lies. (Awofeso and Odeyemi,
192 IRORO: A Journal of Arts
Patriarchy
Patriarchy can be defined as a hierarchical system of social
organization in which cultural, political, and economic structures
are controlled by men. In the words of Albert (2002:60), patriarchy
refers “to the sub-culture in which a man naturally sees himself as
having a domineering influence on a woman”.Patriarchy can also
bedefined as a system of male authority that oppresses women
through and bydominating the social, politicaland economic
institutions. In other words, patriarchy is a socio-political cum
Sexism between the Male and the Female Gender: An Exposition of ... 193
economic system that asserts the superiority and domination of the
male over the female. The male sees it as inherently and naturally
endowed with the right to dominate and rule over the female who
they consider to be weak. Males are classified as having the following
qualities: strength, vigour, virile/powerful courage, self-confidence
and the ability to ward off enemies away from the society. These
qualities are however reflected in the kinds of work that men engage
in. Men are responsible for much of what is thought of as “hard”
labour. JessieBernard in a way gives credence to this when he asserts:
It is not so much the specific kinds of workmen and
women do – they have alwaysvaried from time to time
and place to place – but the simple fact that the sexes
dodifferent kinds of work, whatever it is, which is in
and of itself important. The divisionof labour by sex
means that the workgroup becomes also a sex group.
The very natureof maleness and femaleness becomes
embedded in the sexual division of labour. One’ssex
and one’s work are part of one another. One’s work
defines one’s gender.(Jessie,1981, 3).
However, given this seeming classification of qualities and
gender which tends to be defined along the line ofsexual division of
labour, one way to argue for this division is that in pre-colonial
society, women are not to be exposed to hard labour and hardship.
As such, such treatment is a sign of dignity, respect and honour
given to the women. Nevertheless, while the men see their role as to
dominate and rule in everything, they see that of women as to give
birth, nurture the children and support male dominance or assume
a subordinate role in relation to the powerful men. In an attempt to
understand and solve the problems of women, the feminists argue
that patriarchy is the major enemy of women. The feminists who
react to patriarchy refer to it as a”systematic organization of male
supremacy and female subordination”(Cheris, 1992).Ferriera (2007,
p. 395)describes patriarchy as a system that is both oppressive and
discriminatory.By oppressive, she means patriarchy is oppressive in
virtually every area of the society such as social, economic, political
and cultural anddiscriminatory in its control of access to power,
management of resources and benefits, and in the manipulation
ofpublic and private power structures.While Sylvia Walby(1990)
defines patriarchy as”a system of socialstructures and practices in
194 IRORO: A Journal of Arts
Feminism
Feminism is a range of political movements, ideologies, and social
movements that share a common goal: to define, establish and
achieve political, economic, personal, and social rights for
women.(Hawkesworth,2006, pp. 25-7). Succinctly put, feminism is
the belief that men and women should have equal rights and
opportunities.Such right includes seeking to establish educational
and professional opportunities for women that are equal to such
opportunities for men. In other words, women should be at par
with their male counterparts. Feminism is a general term that covers
a range of ideologies and theories which pay special attention to
women’s right and women’s position in the society. As such, feminism
is used for women’s movements that campaign for political, social
and economic equality between women and men. Suffice to mean
Sexism between the Male and the Female Gender: An Exposition of ... 195
that feminists are united by the idea that women’s position in society
is unequal to that of men and that society is structured in such a
way as to benefit men to the political, social and economic detriment
of women. As such, feminism is a reaction against patriarchy. For
Udokang and Awofeso,(2012) feminism can be considered as “both
a critique and an ideology” (p.159).As a critique, feminism opposes
patriarchy, that is, “a system of male authority, which oppresses
women through the social, political and economic
institutions”(McLean, 2003, p. 196). As an ideology, feminism is a
belief system which preaches equal rights for women and their
emancipation from all forms of domination exerted by
men.(Udokang & Awofeso, 2012)Feminism has equally been
regarded as both an intellectual commitment and a political
movement that seeks justice for women and the end of sexism in all
forms. (Awofeso and Odeyemi, 2014: 106).
Pre-colonial Era
Inthe pre-colonial society,althoughwomen were politically active but
relatively less exclusive in the decision-making process, there existed
some traditional customs and practices that undermine the right of
women. As such, those customs and practicesin the society are
considered antithetical to the development of women in the society
and as well make the female subjugated to the male. Some of those
customs and practices include:
(i) Early Marriage: In the pre-colonial society, girls are given
out early in marriage because it is believed that women are for men
to own. More so, poverty is a critical factor that contributes to early
marriage. As such, giving women out early in marriage will save
the unnecessary and what is believed as wasteful spending on them.
It is in view of this that women will either not be sent to school or
have their education aborted. As if this is not enough, early marriage
exposes the girls to early pregnancies and Visico Vaginal Fistula
(VVF) a disease that leaves its victimsdeformed and unable to control
urination.
196 IRORO: A Journal of Arts
Colonial Era
The effect of colonialism on gender inequality or sexism may not be
generally agreed upon by scholars.The contention is usually as to
the extent the colonial activities positively or negatively affected
gender relations? Colonialism is not without its advantage, it
benefitted some women causes, but on the overall, it caused the
decline of women’s status (Odeyemi, 2013, p. 8).In the words of
Odeyemi, (2013)”the Colonialists positively impacted women’s role
within marriage in their ability to have a say in the process of divorce
which hitherto was limited to decisions taken between families which
was mainly men dominated” (p.8).The colonialist through the
introduction of native law and customary courts prohibits force
marriage, child marriages, and permits easier access for women to
divorce (Odeyemi, 2013, p. 9).Nevertheless, in the colonial era,
women’s status was relegated in defiance of the pre-colonial setting;
women were also marginalized and disadvantaged in relative to
men. One negative effect of the advent of the colonialists is that
women’s socio-political power was unrecognized. Suffice to mean
that the colonialists with their policies advanced and promoted
patriarch in the Nigerian economic and political sphere.The British
dealt directly with the men in the administration and running of
the state since the colonialists considered “only men to be active in
the public sphere and earn a living to support their families”(Assie-
Lumuba, 1996, p. 3).The colonialist suffered from the limitation of
funds and personnel, therefore, saw the need to make use of native
indigenes in the day to day affairs of the government, as such,
education was the first consideration. Thus, the colonialist through
the aid and activities of the missionaries established some schools.
However, “women’s education was not given much consideration,
and the few women who came into the mission homes ended up as
housekeepers of the missionaries”(Omolewa, 1986, p. 143).In other
words, according to Omolewa, though the colonial system of
education was primarily geared toward meeting the manpower need
of the colonial government, yet the system obviously alienated
women from educational and economic opportunities.As such, this
act gave an undue advantage of the male over the female
200 IRORO: A Journal of Arts
Postcolonial Era
The effects of colonialism, the influence of the two main religious
incursions into West Africa and the impact of these collusions have
changed the course and turn thetide of the African’s history and
fortune. The two new religions were based on a philosophy of
separate spheres where men were associated with the public world
of education and work, women were associated with the private
sphere of the home.This ideology, which was totally strange to Yoruba
culture, suddenly became the legitimate religious and imperial
justification for gender differentiation (Gulnar, F.D. 2004: 128).
Colonialism with missionary activities is not without its pains and
gains. However, with regards to gender relations, the disadvantages
obviously outweigh the advantages. Though Christianity, as a
colonialist tool, is accused of engendering this ideology of sexism or
gender differentiation,paradoxically, this impediment also became
grounds by which women, decades later claim their
liberation.(Gulnar, F.D. 2004, p. 129)Odeyemi lends credence to this
when he asserts that,
closely related to the paradox of the effects of
Christianity on the traditional Yoruba culture and
society is the same kind of ambivalent effects of western
Sexism between the Male and the Female Gender: An Exposition of ... 201
education. On the one hand, it limited the possibilities
of what women could achieve within a British
patriarchal setup. At the same time, it setup the
possibilities for women who will eventually excel by
breaking boundaries and barriers, especially after
independence to begin to fight for women’s rights.
(Odeyemi, 2013, p. 12)
By this he means, the problem of educationalmarginalization
of the women created by Christianity later became grounds by which
women claim their liberation.Succinctly put, the work of the
missionaries contributed immensely to creating a dichotomy in
gender and subjugation of the female gender to the male gender
which was almost non-existent prior to the arrival of the missionaries
and the colonialists.However, this struggle for relevance, liberation
and equality would not have been necessary in the first place if
policies of subjugation by men against women have not been
introduced by the colonialists’.
With the passage of time and in order to struggle for relevance,
liberation from the shackles of men and equality, women’s
participation in formal education began to improve immensely.
Though women’s condition and status began to improve
tremendously with their participation in formal education, men still
take the lead in the political and economic sphere of life. Nevertheless,
women’s condition and status have improved to the point that
women were no longer passive or voiceless. In other words, the
men, having tasted political power and found it appealing, continued
to consolidate its position by fencing out their female counterparts
from the mainstream political activities where the real power lies.
In the political sphere, women were at best, reduced to the second
fiddle offices of ‘deputy’ and ‘vice’(Awofeso & Odeyemi, 2014, p.
105).
Gender differentiation has raised several questions and
approaches about this among various scholars. This is hinged on
the assumption that women are subjugated by men, as such, women
are seen as the primary victims of sexism in contemporary societies.
However, the questions that immediately come to mind are:
givenpatriarchy as the enemy of women, will the problem faced by
women go if they are on a par with the men or are allowed to take
the place of men in their society?Are men always and only the
oppressors of women and who is oppressing who?
202 IRORO: A Journal of Arts
References
Acholonu, C. (1995)Motherism: The Afrocentric Alternative to
Feminism. Owerri: Afa.
Acker, J., Barry, K. and Eseveld, J. (1991). Objectivity and Truth:
Problems in doing Feminist Research, in Fonow, M.M. and J.A.
Cook (Eds): Beyond Methodology: Feminist Scholarship as Lived
Research, Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University
Press, pp.133-153.
Albert, I.O. (2002)Rethinking the Impact of Patriarchy on Feminist
Epistemology and Methodology in Nigeria, In C.E Ukhun (ed):
Critical Gender Discourse In Africa Vol.1., Ibadan: Hope
Publications.
Aina O.I (2012). Two Halves make a Whole: Gender at the Grassroots
of the Nigerian Development Agenda Being the 250th Inaugural
Lecture Series Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria. P.6
Albert, I.O. (2002) Rethinking the Impact of Patriarchy on Feminist
Epistemology and Methodology in Nigeria. Op.Cit. p.69.
Asha, S. (2008) Narrative Discourses on Purdah in the Subcontinent,
ICFAI Journal of English Studies Vol. 3, no. pp.41-51
Assie-Lumuba, N.T. (1996). “Behind and Beyond Beijing: An African
Perspective on the Fourth World Conference on Women” in
CODESRIA Bulletin. p. 3.
Awofeso, O and Odeyemi, T.I. (2014). Gender and Political
Participation in Nigeria: A Cultural Perspective, Journal Research
in Peace, Gender and Development, Vol. 4(6),pp.104-110.
Awofeso and Odeyemi., Op.Cit. p. 109; CF Ayabam AT
(2013).”Women in Politics and Decision-Making in Nigeria:
Challenges and Prospects”, European Journal of Business and
Social Sciences 2(8): 52-4.
Awofeso, O. and Odeyemi, T.I. Op.Cit. p.106.
Azodo A. U., & Eke M. N. (2007). Gender and Sexuality in African
Literature and Film. Eritrea: Africa World Press, Inc.Dogo, S.A.
Sexism between the Male and the Female Gender: An Exposition of ... 207
(2014). The Nigerian Patriarchy: When and How, Cultural and
Religious Studies, Vol.2, no 5, pp.263-275.
Beasley, C. (1999). What is Feminism?New York: Sage.
Cheris, K (1992). The Condition of Patriarchy In Kramarae Cheris
and Spender Dale (eds.) The Knowledge Explosion: Generation
of Feminist Scholarship. Athen Series, Teachers College Press,
London. Cf: Stacey, J. (1993) Untangling Feminist theory In
Richardson D. and Robinson V. (eds.) Introducing women’s
Studies: Feminist Theory and Practice. Macmillan, London.
Chua, P., & Fujino, D. (1999). Negotiating New Asian American
Masculinities: Attitudes and Gender Expectations. Journal of
Men’s Studies, Vol.7.no.3, pp.392-413.
Code, L(1991).What Can She Know?: Feminist Theory and the
Construction of Knowledge, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Corkburn, C. (2004). Militarism, Male Power and the Persistence of
War. Paper at a seminar: Militarism and Male Violence.
Enemuo, F.C (1999). Gender and Women Empowerment In
Anifowose, R. and Enemuo, F. C. (Eds) Elements of Politics,
Lagos: Sam Iroanusi Publishers.
Ferriera A. M. (2007). Patriarchy. Molefi Kete Asante and Ama
Mazama [Electronic version]. Encyclopaedia of Black Studies.
Izugbara C.O (2013). Contemporary Gender Studies; Roots,
Approaches and Future Director In Ekpe, A. E. and Akpan, O.
(Eds) Readings in Int. Pol. Economy, Yaoundé, Cameroon: Book
House.
Gulnar, F.D. (2004). The Gendering of Missionary Imperialism: The
Search for an Integrated Methodology, InUrsula, K. & Tina, B.
(eds.). Gender, religion and Diversity: Cross Cultural perspectives.
New York: Continuum Press, pp.125-137.
Hawkesworth, Mary E. (2006). Globalization and Feminist Activism.
Lanham:Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Jessie, B. (1981) The Good-Provider role: Its Rise and Fall,American
Psychologist. Vol. 36, No. 1, pp.1-12.
John Segun Odeyemi, Gender Issues Among the Yorubas, The
International Journal of African Catholicism, Winter 2013.
Volume 4, Number 1, p.2.
208 IRORO: A Journal of Arts